Why do so many Americans treat the War of 1812 as a victory and a source of pride, even though Canada managed to burn the White House and push US forces all the way south to New Orleans?

The US National Anthem commemorates a battle in the War of 1812. The US Military, which I served in, loves to hype up the War of 1812 as a "victory for our young nation." Most schoolchildren are taught that the War of 1812 is a source of national pride.

Why is this? By any object standard, the War of 1812 was a compete defeat for the USA.

The US invasion of Canada was repulsed by a much smaller Canadian Militia.

British/Canadian forces took Detroit in 1812 without firing a single shot.

In 1814, Canadian/British forces marched 400 miles south to Washington DC and managed to burn the White House.

By 1815, the British/Canadian Army had marched all the way south to New Orleans. Sure, Andrew Jackson managed to win a victory and prevent the City of New orleans from being taken, but given that the US forces had been pushed that far south in the first place, I can't see how that's something to be proud of.

Basically, the War of 1812 resulted in the United States being almost completely overrun by a British Canadian Army. Why then is it such a source of national pride in this country when any objective analysis of the War of 1812 would label it an American defeat?

1 Answers 2017-03-30

I'm a Greek/Persian/Roman/Chinese/Any soldier before the late 1800's whose wound is infected and I'm gonna die - what wound infections were most prominent and lethal?

1 Answers 2017-03-30

What did Russians think of the Lend-Lease equipment they received during WWII? Was it generally positive feedback or negative about the suitability of the equipment provided to them to be used in combat? Did they favor particular equipment?

1 Answers 2017-03-30

How accurate, historically, are James Clavell's novels about Asia?

I've always heard, that they are very accurate as far as historical events, political/religious factors, etc. go. I have read the Asian saga myself, and they are some of my favorite books, but I'm not much of an Asian historian, so I always wondered how they hold up when somebody who knows the history through and through actually reads them.

1 Answers 2017-03-30

Was it common for soldiers in WW1 to receive cigarettes as part of their ration? Did the military planners find any use in providing them?

I read the answer about the German Imperial Army in WW1 in this thread:

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/628k4e/during_world_war_i_i_what_sort_of_rations_were/

How common was it that soldiers were given cigarettes in their rations? Why?

2 Answers 2017-03-30

Why, when Peter the Great modernised the Russian empire, did he not adopt the Latin alphabet

Peter made incredibly broad-ranging changes to Russian society: he changed the relationship between peasants and the gentry, he (rather forcibly, at times) changed the very style of dress of the gentry, he brought Russia's aristocratic wives from seclusion to Court, and he made wide-ranging orthographic reforms.

But when he did the latter, why didn't this Emperor - so well-traveled across Europe and so fascinated with Europe - go further than merely implementing huge orthographic reforms to the Russian language and implement the Latin alphabet?

Peter's orthographic reforms began in the early 18th century as Russia moved towards Europe. In the early 20th century, in Turkey, Ataturk abolished the Arabic alphabet in favour of the Latin in his attempt to Europeanise Turkey.

It seems curious to me that an Emperor so obsessed with Europe to the extent of repudiating almost all of his cultural heritage wouldn't adopt the Latin alphabet, particularly given his immense power over the very few of his subjects who were literate.

1 Answers 2017-03-30

Did older men also lie about their ages during WWI?

There are lots of stories of teenagers lying about their ages to enlist (facilitated by recruiters willing to look the other way) during WWI.

Did older men ever claim they were younger than they were to get into the military? For example, men in their late 30s claiming they were in their 20s?

1 Answers 2017-03-30

Would a First World War historian be able to give me information regarding a specific Eastern Front German reprisal camp for British prisoners?

I think this is likely to be a long shot, but any help is greatly appreciated.

My Great Great Grandfather served with the 4th "Queens Own" Hussars in the First World War and was captured by the Germans sometime around early October 1914, very early into the war. I have done fairly extensive research into his regiment's exploits - mainly a combination of following his regimental diary and guesswork - and have hit upon a problem.

I know for a fact that for the majority of his life as a POW, he was kept in Doberitz - which I believe to be a fairly common occurrence for captured Privates. My problem is that I have a first-hand account of My ancestor's in which he describes the treatment of him and his fellow prisoners in a German reprisal camp near Riga then in Russia, called "Larchen". He says that he was there from Feb 10th 1917 to Jun 10th 1917. I can find absolutely nothing about this camp. The internet has revealed absolutely nothing and any list of German camps that I have found seem to be devoid of any information about individual reprisal camps. I understand that this is likely due to the fact that most of these camps were hastily put together to house the prisoners before they were sent to the front lines to do hard labour, but even so, there must be information out there.

The treatment that my ancestor and his five hundred other companions endured at this camp shouldn't be forgotten. As far as I am aware, many people would have died there and my ancestor was in such bad shape when he was released that he was deemed "unfit for military service".

If anyone could provide any information about this camp, I would be most grateful. Preserving my ancestors history is vitally important to me.

Thank you for reading.

1 Answers 2017-03-30

When did Egypt and Mesopotamia start being seen as the "founders" of civilization? Was it ever controversial to suggest that civilization began outside of Europe? Or was it something that played into Eurocentric theories about history?

1 Answers 2017-03-30

Wars against the Teutonic Order

I always found the wars by Catholic Kingdoms against Catholic Holy Orders confusing. Were any of the leaders of Poland or Lithuania excommunicated for attacking the order? Was the Pope relatively indifferent? What was the overall European reaction? This whole time period in the baltic confuses me.

1 Answers 2017-03-30

Why does coverage of Shackleton's ill-fated Imperial Transantarctic Expedition tend to gloss over (or omit) the Ross Sea Party?

1 Answers 2017-03-30

Saw this story about the Bush War on my FB feed, is there any truth to it?

http://i.imgur.com/OB14pwch.jpg

Surely the Zimbabwean revolutionaries had their shit more together than this, and I could not find any backing for the story online.

1 Answers 2017-03-29

Why are there people that deny aspects of the Holocaust or even the Holocaust as a whole?

1 Answers 2017-03-29

Why are we so obsessed with the west?

Why is African, Asian and South American history taught so rarely in schools (particularly in the U.K)?I had no chance to learn about any of this until University.

(Also any recommendations on books relating to these topics would be great!)

1 Answers 2017-03-29

What was civilian life like during WW2? During WW2 in US was life in country more or less "business as usual"?

Growing up I had the idea that the country just unified as a whole with all effort towards the war but growing older it seems like it would be more like what life was like during immediate 9/11 aftermath or during the more significant stages of Iraq war. What I mean is that while the country was tuned into the events most people's day-to-day life was largely the same unless directly involved such as a victim of an attack or their family and of course for the military/first responders, etc.

2 Answers 2017-03-29

How could Polynesians navigate so well without compasses or sextants and how could they build ships capable of traveling deep ocean?

As the title says, I want to know how Polynesians sailed and what techniques they used, and what types of ships they built that could sail on deep ocean.

I searched around a bit and found out that clouds ( their color and shape ) can sometimes indicate if land is nearby, and that by watching the currents and the direction of the waves they could find out if islands were nearby. I also read that some Polynesians predicted once-in-a-century storms and used them to island hop. If so, how did they do so?

Also, did they have any kind of instruments that aided their navigation or was it purely based on human knowledge?

Any information would be appreciated, thanks!

1 Answers 2017-03-29

Wikipedia states that narwhal tusks were sold as horns from unicorns in the middle ages/renaissance. Was there a serious belief in the existence of unicorns among academics at the time?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unicorn#The_narwhal

1 Answers 2017-03-29

(x-post from r/AskHistory) What were the non-Jewish people of Germany, Italy, Poland, etc. doing during the Holocaust? Did many people help the Jews evade concentration camps?

I've heard of a few stories of Christians hiding Jewish people in their homes. Was this and similar instances common? Surely they were susceptible to punishment by the Nazis, so I assume not a whole lot of people aided the Jews. (I was told I should repost this question on here to get more accurate answers.)

1 Answers 2017-03-29

Can anyone help me identify where this set of spears and shield is from?

Photos:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/Zardiel/image1.jpg http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/Zardiel/image2.jpg http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/Zardiel/image3.jpg http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/Zardiel/image4.jpg

I came into ownership of these a few months ago, but I don't really know much about them. All I know is that they're about 100 years old, and belonged to a real cannibal tribe. The person who owned them before me was an 'eccentric' friend of my mum's, and she passed away last year.

Apparently, the story is that a vicar friend of hers made a pilgrimage to whatever country this tribe was in, in an attempt to introduce Christianity to them. And on his first visit, he got on really well with them, and they gave him these spears and shield as a gift, which he brought back to England.

Then he visited the tribe a second time... and they ate him.

I don't know how much of that story is embellished, but supposedly that's what happened. I have no idea what tribe it was, or what part of the world they were in. I've had a look online, and there seem to be a lot of Indian shield designs with these 4 'buttons' on the front, but that's as close as I've been able to get.

Anyone got any ideas?

1 Answers 2017-03-29

Was there something unusual about the economy of England in the Middle Ages?

In various places I've seen references to or hints that the economy of England was unusual in the Middle Ages. William the Conqueror's chaplain called it "a treasure house of Araby" for its gold and precious metals. There's also the early spread of payment in lieu of military service, and, at least in the later Middle Ages, hinting at a more developed cash economy (which would tally with the availability of metals). Then there's the idea of the stout English yeoman, something more than an impoverished, oppressed peasant.

So are there things that made the English economy distinctive in this period? And if so, do they make England particularly unusual compared to its neighbours, or is it just the usual variation between countries?

1 Answers 2017-03-29

When did travel for entertainment become a thing?

1 Answers 2017-03-29

What were hairstyles like in the middle ages throughout Europe?

1 Answers 2017-03-29

What ever happened to Christopher Columbus's ships? (Nina, Pinta, Santa Maria)

2 Answers 2017-03-29

Why is there such a sharp and dramatic drop in US population density when traveling from east to west?

When looking at a US population density map, there seems to be a clean cut vertical line running from San Antonio Tx to Fargo ND. With a few exceptions, there's absolutely nothing west of that line until you hit the west coast.

http://www.learnnc.org/lp/media/uploads/2010/02/usa-2000-population-density.gif

Take Lincoln Ne. Travel east on I80 you hit a major city every couple hours from Omaha, Des Moines, Cedar Rapids, Chicago, etc. Go east and you have nothing. Absolutely nothing. til Salt Lake City.

This split does not exist in Canadian population density graphs however so I'm concluding it's not a geographical divide.

Was there a specific element in US history which stopped people from moving any further west and gives that particular line of longitude any importance?

1 Answers 2017-03-29

What was east of Ancient Babylon?

So, the Persian empire and Alexander's empire extended to the Indus River on the border of India. What exactly was between Mesopotamia and the Indus River that was worth conquering?

2 Answers 2017-03-29

⯇ 3512 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start