Floating Feature: Pitch us your alternate history TV series that would be way better than 'Confederate'

Now and then, we like to host 'Floating Features', periodic threads intended to allow for more open discussion. For obvious reasons, a certain AH rule will be waived in this thread.

The Game of Thrones showrunners' decision to craft an alternate-history TV show based on the premise that the Confederacy won the U.S. Civil War and black Confederates are enslaved today met with a...strong reaction...from the Internet. Whatever you think about the politics--for us as historians, this is lazy and uncreative.

So:

What jumping-off point in history would make a far better TV series, and what might the show look like?

86 Answers 2017-08-09

Was the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki necessary for a decisive military victory?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-08-09

Does game of thrones have a specific time period in human history that we can pin point (other than sometime in the Middle Ages)? If a historian was to look at things like weapons, armor, communication methods, and technology (among other things), what time period would we put the show in?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

Good books on Haitian Revolution (1791)?

Hi everybody! How are you?

I would want to know if any of you are aware of good books on the subject of the Haitian Revolution. On one side, I wanted a synthetic and well narrated one focusing merely on the facts of the revolution (beginning, conflicts, aftermath). On the other side, more precise and complex analysis of the causes and effects.

Thank you very much!

PS: If you can clarify the author's perspective, great (e.g.: marxist, liberal, historical revisionist of a certain common thought about smth, etc)

6 Answers 2017-08-09

Did the pluralism of the British and Russian empires make them more or less tolerant?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

Romans threatening to throw someone to the lions is a running gag in Asterix. How common was it really as a punishment, and for what crimes would it be proscribed?

In the Asterix comic books, it seems that just about anything could get you thrown to the lions, in particular incompetence/lazyness/dereliction of duty. But what kind of crimes would really have carried this penalty in the 1st century BC? And would Roman citizens, such as the soldiers that are usually threatened with this, have had to face the lions, or only outsiders?

2 Answers 2017-08-09

Why did the fertile areas of roman africa shrink over time?

The History of Byzantium mentions how the fertile areas of roman owned africa and other areas near the deserts shrank over time. (I think it's his questions episode around #40) He mentions how there are now former roman farming estates/towns in the desert and some type of plant that can no longer be found in the region. Could anyone explain why this happened?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

Were earthquakes less dangerous in the past, since there were fewer and shorter buildings and most of the population lived in farms?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

Why do all the questions I really want the answer to on here have so few replies?

7 Answers 2017-08-09

What caused the U.S. to become the most military focused country in the world?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-08-09

Would it have been possible to live anywhere in the world whilst World War 2 was happening and not know about the war?

3 Answers 2017-08-09

What the sexual attitude towards widow monarchs?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-08-09

How did the idea and practice of landownership come to be?

Where did the concept of landownership come from? It is clearly not universal, given the fame of the indigenous Americans famously lacked the idea. Did it develop from a common root or was it spawned in parallel, by many communities? Furthermore, how did societies manage land use rights in the absence of codified land ownership?

2 Answers 2017-08-09

Since when Christopher Columbus sailed to America, he was originally trying to find India, did he just assume that he had found the Indians when he encountered the Mezoamericans? If so, how long did it take for people to find out that the Aztecs weren't the Indians?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

When Lincoln said "Four score and seven years ago", was he talking the way average Americans talked, or was he intentionally using lofty language?

2 Answers 2017-08-09

Why wasn't there a widespread adoption of horses by the indigenous people of southern Africa?

Hi there r/askhistorians! I'm on a reading binge on the history of horses in Africa, and I'd like to know why there didn't seem to be a widespread adoption of horses by the Bantu/Swahili people of southern Africa.

As I understand it, horses were widespread among the North African civilisations, which were firmly in the Mediterranean sphere and therefore shared a lot of geographic and cultural similarities with southern Europe and the Middle East. Further to the south, horses also played a part in the military and cultural traditions of Sahel cultures like the Mali and Songhai empires, as well as some medieval Nigerian states. Looking at the map, it seems that the Congo Basin was the main barrier to the widespread adoption of horses: the jungle terrain appears to be thoroughly unsuitable for the animals, and I imagine that tropical diseases would've taken a grisly toll as well.

However, the terrain of southern Africa seems to be dominated by open, low-lying savanna - ideal ground for travel on horseback. It looks like there were a lot of opportunities to introduce horses to the region, too: the Swahili coast was historically an important trading hub with tons of exposure to the greater Indian Ocean sphere, and the Portuguese and Dutch surely must've brought some horses along when they colonised Angola and South Africa in the 16th-17th centuries. And finally, many groups in the region seem to have subsisted on cattle and goat-herding, like the Zulu, Xhosa and Khoisan. Looking through history, pastoral cultures across Europe and Asia were practically synonymous with horsemanship. Why didn't these groups integrate the horse into their lifestyle? This seems particularly jarring when contrasted with Plains Indians like the Comanche, who adopted the horse with great enthusiasm and went on to use them to dominate the Great Plains in the same time period.

I'd like to apologise if I've gotten any of the facts wrong, and would greatly appreciate any recommendation for reading materials re:horse cultures around the world. Thank you very much!

1 Answers 2017-08-09

I have recently become increasingly interested in the Black Panther Party

and their ability to militarize and arm themselves under the watchful eye of the US government.

Does anyone have any knowledge of other attempts in US history to oppose the US government in a militant fashion such as The Panthers?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

How to read corroners rolls

Heya folks,

I've started reading corroners rolls from old England and I'm not sure I understand everything correctly. First off, I'm not a native English speaker or reader and I haven't studied legal jargon.

Here is an example of the difficulties I have:

...Alice, his wife, went forth from the house and raised the hue; the hue was pursued, and the neighbours came

What is this hue they talk about, is this just a commotion?

Another part of the same text:

Inquest was made before Simon Read, the coroner, by four neighbouring townships, Renhold, Goldington, Wilden, Barford; they say that they know nothing except as is aforesaid. Alice, Henry's wife, found pledges: Roger Reaper and Simon Rivers, both of Renhold

Ok, a lot happening here. I suppose inquest is just that they requested the coroner to have a look at the case but what's up with the 4 neighbouring townships? Was it common to have other towns request this on behalf of the town afflicted?

Also, Alice found pledges... What do they mean by this? Do they mean witnesses?

And finaly, as almost all the dates are made with references to holidays, would someone have a calendar at hand of English holidays in the 13th century?

Many thanks in advance ;)

1 Answers 2017-08-09

When England won the World Cup in the 1960s all the fans waved the Union Jack but nowadays England fans use the Saint George's Cross (the flag of England). When/why did this change?

2 Answers 2017-08-09

Who were the technologists in Viking-era Scandinavia?

In Neal Stephenson's novel Cryptonomicon, there's a long dialogue about how societies adopt technology, and what they do with it. Vikings are used as one example of a society which would have been dismissive of technological progress. Is this accurate? What role in Viking society would most have involved the mastery of technological minutiae (and/or their refinement)?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

Dear Askhistorians, What is the history behind the branding of goods?

e.g Stickers with manufacturer on things such as mirrors, or tables.

2 Answers 2017-08-09

I've often seen it written that racial (rather than religious) anti-Semitism is very recent (I'm thinking late 19th or early 20th c.). However, isn't Martin Luther's statement about how he'd baptize a Jew by drowning him pretty clearly an instance of racial anti-Semitism?

2 Answers 2017-08-09

Did any Mexican soldiers (I mean Mexican citizens, not Americans of Mexican descent) fight in the Vietnam War?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

What do we know about the early exchange of different languages between people?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-08-09

When evaluating the effectiveness of historical medical practices, how do historians account for the placebo effect?

1 Answers 2017-08-09

⯇ 3213 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start