How did the 'natives' that were 'discovered' in the 15th, 16th & 17th century get to those places?

I watched a documentary about how Christopher Columbus 'discovered' Cuba and there were Cuban natives there, and it got me wondering how on earth they got there. Could anyone help?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

Is the Prussian Region historically and linguistically Germanic, Baltic or Slavic?

While Prussia is located in modern day Poland (West Slavic country), it had been a part of Germany -or whatever it was called- for a long time.

So is it historically and linguistically Germanic, Slavic, or is it Baltic (As it's close to the Baltic countries)?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in February 16 2017:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

1 Answers 2017-02-16

What do we know of the early Sassanid army?

The rise of the Sassanian dynasty in the first half of the third century is often mentioned as an event that had a major impact on the history of the Roman Empire. Reason being that the Sassanid Empire was a more powerful state than the previous Parthian Empire and so Rome had to rethink its defense strategy in the eastern frontier.

Indeed, the Sassanid under Shapur I had many successes against the Romans, going as deep into roman territory as Antioch. Those campaigns are the evidence that is used to defend Sassanid superior military power compared to Parthia. They had more success against Rome therefore they were better at waging war.

However, as Adrian Goldsworthy notes, the Sassanid and Parthians were essentially the same people, only ruled by a different house. And so it's expected that their armies wouldn't be that different in aftermath of the fall of the Parthians as the rulling house.

So my question is, do we know how the early Sassanid army looked like (say before IV century)? How similar or different it was to the earlier Parthian army? What tatics it use and stuff like that?

Gratitude.

1 Answers 2017-02-16

For honor.

The knight armor from the game "for honor" comes from which era and is it proper representation of war in that era?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

I am a god-fearing peasant in England during the 1530s and Henry VIII renounced the papal authority. What does this mean for me and what kind of effect does it have to my life and beliefs?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

How effective was plate armor against musketballs?

Cca 15th century? What about cca 17th?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

I have heard some people claim that British Colonialism was less bad to the natives as compared to French, Portuguese or Spanish Colonialism. Is this true?

2 Answers 2017-02-16

Why are rampart walls zig-zagged shaped? (X-Post from r/MilitaryHistory)

I am doing a university architectural project which is proposing a flood defense system in Zurich and thusly I am looking into the historical defensive architecture of the city by way of precedent.

Can someone please explain the reasoning for this shape which is common throughout European cities? Does it have a name?

In citadels which employ a similar shape I understand it is so you can be on the flank of an attacking forces, but looking at the linked map the shape doesn't seem to provide much of a flank at this bigger - city - scale. Surely they could just try to breach the walls at the "points" of the walls rather than the inner corners which would be slightly flanked from above by the defenders?

Many thanks.

1 Answers 2017-02-16

How good a tactician was William T. Sherman?

I'm currently reading "Fierce Patriot: The Tangled Lives of William Tecumseh Sherman", by Robert L. O'Connell - it follows Sherman throughout his whole life, with his military career as a vital component.

One thing that I'm uncertain of, however, is how good a tactician Sherman was (perhaps because I'm not yet finished the book). O'Connell seems to mainly praise Sherman's strategic skills, but far less is said about his tactical skills, leaving me unsure of what to think.

1 Answers 2017-02-16

Where Did the Stereotype Jews are "Cheapskates" Originate From?

Lately I have seen a few memes refencing it and am interested in how far it goes back, where it started, etc.

Any info is greatly appreciated!

1 Answers 2017-02-16

The Nazi Party's name is the National Socialist German Workers' Party. Why is it considered Fascist rather than Socialist?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

Were there any colonial empires that treated their colonies as benevolently as the United States supposedly treated the Philippines?

I keep hearing this assertion that as a colonial power the US was allegedly the most benevolent of the bunch, launching free public education, paving roads & building modern infrastructure, and even teaching muh democracy to the locals. (And in the Filipinos' case the Americans were oh-so-kind that they even willingly planned Philippine independence & granted it in 1946! Something they didn't even do for Puerto Rico and the others.)

Were there any other colonial empires (British, French, Dutch, German, Spanish, Portuguese, Japanese, etc.) who were this "kind" to any of their colonies, in theory or in practice?

PS. By "any of their colonies" I mean the ones where they came in primarily as occupiers of some kind, not as permanent settlers—in other words, not settler colonies, like colonial America, Australia, or Canada … and just on the record, I do think this perception of the US being a benevolent coloniser is at the very least rather overrated, as it still is not above underhanded, colonial-in-all-but-name practices, like total educational indoctrination, invasions & commercial domination in Latin America, etc.

2 Answers 2017-02-16

Prior to being elected President, Vladimir Putin spent more than a decade in the KGB, and then, following the collapse of the USSR, worked his way up in politics. At what point would he have popped up on the United States government's radar, and what did they think of him as his power increased?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

Growing up, when I asked my dad any question at all about history, he would tell me that he couldn't possibly explain without starting at the Battle of Actium.

[deleted]

2 Answers 2017-02-16

Is this sub included in part of the new /r/popular [META] ??

I can't recall if this us is included in /r/all or not (I think it is but can't be certain) and wonder if the mods were approached about being filtered into the new sub.

3 Answers 2017-02-16

Was there anything useful to come from Nazi experiments during the war?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

Why is Circumcision So Important in the Bible [NSFW]

Im currently reading the Bible for multiple reasons and as I go through Genesis circumcision is shown to be highly important. In the story "The defiling of Dinah" an entire town is destroyed because someone with an uncircumcised penis had sex with a follower of God. I was just wondering if there is broader historical context here, or even an answer wrapped in theology.

2 Answers 2017-02-16

Why didn't Vikings bring European diseases to the Americas?

It's a well known fact that when Columbus arrived in the Americas, he introduced diseases that ended up killing millions of natives. The Vikings, who also would have been exposed to these European diseases, established colonies in the new world several hundred years before Columbus. Why did it take until Columbus for these diseases to infect native Americans?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

Is there any evidence that the Soviets used stolen information from the United States to develop their first nuclear weapons?

For the first time today I encountered a claim that the Soviet nuclear program was made possible by an American security failure. Is there any evidence to back this up?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

New Atlantis or Old Brasile?

The following is from Mary Geiter's "The Restoration Crisis and the Launching of Pennsylvania, 1679-81":

In April 1679 Charles made the first move to neutralize the opposition by forming a new Privy Council with the Earl of Shaftesbury as its president. Although the news was greeted with "joyful bonfires" in the City, the verdict had still to be given as to "whether we are landing upon New Atlantis or only in the view of old Brasile."

The footnote for this phrase states it was found on the back of a list of names for the new Privy Council.

What exactly is meant here by New Atlantis and old Brasile? I can gather that new Atlantis is hopeful of some ideal that this council will bring about, but old Brasile doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me. My guess is "same old shit," but why that specific phrase?

1 Answers 2017-02-16

Did German soldiers on the Western Front always dig trenches to fortify towns/villages

Not necessarily to the extent of large positions such as the French Maginot line, but more like places on the outskirts of Aachen or other important rural positions in towns/villages

1 Answers 2017-02-16

I have heard a long time ago that the Nazis had a plan to place all of the world's Jewish population on Madagascar, is this true ?

1 Answers 2017-02-15

Recommendations for readings about imaginings of the post-colonial subject?

I'm an undergraduate History major beginning to start thinking about my senior thesis major and one thing that I am particularly interested in is anti-colonial movements and how those rejections of the colonial are imagined/conceptualized. I've done some reading of Frantz Fanon writing about the effects of colonialism on the colonized individual and would like other reading similar to that but also works that more explicitly imagine the decolonized future, both in terms of the state, the nation, and the individual. I am particularly interested in ideas like Cuba's New Man and the transformation of the colonial subject after 'liberation.' If any of you have any readings that could introduce me more to this topic, both in terms of primary readings, historical analyses, and works of theory, I would be very thankful.

1 Answers 2017-02-15

Did Illinois used to be 2 states? Trying to make sense of this 1824 Electoral College map

Here is the map

Did "A1" used to be it's own state? What was it called? Why did they eventually merge together? Or was it just a voting line and the state was effectively already one thing?

Curious to know the story.

1 Answers 2017-02-15

⯇ 3601 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start