I read that the Ming dynasty was in general hostile to Portugal because of their intrusion on their sphere of influence when the Portuguese captured Malacca. How did the Portuguese purchase Macau then if relations were poor with the Ming court?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Repost: How populous were Norwegian cities around 1000 A.D. (or near the end of the viking age)?

What is a rough estimate of the population and size of Norwegian cities such as Nidaros and Tunsberg, around the year 1000? To my knowledge Scandinavian countries were a lot more rural than continental European countries. Especially Norway, since it is still very rural according to modern standards. I'm curious to know if these cities and towns could be compared to their European counterparts in size?

I'm not necessarily looking for such a specific answer. Estimates on other Norse cities such as Hedeby, Uppsala, and Jomsborg are also welcome. The time period can also be flexible (850-1250), altough I'm mostly interested in the end of the viking age or shortly after it ended.

This is a repost as my previos post didn't gain popularity or responses.

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Was the Bosnian genocide planned?

And are the serbs only the guys with horrible crimes during the yugoslav wars?

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Why do we refer to some historical leaders by their language's title(i.e Kaiser Wilhelm II or Tsar Alexander III) but then use the English version for others (i.e Emperor Charles V).

This is a question I've been trying to figure out for a while now after noticing in my History lessons Charles V being referred to as Emperor but the Russian leaders being referred to as Tsar and not Emperor. Everyone I've asked has no idea why we do this and I find it very odd how we refer to Wilhelm II as the Kaiser but then call Charles V the Emperor despite the fact the Holy Roman Emperors would have been called Kaiser. Does anyone have any idea why we do this?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

How come there are no famous or well-known Civil War songs from the North?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Where to learn about the Holy Roman Empire?

Hi, I was wondering if anyone could point me to the best videos, books or podcasts about the Holy Roman Empire? Preferably something that is not too overwhelming for a beginner but still detailed enough to be worth reading. Anything would be helpful, but especially the medieval era. Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2017-09-24

When and why did the world divide into the US writing dates as mm/dd/yyyy and the rest of the world writing them as dd.mm.yyyy?

Edit, after checking wikipedia I see that at least according to it most of East Asia and some other bits and pieces use yyyymmdd, which I know at least programmers would love to be more common. I'd be happy to read answers dipping into the reasons for that too, but the title is the one I'm looking for.

2 Answers 2017-09-24

What does it mean for an admiral to "raise his flag?" Did/do admirals have personal flags? Are there standard flags based on something like rank?

For example, from "The Conquering Tide,"

"On July 30, he broke out his flag above a tumbledown house in Rabaul township."

This is just the example right in front of me. I've also been reading "Rules of the game" and that mentions Admirals flags many times.

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Is there a tartan or equivalent (traditional fabric type/pattern) which is recognised as being of Cumbria or the North West of the UK?

I'm from Cumbria and proud of it. I'm making a bush shirt and I wondered if there was a Cumbrian or North Western tartan or tartan-equivalent (as in a traditional woven, patterned fabric).

I aware of the somewhate fluid history of names and borders in The North West of th UK. I consider myself to be Cumbrian and that's fine, but I'm also happy to use a patten which is associated with that area in general, or with a defined area which was once where Cumbria is now or vice-versa (Westmorland, West Ridings etc.).

All help appreciated, thanks

1 Answers 2017-09-24

There are obvious records of religious beliefs dating back to the cuneiform scripts 5,000 years ago, but has any evidence whatsoever emerged that suggests religious beliefs existed before then? And what is the absolute earliest any evidence points to?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-09-24

This Week's Theme: Gender & Gender Roles

1 Answers 2017-09-24

How have previously mainstream political parties phased out?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Is there any evidence to support that troops upon returning from the Vietnam War, were spit at and/or had rocks thrown at them?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

In 1858, a child was taken from his Jewish parents under the law of the Papal States. How big a role did the international reaction really play in the subsequent downfall of the Papal States?

I have been reading about the Mortara case, in which a young boy was taken from his Jewish family in 1858 because a servant had allegedly baptized him. The law of the Papal States apparently said that this made him irrevocably a Christian, and it was therefore illegal for him to be raised by a non-Christian family.

The Wikipedia article says that the resulting international controversy played a part in the downfall of the Papal States during the unification of Italy, in part because it influenced Napoleon III to change his position. How big a role did this one incident really play, though? For that matter, I don't know much about the Papal States or Italian unification to begin with, so any broader context would be helpful. Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Singapore's rise as a global center of trade

Singapore is a unique country in that it's also only a city and happens to be one of the premiere centers of finance, trade, and so much more finding itself outperforming many other larger and even more powerful countries in many ways.

Obviously, this is in part due to its geographic location, but this can't explain the success of Singapore alone as places like Egypt and Panama also hold trading choke points without the same level of success.

In addition, Singapore must have the support of more powerful nations but often doesn't find itself mired in global international conflicts between the US, China, India, Russia, etc (at least not outwardly).

I'm curious as to what resources peal back some of these layers of its history, the power struggles, the agreements made around it, and how it continually keeps itself such a politically exceptional entity, especially in context to what the area was like before global trade. If there are any who have an expertise in all this and can share their own version here, it's much appreciated!

1 Answers 2017-09-24

I am a 13th century nobleman and news of an ambitious eastern King (Genghis Khan) conquering large chunks of the Eurasian steppe comes in, how do I react to this?

So in simpler terms, how did Europe react when they heard of the Mongol invasions and their overwhelming success?

2 Answers 2017-09-24

Why are American dollars often referred to as "bucks"?

2 Answers 2017-09-24

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | September 18, 2017–September 24, 2017

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

4 Answers 2017-09-24

Who were the "Divine Pharaohs" that the Ancient Egyptians claimed preceeded them?

Apparently the Ancient Egyptians claimed that they were carrying on a legacy dating as far back as 13000 years. The papyrus of Turin (dating from Ramses II) supposedly has a list of historical pharaohs and says that their legacy dates back this 13000 years.

This somewhat coincides with the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sphinx_water_erosion_hypothesis which states that water erosion on the Sphinx and Pyramids puts their date of construction somewhere in the 6th or 5th millennium BC. Long before the generally agreed date that they were constructed.

Is this a conspiracy theory? A misunderstanding? is it correct?

2 Answers 2017-09-24

Was fashion in ancient times as changeable as it is these days?

So often the picture we're presented in the media of the fashion in ancient times is a static one. Ancient Rome, for instance, is always toga and tunics. Based on how much fashion has changed in just the last century, it stands to reason that fashion underwent rapid changes like that in those days as well. Was fashion as important a topic in the days of Republican Rome as it is today? Were their any fads that are similar in scope to the fashion trends of today? Was it a topic of record in those days...for instance, were there "trend setters" or people that were considered fashionable and their style of dress and accessories emulated in the general populace?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Why did Revolutionary France invade the Dutch Republic considering they were a self-serving republic for more than a hundred years in contrast to their regular monarchic foes?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

How was life in frontier regions of Ottoman Empire? For example arabian peninsula or balkan lands that are really far from the capital? Did people in these actually felt an ottoman presence?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Chess in M.C. Escher's work

I'm at the Escher museum in The Hague, and one of the prints of Metamorphoses contains a particular chess pattern that I found interesting. It's called a smothered mate, where a lone piece deliverscheckmate to the opposing king despite it being surrounded by many allied pieces.

Was Escher a chess player (presumably he was, to know of such a motif), and was there a reason he included this particular pattern in his print?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

Was the Greek pensiula not as involved in the middle ages?

I spent a couple weeks in Greece, followed by a couple weeks in Romania. In Greece there were ancient ruins all over the place. But in Romania there are ancient and medieval structures. Why? What were the Greeks doing for that millennia?

1 Answers 2017-09-24

The evolution of the democrats/republicans

I guess I'm after something between a lecture and a TL;DR, but as an australian i'm fascinated by foreign and historical politics. Perhaps it is no surprise that some of the highest profile records are that of the USA.

So I'm intersted, what's the deal with the republicans and democrats through the ages.

To give context to my question:

Recently, in house of cards, Underwood is a democratic president with deep south connections. On the face of it, this flies in the face of the south's depiction in maintsream media. (ie, it is 'backwards' and racist - not the overt qualities of a US president)

And then this question: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/71z0op/so_the_kkk_in_the_mid1920s_could_boast_having_45/

lead me to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Birth_of_a_Nation

Which talks of Lincoln's (an independent/whig ((which raises further questions, a whig, I tend to think of as a westminster/english idea!?)) that advocates a more or less conciliatory approach) actions in dealing with the southern loyalists. (now, I will obviously concede that TBoaN is fiction and I have no idea of the real treatment of any of the southern captives/defeated states at the hands of the north)

It just seems to me that at some point american politics have been 'twisted.'

You don't seem to have a working class V 'landed gentry' kind of narrative. I'm just seeking insight into the situation.

1 Answers 2017-09-24

⯇ 3112 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start