Does the tv show 'Hunting Hitler' have any credibility to it?

2 Answers 2016-11-19

Who/what were Freemasons, and why did so many groups (Catholics, Anti-Masonic Party) dislike them?

Trying to find out about them, I've found differing views: some say that Freemasons are a cult, others say it's some kind of society that people including George Washington were members of. However, I've yet to find out what they actually are or what they do.

2 Answers 2016-11-19

Why didn't the US directly attack Hanoi, or the north in general during the Vietnam War?

Were there any specific reasons why the US didn't launch any offensives in the north? Would capturing Hanoi not have been a big blow to the NVA or did the war not work that way? Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2016-11-19

When and how did we end up with a system where the people vote for presidential candidates rather than state legislatures or the people voting for members of the electoral college?

It seems to me like in the original design of the electoral college, there wasn't any role for the popular vote: the state legislatures would pick the electors, and the electors would have a conclave of sorts where they would debate and vote, without having been pledged to any candidate.

Looking at the Wikipedia article on the 1788 presidential election, it seems like even then some electors were chosen by the people of their states, but it seems like the people were voting for electors, not candidates.

In a modern presidential election, you don't vote for electors, you vote for candidates. For example, if you were a voter in Alaska in 2012, you saw on your ballot the names "Barack Obama" and "Mitt Romney". But if you voted for Romney, you were actually voting for Kristie Babcock, Kathleen Miller, and Christopher Nelson (the three electors from Alaska that year; each had pledged to vote for Romney). In a modern presidential election, the voters vote for electors who have been pledged to candidates without actually seeing the names of the electors.

When did electors start being pledged to candidates? How did the transformation occur?

1 Answers 2016-11-19

Is it realistic to be able to rate ww2 Field Marshals? If so, who were the most innovative, successful even during rear-guard? And, in comparisson to other nations?

Found this about link Hermann Balck http://www.historynet.com/the-greatest-german-general-no-one-ever-heard-of.htm

“Balck has strong claims to be regarded as our finest field commander,” declared Maj. Gen. Friedrich-Wilhelm von Mellenthin.

1 Answers 2016-11-19

Saturday Reading and Research | November 19, 2016

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

11 Answers 2016-11-19

At what point did professional athletes go from regular people who worked jobs in the off season to millionaires? What caused this dramatic change of lifestyle for athletes?

5 Answers 2016-11-19

What property/financial loss did Japanese-Americans incur when they were interned?

Edit: follow up question - how much of a notice were they given before they were interned?

1 Answers 2016-11-19

Can anyone with knowledge on the Cold War (particularly the KGB and espionage) tell me what this paragraph means exactly?

It's from "A Note On KGB Style" on the CIA website.

"The typical KGB officer, trained in an environment where political agitation is part of daily fare, sees political action and propaganda as part of his regular routine. There are numerous examples of Soviet officers around the world who seem to concentrate almost exclusively on pushing the Soviet line on the issues of the day with whatever contacts they meet. To them the political approach is not something apart from spotting, developing, assessing, recruiting and agent handling. It is integral to that effort. Some do it crudely, some ineffectively, some with great skill. The point is that in almost all cases, it is a part of the operation."

Here's the whole article: https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study-of-intelligence/kent-csi/vol15no1/html/v15i1a08p_0001.htm

2 Answers 2016-11-19

Just finished watching Manhattan, and I wonder if some of what win the show (spies, suicides, soldier prostitution, killings, etc) is based on real events, as is the show background, or not.

1 Answers 2016-11-19

How were soldiers in the Roman Army paid over time?

From the inception of The Roman Republic in 508BC forward how was a soldier in the Roman army rewarded for their service and how did this change over time?

Coins had only just been invented at the start of this period so I imagine that at the start they were paid in other means or were simply forced to fight?

I'm particularly interested in how much their pay was worth - what could they buy for it?

1 Answers 2016-11-19

In an imaginary court, I have to convince the judge that Christopher Columbus is responsible for initiating the Columbian Exchange, resulting in the enslavement of millions of Africans. I have to give witness as an African slave. I am stuck as I can find no log of how African slaves were mistreated.

If you could point me toward the right direction, that would be great. Thanks in advance.

2 Answers 2016-11-19

Netherlands abolished slavery in their colonies in 1863. Was there a big abolitionist movement at the time? What was known on the continent about the treatment of the slaves? Was the Dutch pro-slavery rhetoric much different from the main arguments of the U.S. South states?

1 Answers 2016-11-19

How was Genghis Khan able to manage his empire given its size and the lack of technology at the time?

2 Answers 2016-11-19

[Medieval Ages] Were visions or messages that appeared to priests or spirit mediums given a lot of credibility?

In the movie Rashomon (11th century Japan) a medium is used to relay the account of a deceased victim. In an historical fiction book set in the 12th century (A Morbid Taste for Bones by Ellis Peters), a vision comes to one of the priests in a church and on this basis alone the church members journey to acquire a relic. Were the accounts of priests or shamans always accepted unconditionally even by those in authority?

2 Answers 2016-11-19

How did the Byzantines/Eastern Roman Empire lose the Battle of Yarmouk?

I've always had a hard time wrapping my head around this, mainly because the common answer I always get is that Khalid al-Walid was a tactical genius...but even then, how can a tactical genius with 20k to 40k men defeat an army 140k deep from THE superpower of that era...and its not like the Romans didn't have experience, they'd been fighting the Sassanids on and off for centuries...can someone please clear this up for me its still hard to fathom just typing it out here

1 Answers 2016-11-19

I want to learn about the French Revolution, but I can only listen to audio sources. What do you recommend?

I bought Citizens by Simon Schama, but the narration is really difficult for me to get through because the man reading doesn't know how to take a breath before he starts a long sentence, and it's driving me crazy

3 Answers 2016-11-19

What was the real purpose of knights in Medieval Europe? Were they anything like we see in fantasy fiction?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-11-19

(How) did polytheistic religions get more gods for their pantheon?

Most polytheistic religions that don't have some sort of set pantheon of a handful of gods and no one else will have absolutely thousands or even hundreds of thousands of gods. For example the Greco-Roman Pantheons and Hindu ones.

I know some gods were taken over by Romans as they conquered land, but are there also cases where people make up gods? I mean, without trying to step on too many toes, they all were of course. But could you just make up a god in an afternoon and was it accepted that that was then an accepted god of the pantheon? Or was it necessary for a priest to be involved and somehow make note of the new deity for the "archives"? I suppose the best way to find out would be Hinduism, since that one's still around.

1 Answers 2016-11-19

At what point in US history were the most former presidents alive?

1 Answers 2016-11-19

Back when the Georgian calendar was introduced (1582) why were the prefixes "sept-" and "oct-" used for the 9th and 10th months rather than the 7th and 8th respectively?

2 Answers 2016-11-19

How was the New Deal payed for?

Steven Bannon says he wants a "Trillion dollar infrastructure plan." Trump also stated that he plans on lowering taxes. I wonder how in the past we paid for large projects like this.

1 Answers 2016-11-19

When did Nationalism become a "bad" word?

In particular, what are the differences between nationalism in the 21st century vs 19th century? I've always associated nationalism with the revolutions of the 19th century but with the recent election cycle, I've been seeing the phrase "right wing" or "white" nationalism used in a frequently negative connotation. Has nationalism always carried connotations of racism, xenophobia, etc. or is that a recent phenomenon?

I apologize if any of the questions seem loaded. I'm not intentionally trying to paint the recent wave of nationalism in any positive or negative way.

1 Answers 2016-11-19

How has the perception and measurement of time changed over... time? Have different cultures approached the concept and measurement of time differently?

If this question is too vague, I'll gladly accept criticism to narrow the focus. I'll throw in some specific queries to get a jump start - I'm not interested specifically in the history of mechanical clocks (though I like that history too), but "time" as a more general concept.  

What kinds of natural phenomena have been used as "clocks"? I'm familiar with the nail-in-candlewax, sun dials, mechanical clocks - are there lesser known "clocks" that have been used? Who used them, and for what purpose? Were there any cultures who had unique needs or desires that led to different timekeeping methods?

Have units of time always been understood as objective and the same for everybody, everywhere? For example, barring relativity/minute measurement issues, I believe that one day is roughly the same duration as another and can be subdivided into equal parts. In the past, was there ever a perception that over long distances time could be somehow "different"? Maybe like Lothlorien in Lord of the Rings?  

I'm curious about anything to do with time and clocks!

1 Answers 2016-11-19

Has any former US president actively gotten back in the political scene after leaving office?

Have they all pretty much retired and gone into philanthropic work after leaving office?

Or have any of them ever gone back to being a senator, governor or held any public office?

4 Answers 2016-11-19

⯇ 3813 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start