Has there been anytime during her life from 962-1806 that the HRE had been United, it could even have be in the first year of her foundation by Otto the Great, i just wish to know, thanks for any response and this is my first time here so of someone else gave an answer then could you link it please?

Thank you for any response

1 Answers 2022-06-03

Why did they attack 5 different beaches on D-day instead of sending all the troops to one beach?

My cousin brought up this point and I don’t think it would have been a better way, I just don’t know why it wouldn’t be

1 Answers 2022-06-03

If World War One was poorly coordinated by outdated generals, how should the generals have approached the tactics?

1 Answers 2022-06-03

Best of May Voting Thread

13 Answers 2022-06-02

The Pompeii "Cave Canem" dog appears to be executing the "bow" behavior modern domestic dogs display when soliciting playtime. Was this likely an intended tongue-in-cheek joke, or simply a disconnect with our understanding of canine behavior today compared to how it was viewed in antiquity?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

Why did so many more English than French colonists settle in North America in the 17th and 18th centuries despite France having 4 to 5 times the population of England in that same period?

2 Answers 2022-06-02

I'm a Roman Naval Officer. Why?

I never got an answer to my question so I thought I'd bring it up again!

From an outsider's glance, it seems there are a variety of benefits from joining the Roman Army as a member of the equestrian class, with opportunities for battle, prestige, and even a chance for political power or in the imperial period, the Emperorship!

Meanwhile, the navy seemed relegated to a second-class service where you'd be commanding mostly non-Romans, primarily fighting pirates (I'm guessing less loot there versus sacking a Persian city), and there doesn't really seem to be a Navy->Emperorship pipeline

So, if I am an ambitious young eques, why would I consider a career in the Navy over the Army? Would certain families or regions groom their young men for the navy? Were the benefits more considerable than it seems?

Much appreciated in advance!

2 Answers 2022-06-02

Did Lenin and Stalin ally with Germany, promote the Nazis over the German communists, and aid violation of the Treaty of Versailles, for the purpose of starting WWII, believing it would be the best way to spread communism?

If so, why isn't it part of the "standard" WWII narrative? If not, why might Richard Pipes have claimed this in "Communism: A History?" He frequently quotes primary sources for states of mind and subjective experiences, but he also makes a lot of claims in a somewhat off-hand way.

2 Answers 2022-06-02

i am a beggar during the middle ages and i had a vision of god telling me to follow the clerical vocation. realistically, how would I go about being ordained as a priest/nun?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

Did any US fratricide incidents during the Gulf War involve US Marine Corps artillery?

Were there any US fratricide incidents in the Gulf War that involved USMC artillery?  I’ve looked at all the online sites and reports Google came up with but, of all the fratricide incidents in those sources, none of them seem to have been caused by Marine Corps artillery.

I ask because a friend of mine mentioned that he was involved in one when he was assigned to a Marine Reserve artillery unit deployed in theater. He didn't actually say what role he or his unit played in the incident, so I'm making an assumption it was his unit that fired the rounds, but I don't actually know. He was very down on Memorial Day and he carries a lot of guilt about it. I don’t want to press him for details but I would like to know a little so I have context when he does talk about it.  Sent from my iPhone

1 Answers 2022-06-02

Side gigs for Historians?

First time poster here on r/AskHistorians.

My question is do any of you have any (income earning) side gigs based on your love of history/history degree?

I’m sure I’ll get some part time professors and bloggers, and I know volunteering is an option, but I’m curious to know what options are out there.

I have a non history day job, (BA in History, Masters in Policy) but really want to put my hobby of researching and wanting to writing about history to use.

1 Answers 2022-06-02

Was 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea based on the CSS Hunely?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

Why use the term “Anglo-American” on a Texas state marker in 1936?

One of my ancestors is mentioned on a Texas state marker as being the first “Anglo-American” born there. I’d always assumed this was Texas’s way of saying “first white child,” but in my own research I learned this term was supposed to specifically designate someone born in England or of English ancestry. This lead me down a rabbit hole of reading about anglo-saxonism and some other racist ideologies that popped up around that time.

My family was Irish. So … had this just become a blanket term for “white” by then or did the state just decide to call us English?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

If I wanted to do a tour of the locations of India where Alexander the Great's campaign was, where would you advise me to go?

Later this year I plan to do a tour of the areas of india where Alexander the Great would have ventured and fought the ancient Indian leaders/warriors. I am not a hardcore historian, but I enjoy learning about history. I know very little about Alexander's campaign of India, but reading up a little on it, I am intrigued and want to know and learn more, and especially visit the key locations, both of the battles and where the Indian leaders of the time would have lived. I would love some suggestions on this if you can provide it. Thank you.

1 Answers 2022-06-02

Bijan Stephen host of the Eclipsed Podcast on r/askhistorians

3 Answers 2022-06-02

What kinds of things have preindustrial peoples used for sunscreen?

This morning, I find myself with a sunburn that makes me want to die covering most of my back, and the thought came to me, that getting sunburnt is something id never considered about living in the past. And, now I'm curious. What kinds of things people in the past have used for sunscreen? This isnt specific to one people or time period. If you have any knowledge on this subject feel free to share it

1 Answers 2022-06-02

Why did US prohibition of alcohol seem to require a constitutional amendement in 1919, but 50 years later, Congress was able to prohibit a variety of substances (Marijuana, etc) with a mere act?

6 Answers 2022-06-02

What is the current view on the crisis of the late middle ages in historiography?

In 1966, Leopold Genicot wrote: "Crisis is the word which comes immediately to the historian's mind when he thinks of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries." I was wondering if the general view changed since then. Is the concept "crisis of the late middle ages" still used today? Or did its meaning change?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | June 02, 2022

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

7 Answers 2022-06-02

How did humans understand evolution and heredity before Darwin?

It's been thousands of years since our ancestors domesticated animals and plants. Farmers and breeders have been producing more "useful" species long before biologists, but Darwin (1809-1882) published his On the Origin of Species as late as 1859. So how was it like before Darwin? How much did they know, and how much they didn't?

2 Answers 2022-06-02

Could Anne of Cleves had remarried after her annulment?

After her marriage to Henry VIII was annulled, was it a possibility for her to get remarried? Do we know why she didn’t?

edit: have not had in the title

1 Answers 2022-06-02

How were wisdom teeth dealt with before the rise of modern dental care?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

A lot of early modern literature, like the Three Musketeers, and War and Peace, were released serially. Did these works have 'fandoms' similar to most modern serialized works like TV shows?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

What did marriage in the Middle Ages look like?

Did poor people like peasants go to the church for their marriage? What did the process of finding a wife look like? Did she come from the same village? I know something about marriage in nobility, but what did it look like for normal people?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

I just saw a video of a gorgeous silver Athenian tetradrachm on another sub (c.440-404 BCE). What could it have purchased at the time of minting?

1 Answers 2022-06-02

234 / 7255

Back to start