How much resistance was there to Italian unification, and what was the nature of that resistance?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Are there any online databases of archaeological photos, findings, illustrations, etc. from the 19th to early 20th century?

This is a bit of a weird request but it is quite often difficult to find these kinds of resources if you either do not know where they were published, they were not widely circulated within their field or they were not published in any journals.

To specify, I am looking for any sites, journals and so on that can be used to look up archeological findings from Egypt/Sudan and published in the 19th to early 20th century. Photographs, illustrations, models, articles, translations and the like.

University sites usually have these but I was wondering if there was something a bit more comprehensive or any recommendations anyone might have on where to look.

1 Answers 2017-01-09

When and how did the paternalistic idea of donating to "charity" evolve into more egalitarian or idealistic "humanitarianism"?

In the Middle Ages, for example, giving money to "the poor" (whether that meant the actual poor, or the so-called 'spiritually poor'/religious communities) had a lot to do with personal benefit--helping secure easier passage through purgatory through penance for sins. Plenty of that persists today (including within humanitarian efforts!), but there is also a sense of "giving for the good of the world", anonymous donations, etc. Where does that sense of 'all humans in it together' come from?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

How did Calusa, Jaega and Ais religious beliefs and practices differ from the Seminole who eventually followed them? How do Native Beliefs differ in ancient Florida?

Also, were the religious practices of the groups on Florida's East Coast even related?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Did the Allies in World War II ever entertain the idea of offering a conditional surrender to Nazi Germany before the end of the war? Do we know any details on what the conditions of these offers might have entailed?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Did Soviet planners ever think they had a realistic chance of overrunning NATO and conquering Western Europe in a conventional war? What about NATO?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Was there such a thing as a twelfth-century renaissance?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Nazi "Ecology": How important was it in the ideology of National Socialism? What, if any, environmental policies did the Nazi state enact.

Every now and then it's pointed that there was a "green" tendenancy in Nazi ideology. Often I hear this in partisan contexts as attempts to discredit or smear advocates of contemporary environmental protection policies. More recently, I encountered Timothy Snyder's book Black Earth, which argues that Hitler's obsession with carving out territory in Eastern Europe, lebensraum, was underpinned by anxieties in Germany regarding diminishing natural resources and agricultural productivity. Snyder's argument would suggest that an ecological panic was a major contributing factor to the Second World War and the Holocaust. I'm curious to know what r/askhistorians makes of this specific claim.

I'm also curious, however, about the extent and importance of "green" or "environmentalist" strains in Nazi thought and policies, though I appreciate that applying these exact terms here is an anachronism. Was an appreciation for nature more of an ancilary concern for the Nazis, something coincident with the much broader lineage of nature worship in German Romanticism? Or was it intrinsic to the rest of the Nazi worldview?

And finally, one last question, to what extant were any environmental policies actually enacted by the regime? I know there were plans to "Teutonize" landscapes in territory incorporated by the Reich by introducing select species of plants and animals native to Germany (though this is actually the opposite of what ecological wisdom would encourage). Were these ever implemented? Likewise, were there any efforts to establish any agencies or programs akin to the American E.P.A., i.e., programs charged with things like pollution restrictions, land use regulations, et cetera?

2 Answers 2017-01-09

What are some contributions in science, technology or society that we in the west have to thank the ottoman empire for?

I was talking to a friend about great empires and their impact on our societies today and he said that the Ottomans have not contirbuted in any way. That can't be right. Please help me out Historians of Reddit :)

2 Answers 2017-01-09

How does the public perception of historical events compare to the actual history?

How has the perception of history overshadowed actual historical events? For example, Benjamin Franklin flying a kite with a key to “discover electricity” might be a small scale example. Or people “knowing” history from Shakespeare or movies.

What scholarship exists on the perception of history?

Finally, what do you think the impact of collective memory or public opinion is on the historical record/how history is presented? (For example the cancellation of the Enola Gay exhibit at the Smithsonian Institution's National Air and Space Museum.)

1 Answers 2017-01-09

How "uniform" were European armies from the early Middle ages?

For example, English armies depicted in shows like Vikings have all the soldiers wearing the same basic armour, with the same helmets and most equipped with similar looking swords (screengrabs here, they aren't great quality but I think they show what I mean).

How accurate is this? Would soldiers be equipped by the state with standardised armour, as was the case with the Roman armies? Or is this just more Hollywood-conjecture, with little basis in reality?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Can we identify isoglosses in folkloric traditions?

It's often possible to identify reasonably sharp boundaries for linguistic features. For instance, people who grew up in Cleveland, OH have a particular vowel shift that people who grew up in Columbus lack. There are even formations like the Rhenish fan, where you have a series of related isoglosses set off from each other, creating a transitional area.

Are there any similar phenomena in folklore?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

What about Michel Foucault's theories made them so influential in the historical discipline?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

What would your quality of life be like if you tore your ACL or MCL in the 18th Century?

Watching football yesterday, I realized some of the injuries we see today must have happened a few hundred years ago as well. But, what would your life be like if this type of now 'common' injury were to occur a few hundred years ago.

5 Answers 2017-01-09

Why are there so few remains of german culture and language in today's USA when german used to be the largest group in terms of ethnic heritage

(Just recently surpassed by 'hispanic')

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Why were Tiberius Gracchus and Gaius Gracchus able to be tribunes, while Clodius needed to be adopted into a plebian in order to be a tribune?

My only guess is that this was one of Sulla's reforms. Is that true?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

When did Western countries start to outsource their work to poorer countries?

Both the design and the manufacturing. I assume manufacturing went away much before design, but design is slowly going too.

And what was the reason behind it? If it's the price, why didn't they do it earlier? I know most Westerners were also quite poor by today's standards in the older times, but I can't imagine them being poorer than the people of countries where the current jobs went away. Logistics and infrastructure can of course be a problem if you think about outsourcing to India in 1930, but Mexico for example, was quite feasible.

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Life shortly before "Civilization"

What was life like in regions like soon-to-be-sumeria and soon-to-be-egypt before they were considered civilizations ? And at what point were loose groups of small towns with a similar cultural background no longer seen as that, but as a civilization. Were the people living at that time aware of that change ?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

How did European microstates survive during the era of nationalism and centralisation of the 19th and 20th centuries?

eg, Liechtenstein, Monaco, Luxembourg

1 Answers 2017-01-09

Was siege warfare predominantly a battle of attrition or was the determining factor a breach of the walls?

This question might be a bit too general, so the specific time period I am looking at is medieval and post medieval Europe. Did siege weapons, such as the catapult and trebuchet change the winning strategy in any manner?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

What do we know about the West Germanic/Non-North Germanic pantheon from before the christianisation of those people and how well does it line up with the Norse pantheon?

Are parallels such as Donnar - Thor and Wotan - Odin mythologically equal or is there simply a dominant linguistic connection?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

What were the reasons for the resurgent of extreme Islam in the Muslim world?

I read that Muslim populations throughout the middle east in the beginning of the 20th century weren't as religious and extreme as they are today or even 20 years ago. What changes are largely responsible for the radicalization of the Muslim population in the ME in the 20th century?

2 Answers 2017-01-09

Prior to the Kursk Offensive, Red Army soldiers were promised 1,000 rubles for destroying German tanks. Were these rewards ever paid?

1 Answers 2017-01-09

I have encountered factoids about Romans using urine to whiten their teeth or as a cleaning agent for clothes. I've also read that "money doesn't stink" is attributed to emperor Vespasian after introducing taxes on distribution of urine. So, how useful was pee in Roman Empire and Late Republic?

I have only seen Cattulus mentioned as a source for the teeth cleaning part, but generally, is there enough in the sources to establish a picture of what Romans' relationship with their bodily waste was when it came to practical usage? Was urine the best way to get ammonia?

2 Answers 2017-01-09

When reading a history book how do you determine if it's good scholarship and/or well-researched?

This has always been a point of mixed amazement and befuddlement for me (a layman) when discussing what I've read with my friends who have advanced degrees in history (or some such similar subject). They'll often comment that a book was "well-researched" or has "terrible scholarship" or a similar remark.

I've never wholly understood how they reach these conclusions and I'd like to know how one does this so I can start making these investigations and assessments myself.

1 Answers 2017-01-09

⯇ 3691 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start