2 Answers 2018-02-03
I was on the Jewish Virtual Library, and it lists nations affected by the Holocaust, and their Jewish populations pre and post war. Some, like that of Poland and Germany, were understandably obliterated. But when it came to countries like Italy, Bulgaria, and France(I assume occupied), the number of Jews killed were between 20-25% percent. I know Italian fascism did not rely as much on blaming Jews, but why didn't Hitler pressure the Italians more to exterminate their Jews? And did the Nazis take a less aggressive pursuit of the final solution in occupied France than they did in Poland, Occupied Russia, and the baltic?
1 Answers 2018-02-03
I've often heard that it's 70 percent history and 30 percent fiction. Is this true? Is there a more accurate assessment of Romance of the Three Kingdoms?
1 Answers 2018-02-03
1 Answers 2018-02-03
It would seem that the National Socialist party would adopt some kind of a German symbol like the Prussian Eagle to signify their love of Germany. So why the Swastika?
1 Answers 2018-02-03
stupid question, i know, but my dad claims that the presence of the evacuees from Dunkirk was a major factor that Germany considered when dropping the idea of Operation Sea Lion, which i want to clarify
1 Answers 2018-02-03
Just saw a preview for an upcoming episode on PBS (US) that showed a young Victoria protesting the state of Irish during the potato famine. Is this accurate?
1 Answers 2018-02-03
1 Answers 2018-02-03
1 Answers 2018-02-03
Recent research tells us that, at its peak, Mayan civilization was a densely populated myriad of thousands of city states, comparable to the city states of classical Greece. My understanding is that overpopulation drove the Greeks to settle distant colonies all around the shores of the Mediterranean and Black Sea.
Did the Maya do anything similar? The isthmus of Panama seems climatically similar to the Yucatan, so did the Mayan culture reach that far?
1 Answers 2018-02-02
It is well known that Anti-Federalist were thoroughly included in the process of creating the United States. The US has had Presidents and founding fathers that were notable Anti-Federalists and it seems that their cause was just a legitimate as the Federalist cause.
Meanwhile, this phenomenon seems not to be apparent in the cause of the loyalists. I don't think that there are any US Presidents/founding fathers who were loyalists, and of my education I do not know of many/any loyalist being included the the creation of the US and its institutions.
Am I wrong, and if not what explains this?
1 Answers 2018-02-02
After Constantinople fell, did the Ottomans and the world in 1453 know that the Byzantines were the last remnants of the former Roman Empire and that they were witnessing its death?
1 Answers 2018-02-02
2 Answers 2018-02-02
Quite long ago I saw the film Battle of Britain (1969), which is a film about the Battle of Britain in 1940. At the end of the movie, I wondered whether or not Churchill purposely sacrificed London in order to protect RAF bases?
The movie depicts how Churchill was the aggressor. The RAF bombed Berlin first, as a provocation, which leads to the Luftwaffe bombing London and other cities instead of RAF bases. The movie paints Churchill as a provocateur, who purposely bombed Berlin, in order to provoke Hitler and make him divert away from his original plans of bombing RAF bases. In the end of the movie, Churchill saves the RAF but London endures much destruction
I searched around for a bit but haven't found any concluding answers.
So is this movie true in its depiction and did Churchill deliberately sacrifice London?
1 Answers 2018-02-02
You know the deal. Vote for the threads you enjoyed most from the past month. If there was an answer you liked that you don't see here, feel free to post it.
12 Answers 2018-02-02
Edit: I need more coffee, I meant Königgrätz. You knew what I meant, dang it.
I'm aware of this discussion here, detailing much on the effect of infantry firepower on the dissolution of cavalry. https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2kcv1d/we_often_hear_about_how_war_changed_in_the_20th/clk900x/
I've also read through a few papers on the arme blanche controversy that persisted in British military circles from the late 1800s to 1914. As well as a book or two on the move away from closed order. I'm not interested in these things at the moment.
I'm interested in literally anything else.
The vast majority of the sources and material I have found on this era seems to be laser-focused on specific spots like the needle rifle and The Charge Of The Light Brigade, with nearly nothing at all on the changes in doctrines and organization, and most of the material on the other wars of this century focuses on the political and socio-economics, with the details of the wars themselves completely omitted.
Tell me about the doctrines, tell me about the early experimental weapons, tell me about the colonial shootouts, the Anglo-Zulu wars and the Sepoy Rebellion, tell me about the Opium Wars and the Taiping Rebellion, or anything from that whole hundred years' worth that isn't another rehash of 'The Austrians went into the woods and was annihilated by the breech-loading needle rifle, leading to the skirmish line'.
I've scraped the local provincial library system clean, and have sank as low as consulting 1800's era patent papers to get information. Help me out here.
Books, papers, any source recommendations are also appreciated.
2 Answers 2018-02-02
I was watching a youtube video on the death of Roman Emperors and quickly noticed how often the Praetorian Guard was responsible for an Emperors demise...
Why did this continue for so long? Why would Emperors continue to keep the Praetorian Guard, knowing their history of murder?
I'm sure this is a very loaded question with entire books on the subject, but it seems incredibly odd that such a tradition would be continued.
1 Answers 2018-02-02
In this article one historian is suggesting the population could have been 10-15 million. But other than "complex irrigation" the article does not offer much explanation.
What was Mayan agriculture like and do we know much about their division of labour?
1 Answers 2018-02-02
I just heard about the Black Legion, and they seem almost worse than the KKK. They were an offshoot AFAIK, yet they are almost unheard of. Why is this?
1 Answers 2018-02-02
2 of the formidable Panthers were captured by the poles in the uprising, how well where they used and what was their fate ?
1 Answers 2018-02-02
1 Answers 2018-02-02
Between the World Wars, it doesn't seem like there were sufficient engagements to develop the robust theory of combined naval/air warfare that we see in WWII. How was that doctrine developed, and how were combatants able to completely revolutionize naval combat doctrine so quickly?
EDIT: I have a great answer about the Royal Navy, but if anyone has an answer for the US or Imperial Japanese Navies, I'd love to hear that as well.
1 Answers 2018-02-02