i keep reading that Hitler was dismayed by France and Britain's declaration of war in 1939. Did Hitler ever have a plan to eventually turn and attack West before their declaration of war?

1 Answers 2018-01-26

Why was America so concerned with the "Polywater Gap" in the 1960s and 1970s?

I was reading about this on Wikipedia. Soviet physicist Nikolai Fedyakin believed he'd discovered a new state of water that was syrupy and remained liquid at both lower and higher temperatures, and the American military was very concerned with their ability to produce as much of the substance as the Soviets were (though it was later discovered that Fedyakin's methods were flawed, and what he'd taken to be a new state of water was simply ordinary water with pollutants in it).

But why was America so worried about this? Was it simply run-of-the mill Cold War paranoia about the Russians having something we didn't, or were there specific potential military applications of the supposed substance which they believed would grant whichever nation possessed the most of it a specific advantage?

1 Answers 2018-01-26

How was rock music treated behind the Iron Curtain?

Rock music, especially punk, has strong political and social connotations that were controversial even in the west and yet I've heard of many instances of rock in communist countries in eastern Europe. Elton John famously toured the Soviet Union in 1979. Frank Zappa was apparently very popular in Czechoslovakia and was even designated a cultural ambassador. Moreover I've listened to many punk bands from Poland (Siekiera, Klaus Mittfoch, Brygada Kryzys) who were active and released albums in the 80's while Poland was still communist.

How was rock recorded, performed, or distributed behind the Iron Curtain? Was it censored or lead to political repercussions? How accepting were various communist countries to western style rock music?

2 Answers 2018-01-26

Were the Picts Celtic?

And if not, how are they classified ethnically and linguistically? It seems that there has been debate in the past, and I am curious what the modern view of the Picts place in history is.

2 Answers 2018-01-26

Historians, Hollywood and many others focus more on the Western Roman Empire because of their various historical remarks that made them legendary but you often find little focus on the Byzantine Empire. Did the Byzantine Empire leave anything remarkable in comparison to the Western Roman Empire?

I just learned recently that the people of the Byzantine Empire while still a part of the Roman Empire, did not actually call themselves as Byzantines but rather as Romans (it turns out that historians called it the Byzantine Empire to help people make distinctions on which part of the Roman Empire they were talking about)

So technically, the Byzantine Empire continued to the Roman Empires legacy even though the Byzantine Empire is often very distinct than the Western Roman Empire like the choice of clothing, the religion and so on.

We are often more exposed to the Western Roman Empire because of their economic, political, social and military structures that had left an impact on their entire world and future generations and the legacies behind such structures.

(some of those structures are still used, are being implemented and still being studied and researched today and more discoveries are still being found)

lHowever, you often find little focus on the Byzantine Empire despite that the Byzantine Empire continued to prosper in many ways for almost 1000 years after the Western Roman Empire fell.

Did the Byzantine Empire leave anything remarkable like the Western Roman Empire did when the lost technologies and arts of Rome were rediscovered and studied during the Renaissance?

Or is this just an over-saturation or over-appreciation by historians or Hollywood or the general public because we are more familiar with the Western Roman Empire (similar to how we are more familiar with the Greeks than other ancient civilisations like the Persians) or is this just an appreciation of the Roman "fluff" so to speak *(similar to how we often have an appreciation for ancient mythologies like that of the Greeks, or the Norse gods or ancient Egypt)?

1 Answers 2018-01-26

Why did some Romans only have 2 names in the Republic?

I was curious as to why some Romans only had two names. I found out that during the empire the praenomen's function was gradually eroded and no longer recorded, but I could not find anything on the Republic times.

Why did some people, like Marcus Antonius, Gaius Marius, Gnaeus Pompeius, only have 2 names, while people, like Caesar, had 3 in same time period? Did they only have praenomen and nomen or no praenomen with a nomen and cognomen?

thanks,

1 Answers 2018-01-26

Julius Caesar is the most famous Roman to the best of my knowledge. I've been reading a lot about him and saw some video's of his battles. Was he really as great a general as we see or is this just a case of the victor writes history.

There is no doubt that he was a great general but I saw somewhere that Romans often over exaggerate the numbers they where up against. Did Julius Caesar do this as well to make himself look really good for the senate and the public. Is there any other none Roman accounts of him.

My personal favourite battle is the The Siege of Alesia.

1 Answers 2018-01-26

When did female impersonation (drag) become a tradition in the gay community?

I’d also like to know why if we have insights on that.

1 Answers 2018-01-26

How were historic cisterns kept clean? Would there be any issues with mold or contaminants?

Looking at the green stuff on the ceiling of this 1514 Portuguese cistern, the first thing I thought was mold, but it's probably just moss or algae. However, it made me curious about how water quality was maintained before chlorine and other chemical additives.

Could enclosed cisterns such as this have had potential issues with mold, bacteria or other microbial problems? How severe could it get? What about open-air tanks?

1 Answers 2018-01-26

Before the BC/AD labeling system was put into use, how did people label the year?

1 Answers 2018-01-26

In the U.S., "tax season" is ending in April. Citizens must file their taxes but the 15th of April. Why is it in April? Is it law, tradition, or both?

1 Answers 2018-01-26

Why isn't the University of Constantinople considered the world's oldest university?

1 Answers 2018-01-26

Context for this photo

My cousin found this photo and is not sure about who the men are. The back of the photo says "Lodge, Beckley West Virginia." There is a Moose Lodge in the area, so maybe that is it? I don't know what the medals are that many have on. Any info is greatly appreciated!

1 Answers 2018-01-26

How did the Doomsday Clock become so prominent in the media?

Considering it is run by the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, who no disrespect, are not international affairs scholars and this not really qualified to make such judgements. It seems to be given legitimacy and is constantly written about when updated (as happened today), though there is no apparent basis for how they reach these numbers, no defined system aside from their own beliefs. While I could be totally incorrect here, it seems like it's just an opinion piece that has been given undue weight for whatever reason.

1 Answers 2018-01-25

What would an airborne plane do if it lost its carrier during the pacific theater?

Would they be able to make it to land or would they be essentially dead at that point?

1 Answers 2018-01-25

Did people in the past have a concept of “working out” to stay fit? I know soldiers of ancient times and such must have done some physical exercise to fight well but what about others?

1 Answers 2018-01-25

It seems as if the Romans have been revered throughout history due to Europe's continued use of Latin and Roman imagery. Was this the case during the fall of Rome as well?

At what point did people stop wanting to be independent and start imitating the Romans? Was it Charlemagne who essentially started the practice?

1 Answers 2018-01-25

How did Haiti, a nation that has been independent for nearly 200 years; end up being so poor?

1 Answers 2018-01-25

Could any change in supply chain tactics have allowed the supply line for Germany's storm troopers to remain intact during the Spring Offensive of 1918 and therefore changed the outcome?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-01-25

What are historians' main criticisms of Silvia Federici's book "Caliban and the Witch"?

I recently read Caliban and the Witch based on a friend's recommendation. I found her argument (which I attempt to summarize below), to be very exciting, but because it seems like a revisionist history of feudal Europe and because of the somewhat loose and polemical style it's written in, I feel hesitant to believe everything in the book without consulting other sources, so I'd like to know what actual historians think of it. I'm especially curious what the main problems with the book are, so that I can avoid believing things that aren't true. [Also, this question has been asked once before, but it didn't receive any answers so I though it'd be okay to ask again. Mods, please tell me if this is against the rules and I'll remove this post.]

To give a cursory summary for those who aren't familiar with the book, Federici's main goal is to criticize Marx's theory of primitive accumulation for overlooking the role of women in the transition from feudalism to capitalism. For Marx, 'primitive accumulation' refers to the process by which the seizure of land created a difference between the proletariat and the elite, property-owning class. Federici claims that Marx failed to realize that elite control of women's bodies was a major part of this process, since landowners required peasants to produce future generations of workers. Federici cites the banning of illegitimates births, criminalization of infanticide, the replacement of midwives with male doctors, and the exclusion of women from non-domestic labor as evidence of a desire by the ruling class to control women's reproduction. For Federici, this is exemplified in the witch hunts, which she claims were a way for authorities to eradicate 'wise women' who knew how to induce abortion, to terrorize women who sought independence, and to pit peasant men against women by offering them the promise of submissive wives.

I'm very sympathetic to what Federici is trying to do in the book, insofar her broader goal seems to be drawing attention to the historical origins of many issues that women face today and the way in which unpaid domestic labor is part of capitalism. However, there were many times in the book where I felt like Federici was drawing causal connections between events and intentions without adequate evidence. I also realize that she's coming from the same tradition as Foucault and Edward Said, in which historical data is sometimes warped or cherry-picked to fit a particular 'big idea' or ideology. (And like Foucault, I think that Federici is by training a philosopher and not a historian.)

Since I'm pretty much a complete layperson when it comes to this period of history, I'd be interested to know what actual historians think of Federici's book, and in particular what the main problems with the book are in terms of the facts presented and the historiography.

2 Answers 2018-01-25

How much ammo did the average soldier (on either side) carry during the American Revolutionary War?

So I'm trying to design an RPG, and I find myself stumped by the above question. When concerning archers, it was relatively easy to find that a quiver could contain a sheaf of arrows (24), but I find this question for riflemen more difficult.

The firearm technology is still at a muzzleloading/flintlock stage, where only the most advanced nations (more like nation, singular) have moved on to using metal cartridges.

So back to the question: American Revolutionary War era; how much ammo did the average soldier carry for his musket?

1 Answers 2018-01-25

Is there any truth behind the claim that The Prince was actually written as satire?

We talked about Machiavelli in history class today, and the teacher said that she personally believes he wrote The Prince as satire, which initially made sense to me because I thought most of his ideas were absurd, but at the same time she has told me stuff that was straight up not true so I wanted to ask Reddit to confirm.

1 Answers 2018-01-25

German Jews had lived alongside the Germans for 1000 years, spoke German, ate German food, worked middle class jobs, had German names, and looked white. How could their dehumanization have continued for so long?

African-Americans in the US that were enslaved and forcibly segregated were not targeted for genocide as systemically as Jewish people in Germany. I can understand how dehumanization could have started in 1100 AD, but by 1917, how could anyone still have so much hatred against people that look like them?

1 Answers 2018-01-25

Sources for reading about Ancient Egyptian religion?

Huge fan of studying comparative religion and lately, I'm interested in learning more about ancient Egypt: their beliefs, their practices, and hopefully even some lesser-known myths I haven't heard.

Particularly interested in Anubis, but it seems when I try to find sources for Egyptian religion, I'm more likely to find New Age stuff about shamanism and the power of the spirits than anything even remotely related to actual Ancient Egyptian religious beliefs.

1 Answers 2018-01-25

Why Did the Arabs in the late 5th/6th century call Roman/Byzantine and Persian Leaders by Kaiser and Kisra respectively before this was a thing?

while calling Persians leader after Khosrow never really became a trend, even in Persia Itself, Emporaros calling themselves a variation of the Title Caesar become popular. albeit way, Way later in history. why Did the Arabs do it... and that early!

Is it for example that Arabic simply did not have a word for Shah or Emperor or maybe the Quran came up with/popularized those title?

also, Arabs were loyal Allies to Persia and a Major trade partner to the Romans, so it's like they were foreigners who had no Idea what they were called!?

1 Answers 2018-01-25

⯇ 2861 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start