Why do modern Germans use a different word for ancient Germans?

As a German, I grew up with an identity of being "Deutsch". Germanic tribes were known to me as "Germanen". It would be very wrong to call them "deutsch" which, to me, makes them out to be sufficiently different to warrant a different name.

Kinda like Italians today don't call themselves Romans (maybe with the exception of those living in Rome).

What is the reason that the English language doesn't care about making that distinction? Is it a sort of "laziness"? Dan Carlin said that it's not certain whether Caesar's Germani are actually related to moder Germans even.

1 Answers 2018-04-21

When social security was implemented in the US, what happened to those who were already elderly or middle-aged and therefore had worked their whole lives without paying into it?

1 Answers 2018-04-21

Did the outcome of WWII in the Pacific Theater drastically change for the United States because its aircraft carriers were not in port at Pearl Harbor?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-04-21

Why didn't Russia use the "retreat and freeze" tactic in World War One like they did in World War Two?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-04-21

Is Natural History more science or history?

I mean when referring to studying things like dinosaurs and the general history of life on Earth

1 Answers 2018-04-21

Can anyone help identify a found mortar and pestle, story inside.

A little over 100 years ago, my wife’s great grand father found this mortar and pestle while plowing their field located in Christian County Kentucky. Their family farm has been there since the late 1700’s. Both my wife and her mother are interested in finding out if anyone can identify it based on the photos located here:

photos

This area was primarily occupied by Shawnee Indians as well as Cherokee Indians; also this area of Christian county is on the Northern route of the Trail of Tears, so it may not be Shawnee or Cherokee. We have found very little in our research and hoping to find out a little more.

1 Answers 2018-04-21

Did the creation of the USSR change the national/ethnic composition of countries like Estonia? For example, did the creation of the USSR result in an influx of Russians to other socialist republics? Was the USSR like the EU--was it now easier for a Latvian to work in Moldova?

I was just reading about a hockey player who's Russian but born in Estonia and raised in Finland. Made me wonder if the USSR allowed easier travel between nations and if there was an influx of Russians in the smaller Soviet Republics.

1 Answers 2018-04-21

Have i been taught the truth regarding hitler, the holocaust and nazi germany?

I live in the UK and i am concerned that i may have been taught a very one sided version of history and, in particular, the events of ww2. After watching and listening to “revisionist” historians i now find myself unsure of who to believe.

2 Answers 2018-04-21

Are the Transylvania saxons German, and if they are, How did the Transylvanian saxons manage to stay German for 800 years!

So I’ve been reading about the Transylvania saxons. They migrated to Transylvania Kingdom of Hungary in 1100’s and stayed untill ww2 when a ton were expelled by the Soviet’s and some are around in the modern day.

So my question is how the heck did they manage to stay German over 800 years in foreign lands surrounded by Hungarians and Romanians? They still are German culturally, language wise, and by DNA, but how? How did they not intermix with the Romanian and Hungarians after 800 years? How did they keep their language and traditions and not assimilate. Did they literally only marry other Transylvanian saxons?

Question 2: did other Germans from Germany and Austria consider the Transylvania saxons German even in the 1800-1909’s? Like did the Nazi’s consider the Transylvania saxons to be true pure Germans or did they see them as “mud blood” intermixed peoples of German and Eastern European descent? And did the Austrian empire classify them as ethnic Germans or as Eastern Europeans in say the 1900’s late 1800’s?

1 Answers 2018-04-21

Why is Rhode Island a state?

It seems like it could’ve easily been slotted into Connecticut or Massachusetts. Why was it separated?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

Why did the Holy Roman Empire only contain northern Italy, German principalities, and Austria (with a few other smaller areas)? How was it able to acquire those areas but not France, Spain, England, etc?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

What motivated the average person to fight for the White Army during the Russian Revolution, as opposed to joining the movement that promised them so much?

I hope the way I worded the question in the title makes sense. Basically, I can understand why Communism would be appealing to the average person living in Russia in 1917. However i'm wondering about the motivations for the average person who fought on the side of the White army, the average non-wealthy, non-noble, non-aristocrat Russian? Thanks!

1 Answers 2018-04-20

What happened to the international volunteers in the Spanish Civil War?

Regarding the volunteer army that was established to fight the Franco forces, were they captured as POWs or did their own respective governments bring them back to their homeland?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

Has Roe v. Wade ever been at serious risk of being overturned?

In recent years a number of high-profile abortion restrictions or bans have been overturned. With a majority of Republican-held state legislatures, a current Republican president and Congress, and a new conservative Supreme Court justice, the idea is that Republicans at the state level are trying to get a test case up to the Supreme Court to overturn Roe v. Wade. Is this an unusual phenomenon?

In the 25 years after Roe v. Wade (up to 1998) there were 3 Republican presidents opposed to the decision, various Republican-held houses of Congress and state legislatures, and a somewhat conservative-leaning supreme court. At what times have there been the most political will to overturn the decision, and have any cases come close?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

How did Peruvian Silver get from Peru to Spain?

I figure that it was transported by cart to the sea and then by ship away from Peru. However, I understand that sailing around Cape Horn is difficult (and not somewhere you'd want to put an extremely valuable ship) and I was under the impression that pirates during the Golden Age of Piracy were primarily raiding Spanish ships, and that Spanish treasure galleons were one of their targets. Was there an overland route through South America or across Panama? Or am I just mixing up the time period?

I'm also just generally interested in the mechanics of getting silver from the New World to the Old.

1 Answers 2018-04-20

We know native American populations were devastated by diseases introduced by European settlers. Was the opposite true as well, i.e. were Europeans threatened by diseases unique to the Americas? If not, why not?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

Modern speakers of Sumerian?

Are there any historians, archaeologistis, Assyriologists etc around today who can speak, read, write or understand Sumerian?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

Did soldiers equipped with muskets ever really fire their ramrod as a last resort?

This may seem like an odd question, however in film and television there are examples of people armed with muskets firing their ramrod at the enemy when they did not have another musket ball (Sgt. Harper from the BBC series Sharpe does this in an episode)? I realize that this may very well just be a creation of the film industry, but i figured i would ask because it would certainly be cool if it was true.

1 Answers 2018-04-20

How did the sailors of the ancient world manage to navigate before the advent of the compass?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

The year is 50 BCE. I am a Roman merchant sailing through the Eastern Mediterranean trying to sell my wares. Would the Greek spoken in Alexandria, Antioch, Athens etc. be the same or would I need to know multiple language to engage in business?

The question might be better served if we change the time period to 150BCE, before the Romans had near complete control over the region

1 Answers 2018-04-20

How prevalent was Russian Roulette during the Vietnam War?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

Doorways and early Medieval Danes

A student asked a fascinating question in my Senior English class today: "What would the doors of Herot have looked like?" This was asked in conjunction with an assignment to draw Beowulf and his setting in your own interpretation. The student was trying to do a hyper realistic version.

1 Answers 2018-04-20

Calling someone a snake comes with a rather negative connotation. Was this not the case with the American Revolution and the image or the snake on "Don't Tread on Me" and "Join or Die" flags?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

How did Kichisaburō Nomura (The Japanese Ambassador to the USA at the time of the Pear Harbor attack) travel from the USA to Japan in 1942?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

What made Ancient Greeks "Greek"?

This was a conglomeration of various city-states with independent governments, cultures, etc. At times they even fought against each other. So, what exactly, if anything, made them think of themselves as one people. How did they differentiate themselves against contemporary civilisations?

1 Answers 2018-04-20

⯇ 2682 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start