Recently, changes made to the AP World History course have been met with controversy due to a reduction in the focus and scope of what was to be considered "World History," notably not having it begin until 1450 making it essentially colonial world history.
In light of that controversy, what does an ideal World History course look like? What events, civilizations and people are crucial to know about that might not otherwise be taught? And how much of it can reasonably be put in a single history course?
Put another way, what is the "history of the world" that everyone should be at least cursory aware of?
I know this is more of a meta question, let me know if it breaks rules.
3 Answers 2018-08-30
2 Answers 2018-08-30
Beethoven named his 3rd symphony after Napoleon, and then when Napoleon invaded Germany he scratched out the name so hard on the original manuscript that it left a hole. Now the symphony is called Eroica.
Do we know if Napoleon ever heard the symphony? And do we know what he thought of having a piece of music named after him?
1 Answers 2018-08-30
Who did Knights Hospitaller and Knights Templar fight in say 1297 or around that year? I currently think groups of them fought independently for I am not sure who.
1 Answers 2018-08-30
Time: Peak Roman Empire (AD 117-395)
Place: Roman frontiers, campaign area.
After scouring 4 years of archive, I think I can ask a few questions which have not been asked much lately.
Context: writing fiction, need plausible things to happen around my character while he's on march.
2 Answers 2018-08-30
I understand that it probably varied greatly across regions and periods, but I'm interested in answers from whatever area and timeframe.
I am wondering about things like:
1 Answers 2018-08-30
Recently I read through Cortes' letters (https://www.historians.org/teaching-and-learning/teaching-resources-for-historians/teaching-and-learning-in-the-digital-age/the-history-of-the-americas/the-conquest-of-mexico/letters-from-hernan-cortes) and bernal diaz del castillo's "true history of the conquest of new spain." It seems like the Spanish won an awful lot of battles against long odds. Is it true that there were only 500 or so Spanish, with only 20 or so of musketeers and crossbows? if so, how did they keep winning battles against thousands of native americans? they all seem to get wounded a lot, too - how did they avoid dying of their wounds/sickness? in del castillo's account they also seem to get into battles every other day - didn't they get tired or mentally broken or develop PTSD? a lot of it seems hard to believe. Are these accounts well-regarded for their accuracy? did the Spanish actually fight dozens of battles against 100 to 1 odds or is this historical embellishment?
1 Answers 2018-08-30
I saw this post today sowing the evolution of the Latin alphabet. What caught my eye is the fact that many of the characters seem to be mirror images of one another, save for an extra line here or one less line there in each character.
When and why did this happen? Did it perhaps have anything to do with printing/reproduction innovations?
1 Answers 2018-08-30
Reading through the wikipedia on Chinese Mathematics, I came across a myriad of surprises including:
"Si-yüan yü-jian (《四元玉鑒》), or Jade Mirror of the Four Unknowns, was written by Zhu Shijie in 1303 AD and marks the peak in the development of Chinese algebra. The four elements, called heaven, earth, man and matter, represented the four unknown quantities in his algebraic equations. It deals with simultaneous equations and with equations of degrees as high as fourteen."
A main takeaway I get from this article is that Chinese mathematics was not motivated by the beauty of mathematics or its theory (most things were left unproven), but by purely practical concerns of astronomy and engineering. What practical problem warranted a 14th degree equation?
Bonus: Do we know how much paper it would take and how long somebody could take calculating such a thing?
Edit: Wow, thank you for all the responses so far, guys! I have a newfound urge to take abstract algebra and learn to use a 算盘.
However, the main question still remains unanswered. What tangible problem motivated such computationally intense procedure?
Edit 2: Oh, it appears one use was to measure the dimensions of walled cities. Thank you.
3 Answers 2018-08-30
So he knew that he will be attacked by Harald Hardrada and by William the bastard and yet he tried to fight both of them.
Why such a decision?
3 Answers 2018-08-30
Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:
Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
...And so on!
Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.
6 Answers 2018-08-30
It was such huge empire and I guess its hard to control. Did they have an inteilligence service?
If yes, how was it different from current intelligence.
1 Answers 2018-08-30
Of the four assassinated US presidents, Kennedy was more or less killed instantly, and Garfield and McKinley died essentially of sepsis (which today one would hope wouldn't be the case).
In contrast to both of these extremes, Lincoln died the day after being shot. Have medical historians examined his case? Was his situation something that might have had a different outcome with modern medical practices?
1 Answers 2018-08-30
3 Answers 2018-08-30
Isn't this a myth? Maybe /u/Overunderrated knows?
1 Answers 2018-08-30
1 Answers 2018-08-30
1 Answers 2018-08-30
1 Answers 2018-08-30
What does respect signify here?
1 Answers 2018-08-30
In old books and such - I'm thinking 18th and 19th century here - people would sometimes switch or change horses in the middle of a journey. How the heck would this work? Horses are not fungible.
**Edit in response to one comment. I'm referring to the situation where one rider has a long distance to go, and mounts one horse, rides it for a certain distance, and then switches to a new, fresh horse that is found at some waypoint, leaving the first horse behind. If we're talking about the Pony Express, it's easy to guess that there's no trouble at all in switching from one company horse to another. But if it's a private individual, it would seem like a horse switch would involve quite a bit of bargaining at the very least to establish the differing values of two horses.
(There's one question on this in the archives, from 5 years ago, with no authoritative answer.)
1 Answers 2018-08-30
One general sense I get from Iranian historiography is that Iran under the Ikhanate and Timurid dynasties are not really considered Iran in the 'proper' sense.
However it occurs to me that the distinction seems artificial: both states were founded by non Iranian conquerers who eventually adopted the local language and culture. If this sounds at all familiar, this is the same story as the Safavid dynasty.
So in contemporary times, were the Timurids and Ikhanates considered kings of Iran, and was the state they ruled considered by outsiders to be Iranian?
1 Answers 2018-08-30
2 Answers 2018-08-30
You can hear it here.
I've always wondered where this came from. It sounds distinctly American to me but I can't say that I really know why I get that impression. I know that I've heard similar utterances made elsewhere but I can't for the life of me remember where.
1 Answers 2018-08-30
He goes on to say that chariots had an incredible amount of problems, they were time consuming to build, they were incredibly hard to control and they would easily get bogged down in mud. I can't help but wonder how effective these formations were.
1 Answers 2018-08-30