Neo-Nazis and other Antisemites claim that academics are forbidden from discussing the holocaust or questioning the Jewish narrative. This, we all know, is so incorrect that it's not even wrong but it does lead to this question: how has the historiography of the Holocaust changed over the years?

2 Answers 2018-11-17

Why did Sherman not burn down Georgia University?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

My grandfather always told me that during WW2 the grand majority of soldiers on both sides during battle would pretend to fight by purposefully misfiring or purposefully not shooting a fatal area, how true is this?

My uncle would always tell me that about 90ish% of soldiers would shoot over head or just shoot a leg or arm, this doesnt sound right given all the stories of how brutal WW2 was.

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Did pirates actually talk like that?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Did the Greeks really invade the city of Troy by pretending to give up, and then giving them a giant wooden horse as a gift that was actually filled with soldiers? Is there any evidence of this?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

How did the Romans capture the lions and other animals they fought in the gladiator pits ?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-11-17

When was France established?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-11-17

What do we know of the earliest appearances of full plate armor in combat scenarios? How did Medieval Europe react to it?

It surely must have been a sight to behold then, that's why I was wondering to we have any direct sources on it. Of course I am aware that there was a transitional period, plated knights didn't just come out of nowhere. Yet still I am wondering did the fully plated knights leave a huge impression at the time?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Iberian Peninsula in Medieval times

I have tried to research on it, but perhaps because i´m not an expert, i have failed to or come upon sparse information on the topic, but heres the question: in what ways did the iberian peninsula culture differ from the rest of europe? Im mainly interested in xiv and xv century christian countries, but i would also want to know about earlier periods and the muslim world on the peninsula.

We, or at least me, are shown mostly medieval england and france in pop culture as the "standard" medieval depictions, but from the small information i came upon, i realized that portugal, castille and aragon would be a lot different from that, i imagined because of climate, size of the realms and the mixing with muslim culture.

The first thing i noticed, at least in portugal, is the considerable small forces that are used. In an old book ive read (historical fiction) about king John II and the campaign that led to the battle of Toro ( 1476 ), it is mentioned that a small group os soldiers, around 20 or 30 were sent to take a minor castle. Is this reasonable at the time to take a small castle with such a small force?

Another thing is arms and armor. From what i gathered, the tradition of the heavy cavalry from france wasnt such a big thing here, and Ginetes light cavalry was the thing. Did "light cavalry" not wear armor? wanst there the image of the knight in shining armor a thing?

What about art? was italy and the netherlands the only place where that side of the renaissance took of? what happened here in iberia?

Did the feudal structure from iberia differ in any way from the rest of europe (at least that classical image we have from it)?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Was what we think of as North American “grandma decor” popular among young people in the 1950s?

Like many, I’m a millennial visiting family for the holidays. I was discussing with my friends about my grandmother’s house, which, while very tastefully decorated and maintained, has a certain look and feel to it that young people (even ones who have tastefully decorated and maintained) houses do not.

Examples of things I’d consider “grandma decor”:
-Potpourri
-Fake flowers -Fake fruit -Decorative plates (not just in the fine China cabinet)
-Decorative towels and little placards that either say warm comments about home/family (“Home is where the heart is”), or are cheeky jokes about wine (“Age improves with wine”) -Statues of the Virgin Mary (maybe only for Catholic grandmas) -Cross stitch. So. Much. Cross stitch.

(By contrast, I would imagine “modern millennial decor” to have none of the above things, but instead have lots of pillows, paintings or photographs instead of cross stitch, books or nothing (minimalism) instead of fake fruit and flowers, etc.)

If I was a 20-30 something woman decorating my home in the 1950s, would it look like my grandmas house today? Or were there different styles back then?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Audio AMA: Dig History Podcast

Hello everyone!

I will be interviewing the amazing panel of the Dig History Podcast (https://digpodcast.org) soon, and we wanted to try out an AMA format where you could ask questions here and they could answer them on the podcast!

So please post questions here for them!

3 Answers 2018-11-17

Any work done on teaching history through video games?

Hi folks!
Im studying to become a upper secondary school teacher in history and I have a intereset in videogames and might write an essay about something along the title in the future, therefore Im trying to find some research or papers about bringing videogames into the classrooms. I've found a few just through simple "googling" but if you guys know any papers or works done on the field please feel free to share!

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Saturday Showcase | November 17, 2018

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Why Operation Unthinkable, Allies plan to attack Soviet Union after the end of WW2, was so unthinkable, when Allies had clear andvantege by having A-Bombs at the time?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

If we had lots of steamboats in the 1800's, why didn't we have steamcars?

Seems like the invention of the combustion engine which quickly led to cars (and more importantly trucks) is what caused to the fall of steamboats. But I don't understand why we didn't have steam-powered trucks 50 years before that, which would have almost eliminated the need for steamboats...

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Is it true that in some battles of the First English Civil War, pikemen on both sides would just "wave their pikes around" pretending to be fighting, and hoping their commanders wouldn't notice it?

I was listening to Mike Duncan's Revolutions podcast, and at some point in this episode (concerning the armies of the English Civil Wars) he says this:

The pikemen were usually bunched at the center of the battle line and operated much like an old Greek phalanx. They would line up 6 deep carrying 15 to 18 foot pikes and march forward until they hit the line of enemy pikemen.

They were all supposed to be outfitted with a metal breastplate, but they were usually issued only a leathered buff coat, which you would think would make all of this a very messy and very stabby business; but in reality, being run through with a pike was actually a pretty rare thing. The goal was simply to win the contest known as the "push of pike". Which is exactly what it sounds like: you were trying to shove, push and knock off balance the other side until their ranks broke and ran off.

Sometimes, the "push of pike" was a hell of a contest. But often, one side or the other just wasn't that into it, and after a perfunctory showing would break and run. Then there were my favourite times, when neither side was into it, and they would just kind of stand there and wave their pikes around to make it look like they were fighting, occasionally looking over their shoulders and hoping the generals way in the back were buying it.

(at the 03:43 mark, for those who prefer listening to it)

Nothing against Mike, I know he surely took this from a solid source. But he doesn't quantify the events he's talking about, which leaves me highly curious.

So I ask: what is the source for this? If it did happen like he describes, was it a single episode involving a dozen men or a widespread phenomenon throughout the conflict? If so, how did commanders deal with it?

Edit: I should not have referred to the "First English Civil War" in the title, since there is no implication by the podcaster that what I'm asking about happened in a certain phase of the conflict. Take my question as applying to the entirety of the English Civil Wars.

3 Answers 2018-11-17

Evidence for the Seven Ancient Wonders of the World?

What sort of physical evidence for the seven ancient wonders of the world currently exist? I know that the Giza pyramids are still around so thats evidence, and the hanging gardens of babylon is listed as potentially not real, but what about the other five? Is it just historical accounts, or is there physical pieces, such as chunks from the Collosus of Rhodes?

2 Answers 2018-11-17

Was facial hair more common in Ancient Greece than it was in Ancient Rome?

I was watching an AlternateHistoryHub video about Rome today and I realized that pretty much throughout my life, whenever I pictured an ancient Roman, I saw a smooth-faced fellow in my head. By contract, picturing a Greek gent of the same(ish) era, I always picture a curly, dense, bushy beard.

Were the Greeks more inclined to facial hair? Or is this just a product of the statues and other likenesses that have survived of each civilization? Or is there a totally different answer?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

In what ways were New World people (Incas, Mayans, Tainos, Apache, Iriquois) harsh or oppressive to their lower classes?

Descriptions of New World exploration often describes the people as peaceful victims compared to the conquering Europeans, but is that accurate?

I am wondering if the New World people were also harsh or oppressive to their lower classes and were conquered because of something other than being taken advantage of.

1 Answers 2018-11-17

A heavily signed trivet from WWII Germany's 193 News Division (Nachrichten-Abteilung 193), 93rd Infantry Division, with a 1940 date. Are there listings of who was in this division in 1940 to connect the autographs with real people's stories and is there anything more of interest? - Images in comment

Years ago in a thrift shop I found a heavily signed trivet from WWII Germany's 193 News Division (Nachrichten-Abteilung 193), 93rd Infantry Division, I believe, with a 1940 date. Are there listings of who was in this division in 1940 so one might connect the autographs with real people's stories and is there anything more of interest that is noticeable from either the logo or the back?

https://imgur.com/a/JZf37o8

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Were the state-owned British railways better than before the nationalisation?

Let's say in the 50s and 60s, before the oil crisis hit and after they'd had enough time to move past the transitional stage, were the passenger services offered by British Railways cheaper (per mile travelled or per average daily commute of the respective period), safer (accidents/casualties per mile), more efficient, more easily available, and more comfortable than, say, in 1938? What about before the WW1 interventions? I'll be happy with partial answers as well as with answers related to criteria I forgot to include. Edit: typo.

1 Answers 2018-11-17

How did the navy function during the golden age of piracy

I've been researching the golden age of piracy while writing a story. I want to ask those knowledgeable how did the Navy's of countries especially the UK. How did they recruit, what positions could new recruits get, what were rules aboard royal navy ships? Any other small details could help as well. Thank you

1 Answers 2018-11-17

When and who decided what words were dirty? How were “curse” or “cuss” words born?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Is it accurate to consider the Norwegian settlement of Iceland to be colonization?

1 Answers 2018-11-17

Why didn't Russia discover America? With Alaska being so close to Russia what did they think the land to the east was?

Curious why Russia never ventured east. Maybe they did and I am missing something but it would make sense as they were much closer to North America than the Spanish Portuguese were.

1 Answers 2018-11-16

2282 / 7255

Back to start