How were the Egyptians able to build the great pyramids and how were they able to do so with such extreme precision?

The pyramids are an astounding feat and while there are many hypotheses regarding how the pyramids were constructed, most fall short of being able to explain how the largest stones were placed, how they were so precise, or how the projects were completed within such a relatively short period of time.

Thank you in advance for your responses!

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Is there any evidence that William Shakespeare was gay or is it just heavily rumoured?

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Are there any academic degree programs for the study of ancient human migration?

I'm mostly interested in learning about ancient human migration on a global scale. Googling turns up a few modern or specific migration studies programs, like migration to the Americas after 1500 or Mexican migration to the United States.

Edit: It doesn't have to be just ancient migration. I'd be interested in later periods, too, as long as they are global in scope.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

WW2 Heavy bombers vs ships

I was reading about the battle of midway and one thing that struck me as weird was the fact that army B-17s were deployed against the Japanese fleet. I looked into this idea further and learned about an entire class of patrol aircraft such as the PB4Y-2 Privateer, Fw-200 condor to name a few. My understanding is these planes would primarily hunt submarines and merchant shipping, but could engage warships like the battle of midway I mentioned earlier. I was wondering how exactly these planes would go about attacking such a target? How effective were they in this role? I can't imagine it was easy, the maneuvering of the ships and the difficulty maneuvering the bomber to hit the ships, compounded by the fact that they are taking varying amounts of fire based on how high up they were flying. I'm just having trouble wrapping my head around how they would accomplish this often enough to make it worth attempting?

2 Answers 2017-09-25

Why does Ptolemy have a "silent" P even in the original Hieroglyphics? Do we know if Ancient Egyptions would have pronounced the P?

I was reading a bit on the Rosetta Stone this morning and learning about how Hieroglyphics were finally able to be translated after the works of Young and Champollion.

I started thinking about the silent P in Ptolemy, but all of my googling turned up answers saying that Ptolemy with the P is a carryover from Greek. However, I noticed that the hieroglyphs for Ptolemy include the P at the beginning, so it appears it was there from the start.

So, why? I understand it's difficult if not impossible to reconstruct pronunciations for Ancient Egyptian - do we know if or how they would pronounce the "Pt?" What about Ancient Greek?

3 Answers 2017-09-25

How did so many Kurds end up in North Khorasan Province in Iran, so far from the other major Kurdish populations in Iran/Syria/Iraq/Turkey?

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Two huge aspects of Western Civilization both seemingly came to be in Italy- the rise of the Roman Empire, and the Renaissance. What made (or makes) Italy so conducive to such developments?

1 Answers 2017-09-25

AskHistorians Podcast 95 - The Revolution before the Revolution w/Doug Priest AKA u/TenMinuteHistory

Episode 95 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make /r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode:

Today Doug Priest (u/TenMinuteHistory on the subreddit) will explain the 1905 Revolution. This less well known precursor to the 1917 Revolutions, illustrates how the repeated failure to resolve Russia's most pressing economic, political, and social issues would set the stage for the overthrow of the Tzar over a decade later. (61 minutes)

You can check out his website, here and find him on Twitter as @10minutehistory.

Questions? Comments?

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.

If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.

Thanks all!

Previous episode and discussion.

Next Episode: u/AnnalsPornographie is back!

Want to support the Podcast? Help keep history interesting through the AskHistorians Patreon.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Historically, why do women have long hair, rather than men? Where did the cultural significance come from.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Did people from the Middle Ages or earlier come into contact with radioactive materials?

Obviously they would not have had the vocabulary or scientific knowledge to understand or identify radiation... but are there any historical accounts which today we might recognize as encounters with it? Say, some miners are following a gold vein and unknowingly chance upon uranium?

I ask because TIL [there's a naturally occurring fission reactor in West Africa.] (https://gizmodo.com/there-s-a-naturally-occurring-nuclear-fission-reactor-i-1475445638)

1 Answers 2017-09-25

How did the NBA, NFL, and NHL companies get started and take control of these sorts teams?

2 Answers 2017-09-25

why wasn't South Korean capital kept in Busan or moved to any other city rather than back to Seoul which is very close to DMZ?

1 Answers 2017-09-25

AMA: Honor and POWs in the American Civil War.

I am Lorien Foote, Professor and Director of Graduate Studies for the History Department at Texas A&M University. I have authored four books on the American Civil War. I am here to answer your questions about honor among Northern soldiers, military discipline and justice, prisoners of war, the mass escape of 3000 POWs, and conditions in the South as the Confederacy collapsed.

29 Answers 2017-09-25

To what extent can the Iliad and Odyssey be seen as echoes of the Mycenaean bronze age collapse?

This is a thing that I have been wondering for a little while, as I find the whole wide scale collapse extremely fascinating, and for what I understand from what we know the epics were told orally for several centuries before written down in the way we know them actually.

That begs the question though, how much of the tales is indeed an echo of the troubled times of the end of more complex Mycenaean civilization? Not an accurate account of course, but as a sort of a post apocalyptic tale of the great times that were no more.

Thanks for the time, and sorry for any typos, english is not my first language

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Did the USSR have an agency analogue to the US Secret Service, and if so did it have the same cultural influence as the USSS?

Regarding specifically the USSS's role as security and protection personnel for the US president, vice-president, presidential candidates and foreign dignataries.

on the second part of the question, "the black-clad Secret Service agent taking a bullet for the president" and "get down, Mr. President!" are major tropes in the Western world. If the USSR did have such an analogue, did it play a similar cultural role? If it didn't, what other agency "filled the gap" for it, so to say?

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Was the all-male jury in the 1957 film 12 Angry Men representative or did it already seem anachronistic at the time? Was the right (and obligation) of women to serve on juries a widely discussed topic like suffrage?

According to Wikipedia, by 1957 women were eligible for jury service in all states apart from Alabama, South Carolina and Mississippi.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

I remember reading in r/askhistorians about an early AD Chinese dynastic textile innovation that was never used, due to abundant labor, only to be "invented" by the Europeans at a later date. Can anyone help me figure out what I'm thinking of and tell me more about the subject?

IIRC it was the Spinning Jenny or similar loom-like device.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

In the English Civil War were tenant farmers exposed to what was later seen as luxury conditions?

Hey there, just wondering, during the English Civil War of the 1640s were British tenant farmers/commoners exposed to something which after returning to the Stuarts reign would of caused dislike? I hope you understand my question, and thanks!

Edit: In addition, I know its a bit off topic, but in the English Civil War I understand religion played a large factor but is there evidence to suggest that: The civil war gave way to Catholicism in English society?

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Was the industrial revolution a result of science?

In Antifragile, Nassim Nicholas Taleb claims that the industrial revolution was not caused by a corresponding scientific revolution (or the Enlightenment), but rather that it was the product of a series of (non-theoretically minded) tinkerers. Is this accurate?

I apologize for any vagueness in my question: I realize that the term Industrial Revolution may refer to more than one time period, but since Taleb doesn't spend much time on his point, I couldn't tell you which one I'm asking about. Probably all of them.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Monday Methods|How can dialogue between History and other disciplines give us a better understanding of the past?

Hello everybody, /u/commustar here stepping in for a guest-post.

History, as an academic discipline, has traditionally been defined by the examination written accounts to study and understand the past.

Of course, this method can run into many problems. Documents from the distant past may not have been preserved well. In eras of low literacy rates, the perspectives that are written down tend to be those of elites (usually male elites), and the sources may demonstrate biases. Or there may be times and places that exist before the introduction of a writing system, like areas of pre-colonial Africa, or pre-Columbian North America.

Of course, textual historians are not the only discipline that examines the human past. There are Oral Historians and Folklorists who take oral testimony, oral traditions, and folklore to study memories of the past that have not been written down. Archaeologists can study what materials have been left behind in the ground (or at the bottom of bodies of water) to gain understanding of past behavior and lifestyles. Historical linguists may examine the syntax and vocabulary of languages, or look at specific words across a family of languages, and be able to conclude where a word is borrowed into one language from another (and by extension, that a technology or concept was likely introduced by that route).

So, to what extent are Historians working with Oral Historians, Folkorists, Linguists, Archaeologists, and other specialists?

Is the trend in academia a desire to move towards more interdisciplinary collaboration, or do disciplines fail to see eye-to-eye? Does it vary by specialization (i.e. scholars of Vikings play well together, but studying the classical mediterranean is fragmented?)

What does an ideal future hold for dialogue? Where should we be trying to get to? What should historians understand about other disciplines to be able to better understand and appreciate the perspective they bring?

9 Answers 2017-09-25

Were there any ancient Indian historians?

Greece, China, Rome, and the Muslim world developed their own History as a tradition, if not a discipline, and if chronologies are to be counted as History, so did the Egyptians and the Mesopotamians. Seeing how India was home to some of the earliest literate societies, one would expect that they had probably developed their own traditions, with works written in Sanskrit or some prestigious Prakrit. However, a list of "Indian Historians" on Wikipedia points to Kalhana as the earliest historian. Apparently, he is the author of a work on the history of his homeland, Kashmir (called Rajatarangini, i.e. "The River of Kings").

There's just one problem, though: Kalhana lived in the 12th century. What/who were his sources? Chronologies? Do we have any of those?

I'm not really familiar with the history of India, or the historiography of India (obviously), but I know a couple of things: Chandragupta, the Nanda Empire, the Guptas, the Cholas etc. The question is how do we know about any of this stuff?

I realize that people have developed different ways of handing down information, and a search for an Indian Thucydides may well be a completely futile attempt, but they must have had some way of transmitting information about their past. Do you know anything on this topic?

Thank you, in advance.

PS: This is a bit off-topic, but if anyone could suggest any books on Indian history for someone unfamiliar with it, I would be very grateful.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Have gender roles tangibly shifted in post-revolution Cuba, and how has any such change been accomplished?

Cuba is now known to be relatively progressive in terms of women's education and representation in the workforce. I'm interested in how gender roles have changed in Cuba after the revolution at the social level and how these changes have been implemented in a material sense through organizations like the Federation of Cuban Women, for example.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Why did the French Imperial Guard fail at the Battle of Waterloo 1815?

I am curious about the topic area and wanting to write about it in the future and would like some ideas as to why they failed as i have some but i would like other opinions.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Why was the German abwehr (intelligence agency) anti nazi during WW2. What is the context for how this was and why it was allowed.

1 Answers 2017-09-25

Philippe Pétain lead France during the WW2 and signed the Armistice. While he was minister and ambassador before that, did he have before the war any ambitions of leading France?

1 Answers 2017-09-25

⯇ 3110 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start