Why does every interesting question asked here have every single comment deleted?

3 Answers 2022-05-18

89 years ago the Nazis burned the library of the Institute of Sex Research. What research was lost and what survived?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Before the advent of baby formula, wealthy women routinely hired wet nurses. What did poor women do? Would other mothers in a town or family or similar have helped out their lactation-challenged acquaintances for free?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

What did the Romans believe eclipses were?

I know the Greeks believed Eclipses were punishments from gods to the kings. But what did Romans believe an eclipse was? Does it have something to do with Sol and Luna?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Did members of the enlightenment ever speak on the genocide of Native Americans by Europeans?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Is there ambiguity in the distinction between primary and secondary sources?

For example, with regards to Winston Churchill’s histories of the world wars, or Trotsky’s history of the Russian Revolution?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

how did my dad avoid service in vietnam?

My dad was born in 1951 and therefore would have been in the 1970 draft lottery. When I was young i recall him telling a story that his number was #110 and that he lucked out because they only went up to number 108 that year. I decided to look this up recently and found that his draft number was in fact #110, BUT I also learned that the draft went up to #125 that year. My father is dead now and im curious about how he avoided service.. Other than failing a physical or a secret history of fleeing to Canada, both of which I believe are unlikely, does any have any further information about how the draft worked and how my father may have avoided service? Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-05-18

There's been a lot of talk here about how medieval Europe was more racially diverse than we think. Would it be out of the question to see a white person in 1000s-1300s Sub-Saharan Africa?

I assume that by the Renaissance there would be plenty of Portuguese and Spanish merchants in Western Africa, but I wonder how likely it would be to see someone of European descent in, say, Mali during Mansa Musa's reign.

1 Answers 2022-05-18

why Michelin started to recommand restaurant while being a tire fabricant?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Do historians intentionally create primary sources for future historians?

Today is tomorrow's yesterday.

This subreddit is fabulous and I enjoy reading your answers to questions on historical events.

But my question is about creating the history of the future.

Do professional historians create documents about current events with the intention that future historians will have reliable primary sources that explain what is happening today from the viewpoint of people living through it today?

For instance, the COVID-19 pandemic and the range of responses to it. Obviously there are a million newspaper articles and political speeches and health records that future historians will review and synthesize. But each of those is intended for today's audience.

Would a professional historian, knowing the types of information and documentation that is required by professional historians, create documents that are intended for an audience of future professional historians? Something like a time-capsules from today's historian intended to help explain our current events to a historian in the future.

Thanks for all your good work in this subreddit.

EDIT: I can't believe the number and variety of great responses I've had to my question.

I'm currently listening to a great history podcast which is currently covering a period about 1000 years ago. (Shout out to "The History of Byzantium" by Robin Pierson)

One of the difficulties of researching that time is the lack of reliable primary sources.

Based on the responses I've gotten, historians 1000 years from now will have the opposite problem - a wealth of resources available for review.

4 Answers 2022-05-18

To what extent did Romano-British culture survive into the Middle Ages? Did Roman culture influence early medieval Welsh and Cornish culture?

I’m interested in the fate of the Romano-Britons and the vestiges of Roman culture on the island of Great Britain in the period following the departure of Roman authorities and during the formative years of Anglo-Saxon settlement. My rough understanding drawn from media such as The Last Kingdom and other fictional depictions of the period was that the future Welsh/Cornish peoples held onto a sense of their Roman-influenced heritage long into the period of Germanic occupation. Indeed, the consensus appears to be that most famous Welsh folk legend, that of King Arthur, seems to be widely held to be a corruption of legends surrounding the lives of post-Roman Britonnic leaders fighting the investing Anglo-Saxons. However, the map heading the Wikipedia article on Romano-British culture seems to indicate that the future Wales and Cornwall were among the least romanized regions of Roman Britain. Later in the same article is another map showing that the Britons has already lost control of the most romanized areas of the island by the 6th century and we’re beginning to be restricted to Wales, Devon, Cornwall, the Lake District, and Galloway. This leads me to a few questions. If the areas where Brittonic language and culture survived after Anglo-Saxon settlement were the least romanized areas of former Roman Britain, then to what extent was there any influence of Roman culture on the medieval Britons? And, what happened to the Britons in those more Romanized areas which were settled by Anglo-Saxons? Did they move west and north to join their brethren, or were they subsumed by the Germanic newcomers? And, given that Christianity (brought to the island by the Romans) survived amongst the medieval Britons but did not make substantial inroads into the Anglo-Saxons until the Gregorian Mission, did Christianity itself carry cultural connotations of “Roman-ness” to the Britons who practiced it in the early medieval period? I’m generally interested in anything and everything related to this topic, so if you have something to add about it even if I didn’t explicitly ask, please enlighten me anyways!

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Has there ever been a country that went from a dictatorship straight to a democracy?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Why did Russia ally with France against Germany in World War 1?

From what I know, the relationship between Kaiser Wilhelm II and Tsar Nicholas II was quite warm (judging by their telegrams) and they were relatives. Both of their countries were autocracies in which I imagine they held enough power over matters of state to shape foreign policy according to their personal beliefs, since Nicholas at least had the power to take personal command of his army one year into WW1.

Then there is the matter of the Crimean war from 50 years earlier and the enmity that caused between Russia on one side and Britain and France on the other. Why did Russia ally with France before WW1 broke out? War with Germany on France's side seems like an odd outcome considering the aforementioned.

3 Answers 2022-05-18

Short Answers to Simple Questions | May 18, 2022

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
  • Academic secondary sources are prefered. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

37 Answers 2022-05-18

Explain the spectrum of the cognomen, please. Some were awarded by the senate, some by friends, some were hereditary, some not. I vaguely understand the convention changed with time, but generally, what qualifies the differences, in law, of the cognomina (and the agnomina)? Maybe focus on 1st c. ad?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

At the end of the UK miner's strikes in 1985, the Kent Miner's Association was one of only two county associations (alongside Yorkshire) to vote against ending the strike. In a relatively small county for mining (just 2,000), what was the source of their militancy?

Additional:

Being from Kent, I was surprised to learn that our county's mining union was so committed to the strike action between 1984-5 (considering the relatively small numbers of previously mining-dependent towns in the South East). It's not a piece of local history I've heard much of before.

Considering the small size of the 1984 union (roughly 2,000 according to wikipedia), what were the motivations of this commitment?

I understand from browsing that the Kent union may have had an openly communist bent in leadership & officials, and that they were successful in soliciting donations from sympathetic socialists in London. Is this the source of the willingness to keep striking (ie: they had the ideological commitment and the capability from the donations to keep paying their members and prolong the strike)?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

How did caucasians survive in the colonies before sunscreen?

As a milk white guy I realised moving to Australia was against two million years of evolution, bearly surviving walking to the mailbox without getting sunburnt.

How did early settlers protect against getting turned into lobsters before noon? Was there some kind of a trick, aside from wearing a sombrero, that has been lost some sunscreen became widely available?

2 Answers 2022-05-18

What are some anachronisms in books like the Bible?

I've been reading up on the Iliad and the Odyssey and one thing I found interesting was how often Homer got the Bronze Age wrong. He was telling the story a few hundreds years out from when it supposedly took place so certain things, especially combat, were a mish mosh of stuff from his era and the one in which it happened. Of course he wasn't a historian and there was really know way for the average person back then to know the ins and outs of an era hundreds of years past.

Seeing as certain religious or mythical texts cover eras long before they were actually codified, what are some examples of these types of errors? For example, were Jews writing the Scripture affected by their Babylonian context as they wrote about their long history? What anachronisms show up in the great works of religion and mythology?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Why do the Welsh, Scottish, Irish and Cornish call themselves Celtic when all of the British Isles were Celtic?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Why and how did feudalism rise? Was there feudalism before the Roman Empire?

I understand this question's a bit Euro-centric and that feudalism tends to prefer to what society was like post-Roman but how and why did humans find themselves in a society that was reigned by a monarchy and operated on a class system of warriors and farmers and serfs? I want to say it seems that such a system would exist before the Roman Empire but maybe on a much smaller scale.

What was the alternative? How did we go from hunter-gatherers to kingdoms being made? And why were kingdoms made, then expanded and battling others?

1 Answers 2022-05-18

What gave the Chinese empire such longevity compared to other empires?

The Roman empire and the Chinese empire began at relatively the same time (25bc vs 220bc), yet the Chinese empire survived until the early 20th century. Some would argue it still exists today as the borders are largely the same.

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Were all German soldiers in WWIII nazis? Does wehrmacht mean nazi army?

The more I study the more complicated things get

There was a German army and there was a nazi political party. Was there a German army fighting on the battlefront who weren't part of the nazi ideals? Meaning they were fighting without being aware of the concentration camp system going on and were not interested in genocide of hitler's personal enemies?

I'm asking bc that's what was taught in school but I'm reading the betrayal of Anne frank and it's not adding up

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Why did the Mongols not ethnically replace their conquered territories?

ie. why are there no mongols in Iran, Ukraine, etc.

1 Answers 2022-05-18

Why is the Eastern Shore part of Virginia rather than with Maryland?

1 Answers 2022-05-17

Where is all of Africa's history?

I think back to civilizations like Egyptians, Mayans, Greece, Rome, Medieval Europe eventually to Enlightenment era Europe, and think of how all of these groups had well-established periods of growth in architecture, art, math, science, etc.

Africa seems like a place full of biodiversity in all aspects of terrain, animals, peoples and vast in natural resources - it would make me expect to have learned about them somewhere in my education. The only group I've really learned of from Africa is the Egyptians, and I feel like they consider themselves part of the Middle East.

I expect some archeologists and anthropologists have discovered some sort of art and culture from ancient Africa somewhere and the technologies they developed to adapt to their environment, right?

1 Answers 2022-05-17

250 / 7255

Back to start