Why did the allies declare war on Germany but not the Soviet Union when they both invaded Poland in September 1939? And why did they give up Poland to the USSR after the war when they initially entered the war to protect Polish indepence?

2 Answers 2018-05-06

Did the printing press cause any major shifts in monastic life in Europe?

I know monks were often the primary copiers of books in Europe, so curious if there were any changes once that was no longer necessary.

1 Answers 2018-05-06

Agricultural Labor in Ancient Rome?

The Roman historians on here have presented a pretty complex picture of labor in Ancient Rome [mostly talking about the Principate if memory serves]; the urban poor living a semi-migratory life, chasing day-labor through the city*, while large agricultural estates hired large numbers of free laborers during harvest time, when more hands were needed, with slaves serving as the continuous baseline to maintain the estate.

So my question is, was there much overlap between the day-laboring urban poor of Rome and the hired laborers working agricultural estates during harvest time? If not, where did they come from?

Also, regarding agriculture in Roman Italy, is there any evidence to say relatively how much land was held by large estates compared to 'yeomen', and what role tenant farmers played in the picture?

*I'd also be interesting in seeing if there's any evidence to indicate this (or any of the questions above) was widespread through the Mediterranean world, or something unique to Rome.

1 Answers 2018-05-06

Between the movie “The Darkest Hour” and “Dunkirk” which depicts the Dunkirk evacuation more historically accurate?

1 Answers 2018-05-06

At what point did western society accept the concept of the brain as the seat of consciousness? Were there other societies that recognized it earlier?

My understanding is that other organs have been associated with consciousness and emotion in early society, leading to the ideas like love's association with the heart

1 Answers 2018-05-05

In Karl Marx's Lifetime, What Would He Have Recognized as Symbols of Communism?

Since the Hammer and Sickle was designed nearly a generation after his death, what would he have seen as representing Communism in posters, pictures, banners, and even graffiti?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Do historians consider the study of Troy as branch of Greek history or something else entirely?

Is Troy considered a part of the ancient Greek world? Were the Trojans ethnically Greek?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Did the Ancient Greek philosophers ever question the existence of the Gods or the validity of the myths/legends of that time?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Characters in the Sherlock Holmes stories are often described as having attacks of "Brain Fever". Was this an actual diagnosis at the time or is Conan Doyle using the term loosely?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

On Wikipedia it states that sailors from Paekche (eastern Korea) reached as far Phoenicia although this wasn't in the citation. Is there evidence for this?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

How does studying history as an undergraduate differ from being a graduate student?

I know there isn't a universal answer here, but I'm just looking for other people's perspectives. For the record, I'm currently an undergrad in philosophy, but I've always been interested in history and have several friends whose majors are history.

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Do Most Professional Academic Historians Agree With Richard Carrier in his "Proving History: Bayes's Theorem and the Quest for the Historical Jesus" That Bayes's Theorem Is The Best Set Of Methodological Guidelines?

If not, could you direct me to competing epistemological historical methodology.

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Is there a chance of Ancient Astronauts Theory being true? Is there any evidence that is being considered by mainstream historians?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Historically why were Emilia-Romagna so Communist and Veneto so Christian Democratic throughout Italian elections?

I was observing that throughout post-war elections till the early 90s in Italy, Emilia-Romagna seemed to lean heavily towards the Communist Party of Italy and Veneto heavily towards the Christian Democrats.Why was this the case? Were there similar patterns before as well?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

What laws were used to judge the Nazis during the Nuremberg Trials?

International laws outlawing genocide and racial crimes were written by the newly formed UN after WWII precisely in order to prevent another Holcaust, right? Then under what charges were Nazi leaders sentences for their crimes during the war? Had the League of Nations passed similar laws before 1939?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

In WWII, what was the purpose of prison camps for Jews? They weren’t doing anything important, as far as I know, so why weren’t they just cremated?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

When did the royals in Britian stop having power as in deciding what the country does, etc?

I am talking about how, in the medival times, everything was controlled by Kings. But when and how did it stop?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Why was the spear, often without a shield, so constantly used everywhere despite the threat of arrows?

Was gambeson more effective than I thought? Was plate or maille cheaper than I thought? Do most arrows hit the head (helmets were quite common I think relative to other armour)? Was the reach advantage just so damn good over everything else it didn't matter? Pls help

2 Answers 2018-05-05

I am a Master Swordsman in Medieval Europe. Given the common military tactics at the time, how useful would my swordsmanship skills actually be in a large-scale battle? Would I have an advantage or is the battlefield more complicated than that?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

"Abraham riding a camel is the same as Julius Caesar riding a motor-scooter." Is it correct that the domestication of camels was thousands of years later than Abraham's time?

I am very interested in this specific question, but if someone could refer me to reliable sources about historicity of the bible in general, that would be a great addition.

1 Answers 2018-05-05

[Why/] Did the Nazis doubledown on the Holocaust when they started losing?

I've seen this from several sources, that when the war started turning against them, the Nazis accelerated the killing.

First, is this true, and second, why? The infrastructure and manpower required to exterminate a race isn't exactly a line item. That's a huge amount of effort and planning and logistics and people and ... moving parts, that all could probably have been better spent trying not to lose the war.

I've seen some explanations (that I perhaps just didn't really grok) that the leadership believed that it was the Jews who were (perhaps just 'behind') the opposing sides in the war, and that if they just managed to kill all of them... What? The war would end? Victory?

That seems... irrational. I can buy that someone thought that, maybe even a few people, but surely there was someone in Nazi leadership who realized that was completely stupid?

Was this some insane sacrifice? Like, we'll all die, but if we manage to take down the entirety of the jewish race with us, the survivors will be able to complete our grand destiny?

Was someone trying to "hide the evidence" of the holocaust by killing all the witnesses?

What was the thinking behind diverting resources away from the war, towards killing a lot people who were not a threat?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Once the fate of the Mexican-American War was all but clear, was there any serious discussion amongst the Americans to annex ALL of Mexico?

I’ve heard some ridiculous statements from people saying, usually sarcastically, that we should’ve annexed all of Mexico. Well, once it was clear, with the successful capture of Mexico City in 1847, that the Mexico had lost the war, was there any serious discussion in the US government or media to actually annex all of Mexico, and not just its northern territories like California and the Southwest? If so, what were the primary discussion points that were pro-all-annexation and pro-anti-all-annexation?

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Announcing the Best of April Award Winners

The votes are in!

For April, we have once again have a unanimous winner. /u/Lewed_Losel took top honors for answering "How do historians know when manuscripts are dated to, if they have to be repeatedly copied down to preserve them?"

In a tough field, /u/mikedash edged out the competition to take a well-earned second place for their fascinating response for "I was reading about the history of the stapler and found that the first stapler was made for King Louis XV. "The ornate staples it used were forged from gold, encrusted with precious stones, and bore his Royal Court's insignia." Is this true? Does the stapler still exist?"

Taking the "The Dark Horse Award", which recognizes the top voted non-flaired answer, /u/sickhobbit tallied it up in a close fought race for their answer to "Between 1945 and 1949, the Netherlands and Indonesia went to war over Indonesian independence. US and British forces were involved, and there were approx 200,000 casualties, before Indonesia finally prevailed. Why is this conflict so obscure? What were the consequences in East Asia?"

And finally, this month's Excellence in Flairdom award for April 2018 goes to someone you all know and love, /u/td4999! This Interesting Inquirer flair has figured out the ultimate intersection: questions that are interesting to read, questions that are interesting to answer, and questions that get picked up by reddit's algorithm and skyrocket to the top of the sub. Like our other Interesting Inquirers, we love the amount of research td already does in order to ask a clear and deep historical question. Three cheers for td4999!

The winners each receive a month of reddit gold in recognition of their accomplishment!

So as always, a big congratulations to the winners, and a big thanks to everyone who contributed to the subreddit in the past month! Also a reminder, if you want to nominate answers for the monthly awards, the best way to do so is to submit your favorite posts every week to the Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check them out here!

4 Answers 2018-05-05

I heard that in the Austro-Hungarian army in World War One the Habsburg family tree, if so, was there any attempt to rationalise or hide all the incest in the tree?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-05-05

Through German history, why does the heraldic eagle (the Reich- or Bundesadler) sometimes have one head and sometimes have two heads?

Is there a difference in symbolic meaning between the two representations? Is there a point at which it definitively became one-headed?

2 Answers 2018-05-05

⯇ 2649 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start