This painting has meme-ified into a joke about growing up with siblings. But what was its original context? I can't find a source anywhere.

Here's the painting. Seems like a subject matter with a story to be told.

1 Answers 2018-12-07

I saw a recent post showing one system for an alarm using a candle and nails... I’d be curious to know how people dealt with needing to wake up at a ‘certain time.’

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-12-07

When did the people of the Byzantine empire stop identifying as romans, if ever?

We learnt in history that after the initial split of the Roman Empire, the east Calle themselves romans, and did even after the fall of the west. Was there ever a point where this stopped?

1 Answers 2018-12-07

In archaeology, how do we know we're not finding what other societies found?

Say we find an artefact in the area of a civilisation that we know existed in 500BC.

​

How do we know that the 500BC civilisation didn't find that artefact from a 1000BC civilisation and put it in their own museum-like thing before we found it?

​

And does that mean that things in our museums may be found by future humans, and they may mistake our generation for having less sophisticated technology?

1 Answers 2018-12-07

Rockets red glare. How heavily were rockets used in the American revolution? how common were they in conflicts of the era?

you rarely see rockets in depictions of conflicts in that era of gunpowder combat, but I do know they were used. How frequently? what edge did they have over cannon and vice versa?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

What were the specific changes in weaponry and tactics that led to World War 2 not being as trench warfare focused as World War 1?

Specifically in the Western European front, as the fighting took place in almost the same locations as before.

I know trench warfare arose because of a development in weaponry, specifically tanks and machine guns that was able to effectively pin down infantry (?)

So what advancements made for trench warfare to be not a viable strategy anymore?

2 Answers 2018-12-06

lies my teacher told me vs a people’s history of the united states. which is better and why?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

When are the earliest examples of pornography from, and what were the main forms of consumption before mass media?

There are many cavedrawings from primitive peoples, have any of those found seemed to include any form of pornography? Do we know the first documented example of porn?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

The significance of planned vs market economy on the outcome of the cold war

Would market economy inside of the USSR and its allies, but still insulated from the rest of the world make any difference in the outcome of the cold war?

I have recently read this article. According to the article, the country of the size of the USSR with few allies can't antagonize the rest of the world and win the arms race when the world economy is globalised.

1 Answers 2018-12-06

I accidently may have put fake news about Fredrick Douglass on the front page yesterday. Now I'm looking to spread the truth.

I made this post on TIL after reading on Wikipedia that FD never smiled in the many photographs he took to avoiding playing into racist Minstrel caricatures because he believed it would undermine his cause and public image as an abolitionist.

There was a lot of confusion about the accepted style of photo posture and facial expression back then, with many people I suspect generalizing from this popular Vox video. A lot of comments seem to reflect the belief that exposure times were too long to smile ("He's not smiling because he couldn't hold it"), and that it was against cultural norms at the time ("He's not smiling because nobody smiled"). For all I know, the claims in the video are well sourced, but these is different from the original claim. The original claim is that he gives the camera a stern look, which, regardless of the norms on smiling, is a different expression. The Wikipedia article I got the original fact from cites this NPR interview with John Stauffer, who wrote a book on FD. He says in the interview:

MARTIN: So these [photographs] were not just taken for fun.

STAUFFER: That's right. So he spells out in four speeches - essays - that he gives why photography is so important in ending slavery and racism and achieving civil rights. And he believed in the camera's truth value - that even in the hands of a racist white, the camera will not lie. Thus, it was a wonderful critique or counter to the proliferation of racist caricatures, particularly in blackface minstrelsy.

MARTIN: How much control did he have over the way he was portrayed in these photographs? I mean, was it his choice never to smile, or was that the convention of the time?

STAUFFER: Yes, yes. It wasn't necessarily a convention, but Douglass specifically - in print, he said that he did not want - he did not want to be portrayed as a happy slave. The smiling black was to play into the racist caricature. And his cause of ending slavery and ending racism had the gravity that required a stern look. And so he tended to confront the viewer, look directly into the camera. And so it was a confrontational pose that countered what most photographic manuals instructed the photographer - to position the sitter in a visionary gaze so that you looked up or beyond the camera, looking far away.

He was very self-conscious and sensitive of his visual image, even as a slave in the early 1840s. He describes feeling down in the mouth and looking in a mirror and perceiving himself as ugly, which is really fascinating. And he was very self-conscious of how he presented himself both as - in a photograph, as a speaker, as a writer. The public persona - the look of the public persona was crucial to him because he wanted to enter into the public sphere with an equal voice with an equal image and have the same rights as any other citizen.

Could it be that, in an age of selfies, smiles, etc., we bluntly categorize FD's expression as 'smiling or not smiling' because of our expectations for old photos, while to his contemporaries, his 'stern look' would stand out as stonier than the prevailing non-smiling norm? I think only FD's word can solve this.

However, while it is relatively undisputed that FD took an incredible number of photos, I've found it much more difficult to locate sources to this end, beyond John Stauffer, or, what texts John Stauffer is referring to. Other authors seem to attribute his attitudes regarding the value of pictures and his marked stare to inconsistent or nebulous reasons.

So, at 18,000 upvotes and boosting a murky truth, what are some other reliable authors, or primary sources which can succinctly get to the bottom of this? Did Fredrick Douglass take every one of his numerous photos with the intention of sending a message?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

Sword Combat, Twirling a Thing?

In cinema it often depicts in sword fights from the middle ages and of Samurai and Ninjas twirling whilst in combat. By twirling I mean a full 360 degree spin with a brief moment of your back to your opponent. I wanted to know if this was merely theatrical or if there was an advantage to doing so? Was this a part of sword fighting training? Did this give them extra momentum to hit harder? Was it an effort to disorient or confuse the enemy and make your swing or thrust harder to block? Thanks.

2 Answers 2018-12-06

Every Presidential election from 1952 till 2000 in US seems to have ended in decisive victory for the winning candidate in terms of Electoral College votes. Were the races as one sided as the result seem to indicate? If not, why weren't the victories more narrow?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

Were the resources allocated to the "Final Solution" under the Third Reich worth the resources gained from it?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-12-06

I toured the bunker that was supposed to house the govt of the US in case of a nuclear strike in Washington (Greenbrier, West Virginia). I remember the guide saying that it got very close to being used for its purpose soon after it was built (1930s), but I don’t remember why or details. Any help?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

What was it really like for people locked in the stocks?

There's that whole "funny" image of people being locked in the stocks and the townsfolk throwing rotten cabbages at them, but it that really what it was like? Were people mostly respected (if humbled) while in the stocks, or was it common for them to be abused, struck and perhaps badly injured while they can't fight back? What about women, I imagine they could have had a very harrowing time trapped in the stocks and unable to prevent anyone from raping them or otherwise abusing them, etc.

Were there rules around conduct towards people in stocks, or was it a lot worse than the Disney-fied version we have come to think about?

2 Answers 2018-12-06

Genghis Khan question (Song referencing history) not sure if I'm right

So sorry if this is a little off for this sub or rules but I feel like it kind of applies.

There's this song by Miike Snow where he references Genghis Khan in the following lyric - "I get a little bit Genghis Khan.I don't want you to get it on. With nobody else but me."

BUT one of my friends I showed this song to didn't know who Genghis Khan was or its reference use in the song.

So I'll quit horsing around and just ask the question.

Wasn't there a period or event that Genghis Khan was famous or infamous for where there was a type of border conflict/struggle between him and some other country (because of race or something).So his solution to the issue was to smuggle his people to their country and breed with their people so that they had a harder time telling who was what race. (The "I don't want you to get it on. With nobody else but me" part in the song.) Making it a little easier to conquer?

Maybe I thinking of some other historical event? Maybe that never happened at all and I look pretty dumb asking this question lol.

But if this was a event what was it called? If it wasn't then what would your take on the lyric be? because I honestly don't know then. I know he did quite a bit of conquering but for some reason I have a old memory in the back of my head that he did that as one of his strategies. Maybe someone else did that.

Anyways it's been bugging me for sometime and I was hoping someone could tell me if I was right or wrong.

Thanks a bunch fellas! Hope you all have a lovely day.

1 Answers 2018-12-06

The Reichstag fire took place 1 month after Hitler came to power, and allowed him to seize complete control of the German state. Is there any evidence that Hitler was behind the fire? Or was it really just a huge coincidence?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

In the Battle of Trafalgar, the British captured many Spanish and French ships, but almost all of them were never deployed again. Why?

Would appreciate some information on the age of sail in general if nothing more specific about the napoleonic wars and the repair of ships. The British navy captured a bunch of vessels and yet especially during this battle, they never were redeployed. Why? I don't know much about the repair of boats, but the British kept building more ships during the war. Wouldn't it be Cheaper to just fix these boats than build entirely new ones? Any info or direction to a repost would be helpful! Thanks.

1 Answers 2018-12-06

In a letter addressed to the French prime minister, the Alawaite leaders of Syria ask for the French to stay in Syria. The letter praises the Jews of Palestine and defends the Jews of Syria. Did Syrian Alawaites had any form of relations with Jews in either Syria or Palestine?

The letter in question can be found in the Wikipedia page about Ali Sulayman al-Assad.

1 Answers 2018-12-06

Looking for reading recommendations on the transition from medieval society to early modern Europe

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-12-06

What is the relationship of the educational touring industry to the academic historical community?

I used to travel a lot, and I have been on many 1-, 2-, 3-hour long tours, in various places in the world, where the tour guide essentially narrates the entire history of the area. It can be extremely informative and fascinating to learn history from a passionate local.

What sort of interaction does the academic historian community have with these tour guides and their parent companies? Do you fact check them? Do they consult you? Do you learn from each other at all? Is there a mutual respect between you, mutual disdain or just don't care?

2 Answers 2018-12-06

By 2050 70% of the US Senate will be controlled by 30% of the population. I'm curious if representation imbalances like this were present at the time of the country's founding, and if so, how it was discussed.

That estimate comes from a recent editorial in the Atlantic by former congressman John Dingell. While it may not prove to be entirely accurate, it is an interesting problem to consider for responsible government.

I know the senate was setup as a prevention against the "tyranny of the majority," but I'm wondering if the founding fathers ever contended with the idea of a "tyranny of the minority."

2 Answers 2018-12-06

Were the Black Panthers good or bad?

I’ve heard conflicting stories and reports about them and I want to clear it up.

1 Answers 2018-12-06

Were Mulberries and gooseberries ever used in other battles besides D-Day?

As of just learning about then I found them very fascinating and a neat ship to help support after D-Day.

Were they ever used in any other battle?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

When did Zoroastrianism become extinct in Afghanistan and Central Asia?

There are still small continuous Zoroastrian communities in Iran (Yazd and Kerman) that survived the past 1300 years since the Muslim invasion. There's also the very old Parsi community of India.

But what happened to the Zoroastrians of Afghanistan, Central Asia or other regions where Zoroastrianism was commonly practised? Why is Iran the only native country where Zoroastrianism didn't completely go extinct?

Is there a time period when we know the last Zoroastrians of Central Asia were living, and what their dilemmas were? In what cities or towns did they live? What was their economic status or place in society? Are there written descriptions from travellers or locals that came across Zoroastrians in Central Asia, in the same way such descriptions exist in Iran and India?

1 Answers 2018-12-06

⯇ 2246 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start