Why is the US urban-suburban dichotomy flipped on its head in France?

If you find yourself 10 miles north of New York, you'll be in leafy Westchester. Do the same in Paris, and you're in the banlieue Saint-Denis.

Many European central cities have retained their wealth, leaving the suburbs to poorer citizens, while beginning in the 19th century and continuing throughout the 20th century, US central cities suffered economically from suburban flight. Of course, things are changing, but I'm interested in why this happened, particularly a propos the intellectual history of planning in both societies.

What are the origins of this phenomenon, especially in comparative terms? Has the French upper class, for example, have the same aversion to cities as Americans /purportedly/ do? Do multiple national planning philosophies crop up in Europe, according to each country?

Thanks

1 Answers 2016-11-07

Why are the Kurds targeted so often?

In my Middle East politics class we discuss the Kurds pretty often. What I don't understand is why the Kurds are spread out across the Middle East and why they are targeted by both radicals and the government?

3 Answers 2016-11-07

What were North Korea's plans in the event they took over the South?

Do we have any evidence of the military and governments plans in the event they won the war?

2 Answers 2016-11-07

How common was car theft in the 1920s U.S.? Was there a market for stolen cars? How hard was it to identify/change identifiers of a vehicle after it's been stolen?

5 Answers 2016-11-07

When, how and why did many south-east Asian countries (such as Malaysia, Brunei, Indonesia) become majority Muslim?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

What do we know about the experience of Americans waiting for results of the presidential election of 1916?

Hundreds of millions of Americans will be able to follow the incoming election results in minor detail tomorrow, down to turnout in specific counties, and it will be treated as an evolving news story through the day.

How does that compare to a century ago? If I were a cosmopolitan banker in Manhattan, or a ranch hand in Oklahoma, what did I likely know and when did I likely know it? What if I were a county party chair in those same places?

Bonus points for anyone who'd like to discuss earlier eras as well. And thanks for your time.

1 Answers 2016-11-07

Did the high ranked commanders in the ARVN send their money to america pre fall of saigon?

I can't seem to find any information on this. Can anybody help me out?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

How much social mobility was there in the Late Roman Republic? What could a city dwelling plebeian do to improve his station?

I often read of freedmen and equites in this period who rose to great heights, but what about the poor city dwellers of Rome? What could they do, besides joining the army?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

Roman-Chinese ambassadors?

I read that in the 2nd century AD there was an attempted exchange of ambassadors between Rome and China...does anyone know how this turned out?

Did the respective embassies arrive at their destinations and too what degree was this contact maintained (or was it a one-off fact-finding mission) ?

Thanks.

1 Answers 2016-11-07

If Henry VIII annulled his marriage to Catherine of Aragon, why wasn't Mary I considered illegitimate?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

Before easily available media (radio and tv), did election campaigns focus on primarily slandering their opponents instead of issues like they do these days?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

Monday Methods: The Return of Video Games

After having already dealt with the subject, we return today to Video Games. With release of both BF1 and Civ VI, video games based on history are a big thing right now.

Can video games represent history accurately? Is there a need for accurate video games? How can we use video games as a medium to teach / impart history to the public? Does it make sense for historians to get involved in the industry? Share your thoughts and discuss below!

13 Answers 2016-11-07

What made the recovered Romans attack Carthage rather than Hannibal in Europe?

2 Answers 2016-11-07

Was the Winter War a proxy war between Germany and the Soviet Union?

I was reading about the Winter War and I can't help but wonder whether it was a proxy war for Germany to test and attack the Soviet Union (much like the Spanish Civil War in the years prior) prior to their invasion. The Winter War was fought very early in the war, while both nations were officially at peace, and I'm sure that Finland fit somewhere in the Nazi's racial hierarchy. I bet they wouldn't want it to come under the control of what they called "Jewish Bolshevism".

Is there any evidence that Germany supported Finland in their war with the USSR?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

When and how did the religion of the Ancient Egyptians die out?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

We are coming up on exactly 496 years from the Stockholm Bloodbath. Can it be blamed almost solely on Archbishop Trolle?

here is the Wikipedia page to get oriented. Did the events of the massacre pretty much confirm Sten Sture's accusations of Trolle working with the Danes? Was Trolle neccesary for Christian II. taking over, thus making Christian prone to act on the Archbishop's wishes (executing people on Trolle's proscription list)? If this event earned Christian II. the nickname Christian the Tyrant in Sweden, how was Trolle viewed immediately after and later when the power shifted? Is/was he known as a great traitor? Seriously, how cool is the name "Gustav Trolle"?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

Why did Admiral Takeo Kurita turn the Yamato away from the fight during the Battle Off Samar?

I'm sure he knew that he had the most powerful battleship known to man and an entire fleet at his disposal but why did he turn the ship away from a small force of Escort carriers and destroyers?

2 Answers 2016-11-07

If NAFTA was signed by President George H.W. Bush, why is most of the credit given to Bill Clinton?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

What was the role of monks and monasteries in medieval times? Were they respected?

2 Answers 2016-11-07

What sort of government was run by Cromwell?Was it an autocracy,rule by committee or what?Also what led to the decision to restore the monarchy?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

Had the legendary "dwarfs" of Western Europe been associated with Jews before Tolkein (or possibly Wagner)?

Tolkein's dwarves are, in part, inspired by/an allegory for the Jewish people. This connection has been explored in The Times of Israel and in academic writing. (Discussed on AskHistorians recently)

I am curious as to whether anyone associated dwarfs and Jews (or other supernatural creatures and Jews) before this?

The only example I can find is some people saying that that the dwarf in Wagner's Ring Cycle, Alberich, was meant to advance Wagner's anti-Semitic views.

I would be interested in knowing firstly whether there is a convincing case that Alberich is an anti-Semitic stereotype, and secondly whether there are other pre-Tolkein associations between dwarfs/other supernatural creatures and Jewish people.

I'd also be interested in whether and when other ethnicities have been associated with dwarfs (other than Scottish people, already covered last week).

2 Answers 2016-11-07

What did ancient music sound like?

For instance, we know that Egyptians had music..however..were we ever able to discover what their music sounded like? Was there ever a recreated piece? Were there any music sheets back then?

2 Answers 2016-11-07

Why didn't globalization and offshoring from the United States and other first world countries begin sooner?

The end of World War 2 is when we can look back and say that "this is the time period in which the age of Consumerism began." If this really was true, why was it companies that sold goods continued to operate and produce them within the United States? What prevented them from moving their factories overseas in the fifties instead of 40-50 years later? Was it tariffs? Was it trade restrictions? Would nationalism and pride in American-made goods have played a part? What was it?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

How did basketball become such a widespread sport, in contrast to others originating in North America?

Almost every country has a professional basketball league of some sort, and the sport is contested at Olympic level. Contrast that to other sports to come out of North America: baseball, whose spread is limited to areas that are or have been directly in the United States' sphere of influence, and American football, which never took off outside US (and Canadian) shores. So what makes basketball different? Did the fact that it originated in the YMCA play a role?

2 Answers 2016-11-07

Why wasn't America known about by going from Siberia to Alaska in 1792?

1 Answers 2016-11-07

⯇ 3839 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start