What led the way for French, a descendant of vulgar Latin, to be the language of France, and not the Germanic language of the Franks?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Which event had larger death toll: Nanking Massacre or Hiroshima/Nagasaki bombings?

Both are very large estimations:

  • Nanking (50K – 300K)
  • Atomic Bombings (129K – 246K)

Do we have any idea how comparable are both events in terms of death count? Just to be clear, I'm not trying to justify the bombings or anything; just making comparisons for research.

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Morphine addiction amongst former soldiers in the aftermath of WWI

Is there any evidence for the use of or addiction to morphine or other drugs (excluding alcohol) amongst returned soldiers following the First World War, particularly amongst the wounded? If so, how was this addressed?

I've just read an outstanding answer to an earlier question by /u/The_Alaskan:

Marijuana was prohibited in 1937, yet Nixon is said to have started "the War on Drugs". What did Nixon do that wasn't already being done since 1937?

in which this quote can be found:

Even at this early date, drug use was being considered a crime in the United States, not a medical condition to be addressed. Contrast this with the report drafted in the United Kingdom by a panel of experts led by Sir Humphry Rolleston. In 1924, the committee advised the British government that addiction to morphine and heroin should "be regarded as a manifestation of disease and not as a mere form of vicious indulgence."

Looking up Rolleston it appears that he was was consulting surgeon and surgeon rear-admiral with the Royal Navy during the war, and remained active on the consultative board for the Navy for many years thereafter. I'm wondering if it is this experience with wounded troops that informed his opinion, and if it emerges from knowledge of opiate addiction amongst returned ex-servicemen.

1 Answers 2017-04-12

I'm going to marry the woman I love. I'm a Saxon living in 9th/10th century England. What will my wedding ceremony be like?

To be more specific, how different would wedding ceremonies have been from modern Catholic ones?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

What was the contextual historical significance of Year Zero? Why would God have intervened then and not another point in history?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Were the Walloons celts??

English is not my first language, i looked this up and have a hard time understanding if they were, please help to explain.

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Looking for a book on Europe from period beginning in the late 1700s to 1914.

I have been looking but it's so hard to find something unbiased and not to difficult to read. Can someone help me out?

2 Answers 2017-04-12

How silent was Calvin Coolidge, and how did he conduct government business while being quiet?

2 Answers 2017-04-12

What caused Henry V to start using English rather than French in government in 1417?

And are there any other comparable moments in the late Middle Ages/early Modern period where a ruler switched to the language of the people rather than that of the ruling classes?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Hand armor during the early middle ages

I have looked through countless drawings reenactors and various other things and i have noticed i can only find images of bracers that would offer no hand protection which it seems like that would be a very big problem since the hand would be one of the most exposed areas in combat was there any sort of armor for that area before the crusader era?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

On the Wikipedia page for the One-sex and two-sex theory, it says that "Gender, prior to the eighteenth century, was not prescribed upon individual; a man could be physically male, but he could have a feminine gender identity." How true is this?

Also, if any, what's the current consensus on the one-/two-sex theory?

The Wikipedia page in question: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-sex_and_two-sex_theories

1 Answers 2017-04-12

How did the hebrew god Yahweh evolve?. Is he really an offshoot of El, and was it polytheistic in its origins?

I've been wondering this for a while but so far have only picked up bits and pieces. http://www.city-data.com/forum/religion-spirituality/1818445-evolution-yahweh-pagan-tribal-god-israel.html

Above is the best answer I can find to this question.Please ignore the religous convictions and focus on the logical argument and evidence presented. Please, I'm asking for pure evidence here, not religious convictions. What exactly do historians understand about the evolution of ancient Judaism when it comes to yahweh. How did he evolve? In the above thread it mentions that the dead sea scrolls contains references to a polytheistic tabernacle of gods.

Thanks for any responses ahead of time!!!

1 Answers 2017-04-12

What are the differences between Storm troopers, Shock Troops and Grenadiers?

How are they used on the battlefield and does the US Military have any equivalents of these classes?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Why are baby's and children's clothes designated by gender by the colors pink and blue? How did this come about and when did this trend become popular?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

How did the first European explorers in the Americas, and other previously uncontacted parts of the world, communicate with the locals?

I am currently listening to the audio book of Sapiens, and during the chapter discussing Hernando Cortez manipulating the Aztec aristocracy I wondered how he would do so? What about the first Portuguese in Goa? Magellan in the Philippines? Dutch and English in Indonesia and Australia?

What language would they speak? Would they use interpreters? How long would it take to learn each other's languages with zero educational resources?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

What should I ask my 96 year old WWII vet grandfather?

I'm wondering if you all have questions for a relic who loves talking about old times. He's fully cognizant and likes writing letters but I don't know history well enough ask informed questions.

He was an Italian soldier fighting the allies as a paratrooper, captured by the British in North Arica during the battle of El Alamein, escaped the prison camp loosing a friend in the escape, then snuck across North Africa and Europe back Italy. He spent the night between the legs of the Sphinx one of his first nights after his escape! He then moved to Argentina after the war where I hear a lot of former Axis supporters went. He says he didn't know what atrocities the Germans doing during the war and that he doesn't agree with their ideals but he's pretty racist and thinks...differently about people than I'm used too.

He comes from a different time and perspective and we have a great opportunity to learn about the past. It would also keep him engaged. Can anyone think of questions for him or things you'd like to know more about considering his experiences?

10 Answers 2017-04-12

Why did Alexander the Great want to kill King Darius iii?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Why did President Lincoln hold Kentucky in such high regard durine the American Civil War?

2 Answers 2017-04-12

Can you help me come up with a thesis for an analytical paper on black American leaders (pre-civil war)?

Hi historians! I need to write an analytical paper on slavery/black American leaders pre-civil war. While I can think of loads of topics (underground RR, Tubman, Turner, Douglas)...I'm struggling finding something to analyze for 6 pages without just summarizing what/who I'm talking about. Any ideas?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Is it true that there's no documentary evidence that the Japanese army forced "comfort women" into prostitution?

I came across this paper by a Japanese historian. He claims that there is no objective evidence that the Japanese army ever enslaved Korean women for prostitution, other than the testimony of sixteen victims prepared by the Korean government. He's unabashedly right wing and patriotic, but is what he says here true?

This masochistic drift of public opinion within Japan reached its peak in August 1993 when Chief Cabinet Secretary Kouno Youhei officially acknowledged and apologised for the enforced prostitution of Korean women by the Japanese army: "With regard to recruitment of comfort women, businesses who took orders from the Army were the key players but, even so, there are many examples of people being assembled against their wishes by means of enticements or force. It is clear, too, that the Military Police were also directly involved."

At this time, the Japanese government devoted all of its energies to searching for materials that proved this prostitution was enforced, but none were found. Even so, Japan was issued with strong demands from the Korean government to 'restore the honour of these women by acknowledging that prostitution was enforced on them,' and it subsequently issued an apology based on statements from sixteen witnesses prepared by the Korean government, without even cross-examining them. It is worth nothing that the content of these statements has not been made public to this day. Underlying this apology was the preconceived notion that the Imperial Japanese Army had undoubtedly carried out evil actions, and that these Korean women were hardly likely to have lied....

As a result of chief cabinet secretary Kouno's informal remarks, all junior high school history textbooks have since 1997 provided an account of the 'comfort women issue'. However, in that same year, research by the journalist Sakurai Yoshiko showed that Kouno's statement was the outcome of diplomatic considerations, and that no objective proof existed. Consequently, the realisation spread that Kouno's remarks could not possibly form the basis of any historical account. But outside Japan, Kouno's remarks were seen as absolute, evidence-based proof of the Japanese government's acknowledgement of guilt. The situation now is one where people take the extreme view and insist, in all seriousness, that to doubt or deny the enforcement of prostitution by the military is on a par with denying the Nazi holocaust....

...research by Koreans themselves and by the Japanese historian, Hata Ikuhiko, has made it clear that the confessions of Yoshida Seiji about his rounding up of comfort women on the island of Jeju do, off the coast of Korea, which is regarded as the classic case of sexual slavery, are a fabrication. ^(Hata, Ianfu o Senjo no sei, pp 229-48. See the Korean writer, O. Sonfa, who also denies the possibility that the Japanese could have enforced sexual slavery (Seikatsusha no Nihon tochi jidai, pp42-4, 54-5, 223-4))

This is from: Nitta, Hitoshi. “And Why Shouldn’t the Japanese Prime Minister Worship at Yasukuni? A Personal View”. Yasukuni, the war dead and the struggle for Japan's past. Edited by John Breen. New York: Columbia U Press, 2008. Print.

2 Answers 2017-04-12

Gerald R. Ford was a rather minor US President, why does he get the Ford class of carriers?

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Has anyone accused Sir Charles Warren of being Jack the Ripper?

What I know: Sir Charles Warren was the metropolitan police commissioner at the time of the Jack the Ripper Murders. He resigned right before Mary Kelly died and had given an order previously that if another murder occurred, nobody was to enter the scene. This lead to there being a sizable delay entering the crime scene.

My thoughts as to why he is a possibility (highly circumstantial):

-The phrasing of the order is odd given that no other jack the ripper murder occurred indoors.

-The timing of his resignation

-The murders stopping after his resignation and redeployment to Singapore

-He wanted to train bloodhounds to find Jack the Ripper (first to do so), if he was the killer and the dogs tracked him down he would have a reasonable alibi

-Being high-up in the Police would allow him to know the very frequent Police routes of the area and given him an opportunity to survey the area.

problem areas:

-nothing personality wise points to him being the killer

-not a lot of evidence to go on

-older than the suspects described

What I'm wondering: Has anyone done research into him being Jack the Ripper? I tried doing some google searching but can't find anyone accusing him, only referencing his role in the case. If so, is there any evidence I am missing that clearly removes him from the suspect list?

TL;DR: it would be a crazy tv show like twist if the police commissioner was Jack the Ripper but theres some circumstantial evidence that makes me believe its a possibility

1 Answers 2017-04-12

Could Truman have Understood the Full Impact of the Atomic Bomb?

I was listening to a Radiolab episode, called Nukes (If you're interested: http://www.radiolab.org/story/nukes/). They were talking to an historian who stated that Truman was told (not asked) that the military had this bomb and was going to use it. The Generals were sure to mention that it was a much bigger deal than any other bomb, but Truman apparently thought they were only going to hit a "purely military target" and no civilians. He didn't grok.

My question is -- could he have understood? Could any reasonable person who did not personally witness the trinity tests or understand the science understand that a single bomb was going to wipe a city the size of Rochester off the map?

What is a much bigger deal on a scale that does NOT include atomic? What was the biggest bomb we had at the time? Is it reasonable to assume that he should have known? Or was the difference an order of magnitude past a much bigger deal?

2 Answers 2017-04-12

Free Enterprise antebellum cotton plantations

Were there any known cotton plantations in the antebellum South operated sans slavery?

1 Answers 2017-04-11

Russia lost more tanks in Chechnya than in the Battle of Berlin. Is this true?

I am very interested in the Chechen wars, and how a tiny republic was able to take on the heir of the USSR and win (at least in the beginning).

Sources like this:

https://books.google.com/books?id=bYJ7CgAAQBAJ&pg=PA95&lpg=PA95&dq=russia+lost+more+tanks+than+battle+of+berlin+chechnya&source=bl&ots=468lLq6C6Z&sig=YsD87Bwmijm7_jawXx05iXyQvwc&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwix4vaFxp3TAhVY12MKHQOTBmMQ6AEIMzAD#v=onepage&q=russia%20lost%20more%20tanks%20than%20battle%20of%20berlin%20chechnya&f=false

Say that more tanks were destroyed trying to take the capital, Grozny, than during the battle of Berlin.

Is there any truth to this claim?

Also, what is the best estimate for how many Chechens and Russians died in the first war?

I have seen on the high end: 150,000 Chechens (out of a population of 800,000) and 20,000 Russians.

On the low end: 40,000 - 60,000 Chechens, and about 4,000 - 5,000 Russians.

Any help would be appreciated.

2 Answers 2017-04-11

⯇ 3481 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start