Did Athenian fans of Socrates find it improper or distasteful that Plato used him as a mouthpiece for his positions in his texts?

Especially his later works. I know vaguely that Xenophon wrote some dissenting things about Socrates, but do we have sources criticizing Plato for using the Philosopher as a sockpuppet?

2 Answers 2016-12-01

British Merchant Navy during the Seven Year's War

One of the ways that the British Navy became so powerful during the mid to late 1700's was through the use of merchant ships in times of war. The ships were often already fitted with guns for their own protection, so it was a logical jump to outfit them just a bit more and use them for war. How was this different than privateering? Also, what was the average merchant's response to this? Loss of profits?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-12-01

If the Anglo-Saxons settling Britain spoke Old English, and the Angles before settling Britain spoke Old English, but the Saxons before settling Britain spoke Old Saxon, then at what point in history did the Saxons switch to Old English?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

What factors were present in the Roman Empire that made the tenants of a monotheistic faith more compelling than polytheism?

Reading the histories it seems a pretty stark shift from no-Christianity to Christian dominance in the Empire. That seems surprising given the religiously tolerant culture Christianity was created in.

2 Answers 2016-12-01

Were there any anti-war/pacifist, anti-imperial forces in Japan during WWII?

I found this post which only had a few comments. I doubt that there would be any armed resistance, but were there any major or minor groups, individuals, etc. opposed to the war, the imperial system, the bushido code, etc?

The idea of a conscientious objector might exist in the west, but were there any in Japan that we know of, even if the Japanese did not recognize the concept?

Please help with my curiosity.

Thanks

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Free peasants in 11th-12th century western Europe

I'm a little embarrassed to admit this, given my flair, but I don't know awfully much about free peasants and minor landowners in the period; I'm weak in economic history in general. I'm aware of their existence, obviously, but I'm curious as to roughly how common free peasants were and how they fit within and without the manorial/village society. If a village was owned by one or more noblemen, how did this effect a free peasant? Did he exist outside of this relationship? Source recommendations are more than welcome.

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Census 500K Results

Hello friends, after a far too long wait -- we completely dropped the ball on this as a mod-team -- we have results from our census, taken at the 500K subscriber milestone. An enormous thank you to all on the mod-team and former mod-team members who helped with this, including but not limited to u/caffarelli, u/elm11, u/keyilan, u/rioabajo, u/rusoved, u/searocksandtrees, u/sunagainstgold, and everyone else who looked at this in our various drafts.

If you're interested, here are previous census results: from 200K; from 325K. In the most current census, we got 3,893 responses.

#OK fine, what's the tl;dr?

Census respondents are:

  • overwhelmingly male (81 percent)
  • overwhelmingly do not identify as minorities (77 percent)
  • young (mean/median age 27/26)
  • well educated (49.45 percent have an undergraduate degree or higher)
  • interested in Western European History, Military History, Medieval History, History of Ancient Greece/Rome and Science and Technology History

Without further ado, let's get to some of the numbers! Percentages may not total 100 due to rounding; I excluded some null values.


#Demographics

What's your gender?

Answer Number Percent
Male 3,152 81
Female 639 16.4
Other 40 1
Prefer not to respond 61 1.57

Sunagainstgold did visualizations for us throughout. Here is Gender, visualized


#Do you identify as a member of any minority group?

Answer Number Percent of total
No 2984 76.7
Yes 887 22.8
did not answer 21 0.5
TOTAL 3892 100.0

#List any minority identities you are affiliated with

Minority identities have been grouped into rough categories since there were so many unique answers, including many which combined several classifications

Answer (category) Number Percent of total survey responses Percent of minority identities
gender/sexuality 468 12.0 52.8
ethnicity/race/nationality 454 11.7 51.2
did not specify 223 5.7 25.1
religious 122 3.1 13.8
physical/mental health 79 2.0 8.9
social/political 10 0.3 1.1
TOTAL 1356 34.8 152.9

What's your educational level?

Answer Number Percent
Grad degree, history related 105 2.71
Grad degree, non-history 391 10.09
Grad student, history related 136 3.51
Grad student, non-history 281 7.25
Undergraduate degree, history related 290 7.49
Undergraduate degree, non-history 713 18.4
Undergraduate student, history related 239 6.17
Undergraduate student, non-history 683 17.63
Vocational degree or associate's degree 190 4.90
High school/secondary school graduate 414 10.69
High school/secondary school student 342 8.83
No formal education 33 0.85

Level of education, visualized

History/related education, visualized


What's your employment status?

Answer Number Percent
Full or part time, academic history 49 1.26
Full or part time, academic non-history 138 3.55
Full or part time, non-historical 1,525 39.18
Full or part time, other historical field 76 1.95
Full or part time graduate student 312 8.02
Full or part time undergraduate student 761 19.55
High school student or younger 352 9.02
No formal employment 185 4.75
Retired -- academia 36 0.92

What year were you born?

We got a wide range of responses on this, and after cleaning up some outliers/prefer not to respond answers, we came up with a reasonable plot in R. Check out this graph of birth years, all hail u/rusoved.

Description Year Age
Minimum year 1936 80
First quartile 1985 31
Median year 1990 26
Mean year 1989 27
Third quartile 1995 21
Max year 2003 13

What historical topics do you find most interesting?

Answer Number Percent
Western European History 2664 70.3
Military History 2221 58.6
Medieval History 2215 58.4
History of Ancient Greece/Rome 2210 58.3
Science and Technology History 2082 54.9
20th Century history 1820 48.0
North American History 1764 46.5
Cultural History (e.g. art, music, literature) 1732 45.7
Religious and Philosophical History 1667 44.0
Eastern European History 1612 42.5
Other ancient history (e.g. Sumerian, Egyptian) 1596 42.1
Middle/Near Eastern History 1395 36.8
Prehistory 1244 32.8
Asian History 1210 31.9
Renaissance 1195 31.5
Post-Renaissance history 1194 31.5
Historiography/Theory of History 1190 31.4
Gender and Sexuality History 1166 30.7
Central & South American History 697 18.4
African History 655 17.3
Oceanic History (Australia, New Zealand, etc.) 576 15.2
all/anything/everything 21 0.6
Economic history 8 0.2
[other*] 189 4.5

Subfield interest, visualized

#Subreddit Satisfaction

How are the mods doing?

Answer Number Percent
Too lenient 68 1.75
Just about right 3,565 91.6
Too strict 257 6.6

Are you happy with the moderation style?

Answer Number Percent
I don't care 579 14.88
The mods are striking a happy balance 2,948 75.75
The mods are too noisy (too many green comments) 192 4.93
The mods are too quiet (too few green comments) 171 4.39

#Question Asking

Have you asked a question in the last three months?

Answer Number Percent
No 3,445 88.5
Yes 447 11.5

Did you do any research before asking your question here?

Answer Number Percent
No, I wanted an AskHistorians answer first 67 15.12
Yes, I did a basic Internet search or read Wikipedia 265 59.82
Yes, I did extensive research and AskHistorians was my last hope 14 3.16
Yes, I did some more advanced research (books, academic articles) 97 21.90

Was your question answered?

Answer Number Percent
Yes 260 58.43
No 185 41.57

If it was answered, how would you describe the answer(s) you got on a scale of 1 to 10?

Answer Number Percent
1 9 3.23
2 2 0.72
3 7 2.51
4 7 2.51
5 21 7.53
6 19 6.81
7 47 16.85
8 74 26.52
9 34 12.19
10 59 21.15

#Flair, glorious flair

Do you have flair?

Answer Number Percent
No, but I want to apply 176 4.52
No, I don't think I'm qualified 2,640 67.83
No, I don't want it 828 21.27
No, my field doesn't get enough questions 126 3.24
Yes 122 3.13

Flair status, visualized

#Time on Topic

Do you have a reddit account?

Answer Number Percent
Yes 3,834 98.51
No 58 1.49

How long have you been reading AskHistorians?

Answer Number Percent
Less than a month 123 3.71
1-6 months 589 17.75
1 year or longer 957 28.83
2 years or longer 948 28.56
3 years or longer 453 13.65
4 years or longer 186 5.60
I don't remember 63 1.90

How much of your time on reddit is spent on AskHistorians?

Answer Number Percent
Hardly any 1596 41.12
About 25% 1992 51.33
About 50% 187 4.82
About 75% 55 1.42
Almost all 51 1.31

How do you typically come to read a thread in AskHistorians?

Answer Number Percent
I come to AskHistorians specifically 1346 34.88%
From my reddit front page 2488 64.47
Link from a crosspost in another subreddit (such as /r/BestOf or /r/DepthHub) 25 0.65

Have you ever "referred" someone to AskHistorians?

Answer Number Percent
Yes, both online and offline 515 13.26
Yes, somewhere else on the Internet 144 3.71
Yes, on reddit, in another subreddit or via pm 266 6.84
Yes, in real life 1155 29.74
No 1804 46.45

How often do you read a thread at AskHistorians?

Answer Number Percent
Once a day or more 1497 38.52
Once a week or once every few days 1990 51.21
Once a month or once every few weeks 350 9.01
Less than once a month 49 1.26

#Subreddit Resources and Usage

Have you ever used our Books and Resources section?

Note: there were a large number of one-off "Other" responses that I didn't add to this table.

Answer Number Percent
No, it doesn't interest me 172 5.03
No, I didn't know you had that 2,285 66.79
Yes, on the subreddit wiki 868 25.37
Yes, on Goodreads 43 1.26

Do you listen to our podcast?

Note: there were a large number of one-off "Other" responses that I didn't add to this table.

Answer Number Percent
No, I didn't know there was one 2,138 62.66
No, I don't like podcasts 698 20.46
No, I tried it and I didn't like it 79 2.32
Yes, all or most episodes 79 2.32
Yes, but only episodes that interest me 278 8.15

How frequently do you consult the wiki Frequently Asked Questions page, or search the subreddit, before asking a question?

Answer Number Percent
Every time I ask a question 483 14.12
Most of the time I ask a question 188 5.50
Some of the time I ask a question 181 5.29
Rarely or never 377 11.02
I have never asked a question 2,191 64.06

Do you follow us on Tumblr?

Answer Number Percent
Yes 30 0.88
No, I don't want to follow you 75 2.20
No, I didn't know there was a Tumblr account 842 24.68
No, I don't use Tumblr 2,464 72.24

Do you follow us on Twitter?

Answer Number Percent
Yes 157 4.61
No, I don't want to follow you 176 5.17
No, I didn't know there was a Twitter account 1,115 32.77
No, I don't use Twitter 1,955 57.45

#Discovery

How did you originally find AskHistorians?

This chart excludes "I don't remember", which accounted for 1,159 responses.

Answer Number Percent
Link on Twitter or other social media 12 0.44
Highlighted as a trending subreddit on the front page 70 2.56
Friend or family member told me about it 149 5.45
Highlighted in a hub sub (such as r/DepthHub, r/BestOf) 331 12.11
Mentioned in a default sub (such as r/history, r/askreddit) 1,202 43.98
Mentioned in another sub (such as r/askanthropology) 391 14.31
Saw an AskHistorians thread on r/all 373 13.65
Saw it featured on another website (not Reddit) 49 1.79

How do you typically come to read a thread in AskHistorians?

Answer Number Percent
From my reddit front page 2,488 63.93
I come to AskHistorians specifically 1,346 34.58
Link from a crosspost in another subreddit 25 0.64

#More stuff

In the comments below, I'm also going to post the "other" historical responses, and two sets of "open ended" responses we got that were suggestions/criticism, and brief responses. Please let us know if you have any follow up questions at all.

EDIT We have an answer to the discrepancy about question-asking; I switched the labels on "no" and "yes" for "have you asked a question in the past three months." Sorry about that!

10 Answers 2016-12-01

What is this piece of equipment/uniform used by Soviet soldiers during WW2?

The on shown on this picture:

http://i.imgur.com/DWmybsG.jpg

Thank you.

1 Answers 2016-12-01

A lot of early Roman history employs archaeology and mythology as the main sources. At what point do we begin to mainly rely on actual documents and other traditional evidence?

I know the Celts sacked and burned Rome in 390 bce and that this led to a loss of sources for earlier periods, but is there a particular time after this event that historians can more or less rely solely on documents, and not have to consult mythology?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

The selective breeding of slaves

I often read that black slaves in antebellum America were treated "like animals". If this was literally 100% true, then I think their white masters would have subjected them to selective breeding programs to create more practical strains of Negro the way they bred more practical strains of dog and cattle. Was this practiced, to what extent, and to what effect?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in December 01 2016:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2016-12-01

Why were slings still used after the bow was implemented into armies?

I think it's a bit odd that Assyrians, Romans and others hired slingers when archery, even composite bows were in use. The sling to me seems like much less effective, not that I am any kind of expert of course. Were there any strategic advantages? Were they cheaper to maintain than archers? Also: When/why were slings disbanded in warfare?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Dominant Cavarly

I'm looking for specific wars and/or battles where Ottoman and Winged Hussars were the deciding factor or inflicted extremely lopsided casualties. Sources would be appreciated but not neccesary, thanks to all who answer.

1 Answers 2016-12-01

What were the grooming methods for "cave men and women"?

For example, did they file their nails with a rock or bite them, how did they cut hair, do we know preferred lengths?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Are Macedonians the same as Bulgarians?

Hint: I am Bulgarian.

I have read plenty of texts from the 1900s and sources. Texts from Léon Lamouche: http://data.bnf.fr/12932391/leon_lamouche/ seem to point out that a large part of people living in today's Macedonia used to identify as Bulgarians.

A theory in Bulgaria is that during Yugoslavia's Rule history of Macedonia was changed and people were repressed in many ways if they identified as Bulgarians.

Is any of this True?

2 Answers 2016-12-01

Why did Napoleon go for Moscow instead of Saint Petersburg?

It made sense for Hitler to go for Moscow because it was the Soviet capital but why did Napoleon go for Moscow, considering that the Russian capital at the time was Saint Petersburg?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Baath, Sheeba, Bathsheba

So, Baath was a god considered bad by the early Israelites, Sheeba was some Queen(of which period I don't remember), Bathsheba was a queen(?) Involved with some nonsense on David's part. Is there any linguistics connecting this?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

How long could an inmate conceivably survive in Nazi WWII concentration camp?

How long did the longest person last? How did anybody survive a camp that was designed to work you to death? Was it only relatively recent cohorts of inmates that survived to liberation?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Why is mental health so much more prevalent in today's society as opposed to previous generations?

I'm asking this because I am going through a "depression" and the reason I put quotes on that is because although I have medications for it, I still feel like it is something I can get through without all of these chemicals. So what I'm asking you is are we, as a society discovering better treatments than in generations past. Or are we just giving people excuses to act abnormally?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Apart from the literature associated with the "New Culture" movement, what were the major literary trends and genres in the Republic of China?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

Were the dialogues of Plato mostly whole-cloth inventions for the sake of philosophical exploration, or would some Athenians have read accounts of the discussions and said "yes, I remember when Thrasymachus made that point to Polemarchus"?

To unpack the question, are the dialogues decently, loosely, very loosely, or not at all following actual historical meetings in accordance with the context plato provides in his works, and would any of the speeches or lines of argument be familiar to an Athenian audience (especially ones made not by more antagonistic interlocutors)?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

At what point in history did the holocaust denial actually become a thing? Straight after ww2 with the remaining Nazi's?

1 Answers 2016-12-01

How were lighthouses heated?

I am currently writing a short story involving a lighthouse, and I was wondering if anyone knows how they used to heat them, or keep them at reasonable temperatures for the lighthouse keepers (circa 1800). If you don't know the answer, is there another place/ subreddit that would be more likely to answer this question? Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-12-01

How did Scandinavia transition out of the viking age and into the medieval era, culturally, as well as militarily?

3 Answers 2016-12-01

Why do we say use foreign terms such as Caliph and Caliphate or Khan and Khanate but English terms like emperor for Emperor of China and Emperor of Japan, rather than Huangdi of Zhongguo and Tennou of Nihon?

Other examples:

Emperor of Ethiopia

Shah of Iran

Tsar of Russia

2 Answers 2016-12-01

⯇ 3784 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start