What value was of Vimy Ridge for the Canadians in WW1? Also, is the victory a large reason why Canada finally had its own voice on the world stage instead of Britian deciding everything for them?

Sorry if I seem like a knucklehead. I have a limited grasp on the extent of WW1 history.

1 Answers 2018-10-17

A question about Viking age Icelandic law and Njal saga. What exactly was the issue with removing a certain number of judges from a trial?

So, towards the end of the Njal saga there's a courtroom drama where the accusing side attempts to discredit the defending side on the basis that they have bribed their lawyer. So Mord, who is leading the accusing side, demands that 6 judges are removed from the those presiding over the case, and the rest of the judges pronounce the verdict.

Apparently, that was a huge mistake, and he should have removed 12 judges instead, so the total of the remaining judges if three dozen. That was apparently not very widely known (it seems there are very few people among lawyers and other judges that are aware of this), yet a grave enough mistake that threatened to make all of the accusing side (the good guys) exiles and outlaws, effective immediately. Questions:

What were the reasons behind removing judges from the case? How did this practice work?

And why was it so grave a mistake that people could have literally gotten themselves killed over this?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

Historians write that Emperor Hirohito's "Jeweled Voice Broadcast" was comprised of very complex and antiquated Japanese. How different was "courtly" Japanese compared to vernacular Japanese at the time?

Waving aside the fact that his voice was recorded on a record which was then played over the radio, thus making his speech even harder to understand, what exactly was so difficult for the ordinary Japanese person to understand regarding his speech? Was it vocabulary, conjugation, pronunciation? I know that Imperial Japan was trying to retain its samurai traditions, so would the English equivalent be as if, I don't know, Henry VIII was resurrected and decided to speak to a 1940s British public?

Maybe I'm not looking in the right place or not hard enough, but I'm not getting any explanation as to what exactly made it sound so anachronistic, or even an inkling of what I could equate it to.

4 Answers 2018-10-17

Is there evidence of religions believing in giants/gods/generally large more powerful beings due to finding dinosaur bones?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

What was the process of turning Tenochtitlan into Mexico City like? Was the city demolished at once or was it dismantled in neighborhood by neighborhood? How long did it take?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

I am doing a performance based on the hiroshima bombings. What facts and event leading up to the bombings do i need to know to be able to truly grasp the magnituide of the event?

3 Answers 2018-10-17

Why do we see civilization emerging first in the Middle East, one of the most hostile places for agriculture?

My understanding is that humans, as we know them now had moved deep into Europe and Asia by 20,000 years ago. Was this just luck of the draw or were there other contributing factors to large kindoms arising out of the deserts?

2 Answers 2018-10-17

What would be a good academic book on Greek mythology?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

The Romans looked at Germania as an expensive place to conquer that wouldn't bring in enough revenue to be worthwhile. But 500 years later, Charlemagne gladly conquered Bavaria and Saxony. Had the Germans become rich and worth conquering? What did Charlemagne see that the Romans did not?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

Was Stalin Murdered?

I had heard vaguely that it was believed by some that Stalin, who officially died of a stroke in 1953, may have died as a result of exposure to Polonium in his clothing.

Is there a definitive answer for this mystery?

2 Answers 2018-10-17

Looking for recommendations

[deleted]

2 Answers 2018-10-17

How much do you have to know about history to earn a degree in history, let alone a masters or phd?

I've been thinking about this for a while now. Does every historian just have an overview of history and have specified areas where they know much more or do they all have an insanely in-depth view of every event? Obviously this varies on what degree you have and if you've pursued a phd, but I'd like to know how difficult the tests are and how well read the average historian has to be.

3 Answers 2018-10-17

In terms of historical events, how did languages such as German come about?

I learned in school that it has something to do with the fall of Rome and Barbarians being displaced by the Huns? This could all be completely wrong though, so I'm hoping for a more thorough answer?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

Would a peasant farmer in Medieval Britain (1100 - 1400 AD) have known the day, date, month and year of the present moment?

My dad and I were debating whether a medieval farmer in Britain would have been able to keep track of their birthday, or calendar dates such as Christmas day.

1 Answers 2018-10-17

In 1800 Reverend William Linn published a pamphlet attacking Thomas Jefferson,urging Americans not to elect him as president citing among others his "comments on the Indian and Negro race which excluded him "from any department among Christians.". What views was he referring to?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

Who was the first native people of Anatolia?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

Did the Amaleyktes actually exist?

Is there any corroborating evidence that the people described in the christian bible as the Amaleyktes actually existed?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

What are some good books on the power struggles following the death of Alexander the Great?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

How did Hernan Cortes reward the Tlaxcalans and other allies that fought for him?

I have been reading about the conquista and can't find any evidence of the Tlaxcalans and their allies having any spoils of war after the conquista... Seems like they were treated like any other "Indio" after the war with the aztecs was done.

1 Answers 2018-10-17

What happened to Wilhelm II after Nazi Germany invaded The Netherlands?

He was still alive in that time, did he flee to another country?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

Has anyone estimated the total number of humans to have ever lived on earth?

If so, what are some of the estimates? I'm interested in total number of homo sapiens.

1 Answers 2018-10-17

Why did the Surrender of Japan happen on the USS Missouri instead of Japanese soil? Is there a tradition for nations officially surrounding at sea?

I know there was some controversy about the choice of the USS Missouri as the location for the official surrender, since it was not the most decorated ship in the harbor that day. I am curious to know why the surrender took place aboard a ship at all instead of on land.

Was the location choice following some diplomatic norms or were their practical reasons for not doing it somewhere else? I know the surrender of Germany took place in France and that warships are technically considered the sovereign territory of the flag they fly under. Did the surrender need to occur at an allied location?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

Athens and Sparta are well-documented throughout mainstream history regarding everything from their various lifestyles to their military, but what can you tell me about the lesser known states of ancient Greece, e.g. Boeotia and the city of Thespiae?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

What is known about Aztecs before their arrival to Mexico?

I’ve read a while ago that Nahua people came to modern day Mexico somewhere from the north. Is anything know about that time period in their history?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

What is the song "All The Young Dudes" by David Bowie about? What is a dude? What is the news?

1 Answers 2018-10-17

⯇ 2337 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start