Why were the Jews discriminated against throughout history by so many different powers?

It seems like historically, the Jews get blamed for a lot, and not just in ancient or medieval history -- the Holocaust, Soviet Russia, even modern-day anti-Semetism. What made / makes the Jews so darn hated?

1 Answers 2017-07-09

Is there a good book on the history of wonder? What people found amazing at different times in history?

1 Answers 2017-07-09

Help identifying a Revolutionary War symbol/image!

I was at the Museum of the American Revolution and I saw an image repeatedly that I had never seen before that appeared on currency and other artifacts. It was thirteen rings, each ring had a colony's name on it, linked together in a circle. In the center there was a "US" ring (or something to that effect). Any help identifying this symbol? I think I heard someone call it the "ring of states" or "chain of states" but google is not helping me find anything! Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2017-07-09

Patterns in Sengoku Japanese names and their meanings

Hello, r/AskHistorians something that I've noticed for quite some time now, but never thought to ask about it was how there were common "themes" to certain names to nobles in Japan.

For example: During the Oda clan's reign it's very obvious to see the common theme in the clan's naming process to have the prefix Nobu- for the names. So like Nobunaga, Nobuhide, Nobukatsu, Nobukatsu, Nobuyuki etc.... you get my point.

Also the clan's name will be behind it as well, such as Oda Nobuhide and Date Masamune. I'll just assume that is just their last name or whatever so no real significance here.

Anyway my main point I want answered is how come a lot of the time there are common prefixes behind a name? Do these prefixes really have a meaning to them or is it sort of like a familial tradition or both?

1 Answers 2017-07-09

What was the first instance of an aircraft being used for supply movement in a military context, and how did the concept evolve from there?

2 Answers 2017-07-09

How, historically, has the US government gotten involved in treasure hunting or archaeology?

Has the US government ever deployed funds to search for treasure of any kind? If so, why?

How has he US government been involved with these, historically?

It may not be the clearest of questions, my apologies.

1 Answers 2017-07-09

Did tanks during World War II have any sort of system in place to prevent the crew from overheating?

I can't seem to think that steel tanks baking in the sun all day long, combined with an engine in the back, would sustain a comfortable temperature for the crew, especially in fronts like North Africa. Did tanks during World War II have any sort of system to keep the tanks from becoming ovens for the crew?

2 Answers 2017-07-09

Why was the European Parliament created and how has it's role and power in the European Union evolve through it's history?

1 Answers 2017-07-09

How aware were Allied soldiers of the Holocaust/persecution of ethnic minorities during WW2?

I just finished Band of Brothers and the scene where they liberated the camps was quite moving, but I was surprised when the soldiers seemed to be oblivious to the Jewish persecution during the war.

Educated soldiers who read Mein Kampf would have known of Hitler's views of minority groups but was it well known that this was happening by the common soldier?

1 Answers 2017-07-09

During a siege, what happened to the farms and the farmers outside the walls?

Were the people outside the walls be given refuge? Would a town or castle be able to support them? If not were they raped and killed? Was the farmlands destroyed to leave the people starving next year? If so was this used as a threat to get a surrender?

If I must pick a setting, I suppose the hundred years war since it saw sieges on towns and castles. But I would also like to hear from other points in history too.

1 Answers 2017-07-09

In the movie 300, the messenger gets kicked into a 'bottomless pit'. Are there any accounts of similar pits utilized in some way during medieval or ancient times?

I was playing Dwarf Fortress, trying to make a pit for the garbage disposal, when I wondered if there were any historical accounts regarding such 'bottomless' pits as depicted in, for example, the movie '300'?

2 Answers 2017-07-09

Chickens in the west vs tea in the west: why the difference in timing?

Chickens were domesticated out of Asian jungle fowl, probably twice (in the indus region and Burma according to wiki) and spread westward. They arrived early enough to be a part of Roman culture and divination and appear to be an assumed part of domestic life in prechristian times in western europe. They are hardly suitable for trade, since they require live cartage and care unlike walking livestock. They are non-migratory and at best semi or full forest dwellers when undomesticated, their presence supposed trade or human migration. I'm assuming migration? Would we know if they were traded?

Tea was in use in Asia in the 2000bc period and is a highly portable dry good if high value, less than pepper but undeniably tradeable. We know some very high value artifacts traded through Asia and reached western Europe.. so how come we got chickens, which are possibly the least tradeable item but didn't get tea until far later?

1 Answers 2017-07-09

Does asking if a popular documentary series bears any resemblance to reality break the 20 years rule?

Okay, so I've enjoyed several documentaries and documentary-like things in the past, some of which were made more recently than 20 years ago. Would it be acceptable to ask "does x documentary accurately represent an event that happened more than 20 years ago"?

1 Answers 2017-07-09

Whatever happened to axe and shield fighting in the medieval times?

Vikings were the big users of axe and shield in a historical setting, but it seems to fall off after them. However, fighting with an axe and shield is often marked as comparable, or even better than sword and shield fighting in the modern HEMA community. What influences stopped the use of axe and shield?

1 Answers 2017-07-09

How accurate is this video that explains why the Bible is true and trustworthy?

My friend is a Jehova's Witness. She says I should trust what the Bible says but I asked why or how can I trust it? and she sent me this video:

https://www.jw.org/en/publications/books/good-news-from-god/good-news-in-the-bible-from-god/video-bible-true/

I don't know much about history, so how accurate is that??

2 Answers 2017-07-09

When did racism manifest itself as a component of western philosophy/ideology?

I saw this thread, it points out that romans were not racist. This got me thinking about when the ideology began to manifest in western thinking, or re-manifest. The notion of racism is antithetical to much of western ideology.

I would add that I have heard that Protestantism is partially to blame for racist thought in the west. Apparently, certain biblical passages have been interpreted to mean god cursed dark skinned peoples. Did this play any role in racism's introduction to western thought, or was it predicated by some other proponent of racist philosophy?

1 Answers 2017-07-08

AskHistorians Podcast 089 - AskHistorians At the National Council of Public Historians

Episode 89 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make /r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode:

This podcast is a recording of the AskHistorians presentation at the National Council of Public Historians this past April. (90min)

Questions? Comments?

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.

If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.

Thanks all!

Previous episode and discussion.

Next Episode: I'm back as host with an episode on plague and what government response to crisis tells us about the Modern State.

Want to support the Podcast? Help keep history interesting through the AskHistorians Patreon.

2 Answers 2017-07-08

Did Russia and Canada have positive or negative relations during the "Victorian era"?

I made a Reddit account specifically to ask about this topic as I was directed here by a friend, but, I've been trying my darndest to scan the internet for information regarding Russo-Canadian relations during the "Victorian Era", but I've been unable to find much.

Mostly, I'd like to know if they had positive or negative relations, and if a Russian immigrant to Canada during the time would be regarded with suspicion.

1 Answers 2017-07-08

What is the "oldest trick in the book"?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-07-08

Click bait clarification : Israeli attempt to assassinate Indian prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru

http://gginews.in/when-israel-tried-to-assassinate-nehru/ The above is the link to the article which states that there was an Israeli attempt to assassinate the first Indian Prime minister. The author further hopes that the current prime minister will bring up the issue and ask for an apology which raises the following questions.

  1. does this actually qualify as an assassination attempt ? Did Israel really plan assassinations of heads of states at the time ?
  2. What could Israel possibly gain from such a thing at the time ?

Personal note : I feel the article referenced above is biased against Israel,but I would like more views.

2 Answers 2017-07-08

In World War II, what was the reason that so many more Allied soilders and civilians died than Axis ones, even though the Allies won the war?

1 Answers 2017-07-08

Was original sin a big deal before Jesus?

While the followers of Christ were building up his importance, did they come up with the idea that mankind needed to be saved, thus magnifying Jesus' sacrifice?

And, if so, did they reach back into the old testament to find something bad mankind had done which needed saving, thereby anchoring this idea to the respected tome of the Old Testament?

Or was the original sin of eating the apple a big concept already at the time of Jesus?

1 Answers 2017-07-08

Any recommendations for Bronze Age Collapse?

Hey! I am a huge Iron and bronze age nerd, I was wondering if you had any recommendations on books, podcasts or series about the bronze age collapse. I don't quite know if this is the subreddit to ask. Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-07-08

Woodrow Wilson had a PHD. Was he addressed as Dr. President?

1 Answers 2017-07-08

When and why did slavery in the West transform from the conquest-and-economic based system of the Greco-Roman world, to the race based slavery notorious in the colonial era?

Depictions of slavery in the ancient world typically portray it as lacking any racial/ethnic component. A person would not have been enslaved based on their race, but based on their misfortune of being conquered, or because of some debt or crime they had committed. It is often portrayed that they were not enslaved for being considered inferior, but were seen as inferior because they had been enslaved. Was this accurate? If so, how did that system transform into the intrinsically racist system of only holding Africans as slaves, that became infamous during the colonial era in the Americas and Europe?

1 Answers 2017-07-08

⯇ 3289 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start