How advanced was Argentina in 1913? It's GDP per capita was in the top ten. Is that number misleading?

2 Answers 2017-07-24

I am a European Australian living around the time of Confederation. What reasons would I have to support this? Is there anyone detracting the movement? Is this something I would even know about as a common man?

EDIT: The time period refers to 1901. The reason I specify European Australian is that I am unsure what if any role Aborigines played in confederation, and if historically it (at that point in time) mattered in the decision making process.

2 Answers 2017-07-24

During the Age of Sail, the stern of a typical ship of the line were often fitted with large glass windows. This seems like a luxury for a war vessel and was a weak point during battle. Did the windows serve a practical purposes?

Picture of the HMS Victory for reference.

1 Answers 2017-07-24

Was Hungary initially the model for the Chinese economic reforms?

Hungary's new economic mechanism is sometimes compared to China's economic reform, but is there any proof that one influenced the other or was it a purely parallel development?

I have searched online for resources and I have found very little information. Even the resources most related to this topic only have brief mentions, nothing conclusive: https://books.google.es/books?id=FPv_AwAAQBAJ&pg=PR7&dq=china+soviet+Gilbert+Rozman&hl=en&sa=X&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=hungary%20market&f=false

I know family members and friends of a Hungarian Marxist economist/reformist called Tamás Nagy (in Hungarian, Nagy Tamás) (there is also very little information about him online) who was involved in the design of the Hungarian economic reforms, and according to his loved ones, during many years, he was constantly surrounded by Chinese Party members who studied him and his work. While I believe them, I have found nothing online about this. All the information I find about him is related to the Hungarian economic reform, and there is no mention about China.

While I doubt any of your answers will be directly related to this man, any kind of help about the relationship between Hungarian and Chinese reforms will be really welcome!

Thank you in advanced.

1 Answers 2017-07-24

What books do we have written firsthand by Medieval "political subjects" (rulers or their relatives, court members, ...) about their lives or the historical events of their times?

I'm thinking about something like De Bello Gallico or Churchill's books about WW2.

I know about, for example, Anna Komnene's Alexiad and I was searching for something similar.

I'm not particularly interested in historical accuracy, I'm more interested in their perspective and emotions so I'm fine with hagiography and exaggerations and even straight up lies if it makes for a good Shakespearean play :)

1 Answers 2017-07-24

What would usually happen to a Roman man who slept with someone's wife?

I know this sounds like a weird question but as I understand it Julius Caesar was doing a lot of people's wives but he didn't try to charge Clodius Pulcher after the Bona Dea thing that he divorced Pompeia over. Augustus ended up making it so husbands were oblogated to kill their wife's lover if they caught them in their home which seems a little extreme but ok.

What would usually be the penalty before Augustus' reforms? Or after, what if they were not caught in the husbands house but were still found out?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

How Much did the Marshal Plan Actually Impact Economic Recovery in Europe?

The sums involved seem rather low in terms of actual GDP. That German industry was entirely destroyed along with the whole Trümmerfrauen thing have mostly been disproved, it seems.

The requirements to take on American management practices and reorganize seems to be the most important aspect.

Further, US exports only accounted for about 4% of GDP through the 50s - it seems that the boom was entirely domestic - and European countries all experienced their own similar "economic miracles" - so the common idea that the US (or e.g. Sweden) prospered due to everywhere else being destroyed seems rather flawed.

To what degree is this correct?

/u/Shashank1000

1 Answers 2017-07-24

I have read on this Forum that "Adolf Hitler's call on the Eastern Front saved the Wehrmacht from collapse after the defeat at Moscow". What does this mean? How much credit can be given to Hitler for this?

This comment says that " Hitler's call on the Eastern Front likely saved the army moving on Moscow from complete collapse". What exactly did Hitler order and what was the effect of this on the Wehrmacht's positions on the ground?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

What effects did the Mongol conquests have on public geographical and international awareness, government administration and public policy, and international trade in the regions they conquered (or their neighbors)?

Asked this about a month ago to zero responses, so taking another shot to see if I can grab the attention of anyone who might be able to answer this time.

The Mongol Empire stretched from Eastern Europe to the shores of Korea, and they fought the Japanese as well as more interior polities in Europe, parts of the world that were ostensibly completely ignorant of one another's existences at the time.

They also swept through vast regions with completely alien cultures and resources to one another. But I've started to realize that all I know of them through a pop-history study is related to their military activities. I get the impression that they were fairly passive administrators and hear nothing about them traders or regulators of trade, much less as scholars, cartographers, or ethnographers.

How much knowledge did they accumulate of the regions they conquered, and how much did or didn't they facilitate the transmission of such knowledge?

Were they responsible for any new knowledge, contact, migration, legal traditions, or trade outside of just military subjugation? Are there any good books about this subject?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

Books on the Context and Meaning of Pablo Escobar ala Robert Caro?

I'm looking for a book on Pablo Escobar, but I'm specifically looking for something more akin to Robert Caro than, say, David McCullough.

Caro likes to write about political power through the lens of LBJ. I want something that gives me a similar treatment of Pablo Escobar: what his reign meant, how it was enforced, the kind of political power he wielded, and how he wielded it. What I'm not interested in is his "badassery" or Narcos-like "artistic license." I want context, facts, and insight.

Please and thank you, /r/askhistorians. (And if this is the wrong sub, please point me in the right direction. I also posted this /r/history.)

1 Answers 2017-07-24

In preparing eunuchs, why did the Chinese cut off the twig and the berries, when in the Middle East/Byzantium they just removed the berries?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

Were any people of colour present during the evacuation of Dunkirk? If so, how many?

I recently heard a lot about the film "Dunkirk". A common complaint is the absence of any people of colour. I despise pandering to an audience by including silly casting that isnt historically accurate. But both British and French militaries had colonies and soldiers from those colonies. How many were present at the battle?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

[The 11th Century] Is it true that the Pope was planning something like the First Crusade before Alexios Komnenos made his call for aid?

2 Answers 2017-07-24

How did leaders communicate orders to armies that we're tens of thousands of men big?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

How did the colour red become a symbol for socialist/communist movements and political parties around the world?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

why did Ottoman Sultans have their brothers executed shortly after they gained the throne?

why did they do this and when did they start doing this? or did they do this at all? I had never head of this before but this Wikipedia page says they did it before 1603 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mustafa_I. also why did they stop after 1603?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

U.S History: Did southern slave states ever think splitting themselves apart in order to get more Congressional seats?

I know that part of the lead up to the American civil war was the fear of more non-slave states joining the union, but did southern states ever think of splitting themselves specifically to gain more pro-slavery senators and congressmen? For instance, if Alabama split itself into East and West they could have essentially have 4 pro slavery senators instead of two, and maybe could have added an extra congressman or two if they split it right?

1 Answers 2017-07-24

When did a method for using longitude become standard practice for naval navigation? How was this method propagated across ships, navies, merchants, and countries?

I am watching the TV series Black Sails, a "prequel" to the novel Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson. The show takes place in 1715.

  • How did the sailing ships navigate the Caribbean so effectively in that time?

  • It is my understanding that naval chronometers did not become widely used for well over a hundred more years. So, how did they do it prior to naval chronometers? Did they use longitude at all?

  • When naval chronometers were finally invented and found to be effective, how did this technology spread from the British navy to British merchant fleets and then to other countries? How long did this take for it to become standard practice?

1 Answers 2017-07-23

Before the invention of the photocopier, how did the plans for a complex machine like a car or airplane get copied and distributed from engineering to the factories where they were built?

What brought this question to mind was learning that during World War II, many different aircraft companies were manufacturing Boeing bombers. What was involved in trying to produce many copies of hand-drawn plans for all the different parts?

1 Answers 2017-07-23

Bigfoot, Twin Peaks, and sparkling vampires- where does the trope of supernatural or "weird" occurrences in the Pacific Northwest originate?

In modern American media, the Pacific Northwest is the setting of much supernatural or weird fiction: Twilight, Twin Peaks, Gravity Falls, and many other stories. When and where does this trope begin? In what kind of media? Was it originally associated with a particular author or work?

3 Answers 2017-07-23

How much, if at all, did the US supplies given to the Soviet Union help the Soviets during the Nazi invasion?

1 Answers 2017-07-23

I've been put in the stocks, but I'm worried about passers by assaulting me. Is there a limit to what they are permitted to do?

What the title says basically. My girlfriend and I were just wondering what was to stop people, especially the victims of the crime, severely hurting the prisoners.

Edit - I'm thinking Medieval England here

1 Answers 2017-07-23

I am a member of the Air Battalion Royal Engineers and have been selected to join the Royal Flying Corps to fly heavier-than-air aircraft. As this is a newly founded section of the military using new technology, who actually trains myself and my comrades to pilot these new crafts?

1 Answers 2017-07-23

Did Tolkien use a lot of his experiences in WW1 to inspire certain parts of Lord of the Rings?

After learning a lot about WW1 and watching Lord of the Rings I can't help but feel he based a lot of parts in his book on his experiences in the war. ie. The idea of adventure and the unknown of Sam and Frodo heading out of The Shire, Saroman's age of industry trying to conquer all, a war to end all wars and shower the world in darkenss, and the needless death and destruction verses the unyielding hope of Aragorn and Gandalf. Even Smeagals schizophrenia is like a soldier with PTSD! thanks in advance for reading.

1 Answers 2017-07-23

The power of the long bow.

For a while now after reading the Bernard Cornwell books, i have wondered how it came to be that the english long bow became so prevalent and powerful.

Within the era of the nornmal bow and the crossbow how did it rise to fame and how did it stay at the top of its game for so long??

1 Answers 2017-07-23

⯇ 3253 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start