Was there a point during WWII where it looked like the allies were going to lose?

3 Answers 2017-08-22

Advice on possible PhD Programs (Vikings)

Greetings brothers and sisters,

I have a question that I was hoping to get some peer counseling on. I am currently finishing up my M.A. My research area is Scandinavian Mercenaries during the Viking Age. More or less I am arguing that these hired swords played a much larger role in Medieval history than has been previously acknowledged. In addition to that, I'm also hoping to dispell some of the negative stigma that surrounds the term 'mercenary' while also discussing how the environment played a role in making mercenary work an attractive career choice during the Viking Age.

My question, however, is where do I go to study something like this at a Ph.D. level? Do I apply to History programs or Scandinavian Studies ones? I've sent a few e-mails around to schools like Aberdeen, Cornell, Washington, and Minnesota, but so far I haven't really heard a definitive answer.

Also, I know next to nothing about European and Scandinavian universities. What I know about Aberdeen I gathered from the last conference in Kalamazoo.

Does anybody have any experience or recommendations for me?

tldr: where does one go to study Vikings at a Ph.D. level?

Thanks in advance and sorry in advance if this isn't ask historians worthy.

*edited to include brothers of the female persuasion.

1 Answers 2017-08-22

A lot of ancient armies depended on formation fighting. Shield walls, protecting your right side etc. Would being left handed have been something that would disqualify you from fighting?

Holding a shield with your right hand would mess up being in a line with fellow right handed soldiers. How big of a issue would this be in armies such like the Roman Empire etc?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

Were there any female Pope? If so, how did they become one? How good/bad were they?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

How many buildings would an average Medieval City have?

Typically between the 13th century and 15th

1 Answers 2017-08-22

What is the reason Göbekli Tepe isnt universally recognized as the worlds oldest known advanced civilization?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

Is there good evidence that the rush for Edessa was not a cynical or opportunistic power/land grab by Baldwin during the First Crusade? Is it possible this incident had a deeper logic that served the interests of the wider Frankish army?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

How efficient were ravens at sending messages during the medieval ages?

Was wondering this whilst watching GoT, because those ravens have become as efficient as text. How long did ravens actually take to travel hundreds of miles, and what was the success rate of them?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

Egyptian end of the World beliefs

Very simples question.

The Ancient Egypt's priests had an equivalent to the norse Ragnarok for exemple? And if they had what it was?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

19th century France

Is there a book (in English) about how politics and political thoughts evolved in France throughout the entire eventful 19th century?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

Was Albert Pike a founder of the KKK?

This article talks about the Pike statue in D.C. and says Pike founded the KKK. But the evidence is a 1905 book by an apparent KKK supporter. So I don't take this as conclusive evidence. Is there any thing else on this topic?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

How did religious hermits not go insane from the lack of human contact?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-08-22

What did Crusader flags and Knights Templar flags and garb really look like?

Nothing but pictures of fantasy stuff show up on Google searches.

I'm trying to recreate historically accurate flags both of the Crusades and Knights Templar, as well as Knights Templar garb.

Factoring in archeological finds of flags and garb, what did they look like? Has anyone taken pictures of what they have found?

If anyone could post pictures of real archeological finds from the Crusades and Knights Templar, I'd really appreciate it.

3 Answers 2017-08-22

Can someone tell me exactly what this is

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-08-22

Do the Resident Historians agree with this answer on Quora on "Why did Europe develop before the rest of the world? "

It makes for a great story, but I wanted to hear historians chime in on it:

The modern wealth of Europe and the Americas lies in the Fall of the Western Roman Empire. But to back track a bit further before exploring the fall.

Empires, kingdoms, and most political forms of governance since the beginning of agriculture is the rule of the tri-part elite; ruler (king, inca, pharaoh, emperor etc.), the military (sanctioned violence that can be used internally as well as externally) and the priesthood (controllers of information, scribes, administrators, and mediators between god(s) and the people in support of the status quo). One elite or another might be dominant at one time or another but they each needed the support of the others. The king needed the military to control the population and the priesthood to present the reasons that god wanted the people to support the king. The church needed the money that the king extracted (supported by sanctioned violence). The military needed focus and the administrative abilities of the priesthood.

The fall of Rome in the west created a unique situation. (Its uniqueness accounts for much that is cited as important to the development of wealth in the west.) The ruler, the emperor, was gone as was the military that supported the Empire. In their place was a host of petty rulers supported by their small cohort of military. These kept the local populace in control and mounted small wars against neighboring groups.

That left the church, the controller of information. The church had the right of direct taxation - the tithe. Therefore the church was set free of dependence on the other members of the tri-part elite. The church benefited from the wealth of the common folk because they took 10% of every crop and of every sale.

This created a unique situation where the information controller benefited from common folk using technology and thinking about how to improve production. Churches and especially monasteries taught wealthy common people to read and do sums. Monasteries functioned as agricultural outreach centers encouraging the use of the hard horse collar, horse shoes, and the three field rotation system.

The church’s message became, good works are good, technology allows people to make more, when people make more they can do more good works, therefore technology is good.

In China, in the Islamic lands technology was limited to the elite. In western Europe the use of technology by the common folk was encouraged.

When the printing press was first introduced the church was a huge supporter. It wasn’t until the Reformation that the Inquisition became to be anti-press. Printers in Catholic countries found they couldn’t make a living without church sponsorship so they “voted with their feet” moving to Holland (the Spanish Netherlands) and then to England.

There was a glut of printers who printed everything from broadsides to business books, pornography to primers, music, playing cards, how-to books, ledgers and books on double entry bookkeeping. Protestant countries became print intensive. The common people learned to read, do sums and to practice double entry bookkeeping. This gave them a new perspective on doing business. The first capitalists came from these literate members of the craft producing classes.

First in Holland and then in England some master craftspeople began to hire more and more apprentices because they could tract production so they didn’t need to live with their apprentices to know that they were working.

The rest, as they say, is history.

source

1 Answers 2017-08-22

Why didn't the Luftwaffe destroy the Royal Navy to ensure Operation Sea-lion's success?

I've never understood why. The Nazi's Admiral stated that he had "no confidence" that he could keep the English Channel open long enough for Sea Lions force to pass the channel, but with Germany's ridiculously overpowering air presence, why didn't they just decimate the Royal Navy?

2 Answers 2017-08-22

Why was bleeding such a common and assured medical practice for centuries?

It seems so counter-intuitive to us now - who was responsible for its popularisation and continued use?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

WW2 infantry and officer training

What was training like for normal infantry soldiers and officers? Where would it take place? How long would it be?

I'm interested in all nations and any information you think is relevant even if it doesn't directly answer my question.

Cheers!

2 Answers 2017-08-22

Why are political borders always depicted as precise lines on medieval maps when the actual borders were not?

Simple question.

I have read and heard so many times that the political borders between kingdoms during the middle ages (whether it's high or late) were very blurry. People had a general idea of regions being under control of one kingdom or lord but it was not a clear precise border like it was depicted on maps.

Them, if that is the case, why is it that every single map I've seen that represent the political reality of medieval Europe has clear cragged borders?

I think my question can apply to maps from the high or late middles as well as northern, western of eastern Europe. But for the sake of rules, if needs be, we can focus on Western Europe maps for the period of 13th to 15th century.

1 Answers 2017-08-22

What unique conditions existed in Maryland that led to it being the only state of the Old South to remain the Union? Also, what were the extent of Confederate sympathies in DC?

I know that other slave states, like Missouri and Kentucky, remained in the Union, but Maryland was different from those states in that it was one of the original 13 colonies, and had a plantation based slave economy since it's creation. I'm wondering why it didn't secede with Virginia and the rest of the Old South?

I was talking with my wife about this, and she posited that Maryland had a different history than the rest of the South, since it was set up as a colony for English Catholics, and that areas with a large Catholic population were — for whatever reason — more pro-Union, like New Orleans. However, it seems that the uniquely Catholic character of Maryland had been lost by the time of the war, and the demographic makeup of white Marylanders isn't different from that of other white Southerners (i.e. Protestant and of English of Ulster Scots heritage) so that seems implausible. I've also had the thought that perhaps elements of the state did want to secede, but the United States government was very conscious of keeping Maryland in the Union, to keep DC from being an enclave in the Confederacy.

With regards to DC, although it's long been an urban area without the land for a plantation economy, it's my understanding that nearly 1/3 of the population was enslaved, and that it was a culturally southern city well into the 20th century. Were there strong Confederate sympathies in the city? Was there ever an attempt at pro-Confederate insurrection (i.e. an uprising by the population, not an incursion from the outside) during the War? Did the government feel that the President was safe so close to the border, or were there suggestions that Lincoln and his cabinet be relocated deeper into Union territory?

2 Answers 2017-08-22

As a born and bred Missourian, I've always been told that the Tigers militia defended Missouri against the Jayhawkers from Kansas, but in Kansas they tell the opposite story. Do we know who attacked first?

I realize that both sides did some terrible things, but is there any evidence to show who threw the first punch?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

Why is Judaism and Jewishness considered an ethnic identity but not Shintoism, Confucianism, or other religions practiced primarily by one racial ethnic group?

2 Answers 2017-08-22

How have spelling mistakes in ancient or medieval texts ever influenced the subsequent development of that language?

EDIT: Oops, title should be "Have spelling mistakes in ancient..."

2 Answers 2017-08-22

Why after WWII did Europe move toward stronger Consumer Protectionism, while the US seemingly moved toward greater corporate protection?

My wife and I are driving across country, and she asked me this question. We both thought posing it here might get us clearer answers than our postulating. Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-08-22

Arts, Crafts, and Clothes of a 5th/6th century Saxon?

Suppose I'm a Saxon (or Angle, or Jute even) from around 500 AD. What sort of clothes do I wear? How do I decorate my house? (What sort of house do I live in, for that matter?) Who made my baskets, clothing, etc; and how did I get it? Also, how do these things change with my social class?

1 Answers 2017-08-22

⯇ 3181 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start