Saturday Reading and Research | November 26, 2016

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

8 Answers 2016-11-26

How much truth is there in the claim that the average Tibetan lived miserably and in servitude before 1951?

3 Answers 2016-11-26

How were airfields constructed in the Pacific?

They were important to the fighting in the Pacific but I don't know anything about the logistics behind them. I'm mostly wondering if construction equipment/concrete was carried with the Navy? Was it stored at depots? Australia? How long would they take to construct?

2 Answers 2016-11-26

Did Romans abandon the phalanx used in classical combat?

I've noticed that when i think of Romans, I think of tall shields and short swords. It seems that a phalanx with spear-like weaponry would have been more efficient. If the Romans did abandon this form of combat, I'm curious why and how it transformed from spear-like weaponry to using short swords.

1 Answers 2016-11-26

Witch hammer - illustrations

Hi,

I original posted this in whatsthatbook, but they recommended to ask here instead since it's a fairly old book. ;)

My sister professed an interest in getting a copy of the "original illustrated version" of the malleus maleficarum or witch hammer.

I've been googling and trying to figure out which version actually first contained the illustrations as it seems that the original version did not contain them? (Or maybe I'm wrong?) Illustrations such as this one: http://matthias-blazek.eu/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/kupferstich_hexenhammer-191x300.jpg and this one: http://austria-forum.org/attach/Wissenssammlungen/Damals_in_der_Steiermark/Jagd_auf_Hexen/Hexen.jpg

At this point, I've come to the conclusion that they are not from the same issue. There were 29 versions within the first few years of its original publications and I'm guessing different versions have different illustrations.

Right now I'd be very grateful if anyone could point me to the original version containing either of the pictures, a list of the different publications of the first say 20-40 years or a coffee-table book of medival witchcraft/witchhunting prints including the ones from the malleus malifecarum.

2 Answers 2016-11-26

Was Fidel Castro a "good guy" for lack of a better term?

We seen the so called "bad guys" of history, Hitler, Stalin and what not, but did Fidel Castro help his country? I understand he was a dictator but he is not mentioned in the history books over here.

7 Answers 2016-11-26

Where did the fashion of wearing monocles come from? Where did it go?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

What weapons system was more effective during the Vietnam war, the M16 or AK47?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

On the 1930 US Census people were asked to indicate if they were veterans, and if so, of what war. An ancestor of mine wrote 'Mex'.

This ancestor, whose name was Antony, was 37 years old in 1930. What war could he be referring to? I wondered if he might mean the US involvement with Pancho Villa but he would seem too young for that?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

Did people in China resort to cannibalism during the reign of Mao?

I've stumbled upon a question on History Stackexchange, I quote:

I have often heard and read this, but I wonder if credible sources can support these claims. I even heard stories of merchants selling human flesh and children under 12 sold to be eaten. I read about this in "comprendre le pouvoir" by Noam Chomsky and in tuersenserie.org; there's a letter in which Albert Fish talks about a friend of him who went to China and developed a taste for human flesh because merchants were selling it everywhere.

...that got me curious. The most upvoted and accepted answer over there is yes, but it's based on the impressive historical sources like The Guardian or RFA.org. I guess the quality of this subreddit have spoiled me, but I choose to interpret that as no answer at all. There's another "yes" answer based on somewhat more reliable source "Mao,The Unknown Story" by Jon Halliday but still being no historian I cannot verify if what Halliday says is history or just sensationalism.

So the question is, did it happen, and how common/significant was it? I mean cannibalism still happens in developed countries in our day because there is always that one sick psycho, so I'd assume it could have happened in Mao times as well, or any other times for that matter. But was it more common than that, due the famine?

2 Answers 2016-11-26

What were the differences between Republicans and Democrats before 1932

After 1932, it seems that the Democrats and Republicans more or less coalesced into their modern forms. However, before 1932 it seems that each party had conservative, moderate, and progressive factions. What were the issues that united all the Democrats into one party and all the Republicans into another?

For example, why did some progressives (Fiorello La Guardia, Robert La Follette, Jeannette Rankin, Richard Pettigrew, George Norris) join the Republican Party, while other progressives (Glen Taylor, FDR, Rex Tugwell, William Jennings Bryan) joined the Democrats?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

Why did the ancient egyptians stop building pyramids?

Hi! I was just curious why the ancient egyptians stopped building those massive pyramids they were so keen on for centuries and started digging underground tombs instead? Was it simply due to economic considerations or did some other events made them change their mind? Thanks in advance for all your answers!

1 Answers 2016-11-26

Why is saying 'yellow' instead of 'Asian' typically considered incorrect in the U.S., but 'black' and 'white' are accepted?

Does it have anything to do with propaganda campaigns run in the U.S.? If so, which?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

What Happened to the Vikings?

It's to my knowledge that 'nothing' actually happened to them. The foremost trait of Viking culture was raiding. It's my understanding that Vikings ceased when the raiding ceased. What happened in Northern Europe during the middle of the 11th century to halt Viking raids, and essentially putting an end to Vikings as a whole?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

How did John Quincy Adams win the election of 1824 if Andrew Jackson got the most electoral votes?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

If I were travelling around the European colonies as a wealthy private citizen in the 1800s, would I need to carry a bunch of hard cash with me, or would there be lines of credit that I could leverage along the way?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

I've heard that Jimmy Carter "never fired a bullet" during his Presidency. Is that true? It's pretty remarkable if true. Are there any other President(s) that never authorized any military combat during their presidency?

2 Answers 2016-11-26

Asking again, but why did Chinese and Indian armies continue to wear body armor into the 1800s while it was all but extinct in Europe except for some niche heavy cavalrymen by 1700?

3 Answers 2016-11-26

What was the country in Africa that use to be very wealthy almost 1st world, then went to 3rd world country after a war (or genocide it was something major).

I want to say Rwanda but I might be thinking of something different.

1 Answers 2016-11-26

Was Philippe Petain (Vichy France) truly a 'horrible, reactionary, treasonous, Nazi-Collaborator'?

My understanding is that the traditional view of Philippe Petain is as a radical reactionary who became engulfed in the defeatist mentality of WWII France, and so he collaborated with the Nazis for personal gain and/or fear of the complete conquest of France.

However I read a few things describing the amount of respect he obtained from De Gaulle for willfully returning to France to face his punishment, and how even Truman desired for his release a year after the war ended.

It sounds like he's a chivalrous man. Just a leftover of the 'old-guard' of Europe, who was misunderstood by contemporaries.

2 Answers 2016-11-26

Why was highway US-99 decomissioned, when there are many other examples of federal highways remaining when their routes were approximately duplicated by interstate highways?

2 Answers 2016-11-26

Why did water cooled machine guns fall so completely out of favour?

I know that when moving they could be a bit of a pain but in situations of more static defence surely they would have been superior to air cooled machine guns?

So why no water cooled versions of the MG-42, for instance, which went through ammo so quickly that the barrels were in need of constant replacement (which I know was a quick process in an MG-42 but was still time in which you could have sent another hundred of so rounds downrange)?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

Was christopher columbus's actions a product of its time?

I overheard two people at school talking about how other people in their class were wrong about saying christopher columbus was a bad person for killing off a bunch of native americans because it was a product of its time. Is this a resonable opinion and is it right/wrong?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

Why did early rifles have full stocks (a stock that extended close to the end of the barrel) compared to modern rifles

My main focus is that of the lee enfields during the war and the refurbs that were sold to civilians like my grandfather after the war which had the stock cut down into a "sport" version. What was the advantage of this? Why wouldn't it of be implemented during the manufacturing process?

1 Answers 2016-11-26

A quick glance at Chinese history shows very few great Han conquerors, and a great deal of failed military exploits. Why were the famously well-organized Chinese armies so seemingly miserably ineffective at operations outside securing their borders?

2 Answers 2016-11-26

⯇ 3798 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start