What did the "gun reform" look like in pre-WW2 Germany? What about other countries that had major gun reform that resulted in an authoritarian or fascist government?

Asking due to this taking precedent in the political sphere in the US. Genuinely curious. I hear/see a lot of gun activists citing WW2 Germany and post WW2 Cuba as examples of what happens when "gun reform goes bad".

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Do you know of any good books that deal with The Terror or Napoleonic periods of France?

Sorry if this isn't allowed, but I have to do a presentation on a single chapter of a book dealing with either of these topics. I'm much interested in when the monarchy still existed in France, so I'm not as much into those periods.

I think I'd find something about Talleyrand interesting, or Robespierre.

Does anyone have any suggestions?? Thanks so much for any help!!

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Germany under Hitler had the Nuremberg Laws, treating people different depending of their "blood". But how did they handle orphans?

I'm a german myself, so I hope you can understand my question as I'm not a native speaker. To elaborate: obviously there were orphans back then, but how did german regulations treat them?

I.e.:

kid 1 looks aryan (blonde, blue eyes, ...) so it's german

kid 2 looks not aryan (curly hair, brown eyed, ...) so it's not 100% german?

Thank you very much

Edit: I think my title isn't specific enough. I mean babys that were found without indicators of who their parents are.

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Why did Hitler not go around Stalingrad?

Couldnt Hitler simply have encircled Stalingrad and continue the push threw to the Urals? What forced Hitler to capture the city other than its propaganda value?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Is it true that Arthur W. Page wrote Truman's statement announcing the dropping of the Little Boy atomic bomb?

I found it interesting how some articles credit the former Vice President of Marketing for AT&T with writing Truman's statement. However, the sources that I have found are iffy, to say the least...

Can anyone validate this claim?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Why did the Italian merchant republics not seek out colonial empires?

After reading about the Mediterranean trade empires of Venice and Genoa, it seemed weird that neither of those nations would push for an opportunity of a new revenue source, and to further the fiscal benefits I imagine they’d already be getting from their existing Mediterranean colonies. Would the fact that both states already had embraced a form of colonialism for centuries prior to the start of new world exploration not have already given them an advantage in setting up new cities or trading posts?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

How did Britain and France go from enemies to allies?

Specifically how did they go from fighting constant wars in the middle ages and enlightenment, to begin firm allies in the 1900s?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

If you pick up any popular text of Greek mythology, you get the sense that there is one unified mythology. However, looking deeper, it seems to be more heterogenous. Why do popular texts do this?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

When Boris Yeltsin visited Texas in 1990, he went to a grocery store and was shocked by the abundance of food. This shattered his view of Communism and led to him reforming Russia. With all the Russian spies, how did the government officials not know about the condition of America before this?

I don’t have sources, but I also have heard that Gorbachev didn’t believe the grocery stores were real when he visited the US. Like he thought that it and the roads were built specifically for his visit. It just seems like if there were Russian spies, the high up officials would already know this stuff.

Edit Sorry, I got the year wrong. It was in 1989.

Edit again Here is this and this for context if anyone is interested. The pictures are pretty cool to see. And the video on the second website shows a Russian grocery store.

Edit x3 I keep getting messages asking if it was at an HEB. As a Texan myself, I know an HEB is way more amazing. But it was a Randall’s in Clear Lake. From the article: “The Randall's he visited, just off El Dorado Boulevard and Highway 3, is now a Food Town location.”

3 Answers 2018-03-25

Hitler stash

Was the Adolf mustache a common or popular facial hair style before WW2?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

This Week's Theme: Folklore

2 Answers 2018-03-25

2 part question: A) Are the terms "Hellas/Hellene" modern? B) What did the ancient Greeks refer to themselves and their country as?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Why is the Vietnam War so controversial in the aspect of pride for Americans?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Watching Mary Beard's "Meet the Romans" she reads the tombstone of a woman who cohabitated with 2 male lovers. She calls it "a Roman menage a trois" but can you give me any social context for such an arrangement? Historically the Romans were quite a bit more prudish than their movie counterparts

Do we know of many examples of this? Is there any context or explanation for similar phenomena?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Why was Belgium not better prepared for a German attack at the start of World War 2?

The French had built up Maginot Line, and the Germans had bypassed French defenses and attacked through Belgium at the start of the First World War. Why did the Belgium border not have more deterrents in place against Germany?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

An old family scroll?

So my dad just told me about an old scroll that has apparently been in the family for quite some time. As to how long neither of us are sure. He hasn’t seen it since he was a kid and only remembers that it had very old portraits in it (pastel/chalk/some other type of paint perhaps?). We will be getting it from his dad around the 6th of April so I’ll be able to post some pictures here as well (bear with me I’m still getting the whole use of reddit down). Any possible information would be useful, even with the very little info given.

1 Answers 2018-03-25

What percentage of the German military during WWII were actually Nazi Party members or even supported Nazi ideology?

It seems that anytime anyone mentions members of the WWII German military, they are always referred to as Nazis. Surely not every soldier subscribed to Nazi ideology. I can't imagine that the old men and the teenagers who were conscripted near the end of the war actually cared about Nazism. Yet, the German military is collectively recalled as "Nazis."

1 Answers 2018-03-25

If Jews converted to Christianity in Nazi Germany then were they still persecuted? How exactly did the government determine who was Jewish or not?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2018-03-25

Did the Aztecs willingly go to their sacrificial deaths?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

What type of ship would a 40 ton English vessel in 1587 be? Thinking specifically of the Hugh Gallant, Thomas Cavendish's smallest ship.

2 Answers 2018-03-25

Was the British occupation of Ireland (c16th to 1922) worth it, economically?

There are a lot of historical discussions about colonialism, guilt, reparations and consequences. But not much speaking about the positive benefits for the colonizer (morality aside, obviously).

So, from a purely economic perspective, was the occupation of Ireland profitable? Considering how many rebellions, revolutions and how much administrative and military effort had to be expended managing the colony, was it worth it for economic reasons?

Or were there other reasons that made it worth it?

More generally, was the European Colonial Horrific Dystopian Nightmare for Centuries (aka the age of exploration) worth it? From a purely economic stand point.

Morally it was obvious a real dick move.

2 Answers 2018-03-25

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | March 19, 2018–March 25, 2018

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

6 Answers 2018-03-25

Why was it so important to the US to stop the spread of communism in Asia during the Vietnam war era?

I've been doing some light research on the Vietnam war lately and I'm not coming to a good answer on why the US felt it was so necessary to get involved. I see many places citing a domino effect of communism, and that the US figured that if Vietnam fell many other countries in the region would also fall to communism soon after. Why was it so important to stop the spread of communism in other countries?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

How do you use the word "American" when explaining the continent general history?

Cause i know a lot of people are dumb enough to think americans are only from United States. Do you use another name to americans or just say "Americans from American Continent"?

1 Answers 2018-03-25

Why would a slave owner (e.g. Delaware Rep. George Fisher) join the Republican Party?

edit: perhaps I made a mistake to mention Fisher. The linked documents always identify Benjamin Burton as both a Republican and a large (for Delaware) slaveholder but Fisher is only mentioned as a slaveholder in the NYT op-ed

Here are a few corroborating sources: Slavery and Freedom in Delaware, 1639-1865 by former University of Delaware professor William H. Williams, and NYT piece by author of "Lincoln and Race" professor Richard Striner.

I stumbled upon this fairly randomly and was not able to turn up any additional information.

edit: I'm not certain Fisher was a slave owner but Benjamin Burton, the largest slave owner in Delaware, is identified as a Republican in every source I found.

1 Answers 2018-03-25

⯇ 2736 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start