How and when did the German people become so industrious?

Despite two grueling defeats in the last century, Germany has rebuilt itself time and time again, currently the 4th wealthiest country in terms of GDP.

Always an intellectual and economic powerhouse despite immense hardships, at what point were these core values of diligence and responsibility instilled into the nation's core ethos? And by whom?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Hypothetically, would Jesus have understood or spoken Latin?

I understand that he would have lived in a Roman controlled area, and I believe that the predominantly spoken languages in these territories did not generally change, but I find it hard to believe that the general people of a long ago conquered land had not picked up the language of their conquerors.

4 Answers 2017-05-10

Did the everyday first century Jew hate Rome?

I know there were rebellious factions popping up all over the place that eventually led to the First Jewish War of 66-70AD, but did the average, everyday Jewish person like or dislike Rome as a dominant power, or were they more apathetic? Also, did the well-off Jews (financially and religiously) like Rome more for the wealth and security it could provide? TIA!

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Were crippled Wehrmacht soldiers treated to same, or better than other handicapped people?

To my understanding near the end of the war Nazi Germany killed a lot of handicapped people. But I've also read that the soldiers of the German army were treated really well because they fought for the fatherland and stuff. Were disabled/handicapped Wehrmacht soldiers treated better than just random people? i.e. A soldier has his legs blown off by a mine or something. Sorry if this has been asked already, i couldn't find it.

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Why does this book in my library have an old page in the spine?

Found this old book in the stacks in my college library. It looks like the spine has fallen off after many years, and underneath that spine there's some kind of page or newspaper pasted in there. Why was that done? https://imgur.com/gallery/qEYT6

2 Answers 2017-05-10

My professor has a PhD in Byzantine history, bachelors in Latin and Greek. What would this B.A. Look like in terms of coursework? Would it be like a degree in Classics?

2 Answers 2017-05-10

When did polling become such a prominent part of elections, particularly in western democracies?

It occurs to me that the reporting of opinion polling has become a ubiquitous characteristic of modern election campaigns. This recent flurry of European elections and the US election seems to really have brought it into focus.

We seem almost completely obsessed with polling these days, to the point at which many voters who otherwise would consider supporting a candidate, will abandon them simply because they fall out of the "top 2" and seem "less likely to win". Maybe it's some sort of short term memory bias, but I don't recall it being this prominent a feature of election campaigns 20 years ago. It seems to really have kicked up a gear recently.

Does anyone know the history of opinion polling, especially its role in election coverage? When did it become a thing that the average voter cared about, or had regular access to via TV / print media? What were the first elections where it really mattered? Did it feature heavily or even influence presidential or legislative elections in decades or even centuries past?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Can someone explain to me the Caroleans march to Poltava?

I'm just a dude interested in history, but i only used Wikipedia before discovering this sub and reading all the wonderful answers you have here. My question pertains to the events leading to the battle of Poltava between Sweden and Russia. Why would an army based so much on conserving their manpower and taking as few losses as possible like Sweden advance all the way to Ukraine (or Ruthenia) through "scorched earth"? And why Ukraine (or Ruthenia), and not Russia proper? Can someone explain the events leading up to the battle, and the thinking of Charles XII? (not necessarily the whole Great Northern War).

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Where and when did the "New Car Scent" originate in the automobile industry?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Why didn't China discover America?

Hi there! I was wondering about why didn't China discover America before the European.

Was there even a time when it could happen? If so, why it didn't?

Ps. Not a native English speaker and apparently today I can't articulate, so sorry if I've made some mistakes, point them to me and I will edit them

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Recommendations for readings and books on American Psychological warfare programs in the Vietnam War?

Hello, as the title says I am looking for books, even chapters in books, and any other material covering the American Psychological warfare program in the Vietnam war. Any sources are much appreciated, thanks!

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Why was Henry 1 Charter of liberties largely ignored by monarchs until the issuing of Magna carter?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

What was life for Richard Nixon like after he resigned the presidency?

  • Was he an outcast after the scandal and resignation?

  • Did he shy away from the public eye or was he present in different political arenas, public speaking engagements etc?

  • What were his career options (how did he continue to make a living after the resignation)?

  • Did the secret service continue to protect and follow him for the duration of his life?

  • Any other insight into life after resignation is much appreciated!

1 Answers 2017-05-10

How did Ancient Rome and Greece use dogs in battle?

Would any soldier hold a leash, or were there specific dog-handlers? And is there any credibility to the idea of "piriferi", dogs who had buckets of flaming oil strapped to their backs before being released on the enemy?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Churchhill & Bengal famine?

Tried to learn a bit about this from popular media; now at an impasse. What was the reality of the Bengali famine / how do you cut through all the noise?

Sometimes it's listed as a "forgotten genocide", in which 1-3 million people starved to death in 1943. Modern Indian & Bengali pop articles love to reference this alleged Churchhill quote: “I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion. The famine was their own fault for breeding like rabbits.” There's also some quote about how it was more important to make sure the Greek people were well fed? On the flip side, the Churchhill Project @ Hillsdale has an article about it, referencing many attempts to send grain back to India, but doesn't mention a thing about the rice exports. I'm sure the reality is somewhere in between the "The Brits hated brown people the same way they hated the Irish" and "Winston Churchhill is a god among men, war is hell" extremes... but what?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Did Eisenhower really order American and British troops to halt their advance on Berlin in order to let the Russians get their first?

Forgive for me for my sins, but a little over year ago I read just about every book that WEB Griffin has written (sometimes you just need some mind candy). As well as being famously cantankerous, Griffin is known for peppering his works with historical anecdotes that are often untrue (hence "historical fiction"). In one of his books in the "Brotherhood of War" series, he mentions that during the Allied advance on Berlin, Eisenhower orders American and British troops to halt in order to let Zhukov and the Russians take Berlin first. Is this fact or fiction? A bit of both?

Also, he mentions that this decision by Eisenhower sent I.D. White into a flying rage. Is this true? I've looked for sources on White for a while, but have yet to find anything reliable or accessible.

Thanks!

Edit: Christ on a cracker, I can't believe the title says "their" instead of "there." I'm ashamed.

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Oldest Classified Files?

A recent question (https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6aanfn/are_there_still_any_top_secret_or_classified/ ) asked if any files remain classified from the WWII era, to which the answer is (in brief), "yes".

Do we know what the oldest files are that remain classified and inaccessible to those outside the US government without the proper security clearance?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Were there ever any Jewish nobility or royalty?

In A Series of Unfortunate Events there are a bunch of contextual clues which suggest that Count Olaf may be Jewish. Which is weird, because, y'know, the Count part.

Were there ever any instances of European nobility marrying Jews and producing Jewish heirs? If so, were there any scandals about them, as with Wallis Simpson?

Edit: By which I mean European, castles-and-tea royalty. Judean royalty would seem to be a given.

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Wednesday What's New in History | May 10, 2017

Previous weeks!

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Thoughts on Aurangzeb?

Some people really hate Aurangzeb (especially Hindu nationalists). Other people think he was pretty great (https://aeon.co/essays/the-great-aurangzeb-is-everybodys-least-favourite-mughal). Do the claims made by this article (and other Aurangzeb-rehabilitators) on the one hand, or Hindutva type folks on the other, hold up or is this a case of demonisation on the one side and whitewashing on the other?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

Book recommendation about the excavation of Troy

Hello, I was hoping someone might be able to point me in the direction of some good resources to learn more about the excavation of Troy. It doesn't need to be a scholarly paper, I'm just reading for pleasure, but I would like it to be up to date and accurate.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-05-10

A good source for causes WWI?

Hi,

Looking for a good source (preferably a podcast as I have a hard time concentrating on reading) for the causes, course, and results of WWI.

1 Answers 2017-05-10

What was the cause of the Port Royal fire in 1703?

I was reading through Quest for Blackbeard: The True Story of Edward Thache and His World and on page 80, one passage read:

As if emulating the destruction of the nearby Bahama Islands by their mutual enemies, a dreadful fire struck Port Royal on Jamaica, only eleven years after the devastating earthquake of 1692.

I did some quick internet research but the only thing I could find was a google book Investing in the Early Modern Built Environment: Europeans, Asians, Settlers and Indigenous Societies, where between pages 204-205 a passage reads:

Crowded conditions and wooden structures, however, made Port Royal vulnerable to fire, a threat realized on January 9, 1703. The cause of the fire was uncertain, although all observers suggested it started in a store belonging to a Captain Hudson. Some pinned responsibility on a servant who left a candle burning in the storehouse filled with combustible goods. Others thought that lightning ignited some loose powder barrels in the structure.

So there is quite a bit of uncertainty on who or what started the fire, but if anyone here can give a definitive answer I would love to know.

1 Answers 2017-05-10

How much money did Renaissance artists like Michelangelo make? What kind of lifestyle could he afford?

2 Answers 2017-05-10

Did the early-modern developers of the physical/chemical atomic theory explicitly credit ancient philosophical Atomism?

So, as a physicist, it's clear that the ancient Atomism and the physical atomic theory come from completely different approaches - philosophical Atomism is not empirical in the same way etc.

But at the same time, the early modern developers of the physical/chemical atomic theories chose to use the word "atom", apparently in reference to the Atomism tradition - I skimmed John Dalton's 1808 work "A New System of Chemical Philosophy" and noticed that he seems to assume that readers are already familiar with the term, as he uses the term without defining it first.

So, I'm wondering how strong the links are here. Does Dalton or any other scientist from the period explicitly discuss the ancient Atomism of Democritus, Epicurus etc as an inspiration, or do they simply adopt the word because it was in common usage amongst intellectuals?

1 Answers 2017-05-10

⯇ 3416 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start