This map of the Empire of Monomotapa shows an empire that covers all of Africa from the Zambezi down. How (in)accurate is it?

The map in question, dated 1635 from a Dutch cartographer.

All sources I can find about Monomotapa discuss their origins in northern (modern) Zimbabwe and their subsequent conquering of Great Zimbabwe. Then there's not much more. And yet, this map and others I've seen show a far greater empire, all the way from the Cape of Good Hope up to Angola and over to Mozambique.

What's the truth here?

EDIT: I understand the map is hardly "accurate" in a sense, in that its interior is largely guesswork; it still lists the entire coastline under the rule of Monomotapa, though, and that's the land they did have contact with/knowledge of.

1 Answers 2017-01-04

In Ancient Greece, What distinguished tyrants from kings?

The example I am thinking of is the difference between the Spartan Kings and the tyrants of other city states, but explanation of any other example is welcome.

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Why was Ronald Reagan so electorally successful?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Do you use literary works as a source in your field of history? How are they used?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Did Hitler speak English?

Or rather, did David Lloyd George speak German? I'm watching a documentary right now where they're showing videos of Lloyd George's visit to the Berghof and it shows him and Hitler speaking freely and casually to each other (but of course there's no sound on the video so I can't tell what they're speaking). It doesn't seem there was a translator, their speech looks too free-flowing. So which one of them spoke the other's native tongue?

2 Answers 2017-01-04

How did Napoleon win The Battle of The pyramids, if muskets of the time were so allegedly inaccurate while he faced a tenacious melee-oriented foe in the form of the Mameluke horsemen ?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

How is position "in queue" for the British throne decided?

I fell into the wikipedia loophole, and from reading about Belize, i ended up deep, deep in the Royal Family, most people had "X in line for British throne", how is it decided who gets what place, and who decides it?

3 Answers 2017-01-04

Several prominent figures in the East German government (Ulbricht, Mielke, Kessler, etc) defected to the USSR during World War II. How common were German defections, especially early in the war? Why would one leave the "winning (at that time)" side? What separated defectors and POWs?

(Walter Ulbricht, leader, Erich Mielke, head of the Stasi, and Heinz Kessler, minister of defense)

1 Answers 2017-01-04

I've heard a lot about European colonialism and Imperialism on the indigenous people of the Americas but what about Russia's interactions with indigenous people as it spread to the Pacific?

I feel like this is a pretty bad question but i struggled how to frame it as what I saw was the complete absence of coverage. Am I wrong? How have historians covered this and how widely covered is it? How often is it invoked in comparative studies? Wish this wasn't so vague

3 Answers 2017-01-04

Where might I go to find Civil War conscription/draft records by county?

A friend of mine is making stupid claims that his home county supplied more confederate soldiers than any other county in the entire south. Which I know can't be true because that county is one of the least populated counties in Virginia, now and during the civil war.

But i'd still like to find records of some kind just so he'll have to admit he's making stuff up on the spot.

EDIT: i've done a few google searches where you can search for specific soldiers and found multiple genealogy sites but I really just want like counties, and then how many soldiers were supplied.

2 Answers 2017-01-04

How did the Soviet Ruble work in communist USSR?

My knowledge of communism is probably lacking, but my basic understanding is that in a communist system, the people produce goods and hand them over to the state, and the state distributes them equally among the people.

But the USSR had a currency, the Ruble. I would expect the existence of a currency would imply capitalist forces at work.

  • Where did people get rubles?

  • Would they have to spend them in state-owned stores?

  • Was there any "grassroots capitalism", like people using the rubles to buy and sell from each other directly?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

What is the most recent consensus on the fate of skyjacker D.B. Cooper? Have any recent historical investigations offered anything new?

This question pertains to the infamous 1971 plane hijacking, and "Dan Cooper" the perpetrator. As of last year, the F.B.I. closed the active investigation, but has any recent work on the subject been done by historians? I'd be very interested to hear what the community has to offer in terms of the general consensus and likely outcome of the hijacking based on the available evidence and established research.

2 Answers 2017-01-04

Did Monarchs of Nations Ever Marry One Another?

What I mean by this would the King of England ever marry a Queen of Denmark, or a Tsar of Russia marrying an Austrian Archduchess? I assume it happened but not often, because would the female be forced to pass her titles to the other family in the next generation? Thanks for any answers!

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Who would Karl Marx have studied in order to write the Communist Manifesto and/or other works of the era?

No idea is created out of nothing, so I'm just wondering who came before Marx that would have influenced his thinking on the subject.

2 Answers 2017-01-04

Why are countries and ships referred to as 'she'?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Was Napoleon's escape from Elba was a bait set by Talleyrand?

In Robert Greene's The 48 laws of Power he makes the claim that Napoleon's escape from Elba island and subsequent events leading to Waterloo were orchastrated by Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-Périgord. He argues that Talleyrand initially wanted Napoleon to be banished much further from Europe but after realizing it he couldnt make that happen he plotted with foreign ministers of Auatria and England to have Napoleon return to a France. Considering France was in a weakened state upon his return Talleyrand expected Napoleon to fight another war which he would then lose.

That seems a bit farfetched to me but after looking into Talleyrand I'm more open to the idea but i cant just take an uncited claim at face value. Is there substantial evidence to support Robert Greene's claim?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Did the Icelandic people who visited the Americas before Columbus bring disease?

We know that the Icelandic community visited the Americas almost 500 years before Columbus. So why didn't they bring diseases that wiped out the native populations they way Columbus did. Or is there evidence that they brought disease to the native populations?

2 Answers 2017-01-04

How common were misspellings or grammatical errors in old (Greek, Roman, Midieval Europe, etc) texts?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Was there any backlash to Ataturk reportedly sleeping with 15 year old Zsa Zsa Gabor?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Sharing a similar culture and the same language, why does the US seemingly maintain a large emphasis on religion in daily life in comparison to the UK and Australia?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Why does the USA refuse to switch to the metric system, and is there any precedence for a country changing the way it measures?

3 Answers 2017-01-04

What are the historical roots of the modern boisterous "Texas Exceptionalism"?

and did it always play such a big role in public imagination?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

what did hitler do with the jewish peoples houses after they were sent to concentration camps?

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Coast Salish people 1492-1792

Simply, what was happening in Coast Salish society for these 300 years?

I'm from the Puget Sound area, and our common knowledge of the local people begins with a young Chief Seattle seeing Vancouver's ship, and ends with the founders of the city of Seattle naming the new town after him. (Yes, i am aware that's not his name, but I'm not sure how to spell it correctly)

I understand that Europeans and European-Americans took somewhat longer to get out to the west coast, but surely there had to have been some influence and effects from colonization during those centuries. Or maybe not? Were the Lushootseed-speaking people of Puget Sound largely untouched by outside societies during that time? I understand that's not really true - since Spanish, Russian, English, Haida, and other people all interacted with them - but mention it to contrast with the people east of the Mississippi or south of the Rio Grande.

1 Answers 2017-01-04

Tuesday Trivia: Leave It To Fate?

This week's Wednesday Time Warp is inspired by /u/ParallelPain!

As historians, we often look for causes and effects, rational explanations for actions and events. Today, let's get in a time machine, pretend it is still Tuesday, and consider some of the ways and moments that people throughout history have left things to fate or to the Fates.

2 Answers 2017-01-04

⯇ 3703 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start