Why did Rome need to be so large if it constantly struggled to feed itself?

From what I've read/heard of ancient rome the city at it's height was enormous and incredibly densely populated, to the point of struggling to feed itself. Why? Why was so much of the population so centralised? It's not like there were enormous industrial era factories that needed labour, pulling people towards major cities.

1 Answers 2022-04-15

What area was actually under fire during an artillery bombardment in the First World War?

The primary goal (that I know of) of the artillery bombardments was to destroy the barbed wire and soften up the enemy defences. This was done through extended shelling of the target area, but what sort of area would actually be under fire during these periods? Were they just aiming at the front lines of the enemy, or were they engaging the supply lines to the front as well? Also, was it the inaccuracy of the aiming during these barrages that caused the shell scarred landscape of no mans land, or was this caused inaccuracies in the gun itself? I'm assuming they weren't aiming at no mans land so why was it so saturated with shell holes?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

How did Hamilton simultaneously believe in a loose interpretation of the Constitution while opposing a Bill of Rights?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Why do we have ‘3 course meals’?

Starter, Main, Dessert. Where does this originate from?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Why such desirability for *Viscount* Bridgerton?

In Bridgerton series one, Daphne's desireability is explained readily by being appointed the diamond. The Duke's is obvious, given he is the senior most peer of the realm to appear in the show (excepting furriners) in addition to his clear wealth and power.

But why in series two is Viscount Anthony Bridgerton so desirable to all about the ton given how low a viscountcy ranks in the peerage? Were social strata less rigidly defined or policed once one had a peerage, or were more senior nobility so aloofly ahead in a further class of their own that they would normally be unattainable?

(or is it just a symptom of fiction?!)

1 Answers 2022-04-15

How did Alexander Graham Bell's Deaf wife feel about his anti-deaf eugenicist views?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

How effective were actual jump-out-of-airplane operation in WWII and how has the use of wartime airborne units changed since their inception?

With the mixed bag of results from the Russian Operations in Ukraine recently, especially what I've read about the issues at Hostomel Airport I've been wondering how the use and tactics of these forces have changed. It often seems, especially with what I know of the Axis and Allied airborne units in WWII that they are almost always relegated back to ground based roles--even if they do see success in their missions.

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Firsthand Accounts of Colonialism from Military Officers?

Are there any good auto-biographies, testimonies, or journals of military officers from the age of colonialism? I think it would be cool to read what French or British military officers thought about being deployed to Africa or Afghanistan back in the 1800s. What there daily life was like. The hardships, the adventure, the interactions with locals, the political and strategic situation from their perspective?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Why did Hitler hold such a vast amount of Nationalism for Germany if he was Austrian?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

How hard is it to learn enough Medieval Latin for reading sources in the original?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

What is the Oil tree mentioned in the Bible?

Is the olive tree the only tree you can get oil from? I know in the Bible it mentions the oil tree. It might be Isaiah but I'm not sure. Thanks

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Why are The Beatles considered so important to modern music?

Side question: Is there any other band/artist that is comparable in influence?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Shells As Currency: How did inflation not skyrocket, and why didn't the harvesters become the most prestigious communities?

Please help me better understand / correct my misunderstandings of, the details of societies which used shells as currency.

  1. It seems to me that, even if the shell-traders are only interested in a certain distinctive kind of shell, it would be a relatively short time before the glut would make a single shell nearly valueless. But I haven't heard of shell trade being abandoned because of inflation.

  2. I am under the impression that shell trade often made made its way fairly far inland. Would societies necessarily be considered more shell-poor the farther inland they are? If so, why would they value shells on par with the societies closer to the coast?

  3. It seems to me that the societies which harvested shells would necessarily be powerful or influential because of this, but I haven't seen anything which directly relates shell harvesting to regional power. Why is this?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

What's the deal with milk doors?

I mean, I understand how they work, but why? Why couldn't the milkman just leave it on the porch? And why was very specifically milk delivery so important that homes were built to accommodate that one delivery, and a whole occupation dedicated to delivering one specific item? Why didn't people get their milk at the store like everything else? Why weren't there breadmen and eggmen and flourmen?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Why did Britain and France not declare war on the Soviet Union as well in 1939 for invading Poland?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

How was the treaty of Tordesillas (1494) written if at that time they believed America didn't exist and Columbus just landed in India?

From my understanding, Europeans didn't realize that America was an altogether new continent until around 1502; when Amerigo Vespucci realized America wasn't India as what he saw there didn't match the stories he heard from sailors that went to India from the usual route around Africa (If possible I'd like this fact to be checked because I'm not very sure I understood it right).
What matters is that until 1502, everyone (even Columbus himself) was convinced that in 1492 the Columbus expedition just landed in India. That being said, why did Pope Julius II write the
Treaty of Tordesillas (where he divided the world in two halves between the territories that could have been colonized by the Spanish and the Portuguese). Since by his knowledge America didn't exist, he said to Portugal "the territories to the east of Cape Verde Islands are yours" convinced there wasn't actually anything to the east of Cape Verde Islands (apart from India, whose existence was known since they always traded with them).
So, in the end my question is, how did they divide the world into two halves if they didn't know that the second half actually existed?
I am very sorry for my poor English but this is the best I could make, also thank you for the time you already spent reading this post and, possibly, to answer it. Good day.

1 Answers 2022-04-15

How come cashmere never became a thing in the Middle East?

assuming native goats there do indeed produce cashmere? not sure.

1 Answers 2022-04-15

As far ask I know, smoking was introduced to Europe in the 16th century after tobacco was brought from North America. So why does a man appear to be smoking from a pipe in this picture from the black death?

From the video "5 most dangerous jobs in history" at 9:53 you can see a corpse collector from the black death smoking a pipe. Was smoking other substances common place at this time? From a quick google search, smoking from pipes such as the one in this picture had not occurred until the 16th century. What gives??

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Friday Free-for-All | April 15, 2022

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

8 Answers 2022-04-15

Why did France and Great Britain not declare war on the Soviet Union when said Union attacked Poland.?

Great Britain and France declared war on Germany when Germany invaded Poland.

Why did they not do the same to the Soviet Union when the Soviet Union attacked Poland shortly after?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

How were kingship and statecraft different in the copper/bronze/iron Ages than in the medieval age?

I am writing a fantasy novel set in an (as indicated in the title) Pre-classical age, as opposed to the standard pseudo-medieval, with the plot centred around two royal twins, each being groomed for a different role. The Elder to be the heir apparent, and the younger a kind of spymaster.

I would like to know if the plot is compatible with the setting I have chosen, but I'm mostly concerned about how different the ruling of kingdoms was in the 'metal ages' than whatever assumptions someone like me, who has read mostly fantasy, would have.

1 Answers 2022-04-15

How did Hamilton simultaneously believe in a loose interpretation of the Constitution while opposing a Bill of Rights?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

What is the Oil Tree from the Bible?

What is the Oil Tree that is mentioned in the Bible? Was there something else besides Olive that oil was made from?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

Could the average person in the middle ages reasonable expect to have a peaceful life?

I am wondering if my perception of the life in the middle ages is skewed by all the historical fiction and podcasts I consumed or if there really never was a chance to life a peaceful life for the average peasant or merchant.

For example I am currently listening to the podcast "History of Byzantium" and in the 7th and 8th century there were apparently yearly raids on Anatolia by the arabs. Or 9th Century Holy Roman Empire with raids from the hungarians and in other places you got vikings raids and general war between rulers.

So I do wonder, was life just incredibly insecure and did every farmer eventually just experience violence, be at risk to be killed or be enslaved, or could you expect to life a whole life without ever experiencing such traumatic things.

1 Answers 2022-04-15

During Genghis Khan and his successors' time, did the Mongols horseshoe their horses?

1 Answers 2022-04-15

285 / 7255

Back to start