How did bald/balding men in Qing China comply with the queue requirement?

Did they wear wigs, or was an exception made for them?

I suppose I also have a related question that’s broader in scope: did enforcement of the queue vary during different periods of Qing rule? As I understand it was originally a tool of social control, so I’m curious if enforcement slackened in periods when insurrection was less of an immediate threat.

1 Answers 2018-08-31

If I am a resident of Kyoto during the Sengoku period, where would I go if my home and livelihood were destroyed?

My understanding is (please correct me if I'm wrong) that Kyoto at the beginning of the Sengoku period had a population of a about 100,000, but by the end of it, only had a population of 2,000 after the city was captured and recaptured numerous times by various daimyos. Is there any particular place refugees of Kyoto might have gone to?

2 Answers 2018-08-31

Historically, how often were swords actually used in combat, and what was the lifespan of a "working" sword?

edit Let's narrow the time/place down to 17th century Europe.

2 Answers 2018-08-31

Just how repressive was the Tsarist regime?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-08-31

Recommended reading for late Greece / rise of Macedon (picking up after Xenephon's Hellenika)

I've been getting into Greek history and read Thucydides' Histories and most of the way through Xenephon's Hellenika: have been backing these up with some wider contextual books (e.g. https://www.amazon.co.uk/Creators-Conquerors-Citizens-History-Ancient/dp/0198727887 and https://www.amazon.co.uk/Oxford-History-Greece-Hellenistic-World/dp/0192801376/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1535711094&sr=1-2&keywords=oxford+guide+ancient+greece) and watching Donald Kagan's lecture series (https://oyc.yale.edu/classics/clcv-205)

​

I am obviously massively spoilt by having had Thucydides and Xenephon for the period so far, but not sure the best sources for the period between them and Arrian's Anabasis. Are there any good (not horrendously expensive university library only) books, lectures etc. on this period I should check out? Feels like there's a relative gap here (and I suspect I'll hit another one between the death of Alexander and Polybius, but that's a problem for a few months hence!)

1 Answers 2018-08-31

Why did Odoacer want to become a vassal of the Eastern Roman Empire?

He invaded the Western Roman Empire and slaughtered thousands of Romans. What made him think that the Eastern Roman Empire would WANT him as a vassal?

2 Answers 2018-08-31

How Did European Colonialist Who Believed in Their Own Race Supremacy Deal with the Notion of Historical Great Eastern/African Civilisations?

The title maybe isn’t so clear, let me elaborate.

The theory of European racial supremacy no doubt fuelled many instances of colonialism amongst less developed societies, but how did these same people reconcile their beliefs with great non-European historical civilisations and achievements?

Examples such as:

  • Genghis Khan
  • Mansa Musa
  • Chinese Civilisation

And all the countless more before their time.

How did they understand these societies in relation to their beliefs?

1 Answers 2018-08-31

Why did nobody invented the arch in Ancient America?

Virtually the whole civilized world developed the arch - and therefore the dome - except of the civilizations of Pre-Hispanic America. Why? What prevented them to do so?

1 Answers 2018-08-31

Why did Japan attack Pearl Harbor?

From what I've read it seemed like most Americans were opposed to entering the war in Europe. It seems like eventually the US would have had to enter the war, but what was Japan's motivation for an unprovoked attack on the US? Ive also read some stuff saying that the US knew the attack was coming and allowed it to happen to stir up nationalism and pro war sentiment, like the sinking of the Lusitania in WW1. (Not saying the US allowed that to happen, but that event gave way to the US joining the war.)

2 Answers 2018-08-31

Until Clinton's presidency in the 90s, California voted mainly Republican senators and governors and Texas voted mainly Democrat ones. During and since Clinton, California has voted mainly Democrat and Texas has voted Republican. What caused this drastic switch?

2 Answers 2018-08-31

How severe was the grossness/disgust factor in the Pillory/Stocks punishment? How did they use the restroom while confined there? Were dead animals really thrown at them, or was that a rare event or a myth?

Are there any records of someone vomitting in there from the disgust aspects?

I feel like most modern depictions of it are extremely sanitized. And yes, I know on occasion the crowd would throw rocks if they really hated the person and it could get dangerous, but I thought the "disgust" aspect was more common.

Just curious how bad it would have truly been and if it ever led to vomiting or worse from the criminal!

1 Answers 2018-08-31

How do you STRUCTURE a historical essay?

If it's about a historical event do you summarise it from start to finish in one paragraph then flesh it out with body paragraphs?

5 Answers 2018-08-31

Why is there so much on the medieval or ancient history of Western Europe, but virtually nothing on medieval Hungary, who had one the greatest and largest kingdoms?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-08-31

What did Judaism in pre-Christian Ethiopia/Axum look like?

In terms of daily practice and general beliefs, what would one expect from an Ethiopian Jew prior to Ezana's conversion of his empire to Christianity? How would he observe the Sabbath, for example?

More broadly, are there any really good books about religion and culture in Ethiopia in that era? What should I be reading if I want to get a sense of that time and place?

1 Answers 2018-08-31

Why wasn't there a workers movement in the United States like there was in Russia?

We've been talking about industrialization in my history class, and the horrible conditions for workers and drastic inequality. I'm just wondering what made it so there wasn't a stronger proletariat movement, or were unions supposed to be the effective equivalent?

1 Answers 2018-08-31

Did the Mongol Invasion of China stop innovation in China? There seems to be almost no innovation after the fall of the Song dynasty, and this appears to be why Europe eventually became more advanced than China.

​

1 Answers 2018-08-31

Country of Jordan lush greenery once?

Several years ago, I went through a guided tour of Jordan, and Petra. Petra is awesome Btw. However from Aman, where our tour started, the tour guide talked about the desert landscape while we were headed for Petra. He had said that the Ottoman Empire(?) In present day Turkey wanted a railway that connected to the rest of Europe. They built it through present day Jordan. In doing so, they harvested 1 million acres of woodland to be used in building the railway. In doing this, there were serious climate changes. What was once a lush forest became a desert, rainfall basically disappeared, creating the desert we know now. My question to any of the scholars out there. Were we (the other tourists and I) being fed a line bullshit or is this fact?

1 Answers 2018-08-31

In his opening statement at the Nuremberg Trials, Robert Jackson said "These men created in Germany, under the "Führerprinzip", a National Socialist despotism equalled only by the dynasties of the ancient East." To what dynasties was he referring to? Is the comparison valid?

1 Answers 2018-08-31

When did American citizens find out about the plan to drop nuclear bombs on Japan? What was there reaction?

1 Answers 2018-08-30

Why did Victorian dresses have big, puffy shoulders?

Sorry if the question could be worded better but I think of women's dresses from say 1880 and they have puffy shoulders and it's strange that if they wanted women to look feminine but also not sultry, they had the corset and heavy, wide skirt with the frame but they also had puffy shoulders to make them look like football players. Not exactly feminine?

1 Answers 2018-08-30

Origin of stepping on cracks in the pavement leading to bad luck?

I was able to find the unfortunate, racist origins of "step on the crack, break your mother's back" (involving variants of her or your future children being Black), but not the reason that stepping on cracks was considered unlucky in the first place. The previous saying dates to the 19th century, but is the superstition older? I can't imagine people walking cobblestone streets being able to avoid the cracks without playing a never-ending game of hopscotch...

1 Answers 2018-08-30

With casualties so high on Omaha Beach during D-Day, why didn't Aliied troops divert to, say, Utah Beach?

After intial reports came in telling strong resistence, wouldn't it make sense to skirt around to a less defended beach, or would that throw off the timetable, or, make logistics impossible for so many troops to land in another zone?

2 Answers 2018-08-30

How did we lose Greek Fire?

"The composition of Greek fire remains a matter of speculation and debate..." - Greek Fire's Wikipedia.

How did this come about? Wikipedia describes the Byzantine Greek version as a flamethrower. I see that as an effective weapon. Wouldn't this usefulness have kept its contents known to humanity?

1 Answers 2018-08-30

When did rhyming in music become popular?

1 Answers 2018-08-30

What role did universities play in the Scientific Revolution?

I know this is an incredibly broad question. I'm mainly interested in two particular aspects of it: how, if at all, were the major figures we imagine as spearheading the Scientific Revolution in early modern Europe affiliated with universities, and what role did universities play in propagating (or perhaps even hindering the propagation of) the new science?

1 Answers 2018-08-30

⯇ 2427 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start