[META] Giving to thank the moderation team.

The moderation team of this subreddit does a tremendous job, their enforcement of the rules is the key reason why this sub is of such high quality. I wanted to show my appreciation for their work and was wondering what would be the best way to show support with my wallet.

At first I thought about buying reddit gold for moderators, but oftentimes I see redditors who receive gold edit their comment to say that they would rather have the money go towards something else like a charity or foundation.

This is why I'm creating this thread, I want to know if the moderation team has any preference as to how to show our gratitude. For example, I thought users who want to thank the team could make a donation in the name of /r/AskHistorians to a related foundation, museum or charity, and would like to know if the mods have any preferences towards any organisation.

Comment with your thoughts and ideas.

6 Answers 2018-07-27

What kind of carpenter was Jesus?

The bible doesn't really address it as far as I know. Did he build wooden houses, make furniture, or was he a repairman for wooden structures?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

Looking for WWII book.

My grandpa is old, in a home, his wife died and I just visited him for the first time since I'm back in the states.

I saw he was only excited talking from the books he was reading about WWII and my mom says that's the only thing that interests him.

So I turn to you, community of 'History'...what book can you recommend?

Thanks!

EDIT: I appreciate all the replies, thanks!

5 Answers 2018-07-27

US - Schools named after a person

Are most schools in America named after a person? If so, is there a reason behind this?

Ex) in Tennessee (where I am), a handful of schools are named after a certain person (Vanderbilt University, John Overton High School, Scarritt-Bennett College,...).

Some additional questions to elaborate on this (you don't need to answer them individually. I want to communicate my meandering thoughts):

  • Is this characteristic of American schools? Is this found in other countries/cultures?

  • Is there any history, reason, or timeframe behind this trend?

  • Does this depend on geography? (Maybe just in the south?)

  • Is there a list of typical motivations? (e.g. to honor someone, because of donations, because the land belonged to someone, etc.)

  • I've heard that a school named after a confederate general is currently changing their name after Obama; why not just name it after the neighborhood or something else?

Thanks so much.

edit - thank you for the robust answers <3 I've had a lot of fun reading them.

2 Answers 2018-07-27

We often see cases of English and American speakers mocking or least noting each how eacj other's accents and vocabulary differ. Is there any evidence that this used to happen with Latin when it was spoken throughout the Roman Empire, or even later?

Of course, today's world offers more opportunity to encounter speaker of the same language from different nations. But I reckon educated people of the time were also in contact with other nations' inhabitants who spoke the same language?

2 Answers 2018-07-27

Names of commoners in the Late Roman Republic

I'm doing research for a book and am having trouble answering this question definitively. Would common farmers and laborers in Rome during the Civil War period have used the tria nomina as aristocrats would? After the inclusion of the Latins/Social War, they were citizens, so they would have been sorted into voting tribes/gens- leading me to think they would have used the nomen in addition to personal names. I inferred that common nomen would have been used for commoners as well as the aristocracy, but I worry I am missing something. Any insights on this are greatly appreciated. Thanks.

1 Answers 2018-07-27

Friday Free-for-All | July 27, 2018

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

7 Answers 2018-07-27

Why do Judaism and Islam both have religious dietary restrictions but not Christianity?

Also periods of religious fasting? Why does this still apply to two of the three abrahamic religions but not the other, especially since that's the 'middle' one as it were?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

In the film 'Last of the Mohicans', during the penultimate scene, the character Hawkeye visits the hostile Huron village and is able to converse with them, using a belt-like item as part of an empassioned plea. What is this item and does it have any basis in historical reality?

The film is set in 1757 during the conflicts between Britain and France to control North America. It claims to depict the conflict focusing on the lives of settlers and the hostilities between the Mohicans and the Hurons.

It is the belt-like item which Hawkeye bears and he claims is a testament of his people and the trustworthiness of his word that interests me. Any other insight into the customs around such an item - if indeed such a thing did exist - would be most welcome.

1 Answers 2018-07-27

How high were the casualty rates in battles between Ancient Greek Hoplites?

I would assume that the answer would vary depending on when and where the fight took place, and who was participating. But in general how bloody an affair was war in the Hellenic world.

My limited understanding on the matter is that battles were largerly a test of strength: with both sides lining up, singing war songs and then clashing against one another. And that the aim was to break the opposing side's fornation, rather than to skewer them with your spear.

But once the formation broke, was that it? Or would would a more chaotic melee ensue?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

Did 'Greece' exist a concept since the founding of the first set of republics through to modern day Greece?

Sorry if my word choice is poor but as I understand Greece is a very new country with a VERY turbulent recent history. But after the original Greece existed and after the Romans / Byzantines (so Romans) then Ottomans inhabited the modern day land of Greece for millennia has the idea of 'Greece' existed for all this time? Or is it a new construct used to foster nationalism and power.

1 Answers 2018-07-27

What changed to make Rifles more effective than Muskets?

My understanding is, by the time of the American Revolution, rifles existed but they were so slow to load that they weren't efficient in battle. However, by the time of the American Civil War, those same soldiers would have consistently used rifles. What were the reasons for the change?

My frame of reference here is the United States, but the question is obviously the broader European world.

2 Answers 2018-07-27

In documentaries about ancient Egypt how realistic are depictions of workers wearing clothes covering only their hips when they are supposed to be under the dessert sun the whole day?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

Was slavery an advantage or disadvantage to US economy in the early 1800s

Hi, pardon my English, it’s not my native language.

I’m trying to tie my head around what economical effects slavery has when compared to free labour (besides the obvious disastrous human effects).

Some research points out that slavery might have (or did) slower the technological advancement due to there being low incentive for slaveholders to invent methods to make working more effective. Other stuff I’ve come around argues otherwise.

Slavery in the American colonies of France was first repealed (at least in legal sense, less in practice) in 1794 and after Napoleons shenanigans with reinstatement again with a final abolition in 1848. The British empire ended slavery in early 19th century. But US kept on until 1863.

Was there any significant economical or technological influence to US for this? Was it an economical advantage or more of an hindrance? Was there diplomatic repercussions to US for holding on to an antiquated and morally bankrupt practice? Is there any sort of consensus among historians whether slavery indeed stalled technological evolution?

I’m guessing, that the timeframe is too narrow to allow any significant technological difference between the US and other nations (since there obviously are a lot of other factors in the game here) but I would very much like to know instead of guessing.

Thank you in advance.

1 Answers 2018-07-27

Coca-cola largely removed the cocaine from its formula in 1903, more than a decade before it was made illegal- why did they do it? Were there negative associations with cocaine at the time? How did its removal affect the drink's popularity?

3 Answers 2018-07-27

Why Were The North African Colonies Of The Roman Empire So Skinny?

To know what I mean just look at a map of the Roman Empire.

1 Answers 2018-07-27

Why my country have this name ?

Hello evryone, as i asked in the title my question is simple, why my country name is Italia? Where did it camed from? (Sorry for my poor english) Thanks to Who Will ghive me a reply !

Edit: The important part of the question was missing, what is the real meaning of the name Italia? Like a fusion of word, a name of a Princess, a new type of boat.. That's what i want to know more!

1 Answers 2018-07-27

What were the critic's responses at the time to the stories written by Robert E. Howard and Edgar Rice Burroughs?

I'm specifically interested in critical responses at the time to the publications of Howard's "Conan" stories and to Burroughs' "Barsoom" novels. Were they well received or were they panned by critics?

Bonus question: Were either of them considered to be financial successes?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

Why did some countries in the balkans have conversions to Islam and others did not during ottoman rule

Bosnia, Albania, and Kosovo have large populations of Muslims. At the same time Serbia was under ottoman rule longer than Bosnia and in some ways influenced more by ottoman culture than Bosnians. Also how peaceful were this conversions?

2 Answers 2018-07-27

How old of a practice is infant baptism (pedobaptism) in Christianity?

I often hear anabaptists argue that infant baptism was not a practice by the much-romanticized "early church" (which, as I understand it, means the 1st century Christian church). How legitimate are those claims? Was baptism understood as an adults-only ritual in the time of Jesus and the apostles? Are anabaptist arguments about "believer's baptism" as a historical practice of the early church defensible from a secular historian's perspective?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

After a harrowing journey starting with her kidnapping, why did Sacagawea not stay with her band and relatives the first time she was reunited with them, instead choosing to continue a dangerous journey with her baby?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

It is said mongol bows draw weight was as high as 166 pounds. That seems incredibly high. Is there any truth to that?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

What was the public’s general reaction to Robert Kennedy being nominated as John F Kennedy’s Attorney General? Did people view this as nepotism, or did most people generally think that Robert Kennedy was qualified for the job?

1 Answers 2018-07-27

Watching Sergeant York, they're using muzzle loading rifles with round bullets in Tennessee 1916. Was that normal?

Watching Sergeant York, they're using muzzle loading (idk if smooth bore or not) rifles with round bullets in Tennessee 1916. Was that normal? Was Tennessee really that much of a poor backwater?

I guess if they were poor they could be using 50-60 year old hand me down guns but doesn't seem quite right.

This is the scene.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCCpRfB5aUU

Also how can one be accurate with a smooth bore rifle at range if the bullet just bounces around inside the gun?

Thx!

1 Answers 2018-07-27

What was Herman Goering (and others) laughing at [Nuremburg Trials]

I posted this in /r/ww2 before I found this sub. What was so funny?

https://www.reddit.com/r/ww2/comments/91z60j/what_was_hermann_goering_laughing_at_nuremburg/

Also someone linked to this photo of another angle of the same gif: https://imgur.com/a/FQ1q34M

I want to know what made everyone (nazis and allies) laugh!

1 Answers 2018-07-27

⯇ 2493 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start