If the trenches of WWI were so hard to break, why were they not used in WWII?

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Superstition in the elite of 17th century Ottoman Empire

Hello, asking a question for the first time.

I just started reading The White Castle by Orhan Pamuk. The book is set in 17th century Ottoman Empire. One of the protagonists is a scholar close to the royal court, Hoja. From what I gather from the first 60 pages or so, Hoja considers himself a serious scholar who bemoans other people's stupidity. When he would want to explore the world of astronomy, all the royal court (including the sultan) wants of him are astrological divinations. This is a great frustration to Hoja, who wonders why people are so empty of mind and uninterested in real science.

How accurate is this portrayal? Was the 17th century Turkish elite really this superstitious and uninterested in science? I understand that what we consider "real science" (the scientific method, empiricism, rationalism) is a fairly recent phenomenon, with many celebrated historic scientists being interested in trades we nowadays consider false (e.g. alchemy), but the tribulation of Hoja, however, seems to be a total disinterest in natural science in notables around him. While this, of course, can be considered a creative tool, I am interested how close this portrayal hits home.

1 Answers 2018-07-06

WWII

Anyone ever seen something like this or know what it is or stands for? My husband got inherited some stuff from his great uncle and among his WWII things was a stamp.. No words or price..sticky on the back like a stamp but a photo on the front..he thinks it's a picture of his uncle

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Did British colonies and dominions really feel that the Royal Navy "their" navy? If so, what what caused dominions like Australia and Canada to begin to create navies of their own?

British territories got quite involved in funding the construction of RN warships during the great naval race of the early 1900s – Australia, New Zealand, Malaya – but they must have come to believe at some point that the British fleet would not be sufficient on its own to protect them. So what's the history of the Royal Navy's relationship with the broader empire?

2 Answers 2018-07-06

How did it come to be that there is a term, "anti-Semitism," specific for hatred or prejudice against Jewish people, when for all other groups we use the general "racism?"

2 Answers 2018-07-06

Best books on military aircraft 1918-1939?

I'm particularly interested in the design and use of the aircraft during a time of "peace". A book that goes over the major changes and why they made those changes without a major war going on would be really fascinating to read about.

2 Answers 2018-07-06

What Festive Holidays did the Celts Celebrate?

I've heard the Celts celebrated the winter and summer solstice, and that Christianity took over already existing events, but I'm wondering if they regularly celebrated other occasions?

From research into the Romans I've found that resources are limited on Celtic culture, but is there any information available on their festivals and what these celebrations consisted of?

I would love to hear about the Celtic cultures in Gaul or Britannia just before Caesar's conquests, but don't want to limit the question to a period that we don't know much about, again any information about this culture would be fascinating to read.

Thank you in advance!

1 Answers 2018-07-06

How disruptive was radio to established political systems, and how does its rise parallel and influence the rise of Fascism?

1 Answers 2018-07-06

What kind of body armor did Spartan warriors wear in Hellenistic times?

According to wikipedia, Spartan warriors "wore almost no armour apart from a shield, leg greaves, bracelets, helmet and a robe", which conjures images of 300. But then, on historyvshollywood, it says " Body armor was a valuable asset to the real Spartan soldiers. [...] "I took those chest plates and leather skirts off of them [...] ... Spartans, in full regalia, were almost indistinguishable except at a very close angle."

Neither of those are good sources, I know, particularly wikipedia. I'm mainly looking for a simple answer for book-writing purposes, nothing academics-proof. I figure it also depends on one's wealth and status, but a general answer would be appreciated or even a picture.

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Was it always called the ‘Big Bang theory’, or was there a historical development of this name?

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Friday Free-for-All | July 06, 2018

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

15 Answers 2018-07-06

In the Vietnam war the US Army used these "Ghost" recordings. What was the purpose of this and did it work as they had planned?

1 Answers 2018-07-06

In 1651, Knights Hospitaller have acquired four islands in the Carribean, controlling them until 1665. How did Hospitallers manage to establish colonies in the New World? What was their long-term plan for Carribean holdings?

The islands in question are Saint Christopher (Saint Kitts), Saint Martin, Saint Barthélemy, and Saint Croix.

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Why didn't the cities in Italy betray Rome during the Second Punic wars?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-07-06

John Bernard Shaw (probably) quipped that “The English are not a very spiritual people, so they invented cricket to give them some idea of eternity". How did cricket matches become so longspun? Was there a social purpose to the longevity of matches?

3 Answers 2018-07-06

AskHistorians Podcast 115 - The Friends They Loathed - Quaker Religion and Persecution in the American Revolution

Episode 115 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode:

Today we talk with /u/UncoveredHistory, better known as Jason Aglietti. He is a public librarian in Baltimore and he just finished his Master’s thesis from University of Maryland Baltimore County, where he wrote and defended his thesis The Friends They Loathed: The Persecution of Maryland Quakers During the Revolutionary War.

Jason will tell us all about the lives of the Quakers in the American colonies from their founding to their persecution in the revolutionary war. This is NOT the history you usually hear about the revolutionary war, and Jason gives us a lot of new things to think about!

Finding The Maryland 400, the history project Jason worked on and talks about can be found here. Jason's blog is here.

Questions? Comments?

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.

If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.

Thanks all!

Previous episode and discussion.

Next Episode: /u/thucydideswasawesome is back!

Want to support the Podcast? Help keep history interesting through the AskHistorians Patreon.

3 Answers 2018-07-06

In the Christian religion Lucifer punishes the evil in hell, despite him being "the fallen angel" who will fight god at the end of days.... Why would he punish his supporters/followers? How did this belief come about?

It just seems odd that if you were say a Devil worshipper, that you would be sent to hell and the Devil would punish you for it.

How did Christianity come up with this idea of "him" inflicting justice on the wicked?

Edit: I could see how it could happen if he was a moral/amoral god of the underworld such as the Greek Hades, where the Underworld is open to all. But Hell is especially reserved for sinners.

2 Answers 2018-07-06

Why did the distinction of 'warlock' for 'male witch' come about?

"Witch" by itself is not always a gendered term as such, but "warlock" generally is - was this distinction made in medieval Europe during the Witch Trials, or did it come about later, after the term "witch" began to refer almost exclusively to women?

1 Answers 2018-07-06

According to economic historian Paul Bairoch, Norway was the richest European country (GDP per capita) prior to the outbreak of the WW2. Is this claim valid? If so, how did Norway become wealthy before it struck oil?

I often heard that Norway was something akin to Saudi Arabia or the OAE in terms of wealth before it discovered oil. I thought so too. The data shows that it was not the case. Of course, Paul Bairoch was not the only economic historian, as, in contrary, the Maddison project's data claims that Norway while being prosperous, by no mean could be called ultrarich in the first half of the 20 century.

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Why did exotic exploration seem quite popular around the turn of the century?

Is there a name for this time period that started sometime in the 1800s and lasted until about the 40s, in which exploration of the world seemed to be quite notable?

Around this time there were many European colonies in Africa and Europeans made archaeological discoveries in Egypt. Teddy Roosevelt explored the Amazon, exotic goods were being exported throughout the world. Safaris and game hunting became popular among the rich. India was at the height of colonial rule.

Books and movies made this time popular, in ways being depicted in Indiana Jones, Tintin, and many more.

The only thing is, I don’t know what this golden age of exploration is. Why did it come about and what certain events made it what it was? I find it to be very intriguing and I would love to know more about it, or if there are any books or movies, etc, that I can reference.

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Why didn't Alexander expand to the West?

He built a giant empire in Asia, but always expanding to East. With his powerful armies maybe he could have conquered all of the Mediterranean. Why didn't he conquer the western territories of Europe?

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Was there an appreciable life expectancy difference between replacement soldiers in the US army during WWII and those that originally trained with a unit stateside?

I'm rewatching the series Band of Brothers. Its alluded to from the episode "Replacements" on, but directly voiced by the character of Frank Perconte in the episode "Why we fight" that replacements both got Toccoa men and themselves killed quicker. A quick internet search showed that, for example, in Italy in 1943 only 34% of line infantry had been trained with their original unit in the states (the rest were replacement soldiers from "repple depples" or replacement depots). https://www.defensemedianetwork.com/stories/the-u-s-world-war-ii-troop-replacement-policy/

The fact that the individual replacement system was abandoned in subsequent wars by the army supports the assertion that it was ineffective, but doesn't answer whether a replacement or "original" member of the unit had a longer life expectancy.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Why didn't many European armies adopt a lever action rifle?

I saw a question similar to this one in the r/NoStupidQuestions subreddit and one of the responses said that Europeans basically skipped over the lever action repeaters and went straight from single shot rifles to bolt action rifles and that the lever action guns were pretty much a purely American gun. Why was that?

2 Answers 2018-07-06

What was the reasoning and events behind the sudden rise of German immigration to the US in 1880s?

1 Answers 2018-07-06

Is what Rod Dreher said about Rome and Barbarian invasions accurate?

Dreher said "The massive migration of barbarians into the Roman Empire, in the 4th through 6th centuries, changed European civilization permanently. They caused the fall of the Western Roman Empire, and centuries later, the rise of a new civilization there, based on the descendants of old Roman stock and Christianized Germanic tribes. Will the latter-day descendants of those Europeans be able to hold back the “barbarian invasions” from Africa in the 21st century? Or will they have to do as the Romans did and absorb the strangers, and, over centuries, create a new civilization? These are the stakes".

Is it true that the Barbarian invasions were as bad as people like Dreher say they are or is there more to the story?

Edit: I accidentally deleted another portion of my post. What I said was I kept seeing the Barbarian invasions of Rome being used as a comparison for modern migrations, but this doesn't particularly make any sense to me. The comparison seems very forced for one, and the people who make tend to ignore a lot of the nuances of the modern migration situation and the nuances of previous barbarian invaders.

1 Answers 2018-07-06

⯇ 2533 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start