How many people would you have working in a renaissance armoury?

Largely looking at Rome/ Florence/ Milan 15th century-ish.

I have two types of armoury in mind -- ones which made a lot of simple stuff for mercenaries/ soldiers and ones which made very high quality bespoke things for nobles.

Other things I'm curious about --

  • Was the steel plate and stuff produced in-house, or bought from blacksmiths?

  • I want to know more about the work flow, so straight from commission of a breastplate/ helmet for example, what various hands would everything pass through until the final product was completed?

  • How much better was bespoke stuff (aside from being prettier and better fitting) than munitions grade stuff.

Thank you!

2 Answers 2017-06-13

How accurate are these portrayals of Norse architecture?

I'm currently playing The Witcher 3, a game which features an area heavily inspired by Norse culture during the height of the Viking Age. When looking at the buildings and towns in this game, it made me wonder how Norse buildings would compare, so I took some screenshots:

Some commoner's houses: http://imgur.com/seo5Xpx

A wealthy nobleman's manor: http://imgur.com/MLixxWN

A city gate: http://imgur.com/iqIBUfu

An abadonded mansion: http://imgur.com/zn8n0AC

Did the Norsemen build buildings such as these during the Viking Age? How accurate are the building materials and size?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

When and why did Beijing change it's name from Peking?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

The 9th to 11th Centuries in Ireland were marked by endless skirmishes between the Irish and the Vikings, with the definitive Irish Victory at the The Battle of Clontarf in 1014... What do we know about these battles?

I was reading about The Battle of Clontarf in 1014 where Irish High King Brian Boru defeated a coalition of Norse-Irish (but was slain, with his son and grandson in an ambush on their tent). Do we know much about these battles and how they were fought? Specifically, do we know anything about the Irish tactics which let them defeat the Vikings?

In particular, it seems they changed tactics somehow, as inferred from Binchy:

in pre-Norse times, all wars, inter-tribal and inter-provincial alike, followed a curiously ritual pattern. They were hedged around with taboos; one did not continue to fight after one’s king had been slain; one did not annex the enemy’s territory or confiscate any of their land; one did not dethrone the ‘sacred’ tribal dynasty; one refrained from attacking a number of ‘neutral zones’ on enemy soil—the monastic settlements, the property of the learned castes (áes dána), and so on. Now, however, the Irish found themselves faced with an alien foe who respected none of the traditional conventions ~…

  • D. A. Binchy, ‘The passing of the old order’

As a follow up, if I may, how did Ireland not descend into political anarchy with 3 generations of Royalty killed in one ambush? It seems remarkable that Clontarf was considered the turning point which marks the reduction of the Norsemen to a minor power given the damage to the Irish political infrastructure. (Though perhaps a clue can be found in the Binchy quote above, "one did not dethrone the 'sacred' tribal dynasty" so perhaps they went to 4 generations (derbfhine) instead of just 3 (gelfhine) but that is pure speculation on my part.)

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Why Did Revolutionary War heroes Die in Debtors Prison

Ham Salomon and Robert Morris provided financing and sold bonds on credit of USA during Revolutionary War without which several battles and campaigns led by Washington could not have been won. And, likely, without which the war would likely have been lost. Salomon died at after contracting TB in Debtors Prison. Morris, who signed Declaration of Independence, died in Debtors Prison. Who were the creditors? Who were the judges? Was USA Congress responsible for their demise by failing to pay on bonds Salomon and Morris sold?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Tuesday Trivia: History Is Metal, Vol. 1

It's your week to talk about metal objects and their uses in your era!

Next week: History Is Metal, Vol. 2

2 Answers 2017-06-13

Who introduced bathing to the Europeans?

Was perusing through black twitter the other day and came across this funny post that claims the black moors introduced bathing to the Europeans. How true is this?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Why do tank armaments have such unusual calibers?

This question was asked 3 years ago on this subreddit but there wasn't a really conclusive answer. Anyway....

For example, the T-34 was a really popular tank in WWII, and it's main weapons were either a 76.2mm cannon (3 inches almost exactly, but russia never used the english system) or an 85mm cannon (3.34 inches). What's the logic behind using such strange calibers, some apparently being based in inches, others being based in the metric system?

Other examples:

M4 Sherman - 75mm, 76mm, or 105mm howitzer

Slighty off topic, the battleship Yamato had 46cm/18.1 inch guns, kind of a strange caliber.

KV-2 - 152mm, 107mm, 122mm cannons.

2 Answers 2017-06-13

Often photos of Pre-Revolution Iran or Pre-Taliban Afghanistan are posted, showing how similar these countries were in the 60's and 70's to the West. How accurate was this estimation?

2 Answers 2017-06-13

Given that the KKK are the heroes of "The Birth of a Nation," Abraham Lincoln's relatively positive portrayal is surprising. What were D.W. Griffith's personal views on Lincoln? Were they in line with how Lincoln is portrayed in the film?

I know Griffith made a 1930 film on Lincoln, but I haven't seen it. Is the positive portrayal of Lincoln more of a criticism of the Johnson administration than an embrace of Lincoln himself?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

[Asian History] I'm looking for information about the culture in Shanghai in 1936, can anyone explain the time period to me or recommend me articles or books?

I'm looking to learn about 1930s Shanghai, especially around 1936, as I'm going to be playing in a roleplaying game set then, and it's really piqued my interest.

  • What events were happening there?

  • What recently happened there?

  • Why? What happened in the past to lead to those things occurring?

When I look online for information, I can only find "This is some stuff that happened in 1936 Shanghai" and not "This is why some things were happening in 1936 Shanghai". For example, I know the British established territories there where they were under British law instead of Chinese law, but it was hard to track down why it happened - the Opium trade.

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Why did the Nazis possess anti-aristocratic and anti-monarchist views?

You would think that they would be appreciative of a system that enables absolutist rulers

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Is it possible that copies of lost epics like those comprising the Theban Cycle are sitting in private collections? And have any lost works been rediscovered from them?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

How much did Winston Churchill drink in a day? (so I can turn it into a drinking game)

Me and some friends are planning on spending a weekend doing what we've dubbed the "Churchill Challenge" during a visit to Berlin. The aim is to drink the exact amount that Winston Churchill drank in a day at roughly the same time so any information or sources would be appreciated.

2 Answers 2017-06-13

When cargoes could be moved along the Red Sea, why there was still the need for the camel caravans crossing the Arabian Desert for the Spice Trade?

Transportation through waterways was much cheaper. From Yemen to Egypt/Syria, ships could move along the Red Sea. Ancient Egyptians and Romans both used Red Sea for trade with Africa and India.

The Arabians tribes could move spices through the desert on camel backs. But shouldn't it be more expensive than the Red Sea route?

If yes, why did the camel caravans in the desert through Mecca/Medina become so important in the middle ages for transporting spices from Yemen to Egypt/Syria?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

I have a sweet tooth. How limited would my options be as an average urban resident in western Europe of the High middle ages?

I once read in a textbook that for western crusaders, sugar was a once-in-a-lifetime treat. How true is that statement, and does it extend to other forms of sweets? I'm not specifically focusing on crusaders, so I've picked an urban resident since I assume they'd be more exposed to variety due to trade than rural subjects, but I can extend the question to anyone. However, I'm asking about an average earner, not someone rich enough to afford expensive exotic goods.

Were natural products like honey, fruits, or berries affordable to the average person around 12th-14th centuries? If refined sugar was out of reach, were there other forms of affordable sweeteners? /u/sunagainstgold recently mentioned in another post that "various bakers' crafts in the Middle Ages were among the most organized and intricate"; were sweet pastries popular, or were they mostly savoury instead?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Why do we never call our parents by name?

I get that the words 'mama' and 'dada' are easier for a baby to say, but where did the words 'mother' and 'father' come from specifically, and why do we never switch to calling them by name when we're older?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Most SI units are named after prominent physicists in related fields. Why is the watt used as the SI unit for power, when James Watt was an inventor and engineer, but not a physicist?

James Watt made important contributions as an inventor and engineer, including an improved steam engine and other inventions, but his closest field of science was chemistry, and that's not what he's most known for anyways.

Out of all the SI units, base and derived, I think the watt is the only one named for someone not a prominent physicist.

2 Answers 2017-06-13

Were the effects of WWII AA/flak rounds falling back to earth ever documented? One might assume that there exist today areas that are or were littered with all the rounds that would have come back, never having hit their target.

Thanks so much for all the great answers! Fascinating, if morbid, stuff here.

2 Answers 2017-06-13

Did the Romans calculate the year different when the Julian calendar was created, and if yes, when did it change into the present days year representation.

The Julian calendar, proposed by Julius Caesar in 46 BC (708 AUC), was a reform of the Roman calendar. (From wikipedia)

Now because at that time nobody could predict that we would calculate our year based on a religious figure from 46 years later I would assume they did calculate their years normally until a certain date, and then changed this. So my question is, did the Romans calculate the year different, and if yes, when did it change into the present days year representation.

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Why did Rome become an imperium while Athens and Sparta did not?

Above.

1 Answers 2017-06-13

At what point in History did moving from one century to another change Humanity so much? Like 1877 - 1977.

2 Answers 2017-06-13

Has the recent declassification of the records of the french army mutinies of WW1 shed any new light on the events?

The mutinies started the 27th of may 1917 and the records were supposed to be classified for 100 years. I haven't been able to find anythinig online that deals with these new sources. Can any historian share some new insights or haven't the sources been declassified yet?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

Why exactly did they British choose to wear red and not like, blue or something?

1 Answers 2017-06-13

The recent E3 reveal of the new Wolfenstein game depicts a fictional German occupation of the United States, with Nazis (seemingly) befriending the KKK. What were the positions of the KKK on Germany (and the United States' role) during WW2?

bonus question, though possibly a counter-factual (what if) question: Is it conceivable the KKK and/or other white supremacist groups would have welcomed a Nazi occupation because of a shared racialist ideology?

3 Answers 2017-06-13

⯇ 3345 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start