Why did Hitler executed Jews with gas, ovens, shots, etc if they could work? Wouldn't be more efficient just make them work until they starve instead of spending resources with mass killings?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

What role, if any, did the Crusades have in spreading math and philosophy from the Arabic world to Europe

I've always had some vague idea of a crusaders arriving in the Middle East to conquer, merchants are involved also. Somehow they acquire this knowledge and return back to Europe. But I'd like a clearer idea of what was going on. Or were the Crusades a coincidence and normal trade was what spread the books and teachings?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

How come ancient egyptian hieroglpyhs remained relatively unchanged for thousands of years, when I can't even understand English from a few hundred years ago.

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-05-23

[Meta] What is a good book (or SHORT series) about the US Presidents (Preferably up to/including Obama)? I'm having trouble identifying one that doesn't have a political bias to it

I'm looking for a comprehensive as can be book or short series about the US presidents, from #1 up to and including Obama, but not necessarily, since I understand he's not quite history yet, just a few short months removed from office. While I understand it would take a doctoral degree, involving reading dozens of books, primary sources etc to have a complete understanding of each president, I'm looking for something that's a bit easier to digest. Whether it's a single book or a short series, I'm looking for something in the order of several hundred to a couple thousand pages.

To clarify, I'm most interested in their political careers, much moreso than their personal lives, though that is definitely a requirement as well. I don't want to read trimmed-down biographies of these people, detailing how they grew up etc. I want to understand how their administrations worked, what challenges they faced, what they accomplished, I want that to be the meat of the book, while of course also getting personal information to contextualize it all.

To end a rather long-winded post, I'm not interested in reading about presidents from a conservative/liberal point of view. Though I'm as liberal as they come, I don't believe that's a good way to learn about history. I'm definitely looking for something with a more neutral perspective, though some author analysis is certainly welcome if it's along the established thinking.

And lastly, as far as reading level, I actually was a history major so I don't necessarily have a problem reading scholarly work. I specialized in roman history (wrote my thesis on Constantine's "conversion" to Christianity), so I just didn't get the time to focus on US politics. Anyway, while I'm not scared of that kind of dense reading, of course i'm open to lighter, coffee-table sort of reading as well, or anything in the middle.

EDIT: I'm bad at math and made a fatal error. Obviously I need more of an anthology vs one or two books.

1 Answers 2017-05-23

Would any of the nearly 400,000 soldiers evacuated from Dunkirk in 1940 have participated in the invasion of Normandy in 1944? Or is it more likely they were redeployed someplace else, like North Africa?

2 Answers 2017-05-23

Is this warship paint scheme accurate, and if so what was its purpose?

The game 'World of Warships' claims that this was the paint scheme of HMS Hood at the time of the Battle of the Denmark Strait.

Is this accurate? If so, what is the purpose of this specific shade of blue, and white turrets with red tops (if there was one)?

3 Answers 2017-05-23

The Black Prince (son of Edward III), was so called due to his black armour in battle. Was this a contemporary nickname or added in legend. Is there any truth to it? How would he have made his armour black and why was it uncommon for people to have black armour? Thanks.

2 Answers 2017-05-23

So I'm taking a class on piracy...

I am writing a paper on the weaponry of pirate past and present. its been a bit difficult finding credible sources for my information. I specifically need sources for information on flintlock pistols. I really need something I can cite. So historians, can you aid me in my search for credible informations on the internets?

3 Answers 2017-05-23

Render unto Caesar: What was the effective taxation rate of the middle-class in Roman Judea during the time of Jesus?

There is quite a lot of discussion and documentation around what taxation was in ancient Judea and whether it was/wasn't biblical/just/sinful, but there isn't a lot as to what the actual rate of taxation was. What I'm looking for is to understand what a normal middle-class person would pay in taxes per year and what the effective tax rate would be.

I'm also somewhat interested in whether there were progressive taxation rates or whether the Roman Empire operated on a flat/consumption tax model.

1 Answers 2017-05-23

How good of a general was Bernard Montgomery? And why was he so unpopular with other allied commanders?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

What is the Gladio?

In his great answer here about San Marino, /u/commiespaceinvader mentioned the existence of a group called the Gladio, a "NATO financed secret army" which was allegedly active in the 1970's.

A quick google search brought up a lot of conspiracy sounding things so I thought I would ask here, where I'll be able to trust the answer.

Thanks in advance.

EDIT this is awesome, thank you!

1 Answers 2017-05-23

Was the communist takeover of Poland post-WWII an unfortunate necessity to finally unseat the gentry...allowing an eventual functioning Democratic Republic to form?

The feudal system in Poland seemed to linger on longer than most European countries. Many have cited the "Golden Freedom" and liberatum veto of the Polish nobility as factors that, along with bribes from foreign powers, prevented any real unity and lead to the partition. How much power did the Gentry regain after Poland was re-established after WWI and did the communist period finally stamp it out for good?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

Did people living in the Roman Empire call it the "Roman Empire"?

I'm listening to The History of Rome and as I move into the 3rd century and Rome, as a city, becomes less and less important to the Roman Empire the question popped into my head. If I were to walk up to someone on the outskirts of the Empire in say the late 200's and asked them where they live would they, as part of their answer, say "The Roman Empire"? What did an everyman living under Roman rule call / consider it?

2 Answers 2017-05-23

Why did "communist" revolutions often originate in agricultural instead of industrial societies?

A quick search on this subreddit showed that a similar question was asked four months ago, but the only (interesting) answer is about why Cuba's revolution wasn't really communist.

If I recall correctly communism was a response by Marx and Engels on the exploitation of labourers during the industrial revolution. So what lead to the so-called communist revolutions in mostly agricultural societies?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

How did places like the USA, Canada and Australia become successful after decolonisation when so many other ex colonies are still extremely poor and generally undeveloped or developing countries?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

I was told in a lecture that no two (true) democratic states have ever gone to war. How true is this, and what examples are there?

2 Answers 2017-05-23

Is the "leaking" of documents a purely modern phenomenon, or were there politically significant leaks in earlier periods of history?

2 Answers 2017-05-23

A good documentary about the crusades?

I am looking for a decent documentary to watch to get a general overview of the first three crusades and the kingdom of Jerusalem. So far I have only found conspiracy theories about the Knights Templer courtesy of the "history" channel on YouTube.

1 Answers 2017-05-23

[repost as asked by a user][Military History]Static crossbow "loader", why did they use it ?

Disclaimer:

I posted this 10 days ago.

I had an answer from u/Valkine who said that they were in a visit and didn't have access to all their tools/info there and that I should repost this question 10 days later, so here I am.

From the first post however it's been said that it probably was actually used as a tool to build crossbows and not as a crossbow loader, which makes much more sense to me.

The following is a n exact paste of the original post, and here is a link to the original so you can see its answers.

pasted post

Hi everyone

A local newspaper made an article on two crossbow loaders that were found in a neighboring city. Aside from the fact I have a question about it, I think I should put it here as well because according to what's said in the article it's quite a good find and might interest some of you. (to clarify, it's not these small forked objects, it's a huge thing)

Here is the link to the article (no paywall), it is in French. Here's the pic of the loader without the article and bigger, I couldn't find ANY other picture on the internet of such a device

I will write down there a full translation of the digital article in case you're curious, just skip it otherwise, my question isn't answered by the article.

Beginning of article

Two crossbow loaders from 1353 found in Sion

image label: The object now exhibited in history museum allowed to load knight's crossbows

Middle Ages: recent studies allowed to shed light on pieces that were found in the Valère arsenal, crossbow loaders built in Winter 1353.

We thought these were catapults. Two pieces of wood were "sleeping" (kinda weak translation but whatever you get it) in the cantonal depots for quite a while. When the arsenal was inventoried, a hundred years ago, we had labelled them as simple catapults. Until the day where an archeologist and German historian, Fabian Brenker, turns his interest to it. According to him, it is not a catapult but a crossbow loader. "I knew of the existence of this object from the literature, but never, to my knowledge, had we found one in real life." Without waiting, he makes contact with the cantonal museums and goes to Sion. Thanks to his analyses, he manages to determinate the precise date of creation of the object. Winter 1353. The loader although imposing and difficulty transportable, was essential to the knight. Before every shot, this man had to reload his weapon. From shadow to light

the preservation of these objects is a miracle. "They could have been used to make a fire, says Fabian Baker. The fact they still do exist demonstrates of their value." Their identity found again, the most beautiful of the 2 pieces is today out of the shadow. She has made her entrance in the museum of history where it proudly sits at the entrance.

End of article

(The digital article is smaller than the paper one I have, but the only real difference is that it mentions that it was too heavy to carry around so was probably used for defense of static positions such as towns, the rest of the paper article is really not that interesting)

My questions :

Why did we need this ?

I mean from what I've always seen/read/heard on crossbows, I know they're a pain to reload but I thought that you could always do that with both your hands or with a crank for some. Isn't that ineffective to have to line up/move to the location of the loader and wait for your turn to reload this ? Or did there exist crossbows so powerful you couldn't actually reload them by hand ? Was it because it was too early to have cranks invented ? Because it's cheaper than cranks ? Because it's making it less hard on your body to sustain longs periods of using this weapon ? Because there's less risk of harm to yourself when you reload it this way ?

Googling around, I couldn't even find another picture or mention of static crossbow loaders, whether in French or English, looks like a really niche thing so I guess it was far from extremely useful ?

I appreciate you reading this far and hope you'll have useful answers :) (And it looks like knights where I used to live didn't care much about the whole "no range kills" thing, just noticing by the way)

1 Answers 2017-05-23

Did the English Normans and Sicilian Normans have significant trading and cultural exchanges?

England and Sicily were conquered by the Normans around the same time in the 1060s and 1070s, and for a century + we had Norman kingdoms in both. Is there evidence that they had some kind of special relationship between them? The pointed arch appears in England before becoming an iconic element of French Gothic architecture, did the idea come from Norman Sicily? According to a book I was reading, food in early Norman England was more similar to Italian food of the same era than to the much closer northern French cuisine. Is this because Normans built a special trading and cultural relationship between the two kingdoms?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

Did Gustavus Adolphus ride into battle without armour, believing God protected him?

I've seen this claimed at times. I guess leaders have done stranger things due to religious zeal, but it sounds more like something that might have happened once, to boost morale.

Is there any truth to the claim?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

Did guilds exist in classical times? If so did they hold power?

So I was always taught tha guilds were a medieval phenomenon that often held considerable power in feudal society.

I was wondering though, why wouldn't there be something similar in the Roman empire or the Greek city states? Especially considering the high degree of urbanization there was.

2 Answers 2017-05-23

In the song "The Way Of Vikings" by Amon Amarth they sing about vikings fighting to the death during training. Did vikings actually train to the death?

to help out with not having to google the song, here is the actual song, and here are the lyrics for those of you having some trouble following the growled vocals.

1 Answers 2017-05-23

How did the roman empire operate during the tetrarchy? What issues were there with regards to succession?

1 Answers 2017-05-23

Why did Prussia/Germany ask for such relative little after the war against France in 1870-1871?

I don't know much about this war, but one particular thing I'm interested in is why did the Germans ask for so little?

They were destroying French armies left and right, they were unbeaten in the field, the blockade on Germany was basically a failure, the French government was in disarray and Paris was under siege and nearing total capitulation.

They were winning the war decisively, yet when the Armistice was negotiated, all the Germans asked for was Alsace-Lorraine (which is a fairly rich province, to be fair) and an immediate payment.

Why didn't they ask for more? A yearly war reparations, more territory, protectorates (like the Saar protectorate, for instance, was imposed on Germany).

Also, BBC News claims that the treaty that ended this war was more harsh than the Treaty of Versailles, but that's obviously false, right?

2 Answers 2017-05-23

⯇ 3389 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start