In WW2, German infantry doctrine revolved around the LMG, and the entire squad was meant to support it. American infantry doctrine revolved around the riflemen and integrated support elements. Soviet infantry doctrine revolved around SMG's. What was British and Japanese infantry doctrine like?

​EDIT: Oh my god guys thank you so much this is so much more than I had ever hoped for.

10 Answers 2018-08-23

Why didn't air instruments pass on from jazz to later music genres when string and percussion instruments did?

For example the saxophone and trumpets were popular in jazz, but didn't really go on to rock, whereas the double bass became the electric bass and the drums remained

1 Answers 2018-08-23

How were the Colonies of antiquity established?

For instance, the Greeks established colonies on islands in the Aegean, Ionia, and Sicily, while the Carthaginians later established colonies in Spain and other various regions. Were these colonies State or City-State sponsored ventures with a clear economic or political purpose? Additionally, what was the actual process of colonization like, given that there would presumably be native populations in the colonized areas hostile to foreign colonies. Were these colonization efforts aided by large military forces or did they consist largely of militia's?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

If William Shakespeare made up new words for his works, how did contemporary playgoers understand his dialogue

If, as it has been said, William Shakespeare invented hundreds of new words for use in his plays, how did his contemporary audience know what he meant

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Romans usually left the unwanted babies in trash places to die or at the doors of rich families to be slaves. How true is that early christians from Roma “collected” the abandoned kids from trash places and saves them ?

Recently I was reading some posts online (in spanish) that explained how Romans left unwanted babies at trash places or at the doors of the rich families. It also specified that early christians collected the babies to save them, however there was no source for the info. Which is why I’m here. Is this true? How was this viewed by society at the time? Is there anything important to know about it?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | August 23, 2018

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

5 Answers 2018-08-23

Why were Ancient Roman government officials immune from persecution until they left office?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Did leaders really give rousing speeches to their soldiers before entering battles?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

What do we know about Native American tribes’ interactions with alligators in the southeastern US?

I was thinking today about Native American tribes that lived in Florida (and the southeast US in general) and wondered how they dealt with alligators in their daily life. Did they hunt them? Avoid them? Were alligators of any religious significance? Was there any Native American mythology/legend surrounding their existence? Thank you!

1 Answers 2018-08-23

What role did Caesar play in the fall of the Republic of Rome?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Did the Confederacy have economists? As in an academic body that tried to analyze/maximize/debate for slavery?

As in my understanding the southern states dependence on slavery created a long term ineffecient reliance on manual labor in contrast to the Norths growing industrial capacity.

Did southern intelligenta try to defend slavery on economic terms?

I.e where there pro and anti slavery economist camps?

How did these exchanges/debates look like?

Where there prominent economic scholars that a modern reader could read about?

How did political bodies/parties/groups use or meet economic theories on slavery?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

In Revisionist History, Gladwell claims that, prior to Brown v Board of Education, black schools were no worse than white schools and the narrative that they were was, itself, racist propaganda. How much truth is there in this perspective?

In the podcast, he basically says that the education at most black schools was fine, and that the intent of the civil rights movement wasn't about getting kids into the 'good' schools, but rather breaking down racial barriers. He makes the accusation that, while the Supreme Court ruling to desegregate was correct, the stated reason that it irreparably damaged black children was not in line with the stated reasons by the civil rights movement and itself represented racist sentiment among the justices.

It's an interesting idea, and one I've never heard before. I was taught in school that black schools were almost always underfunded and understaffed; is Gladwell's perspective accurate?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Books about the Borgias and the Medicis

Hi everyone,

I'm not sure I'm in the right place here but I wanted to create a post to know if you have some indications about books dealing with Borgia's and Medicis' families.

​

I'm interested by these families and the Renaissance and I would like to visit Italy with a kind of background about them.

​

Thank you for tips and sorry for my english!

​

Tak

2 Answers 2018-08-23

At its most desperate, how thin were the Red Army lines on the West side of the Volga during the battle for Stalingrad?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Was the Ukrainian famine of 1932-1933 caused by collectivization, or is it, how some socialists claim, merely a very unfortunate year harvest-wise?

I have recently come across many arguments, mostly among socialists, that 1932 was simply an unfortunate accident, and that deaths from starvation were simply caused due to a great shortage of grain supply that was prioritized over urban areas as opposed rural areas.

In addition, they argue that collectivization is not to blame for the famine - according to their sources, notably Mark Touger's 'The 1932 Harvest and the Famine of 1933', the 1932 quanta was reduced from 22.4 million tons to 18.1 million tons, alleviating the difference by increasing the quota from sovkhozes, and that overall grain procurement was reduced 30%. And that furthermore, exports were halved in response.

How much truth or falsehood is there to these arguments?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Considering the fact that Austria existed before Germany, that they were for a long time the emperor of the Holy Roman Empire and the most powerful country in what is today Germany, how is it that German is called German and not Austrian?

EDIT: I'm talking about the language, just to clarify.

2 Answers 2018-08-23

John Graham's book 'Blood Money: The Civil War and the Federal Reserve' makes the claim that "the Civil War would not have happened had it not been planned and fomented by Northern capitalists."

the amazon page full description:

https://www.amazon.com/Blood-Money-Civil-Federal-Reserve/dp/1589803981/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_product_top?ie=UTF8

"The author chronicles how the divisive antagonisms between the North and South, finally erupting in the spring of 1861, were deliberately agitated by great international banking houses with the goal of provoking secession. According to Graham, these private interests fully succeeded and set up a huge financial empire centered on Wall Street, using public debt as the source of their wealth. This watershed book explores the economic causes of the Civil War, revealing how the Civil War would not have happened had it not been planned and fomented by Northern capitalists."

I'm seeing this book used to justify the wider claim that the civil war was not about state's rights to own slaves. How true is this and the book's claims?

2 Answers 2018-08-23

Why did civilizations thrive in Persia and the Near East, given large parts are deserts or otherwise inhospitable, geographically?

From the very ancient civilizations, to the Persians, to the muslim conquests: the Near East has been the center of the world for much of World History. Given it's rather barren geography compared to for instance Europe, this seems odd.

Is my conception of the Near East distorted, and is it actually more fertile and resource-rich than I imagine it to be? Or is there another reason that civilizations were able to thrive there?

4 Answers 2018-08-23

Soviet Foreign Policy 1920-1926

I am currently writing a paper on how Stalin's assumption of power influenced Soviet foreign policy during the 20's. Any suggestions on good sources (Specifically about 'Socialism in one country') or in general about the topic?
Thank you

​

1 Answers 2018-08-23

How important was it to the fighting and eventual outcome of the Civil War that the Union’s Capital, Washington DC, was in the heart of Dixie, vs a city much farther north?

Obviously the defense of the capital, and it’s being a constant objective for the Confederate Army’s dictated where many of the great battles were fought. Would the Union have been less aggressive if defense of Washington was not paramount. How deeply would into the North would the war extend? Would the psychology of the Citizens of the North been less protective of maintaining the Union, if it did not mean the capital would sit so close to the border?

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Did Queen Maria Theresa and Frederick the Great meet each other after the 7 years war? If yes, then what was her reaction/thought of the meeting?

​

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Filial Piety in Joseon Korea

I've been reading about Hwaseong Fortress in Suwon and how it was built as a result of filial piety King Jeongjo had towards his father, Prince Sado. However, from the memoirs of Sado's wife, Lady Hyegyeong, it seems obvious that Sado was a terrible person (he raped, murdered, and tortured people on the regular), as well as had severe mental health issues that made him afraid/anxious (to the point of harming others) about things as simple as getting dressed in the morning.

​

My question is, why would Jeongjo want to build something to honor such a monster? I'm assuming it has to do something to do with Korea's deep sense of Confucianism at the time. I also guess Jeongjo probably had a bit of trauma from his father's execution when he was eleven (Sado was forced into a rice chest by King Yeongjo, Sado's father and Jeongjo's grandfather, until he died seven days later). If anyone has a fuller answer, please let me know.

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Does anyone know of interesting primary sources that capture Lenin's consolidation of power?

I was wondering if anyone had any illuminating primary sources that captured the essence or details of how Bolshevik power was consolidated between 1917-1924 (before Stalin came to power). For me it was easy to find information on Stalinist Russia but I'm finding it difficult to picture Russia under Lenin.

1 Answers 2018-08-23

Hey! When was the first time those little preservative packets that show up in ramen, vitamins and other food items first appeared? Who the figured it out it would make good sense to put them there??

1 Answers 2018-08-23

How were Beethoven and other classical composers viewed during their time?

One thing I’ve noticed is that in today’s world the pop stars are generally the ones in the spotlight as composers mostly lurk in the background.

It made me wonder if the currently well-known composers of the past were in a similar situation, or if their popularity exceeded that of the famous singers during their time.

1 Answers 2018-08-23

⯇ 2440 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start