Coinage in fantasy games and byzantium

Okay, so I read somewhere that the reason prices in D&D are so absurd (10 gold coins the size of your thumb for minor stuff a peasant should be able to afford) is because they're based off of byzantine prices in an era where the "gold" coins were heavily watered down. How much would you have to water down gold for a random agricultural worker to be able to get their hands on a "gold" coin? (Also, is the story in question true?)

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Why did the Germans have defenses right along the beaches of Normandy rather than further inland?

Weren't the Germans concerned about naval artillery destroying their fortifications because they were so close to the shore?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Mermaids used to be considered evil, attracting and drowning men. However, now people (Especially children) generally see mermaids as being nice which probably is due to Disney's little mermaid. Where did this idea of mermaids actually being nice come from?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Narcotics and Government Control. When and why did narcotics become illegal? Who started controlling it and why?

Having seen the ads for "Heroin" and also having read/heard about the availability of cocaine around the same time; what was the first substance controlled by a government and why? What substances followed? What countries followed suit?

How quickly was the uptake to the now almost universal stance on illegal narcotics?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

In modern times, the use of public funds to build stadiums and arenas is a point of debate and criticism. Were there Ancient Romans who argued against expensive public construction projects like the Coliseum?

2 Answers 2017-08-07

Why were so many German resources directed towards the fortification of the Channel Islands?

The British evacuated and demilitarised the islands due to their strategic unimportance, no? And yet they were arguably the most fortified part of the Atlantic wall, with not even a single liberation operation attempted by the Allies

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Nazi Occultism

I keep seeing in popular culture how Nazis scoured the earth looking for ancient artifacts and occult weapons. I was just wondering if there is any truth to this or do they just make a safe villain for media.

1 Answers 2017-08-07

How did the Roman Republican Senate get anything done?

I've read that the Roman Republican Senate numbered as high as 900, with each Senator entitled to speak before a vote was held on a particular topic. Furthermore, Senators held the position for life, if I'm not mistaken.

Under these circumstances, I imagine it would be trivially easy for a small minority in the Senate, on any particular topic, to successfully avoid holding a vote via a filibuster or similar. And given their lifetime tenure (yes, I'm aware "lifetime" could vary), they could be a nuisance for a very long time.

So, how did this work in practice? Did the Consul wield enough power to ensure that Senators would cooperate? Did the civil wars ensure that the Senate was stacked with Consul-friendly appointees?

I'm only just being introduced to Roman history, so I'd be grateful for any suggestions for further reading.

1 Answers 2017-08-07

In light of the amazing battle sequence in last night's *Game of Thrones*, how historically accurate is the Dothraki's fighting techniques to the groups they are based upon (Mongols, Turks, Huns, Scythians, etc)?

Any history buff who watches Game of Thrones knows that the Dothraki are clearly based on the various groups of nomads from the central Asian steppes. The writers draw most directly from the Mongols, but they were just one of the more recent of a long history of central Asian steppe horsemen (Turks, Magyars, Huns, Scythians, Cimmerians, Parthians, Xiongnu, etc). From my understanding, all these groups shared a similar fighting style: namely a focus on light mounted cavalry and horse archers.

Game of Thrones is notable for their hyper-realistic Medieval-style battles (see the Battle of the Bastards, Hardholme, the Battle of Meereen, the Battle of the Blackwater, the Battle at the Wall, etc). We've seen the Dothraki in action before, but they've always been mounted light cavalry armed with their Arakhs (curved, sickle sword similar to a Khopesh ). Last night's episode was the first time we've seen Dothraki archers, though.

This is the only example in movies or TV I can think of where we see the fighting style of central Asian steppe nomads depicted so vividly. My question is multi-layered:

  1. How accurate was that depiction of steppe horsemen fighting techniques?

  2. Did steppe nomads use swords (or other bladed weapons like the Arakhs in the show) as much as is depicted in the show?

  3. Is there any other movie, TV show, or documentary that depicts steppe horsemen fighting as well as, or better than, this episode of the show?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

How did Science-Fiction in particular become so popular in the 50s and 60s, especially as it was a comparatively new genre?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Did Imperial China see any foreign country as a "country"?

Sorry for the title gore if there's any, as English is not my language.

Here's a little bit of background about my question. My history teacher told me that, in Imperial China, from Qin Dynasty to Qing Dynasty, there were only eight countries that China see them as a country, and were granted the status "国", which means a country.

The eight countries are:

  • Empire of Japan
  • Russian Empire
  • British Empire
  • USA
  • French Third Republic
  • German Empire
  • Kingdom of Italy
  • Austro-Hungary Empire

Now if I look back, I find that most of the big empires are not granted the status "国", like Persian Empire are just 波斯, India is 天竺, Majapahit is 满者伯夷 and etc. There is neither "国" nor "朝" in their name.

So leads to my question, does Imperial China ever view other foreign countries as equal to China?

4 Answers 2017-08-07

How accurate was the depiction of T.E. Lawrence in 'Lawrence of Arabia' (1962)?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Did recruitment standards for the air force drop during the Second World War?

Becoming a pilot in the RAF is incredibly difficult due to the physical and mental demands required, however, did these standards drop during the Second World War because the demand for pilots would have been greater, if so were there any implications for this?

2 Answers 2017-08-07

Dogfights in aerial combat started out using guns rather than missiles. What happened when the rounds missed their target?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-08-07

What did swordsmanship look like in the middle ages?

When seeing fictional sword fights, they're prolonged, well choreographed, and truly look like all parties know exactly what they're doing. But do we know what sword battles in the middle ages actually looked like? How long did a sword fight in the battle field take?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Are there bodies on the titanic?

When it sank, hundreds of people died on board and in the freezing water, did the bodies sink with the titanic and are they still on board the wreckage or have they decomposed?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

WWII- Was the US Navy 'lucky' and the Japanese Navy 'good'?

I visited Pearl Harbor recently which prompted me to read more about the post-Pearl Harbor war in the Pacific. I read things about how the US was afraid to fight the Japanese Navy at night, and how, even at Midway where the US won a decisive victory, we were lucky with our reconnaissance and the Japanese were unlucky with their reconnaissance , or we were lucky by having a single bomb hit a Japanese carrier in just the right spot to take it out. This doesn't even mention the fact that the US aircraft carriers weren't present at Pearl Harbor on the day of the attack.

Every account of a true naval battle around Guadalcanal that I've read has the allies coming out on the short end. It's my understanding that, at least early in the war, the Japanese could launch 100+ planes in 7 minutes, while it took the US over an hour to do the same.

I understand that our intelligence/codebreaking made a huge difference, and obviously the American industrial complex outclassed the Japanese... but in a fair/equal fight with luck removed, would the Japanese have beaten the US?

3 Answers 2017-08-07

Monday Methods: Discussion post "History in popular media" (or Dunkirk and Videogames 3: Beyond Methoddome)

Welcome to Monday Methods – a weekly feature we discuss, explain and explore historical methods, historiography, and theoretical frameworks concerning history.

Originally, I planned for today to write about about Bourdieu and the history of taste but I was not able to finish it in time. Thus, spurred on by recent discussion of Dunkirk on this sub, a popular theme makes it return! History as portrayed in movies and videogames.

This sub and its expert have produced quite a bit of content over the last years on the subject and for ease of discussion, I have collected some of them here:

and much, much more.

So, can video games and movies represent history accurately? Is there a need for accurate video games and movies? How can we use video games and movies as a medium to teach / impart history to the public? Does it make sense for historians to get involved in both industry? Share your thoughts and discuss below!

9 Answers 2017-08-07

How did a seemingly unremarkable spice like black pepper reach a level of ubiquity on par with salt?

Throughout history, salt has been a dietary staple, a highly valued trade good, and a necessity for long term storage of certain food items. On the other hand, the world at large only came in contact with black pepper much more recently, initially as a luxury item. How did this spice, not earth-shattering compared to others with a similar history, become so common as to establish an intimate pairing with salt?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

The American Army suffered about fifty thousand casualties in the Vietnam war, while the North Vietnamese and their allies suffered about a million. What caused this massive disparity in casualty numbers? How did the Americans have such a massive K/D ratio?

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Comparing the Dothraki to the Mongols and Native Americans.

Tonight on Game of Thrones we finally got to see the Dothraki army in action. They fought completely different than anyone else in Westoros which gave them a huge advantage. From what little I know about combat history I believe this is the same thing that gave the Mongol Hordes so much success.

I have 2 questions

1: Where can I read about the troubles that the Mongol Hordes presented to the more traditional medieval armies?

2: Did the Mongols or the Native American horseman do cool shit like stand on their saddles to shoot arrows or jump over enemy lines.

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Best books on historic Jesus based on reliable scholarship and research methods?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-08-07

is there a source for this particular piece of alleged Knights Templar "Graffiti"

This particular etching is allegedly made by the Knights Templar during their imprisonment

http://www.templiers.net/symbolique/img/domme_9.jpg

Does it have any meaning, or specific name? I can't find anything on Google.

1 Answers 2017-08-07

Where does anthropology end and history begin? Where do they overlap?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2017-08-07

"During the dynasty of Suppiluliuma I, how much autonomy did the Babylonian Chaldeans have? How cohesive was the Hatti/Hittite empire?"

I say this because I remembered about how it is retained a memory about the Kingdom of Asia in the Bronze Age, and since the dynasty of Hatti have long gone to dust, the memory of it was lost, and attributed to the Assyrians, but as many (I assume, I know at the very least Nichols in his "Fragments of Ctesias") know, the Assyrian Empire never reached that extent, nor the extent of the Achaemenid Empire, which was the one supposed to inherit (which was not so, it was only to lend an air of legitimacy to THEIR conquest)

However, just what I said, the recurrence of an extended Kingdom of Asia from Anatolia to Mesopotamia in ages long past (that is, the Bronze Age) made me rethink it, so... was the Babylonian Chaldaean Dynasty a vassal lordship or a vassal kingship? It is hard to believe that the dynasty of Hatti would go all their way to Babylonia to just say "Nay, don't care, we leave these ones in charge, whatever", especially given how they had no further problems from the Babylonians (they had it with the Assyrians, though)

Just for the record, I had in my mind something similar to the vassal lordship of Syria to the brother of Suppiluliuma I (or was a younger son of his?)

1 Answers 2017-08-07

⯇ 3218 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start