Whats strange about WW2 "dogfight" footage?

Hi all,

So one thing thats always annoyed me about movies involving a dogfight at some point in WW2 is that there are usually loads of shots of one plane being entirely still in it's movements before being shot down by another plane that comes from behind it - which to me doesn't make sense as to avoid being shot down it would make sense to maintain erratic unpredictable evasive manoeuvres. Example of annoying footage: https://youtu.be/ykPnJdgGcWM?t=29

Obviously excluding bombers as they weren't expected to out manoeuvre fighters. So I then went about finding actual footage of real dogfights and found that almost all the gun-mounted camera footage was of the same situation. The opponent taking no evasive movements, and being shot until disabled.

Examples I'm working off:

So why is this the case? Is any of this footage real scenarios or are these all taken from dummy target tests of some kind? Would fighters really not attempt to be evasive, or were the planes simply not as manoeuvrable as Hollywood would lead us to believe? Or were they simply not trained much in evasiveness?

Thanks in advance!

Edit: For example, I'd be expecting more footage to look like this: https://youtu.be/L-P7pPgniGA?t=92

3 Answers 2018-01-23

Were Christians in Europe/Asia Minor aware of the existence of Christians in Eastern Africa?

When I say Eastern Africa, I should probably confirm I am just talking about the area under Egypt to Ethiopia along the coast. After playing CK2 I realised this whole region is essentially Christian so it also makes me wonder why they didn't join the crusades at all.

[Edit] I'm aware they weren't of the same denomination or anything as Catholics or even Orthodox

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Soviet WW2 veterans seem to have an amazing number of medals on their uniforms. What accounts for such a large number of medals?

2 Answers 2018-01-23

How developed were the white areas of Rhodesia and Apartheid era South Africa compared to First World countries of the time? Alternatively, how did living standards of white South Africans during Apartheid compare to white Americans at the time?

3 Answers 2018-01-23

Juan Pujol García, AKA Garbo was a British double agent without the British knowing he was. How is he perceived in historiography?

His wiki page and his exploits alsmost are too incredible to be fiction. However I noticed that many cited works are popular history works, many of them based on accounts from Garbo himself and his handler in the British intel. I was wondering in what way his case is regarded by professional historians.

1 Answers 2018-01-23

I was listening to the podcast on the Battle of Jutland, and "..Land a million Russians north of Berlin, and boom..The War's over in a few weeks" caught my ear.

Were there really plans to land a million Russians soldiers north of Berlin? Was that a serious comment or was it just thrown out there?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

What did the Empire of Trebizond call itself?

The Empire of Trebizond was one of the three Byzantine successor states that formed after the Fourth Crusade captured Constantinople in 1204, along with Epirus and Nicaea. The names of these states are all later historiographical inventions, and just like Epirus and Nicaea, the emperors of Trebizond styled themselves as "Roman Emperors" at first, claiming the ruling title for themselves and presumable they continued to refer to their state as the "Roman Empire". After Nicaea recaptured Constantinople, Emperor John II of Trebizond changed his imperial title to "Emperor of All the East, the Iberians and Perateia". Did the name of the state he was governing also change or did they continue to refer to it as "the Roman Empire"?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Why are the Turks reluctant at recognizing the Armenian Genocide?

The EU has always been clear with Turkey: they cannot enter the Community if they do not make peace with their past. Apart from Erdoğan’s reactionary and authoritarian government, why is it so hard for Turkish people to admit such a horrible event? Of course I do know some Turks that admit the slaughter of poor Armenian people occurred during WW1, but quite recently I’ve had an unbelievable argument with some other fiery Turks about this topic

1 Answers 2018-01-23

How did Ancient Romes Society function?

Currently making a Gladiator styled game. Part Fantasy part reality. I am currently looking into making it a sort of Gladiator styled game where you fight for fame in the Roman World and Hellenic world. I would really apriciate anything on the Society of Ancient Rome or any books/places where I can seek out more spesific questions such as architecture and historical Events.

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Many of the the greatest Florentines were exiled at some point (Dante, Machiavelli, the Medicis, Michaelangelo). Was the Florentine Republic exceptionally volatile for its time?

2 Answers 2018-01-23

Dante made the assassins of Julius Caesar two of the three occupants of the deepest circle of hell; how familiar with Roman political history would Dante's 14th century contemporaries have been? Was he telling a story the audience would immediately recognize?

2 Answers 2018-01-23

How were the standard map colors for various countries decided?

On most political maps, each country is generally given a specific color, e.g. England/Great Britain is red, France is blue, Germany is dark grey, pre-Soviet Russia is dark green, Spain is yellow, etc. When and how was this decided?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Was the U.S. Civil War considered to be major world news at the time? How likely would it have been for an average European citizen to be aware of what was happening in the U.S.?

2 Answers 2018-01-23

What factors allowed America to develop its early Northern and Southern distinction by the 1770s?

I'm not American and I am struggling to find answers to this question. Any help is much appreciated :)

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Were the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia and the General Government technically considered parts of the German Reich?

I like tinkering with maps, particularly ones from the first half of the twentieth century, and one thing I've noticed is that there seems to be little agreement between maps as to the exact status of those two territories.

Some seem to shade them and mark them out the same as the other occupied territories

Others seem to consider them as actually integral parts of Germany proper

So what was their official status in the German Reich?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

India formally reestablished diplomatic contacts with Israel by opening an embassy in 1992. Why did it take so long for India to do so?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Why were injured soldiers that had recovered sent back to different units in WW2?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

How were years recorded before the BC/AD Calendar?

Supplemental question: When did the calendar as we know it become (mostly) accepted by the majority of the world?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Recommendations for military history research.

I've been on a military history kick recently, what are some good important battles, strategies, or generals that I should research?

2 Answers 2018-01-23

In 1801, Tsar Paul I of Russia was assassinated by conspirators funded by the British government. How did the British have the means to assassinate a monarch of a European superpower at the beginning of the 19th century?

Follow up question: did other Europeans powers have such capabilities? Was anyone able to do this against the British monarch of the time?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Did the Renaissance exist?

John Green made the argument that the "Renaissance" might not have even existed because:

  • Most people in Europe were unaware of the Renaissance because art and learning affected a very tiny portion of the European population.
  • The Renaissance was only truly experienced by the rich and the painters who served them. The majority of Europeans were peasants.
  • The "Renaissance" is a label devised by the modern people in order to describe this period as opposed to a period labeled in its time like wars and events.

What are your thoughts on this?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Is there any legitimacy to the claim that Crusaders sought to the Holy Grail or is that just a legend perpetuated to give the Crusades a purpose?

Furthermore, did any Crusaders believe they were after a specific item or quest, or was it viewed as purely a religious war at the time?

1 Answers 2018-01-23

Why couldn't jews just deny their identity during the holocaust? How did the nazis know who were jews if they just didn't wear the star? I apoligize if this is a dumb question

1 Answers 2018-01-23

In older film of military parades(and in some modern ones), why do all the soldiers look in the same off-center direction?

I noticed this while watching WWII in color on Netflix. I saw British, German, and I think Belgian armies doing this. This video includes examples of what I mean around 0:35 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BAoYNV5O78 (I sincerely couldn't find a version of this without the wii music, but it's kind of funny to watch anyway)

2 Answers 2018-01-23

What would happen to POWs in the Napoleonic Wars/the War of 1812?

2 Answers 2018-01-23

⯇ 2867 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start