I'm looking for history of science sources that parse progress into (1) fundamental scientific discoveries followed by (2) applications of the discoveries, or engineering. Does anyone know any? I'm trying to understand how (1) leads to (2).

1 Answers 2017-02-19

Looking for Willy Brandt info

Dear Redditors

Can you recommend me the sources about Willy Brandt? I write an essay which states that Mr Brandt was making symbolic gestures in politics and he was inspiring for them too.

By now, I have ofc Warschauer Kneefall and Kennedy's "Ich bin ein Berliner". Subject seems to be very interesting and... I'm stuck. Hilfe!

1 Answers 2017-02-19

How does academia work for historians?

I posted this originally as a comment in r/History 's silly questions thread but they said it's more suited to being posted here:

I'm here as a biologist, with a question not about history itself but about those who study history. What is the job of a historian like, particularly in academia? As an academic scientist our publications tend to be relatively short articles in journals as a way to share results of an experiment or project, or as a literature review. What is the nature of the publications (or whatever the output may be) coming out of academia for historians? Does it tend to be more in the form of books or do you have a similar article based system? What is the process a historian goes through to acquire the information they are going to publish?

4 Answers 2017-02-19

Looking for general information on Norwegian soldiers on the easter front. Especially in Estonia

So i am currently working on an assignment on my late grandfather. He was part of the Norwegian legion and he fought in Narva Estonia. As far as i know. He escaped through Finland into Norway. But he did so before the war ended, did he maybe desert the German army? How was the general Narva Estonia front for both Germans and Russians? I feel this is a fairly overlooked part of the war so i am grateful in advance for all and any answers. I will try to answer any and all questions if my question was a bit vague

1 Answers 2017-02-19

Is There A Historical Reason Why There Are So Many More National Parks In The Western Half Of The US Than On The Eastern Half?

2 Answers 2017-02-19

How were German soldiers who died in the Second World War memorialised after the war had ended?

In occupied Germany how did the to what extent did the Occupiers allow memorials commemorating fallen Nazi soldiers, and what form did these memorials take?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

Could I own a gun if I were living in Chile under Pinochet's rule?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

William the Conqueror was a duke in Francia, but became king of his conquered lands in England. How did the king of Francia feel about this? Wasn't that weird? Like the governor of California just going and conquering a part of Mexico for himself, but not the U.S.? Was that ok with the other dukes?

Do we know anything about the reaction within the kingdom back home? Was this kind of thing expected and encouraged? For dukes to just unilaterally set themselves up as sovereigns of foreign lands? Did the king of Francia at any point try to say "Wait a minute, England should be mine, since you're just my duke?"

3 Answers 2017-02-19

What led to Sulla's retirement after being declared dictator for life?

At the time, was his retirement most likely viewed as a sincere, "now the Republic has a strong foundation on which to stand, we can return to the rule of law," or an insincere, "I'm bored with this, time to go kick it in my country estate."

1 Answers 2017-02-19

Did anybody flee West Germany/Berlin to East Germany/Berlin?

We've all heard stories of wild and brave escapes past the Berlin Wall out of East Germany, but did anybody ever flee the other direction?

2 Answers 2017-02-19

What are good books on the history of animation?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

Need help on the origin of these knives

I think they're German but idk when and if they really are German. Please let me know if you know anything about them, thanks.

http://m.imgur.com/XtfXSNy

1 Answers 2017-02-19

was there ever recorded instances of meso americans or Andean people using guns against the Spanish?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

In times of conscription (eg. USA in Vietnam War or UK in WWI & WWII) did governments pay for soldiers passports?

Question came to me when reading about the policy of pals battalions. What struck me was that obviously a lot of these conscripts would have been poor and ordinarily unable to afford a passport. Did governments put in place a scheme were visas/passports for their soldiers or when you traveled with the armed forces, did it just not matter?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

What different kinds of Christian schools/"types" of thought existed before the Great Schism?

I had Britain in mind when asking this and the competition between Irish and Roman schools of Christianity, but I've heard mention, with no sources, of Gallic, Burgundian, and Egyptian schools as well. How many schools were there, and what were the differences between them?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

This week's theme: 20th Century Black History

1 Answers 2017-02-19

The rise and fall of the Qin-Dynasty

Hello people,

I am currently researching on factors that benefitted or even made possible the quick rise of the Qin dynasty and unision of China, and factors that led to the quick fall of it afterwards. If somebody with knowledge regarding that could share a quick summary, point me in right direction, or just give me some tips I would be most grateful.

Kind regards.

Also: A Chinese friend recommended a older text, but since I couldn't find a translation and my ancient Chinese is still beginner level I forgot the name. I think it was something like 亲过论 (Qin guo lun)

2 Answers 2017-02-19

[META] Question Filtering (aka "So much Hitler in here")

Recently, there was a thread in which /u/Elm11 made this comment which reads in part:

"More importantly, Hitler / WWII / Tiger Tank / whatever questions are still allowed, and all our normal expectations for quality and comprehensiveness apply. Disallowing questions because we've seen them very frequently isn't a particularly useful approach; it's not a questioner's fault that they're asking something which is clearly popular, particularly here on Reddit."

Part of the issue here seems to be a perception of dilution in terms of the amount of varied, nuanced discussions on this subreddit (that is, other topics being "crowded out" by the sheer amount of questions surrounding Hitler, Germany, and WWII).

As a hypothetical mitigation method, would it be possible to allow for particularly popular topics like Hitler and WWII to be given a metatag that could be filtered or blacklisted by users that have grown tired of these topics?

Falling further down the rabbit hole, is there a potential use for apply subject metatags to questions to facilitate connection between those asking the questions and the experts in those subjects? Is there a potential for faster responses or more-populated discussions by allowing users to filter based upon what they feel is most relevant to their studies? Would this be valuable (i.e. outweight any potential overhead costs) if that were the case? Is it feasible to tag popular topics, or most topics?

I welcome everyone's thoughts and feedbacks. It would be interesting to get another peek at the machinations of moderation on this subreddit. To all the members of the mod team: thank you for all of your hard work!

2 Answers 2017-02-19

What were the early Romans like before they encountered the Greeks?

The Roman culture was largely influenced by the Ancient Greeks, particularly in art and religion. However what did their culture look like before they began interacting with and eventually conquered the Greeks?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

Those of you working in education, have you ever been asked to teach a stance you disagree with? How did you deal with it?

This applies to museums, etc. as well as schools and colleges.

I am aware that institutions will try to employ people whose views align with theirs, so particularly egregious examples are unlikely, but I can't help wondering how many times an outdated textbook is still in use and teachers are asked to follow that for 'ease' or 'lack of confusion'.

Similarly, are there instances where the decision makers are not up to date on the latest developments in the field and insist on sticking to what they learnt 20-30 years ago.

How are these issues typically dealt with?

2 Answers 2017-02-19

Can we discuss the "stone age" and what to do about this misleading term?

The first stone tool made by humanoid apes is two million years old. But approx 13'000 years ago when agriculture were developed, Homo sapiens were still in the Neolithic age, or late stone age. Obviously the difference between these two states of being are enormous, yet in popular mind it's still referred to as "stone age". How come? And what can we do to spread the knowledge about early human development?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

Is it true that nobody in the late 80s saw the collapse of the Soviet Union coming?

I just watched the latest Adam Curtis documentary, HyperNormalization, in which he quotes the fact that in the late 80s neither the journalists nor the academics or the intelligence community as an evidence that observers were less and less in touch with objective reality.

How true is it?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

My great uncle enrolled in the Charlemagne Waffen SS Division, is there online ressources I could check to find out what happened to him ?

1 Answers 2017-02-19

Help me identify this item

Hey /r/AskHistorians, I'm here to ask for some help for identification. My grandfather passed away some time ago and while we were clearing out the apartment I found this. He lived in eastern Finland, right next to Russia's border and this knife has two-headed eagle carved in it so I thought this could be some old Russian knife. This is all information I've got and would be super happy to know the origins of this cool knife.

4 Answers 2017-02-19

The Soviet Union/Russia is thought to have copied American technologies such as the atomic bomb, the B-29 Superfortress (became the Tu-4), Space shuttle (renamed the Buran) Did the USA copy any new Soviet tech that we know of?

3 Answers 2017-02-19

⯇ 3594 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start