Quick Lime in the ditch?

I'm reposting someone else's question from 2018 because it got no traction and no replies and I have the same question!

Posted by

u/BOOleanIllogical

4 years ago

Does FDR reference the Holocaust before America knew about it?

📷

In the second-to-last paragraph of FDR's 1941 State of the Union speech (better known as the Four Freedoms speech), given on January 6th, 1941, FDR says, "Since the beginning of our American history, we have been engaged in change - in a perpetual peaceful revolution - a revolution which goes on steadily, quietly adjusting itself to changing conditions - without the concentration camp or quick-lime in the ditch." A quick Google search showed that quick-lime is another word for Calcium Oxide, a compound that was used in ancient weapons and can cause severe irritation to the skin and when it reacts with water, it heats up. Also on Axis History Forum (https://forum.axishistory.com//viewtopic.php?t=23456), Ben Fanjoy writes, "In the account, he claims to have seen two death pits in which Jews were packed, alive, to the brim. On each "layer" of bodies, quicklime was sprinkled. He then said the SS hosed down the pit with water, in turn, turning the quicklime into a caustic substance, thus "boiling", as he put it, the victims.", so it could also have been used by the Einsatzgruppen in this way. Why would he reference "concentration camps" and "quick-lime" if news about the Holocaust only reached the US after Operation Barbarossa? Did he have knowledge of these events, or was he referring to another use of "concentration camps" and "quick-lime"? The Speech if you want to check: http://oppenheimer.mcgill.ca/IMG/pdf/Four_Freedoms.pdf

EDIT: The Axis History Forum post was about a section of a book called "Masters of Death: The SS-Einsatzgruppen and the Invention of the Holocaust"

1 Answers 2022-02-09

Were "WASPs" ever a thing?

To clarify I don't mean the insect. I mean the people who are considered "Old Money" or "Old Stock" of white people whose ancestors arrived from England between 1620-1645, who were said to control the United States or have significant control over the country's institutions. Were these ever a real group of people or distinctive cultural group?

1 Answers 2022-02-09

What was it like being a medieval executioner?

I’ve always wondered how people ended up with that job.

Did they typically come from a certain social class? Was it considered a lowly job or more middling? Was their job secretive or did their family know what they did for a living? Did every town have an executioner?
How many people who attended executions would have known who the executioner was? Why was it important that they were disguised with a black hood when they were doing their “duties”?

1 Answers 2022-02-09

How did the Atlantic slave trade affect West Africa?

Not sure how to phrase this question. Basically, my understanding is that manufactured goods were exchanged for slaves. So how did this process affect the societies and polities involved? I mean both economically and also politically, as I imagine the constant demand for new captives was highly destabilizing.

1 Answers 2022-02-09

What if anything did the people of Classical World know of the Bronze Age?

I played a little Assassin’s Creed Odyssey again recently and it made me ask myself this question again and I realized I never got a satisfying answer when I googled around before.

In the game they reference “the ancients” and in game you go to some ruins which are clearly inspired by the Mycenaeans. I don’t recall them ever using any specific name to refer to them during the story, however.

I know, I know, it’s a video game. But it made me wonder if we have any references from the Classical Age of the Bronze Age beyond the works of Homer and the like. What did the people of the Classical World think of those who came before them? Did they even know of the civilizations that thrived before them? Is that where we get our stories of cities who defied the gods and were destroyed due to their arrogance? Was that the extent of their knowledge?

It just baffles me that these thriving cultures and civilizations that we know had widespread international trade networks could just be completely forgotten for millennia. There must be some mention of them beyond the epic poems and myth in Classical texts. They would have had some concrete idea of where they came from. Something! Right? Right??

1 Answers 2022-02-09

What did Sun Yat Sen think of the Chinese communists and what did he plan to do with them after the Xinhai Revolution?

1 Answers 2022-02-09

In 1962, the monarch of the Imperial State of Iran accused Great Britain of Imperialism. What then is exactly imperialism? I’ve read imperial(ism) being used as a descriptor for the Qing the Ottomans, Iranian and Indian Empires.

Excerpts from His Imperial Majesties Radio, Television and Press Conference in New Delhi 1962 ... “One hundred and fifty years ago, Britain detached this Island {Bahrain} from our country and imposed its imperial power and colonial policy on this land. The time has now arrived that the British must leave this area”. Emphasis mine.

What exactly is imperialism then, if the Shah of Iran accuses Great Britain of it? Would the relationship between Bahrain and Iran too not be characterized as such?

1 Answers 2022-02-09

Were ex-Nazi's in post-WW2 America really treated favourably?

I am currently listening to the latest podcast from Damn Interesting and in it, they mention:

In America, Wiesenthal knew that Nazi war criminals slept easy. Not one former Nazi living as a U.S. resident had been extradited by the government in the nearly 20 years since the war’s end.

Is this true that nobody with ties to the Nazi party has been tried if they were residents of the US?

Is this because not many Nazis fled to the US or because of complications around how Nazis were used by America in the late stages and post-war in the science and tech fields?

1 Answers 2022-02-09

Why did people flee Russia 1870-1890?

I have a great great grandma that in the years between 1870-1890 fled from Russia to Norway sometimes in those years but my grandparents has never told me or the rest of the family why.

I can't find anything that might have made them flee other then Tsar Alexander 2nd was assassinated by revolutionaries and his son gave more power to the secret police. It's clear that they were scared and fled for their life but not why.

I don't know where they lived but they fled to Norway so you can assume they lived somewhere in the western or northern parts of Russia. They had a daughter in 1887 in Norway and they were around 20-30 years old at the time so they fled late 1870s to early 1880s. Almost nothing know of their life in Russia besides that they might have been nobility but it's not 100%.

It's to late to ask my grandparents for answers to I turn to you. What happened in Russia in 1870s-1890s that might have made people flee for their lives? Both why nobility might have fled and other. Reminder, they fled for their life, they were afraid of something.

Thanks for you help.

1 Answers 2022-02-09

Constantinople would have had lots of previous Roman monuments with Latin Inscriptions... Did they have a good connection with Latin even after Greek became their official language?

1 Answers 2022-02-09

REQUEST: What are the best resources (articles, books, podcasts, documentaries, etc.) on Pacific Islander histories?

Trying to find resources on Pacific Island histories of colonialism, imperialism, and militarization to use in my research paper, so I would appreciate any help! Anything from the internet works too. Unfortunately, my books are still on the way, and many PI-related literature are unavailable. I'd love to hear about more.

1 Answers 2022-02-08

Was Sun Wukong a character created for Journey to the West, or was he an existing legendary character that was simply used for the novel, like Odysseus and the Odyssey?

I ask this because everywhere I look him up people are pretty careful to say stuff like "a legendary character best known for appearing in Journey to the West" instead of "a character from Journey to the West". Yet, every info on him seems to be taken specifically from Journey to the West, I haven't found any story about him that predates the book.

Is this a situation like with some greek characters like Odysseus, where, Homer didn't invent the character, the Odyssey is simply recounting already existing myths about him? (At least, that's what I understand about the Odyssey, If I'm wrong about this, please let me know)

Mind you, I'm not asking whether Sun Wukong has similar textual predecessors, like other legendary monkeys that Wu Cheng'en might have drawn from.

i'm asking whether a Chinese man in 1592 would pick up the hot new NYT bestseller and think "Oh, Sun Wukong, yes I know that guy."

And if he did, what would he know of him?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

When Europeans first interacted with Native Americans, they brought diseases they had never been exposed to. Some accounts claim over 90% of Native Americans died due to disease brought by Europeans. How true is this figure? Also did Native Americans ever tell stories of this apocalyptic event?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

Musonius Rufus, "The Roman Socrates," was an outspoken critic of the emperors and was exiled twice, but each time he was recalled. Notably, though he was a thorn in their side, no emperor killed Musonius. Were the emperors worried about repeating the bad PR that Socrates's death brought about?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

How were deaf women treated in society during the Regency era?

I'm specifically thinking something like Pride and Prejudice era, amongst this society of people marrying for status and wealth. How would a deaf girl or woman been a part of this particular culture pre-ASL?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

What would a student meal look like in Western Europe in the 1100s? Was there a concept of a "student diet" like there is today?

My roommates and I are college students recently seized by the desire to host a medieval-themed feast. To the greatest extent possible, we would like to be historically accurate in the execution, dishes included, and table etiquette. However, we're having a bit of trouble identifying what is true and what is popular fiction (would they really have used just one knife? Would forks be allowed? etc). Most importantly, would a university student's diet differ in any significant way from the average person's, the way that a student now might be expected to eat more ramen and poptarts than others might? If so, what was the reason for this?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

When were continental borders created?

It’s pretty easy to track a countries border though their history but what about continental borders?

When and who decided on them? Was it one powerful country at a time or a unanimous conference?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

How many political parties were active in pre Nazi Germany (1920-1933)?

Hi, I was just wondering how many political parties were active in pre Nazi Germany? I've heard several politicians advocate for more than the two party system we have in the United States, and it got me wondering about this question. Thank you for your time.

1 Answers 2022-02-08

why is the ustaša not taught alongside the holocaust?

for more information on the ustaše, here is a link:

https://allthatsinteresting.com/ustase

thank you

3 Answers 2022-02-08

META: In September 2020, AskHistorians hosted its first conference, hoping to bring scholarly conversations to the public like never before. Today, a peer-reviewed article about the conference has been published in ‘History’ – and it’s available to read now for free!

As most of us remember all too well, the spring of 2020 was a difficult time, as we dealt simultaneously with the impact of a new and deadly disease upon ourselves and loved ones, as well as the sudden shock of having to live most of our lives in virtual environments.

Historians, like most other people, cancelled their planned gatherings in 2020, or shifted them online as best they could as we all hurriedly got to grips with Zoom and other online meeting platforms, and loudly wished for the return of business as usual. Yet for those of us involved in helping run AskHistorians, the moment seemed opportune to make the case for the advantages of digital platforms. The whole project, after all, is predicated on the notion that high-quality history has an audience beyond academia. As such, we set out to organise a conference that broke the mould, not just in terms of format, but also in terms of who gets to attend and participate.

With the generous support of you all, we’ve since hosted two digital conferences, and you can still watch the talks and read the AMAs from the amazing scholars who joined us. But we also wanted to share our intentions and lessons with other historians, and help shape what history conferences will look like in a post-pandemic world. As such, in late 2020, three of us (myself, u/Historiagrephour and u/Soviet_Ghosts) pitched an article to a special issue of History on digital public history. Over the course of 2021, we received peer reviews, made revisions, and waited. And, at last, our article ‘Out of the Ivory Tower, into the Digital World? Democratising Scholarly Exchange’ has now been published and is available here:

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1468-229X.13259

Due to an agreement with my own employer, the University of Sheffield, the article is completely open access, and can be viewed for free in perpetuity. We are very grateful for this, as breaking down barriers to knowledge was such an important part of our motivation to begin with, and we’re very excited that everyone here will be able to read it.

We’re all immensely proud to have been part of the AskHistorians Digital Conferences, and to be able to represent this community in a journal such as History. We hope you enjoy the read!

11 Answers 2022-02-08

Was "running away to join the circus" ever actually a viable option for youngsters, or did circuses not want to hire people with no experience?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

What do we know about the historical Cincinnatus?

Cincinnatus was been upheld as a pinnacle of the Roman statesman, but how much of his actual story can we parse from the legend? What are our primary sources for discussing his life, and how accurate should we expect them to be?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

There have been numerous memes and newspaper stories claiming that George V and Tsar Nicholas II got dragon tattoos on trips to Japan when they were young. Is this true? What would the reaction of high society have been to these future monarchs getting tattoos?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

I always seen people debating over Katyń massacre, with one side saying that it was the Soviets who did it, and the other that it was the Germans. Who ACTUALLY did it?

Time to start an argument.

1 Answers 2022-02-08

Did Russians assimilated much of Native Siberians due to greater numbers and intermarriage or genocides them like in US?

1 Answers 2022-02-08

360 / 7255

Back to start