Did soldiers during the medieval times suffer from PTSD?

It appears to me the average person during medieval times suffered famine, poor health and violence (to themselves and against other) quite regularly. As a result, did soldiers who fought in battle suffer from PTSD as we see in modern times? Or did their daily life condition them such that it was less traumatic?

1 Answers 2022-02-12

How did the Alabama incest trope originate? Was there a widespread issue with siblings having children?

1 Answers 2022-02-12

Why didn’t Ford consider Reagan for Vice President in 1976?

If he was choosing not to have Rockefeller on the ticket, I’ve always been confused as to why he didn’t choose Reagan. I know that was a contentious, bad-blood primary but it would’ve United the party behind Ford at the very least.

I feel a similar way about Hillary Clinton not choosing Bernie Sanders, but I was alive for that one so it’s easier to comprehend.

1 Answers 2022-02-12

Why don’t we have a written record of the history of Native American societies, the same way that we have for Europe?

I know that there is written history for some civilizations such as the Maya, however why aren’t there history books that speak of ancient battles, leaders, stories, territories being changed etc for Native American people prior to when Europe settled the continent?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Is it okay to ask for good history literature here?

If yes, than I would ask for the best books about the early days of Nazi Germany and how it came to be. Also from 1920 to 1933 and 1933 to 1939. I want to know more how Strasser and other people gave the Nazi party the opportunity to seize the Reich so fast and how they consolidated power up to 1939.

2 Answers 2022-02-11

Are there any strategies or tactics which could have been used during World War I which would have been significantly more successful than the ones used? How would a general from today handle the trench warfare and meat grinders of WW1?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Agatha Christe, Arthur Conan Doyle, Charles Dickens, and others wrote stories that prominently feature opium dens in London. How common were opium dens in London? Were they illegal? Or were these stories just perpetuating anti-Asian bias, common in stories at the time?

edit: Christie, not Christe, in the title

These portrayals, especially in Conan Doyle's "The Man with the Twisted Lip," depict an otherwise respectable British gentleman who is addicted to opium visiting an opium den to get his fix. How common was this? I know anti-Asian sentiment was common, often portraying Asians as exotic and inscrutable, sometimes with otherworldly intuition or as clever criminals. Were these stories perpetuating those stereotypes, or was there something to the opium den phenomenon, or both? Finally, what are some good sources on understanding anti-Asian bias in fiction, especially golden age detective fiction?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Were pigs on ships in the 1800s to early 1900s usually called Dennis, and if so, why?

The fictional book The Windflower by Laura London, set around 1813, has the following claim:

"If there's a pig on a ship, everybody calls it Dennis," Cat said. "Don't ask me why."

There's a forum thread on a Civil War website that makes a similar claim.

There's also this 1907 article from the Calexico Chronicle referencing a ship pig named Dennis, as well as the following quote from Kevin J Hayes's 1999 book Melville's Folk Roots:

Pronouncing the word "pig" aboard ship was sure to bring forth bad luck; instead, the sailors referred to the pig as "Mr. Dennis," "Little Fellow," or "Gruff."

Was Dennis the pig a thing? Are all these just a coincidence? If Dennis the pig is a thing, when did that start and why?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Why is the Holocaust the famous genocide in the US?

There are a lot of genocides that were never mentioned in my 1990s US public school education. Meanwhile, I had multiple classes over the years that taught the Holocaust (to some level of detail). How did the Holocaust get picked as the one we would study year after year?

Example of other genocides that I don't recall being taught:

  1. Armenians by Ottomans in modern Turkey
  2. Tutsis by Hutus in Rwanda
  3. Cambodians, Vietnamese, and Chinese by other Cambodians

There are also some things I'm not sure count as genocides but feel similar in that people organized to do a thing and then a lot of people died. The "a lot of people died" seemed to be the primary significance of the Holocaust when I heard about it in school. Examples of these "a lot of people died":

  1. Africans by Belgians in modern Democratic Republic of Congo
  2. Native Americans by Spain, US, and Canada (silver mines, trail of tears, residential schools)

Is there something that distinguishes these other events from the Holocaust? E.g., availability of records, perpetrators no longer a major world power, victims still a world power, etc.? Or was my school just bad at teaching history?

Edit: I fully believe in the Holocaust. I do not want to hear your conspiracy theories about how Jews control the media. Holy shit.

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Why didn't the British, Russian or East Asian empires discover the North American continent before Spain?

It makes sense to me why it took so long for most of the Western European powers to discover the American continents. They had to cross a big dangerous ocean so it makes sense they didn't find it until some idiot got really lost. But some Scandinavian Vikings found North America by shore hoping past iceland and greenland, and then left because there wasn't much to raid. So why didn't the British ever do this. And on the other side of the world there's a broken land bridge between Russia and North America. I can't imagine it would be too difficult to sail across it. So why didn't Russia, Japan, or China ever head over there and start the colonizing that empires love to do?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Why do so many traditionally Jewish names reference natural objects like -stein, -berg, -baum, -blat, rosen-, fein-, diamond, silver, gold, etc.?

Was there something about surnames in Central and Eastern Europe or Jewish culture that caused these to be particularly common among the Ashkenazi population? Relatedly, is there any reason for the extra prevelance of precious gems and materials, for example professions they were historically allowed to work in?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Can you recommend any literature on medieval Occitania/southern France?

Less of a specific question and more of a general request for literature on Occitania in Medieval times. Both popular and scientific titles are welcome, though I would rather be tending towards the serious side of things - I am happy to read collections of essays and such.

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Was Rasputin a manipulative mastermind or just insane?

Rasputin had the ear of both the Tsar and Tsarina by convincing them he had magical healing abilities. We're the Russian royals just gullible idiots, and rasputin took advantage of that to gain power? Or did he believe he had powers and was insane?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Why did Hitler call himself 'Führer' instead of 'Kaiser', given how obsessed the Nazis were with Roman symbols and the fact that they called Germany the 'Reich'?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Friday Free-for-All | February 11, 2022

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

9 Answers 2022-02-11

Cold war. Under what circumstances did the Soviet Union consider an invasion of Western Europe or initiating a nuclear exchange? What were their 'red lines'

Most scenarios regarding the cold war turning hot generally focus on a Soviet initiation of hostilities and then likely Western responses. What I have never seen clearly articulated is what situations would have made the Soviet Union consider war worthwhile or desirable?

Was it a certain estimated advantage? A stumbling escalation of crisis requiring drastic action ? Estimating that the balance of strength was slipping away?

Other than outright hostility from Nato, What would have caused the Soviet Union to go to war? Did they know? Did they have policies and protocols?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Why was Sofia bombed during ww2?

Bulgaria joined the axis under "accept or be invaded and possibly sent to camps" conditions.

Bulgaria didn't invade any land (however they occupied some) there weren't any battles between bulgaria and the allies, at most there were skirmishes with remaining forces in german occupied territories.

However Sofia was heavily bombed, sustaining a lot of civilian casualties, and I don't see the reason for such action in such circumstances

Info on this topic is rather scarce, so I wanted to ask if someone knew anything else

1 Answers 2022-02-11

What was the frequency of artillery fire during WW1, and what did an average day look like in the trenches?

I've watched a lot of stuff about what the conditions were like in the trenches during WW1, but I have one question that I'm having trouble getting answered.

The shellings and artillery fire; was it constant from like the early morning until night time or did it only happen before an attack? Did it happen at a set schedule like "Oh lads it's 11 a.m. give them hell" or something along those lines?

My impression is that the different sides, since they had dug in, were almost always in range of eachother's artillery, so it'd make sense to just fire continuously around the clock, no? But then you'd also need sleep and rest if you were to spend weeks at the front wouldn't you?

Any insight would be appreciated!

1 Answers 2022-02-11

More specific books on Ancient Rome technology (architecture, clothing, blacksmithing, etc.)?

I have read some general books on roman culture, but I've been finding them a bit too general. And I haven't had any better luck online. So I wondered if anyone had some book recs to dive into it deeper. Especially in terms of technology.

For example:

Roman architecture - lots of sources like listing all the things romans had, like the concrete, aqueducts, basic plumbing and floor heating, etc. But they never go into much detail. I want to know the process of exactly how the Romans made these things and how they worked.

Clothing - I don't necessarily mean in terms of what was fashionable, but more in terms of practically. How did they use the materials they had to make clothing that kept them warm, protected there feet, etc. What kinds of underclothing did they have, etc. And how did these improve over time?

Production techniques - Things like blacksmithing, cloth making, cooking, farming and mining. What techniques did they use? What procedures did they have? What tools did they use? What exactly did they make and how?

I guess I kind of want to understand their technology in such a way that if I were to be transported back to Ancient Rome, I could just walk right up and start doing one of these production professions. To the extend that that is possible with the limited knowledge we have at least.

5 Answers 2022-02-11

How long did it take for the Greek gods to become the Roman analogues? How long before Zeus became Jupiter?

Were the founders of Roman mythology already believers in the Greek pantheon? Was it an offshoot that developed gradually - both linguistically and mythologically? Or was it a rapid change for cultural or colonial reasons?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Why didn't no-one else use the Husitian battle doctrine?

The hussites had a unique battle plan of chaining carriages to create a mobile wall then peasants with improvised weapons would kill incoming troops from a high-ground. It was very effective, so why wasn't it used ever after? (Or if it was then where and when?)

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Roman soldiers are often depicted wearing sandal-like footwear. This seems very unsafe on a battlefield with heavy/sharp objects flying around/falling. Did they really wear sandals and If so, why not something offering more protection?

If you wore sandals on a construction site you'd be sent home. Surely a battlefield has more hazards

2 Answers 2022-02-11

Good books/articles regarding air raids on Germany, specifically from 1943-45?

If anyone has any recommendations I’d greatly appreciate it. Currently reading Richard Overy’s ‘The Bombing War’.

1 Answers 2022-02-11

Popular history often gives the impression that until like 80 years ago, the field of medicine was little but a collection of nonsense-treatments. What's the history of actual functioning medicine?

There is no limit to the amount of bizarre stories and images out there showing all sorts of "treatments" from the past. Of course memes aren't facts, but nevertheless it often seems like for the longest time, going to the doctor was going to end up with you being told you had ghosts in your blood and that you should take cocaine to treat it. What's the history of procedures/medicines that actually worked and were widely used?

2 Answers 2022-02-11

During the Middle Ages in Europe did anyone live outside the bounds of the feudal system?

So during the middle ages the feudal system ruled as the main political/economic/cultural system in Europe. I am wondering if any people lived outside of being a part of the nobility, clergy, or serf groups. Would people travel from fiefdom to fiefdom? Would anyone live within the area of a fiefdom without the knowledge of the Lord?

1 Answers 2022-02-11

357 / 7255

Back to start