Battering rams with animal heads? Was this a thing? Were they effective?

Multiple movies and TV shows have depicted armies besieging a fortress and eventually resorting to a large battering ram to get through the front gates, either carried or swinging from some chains (Return of the King?) with a metal head of some animal attached to the front.

Did armies put any sort of "cap" on the front of battering rams to make them more effective? Were they even effective to begin with? Finally, if they *did* put some sort of hardened endpoints on the battering rams, did they ever shape them in the head of some animal? Why would they do this?

1 Answers 2022-01-28

Did Ethiopian Christians react similarly to the rise of Islam as European Christians did?

More specifically, did the crusades garner a response from Ethiopian Christians? If so, what was that response? It seems I am assuming that Ethiopian Christians were a unified body but I do not intend that. I am interested in the myriad responses to the Crusades so any at all would help satiate my curiosity.

1 Answers 2022-01-28

When did Hongkongers start using English names?

1 Answers 2022-01-28

In the movie Enemy At The Gates (2001) a German tank is seen moving through the rubble of Stalingrad with a siren broadcasting to the Russian soldiers to join their forces. How accurate is this during the Russian campaign and in general? Would the Germans actually accept Russian deserters?

1 Answers 2022-01-28

Was the naming of equipment and fortifications after contemporary figures, like the Churchill tank or Mannerheim Line, limited to World War II?

(I reposted this to correct a crucial typo in the title -- sorry!)

Not only were they contemporary figures, they were active members of the military or government. Churchill as PM, Mannerheim as Field Marshall, Weygand as Supreme Commander, etc.

The practice seems, to me, to have been pretty widespread, including the UK, France, Finland, and the USSR. When did this practice start, and when did it end? (Or did it even end? Though I have a hard time imagining the Boris Tank or the Biden-class aircraft carrier!)

More broadly, how were these things named? Was there a process, or did someone just, well, pick something? For the sake of specificity, let's say I'm interested in how British tank naming, but I'd be curious about any nation in the early 20th c.

2 Answers 2022-01-28

How accurate are Zinn’s *A Peoples History of the United States* and album’s *Killing Hope*?

As a person in many leftist circles, I am often recommended these. Are they very accurate?

1 Answers 2022-01-28

Why didn't the Entente attempt an amphibious in Belgium in 1915?

Following the race to the sea, my understanding is - in broad terms - that there was some back and forth fighting (Ypres) and then the front (over-statement coming up) settled down until the following spring. I also understand that trench warfare reduced casualties compared to the relatively open fighting that took place prior to Ypres, but also made a return to such warfare difficult due to the power of the defender generally outweighing the attacker. So, why was an amphibious landing along the Belgium coast seriously considered? It would seem to be the ultimate outflanking move that was attempted during the 1914 race to the sea.
In the spring of 1915, Britain and France found five divisions (increased to 15 during the course of the year) to land at Gallipoli. It would seem that the two countries had the logistical and shipping capabilities, as well as the troops to do so. The following year (after further fighting at Artois, Loos, and Ypres), whole new armies were marshalled for the massive Somme offensive. After the relative failure of 1915, why did no different approach occur? The shadow of Gallipoli? I do find it interesting that it would take another year before even Operation Hush was considered, and even then it was proposal for a single division to land in the immediate rear of the German positions rather than further up the coast ala the Second World War Anzio landings well beyond the rear of the Winter Line. An actual landing would only occur in the final year of the war, less than a brigade, during a raid to try and block Zeebrugge from being used. It would seem by this point, the port had gained more importance to the Germans than earlier in the war.

So, why was there no major attempt on the Belgian coast?

1 Answers 2022-01-28

"It is estimated that the port of Antwerp was earning the Spanish crown seven times more revenues than the Spanish colonization of the Americas" How true is this? Did the Belgian port really earn that much?

Found this on Wikipedia on Antwerp's history. It is attributed to this book. Weren't the Spanish earning obscene amounts of money from gold and silver mines in the Americas?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

Did Van Gogh actually kill himself? Where’d he get the gun if so? How much evidence is there to support the theory he was shot by someone else?

I’ve heard a little about the alternate theories to the commonly accepted narrative that VG intentionally set out to kill himself, and was wondering if anyone had any depth of knowledge on this that wanted to talk about the theory behind the cowboy-obsessed kid with an old service revolver and a likely accidental misfire being the cause of his gunshot wound, which he then took credit for to keep them from having their lives ruined over a goof.

And along those lines, is there much theorizing or speculating that VG didn’t actually cut his ear off, and just said he did to protect Paul Gauguin, who sliced it in a fit of rage during their argument and fled that night?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

Is there a list of “types” of flintlock pistol used during the English civil war?

Amongst modern day pistols there are colts, berettas, to name just two. Was there a comparable variety of flintlock pistols during the English civil war? Or was this stuff not that well-defined yet?

Failing that, what would be considered a unique or ‘rare’ pistol from the 17th century?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

What were the reactions and sentiments of the Japanese and German population after their surrender and occupation after World War II?

Was wondering if the population felt neutral or angry about the occupation of their country. If their was discontent, how did the allies handle it so it wouldn't create problems for their occupation?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

[META] Has the possibility of enabling voting on archived posts/comments been discussed for the sub?

Hi, I've seen multiple subs where I can now vote on old posts and comments. I realized today that this is a deliberate decision by the mods of those subs. https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/py2xy2/voting_commenting_on_archived_posts/

I was wondering if there was a conversation regarding enabling this for r/AskHistorians; I searched for META posts on the sub for the last couple of months and didn't see anything, so I thought about bringing forward the question: could we please upvote old posts and answers? There's a ton of excellent content from back before the sub was popular, and I think that many in this community would like to thank the people for their valuable answers even after 6 months have passed.

I understand that this could place an additional strain on the mods of the sub, but I thought that I should ask.

2 Answers 2022-01-27

What's the place of the storyteller when historians record oral history, particularly in studies of historically under/misrepresented communities? Are they/their background analyzed/interrogated the way long dead authors of textual sources are?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

Flat-sided coins seem to be standard across the world for exchanging small denominations of precious metal currency. Were other designs — like spherical or triangular coins — ever tried?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

Was smoking tobacco seen as a vice, even before it was discovered it’s a causer of cancer ?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

Why are Daoism and Zen (Chan) Buddhism so strongly associated with Martial Arts?

I had believed that the stereotype of the "Martial arts monk" was just that, a stereotype, until I learned that the Shaolin temple (the alleged birthplace of Chan Buddhism) is, in fact, real, and not a made-up place like I had believed.

After skimming a bit of research, it seems that Daoism and Zen Buddhism (which was itself influenced by Daoism) both have strong histories of martial arts practice - why is this?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

How did Mormons react to the American Civil War?

Was there a schism within the LDS church?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

In 1924, at the height Jim Crow Laws and immigration quotas, the Indian Citizenship Act was passed in Congress. How did expanding the voting base to more nonwhite citizens happen in such an environment?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

Are poisoned weapons just a thing of video games?

I get that poison would definitely have been used to kill specific people by putting it in their food or drink (or more cleverly by recent Russian attempts), but were poisoned weapons a thing which was used? Many video games allow you to coat a weapon you have with some kind of poison to cause extra injury to your opponent if you strike them and break the skin. Do we know if poisoned weapons were ever happened in history?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

What happened to wounded german soldiers who could no longer serve in ww2?

For soldiers who lost limbs and coudnt serve - what happened? We're they simply sent back home?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

What is the Reason for the Relatively Wide Ban on Nunchaku Around the World?

It seems that since Bruce Lee used them in his films in the early-70s, they increased in popularity and began to be banned in multiple countries. Wikipedia identifies Norway, Canada, Russia, Poland, Chile, Germany, England, Wales, Scotland and Spain as having strict regulations.

UK and German versions of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990) had to be edited to remove Nunchaku (signature weapon for Michelangelo) from the film altogether.

Even looking at the other traditional Eastern fighting weapons used by the Ninja Turtles (Bo staff, sai, sword), I don't believe that any of them are as strictly regulated. Is there any reason for this? Are nunchaku particularly dangerous compared to other weapons used in martial arts? Were there a significant number of injuries at some point around the 70s-90s that led to these restrictions? Thanks!

2 Answers 2022-01-27

Did the Crusaders say anything about hamsters?

Everyone knows that the friendly hamsters we now keep as pets come from the Middle East. Particularly the parts of the Middle East (like Syria) where the Crusaders went.

Did the Crusaders (or the people of Outremer) say anything about the hamsters there?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

I've seen it being joked that many "hot headed" knights of myth were actually just really nearsighted, and thought most people were enemies. Would someone being nearsighted actually impact their career as a knight or warrior? Were there disabled knights?

The joke itself is about Sir Tristram, and how he attacks people apparently without much regard for his own safety or without parleying first. Obviously this isn't a serious claim, but it got me thinking: would a person who is considered disabled or physically impaired in any way today be able to become a knight in the past?

1 Answers 2022-01-27

How did rulers fleeing their countries pay for things?

This might sound like a stupid question, but for example, Wilhelm II fled to the Netherlands near the end of WWI to the Netherlands and he stayed there after the German Empire fell. So how did he finance his and his family's life after he no longer had a country to pay for him? Did he just get a nine-to-five? Did some office have to deal with employing the former Emperor of Germany or did he just bring a briefcase full of bills with him?

2 Answers 2022-01-27

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | January 27, 2022

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

8 Answers 2022-01-27

374 / 7255

Back to start