This article in The Atlantic mentions that the murder rate in the Medieval period was 12%. That seems absurdly high. Is there any truth to it?

the article

It just seems absurd. Like, just estimating, half the world's population or more was in India and China. China and south India both had long periods of political stability - does that mean a European had something like a 25% chance of dying due to violence?

Are they counting people who die to due to war-caused famines as being murdered?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Book recommendations in Chinese History

Hey guys. I'm an American living in China and I intent to go to grad school for my PhD next year. Are there any books on Chinese history you would recommend? I've read a fair bit but am looking to broaden my knowledge before grad school. I'm most interested in the Han, Ming and Qing dynasties, as well as the modern/PRC period. I'm open to any subjects or time periods, however.

3 Answers 2016-09-29

[META] Why not hide posts without actually deleting them, or give a tag of not mod approved?

Why not hide posts without actually deleting them, or give a tag of not mod approved? I hate both censorship and deleted threads on interesting topics, but still appreciate the reasoning behind trying to keep approved answers up to a certain standard.

Question comes from https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/54yk6m/there_was_a_time_when_everyone_smoked_cigarettes/d86kh9y

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Were there conditions that made it unlikely for China to be first to the Americas?

Why didn't they find it first? Did they lack economic pressures to travel by ship in that direction? Did they lack an adventurous culture that was present elsewhere?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Why was "fart" used so much more a few hundred years ago in books?

I was farting around with Google and noticed this: Google Books Ngram

Curious as to why the word was so prevalent back in the 1600/1700s in books? Was it used in like every single book at the time?

Bonus question: why did it's use drop off so suddenly?

thanks

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Did any immigrants immigrate to the US during the US Civil War? If so, what were their thoughts?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Why did Nova Scotia remain neutral during the American Revolution?

I was reading through a thread on this subreddit when I found this sadly incomplete response about why Nova Scotia never joined the Revolutionary War. Searching through this subreddit, most answers to questions of Canadian neutrality seem to focus on Quebec. Can anyone offer some greater analysis into this topic?

2 Answers 2016-09-29

Was there any movement to expand the Soviet Union?

Did the Soviet Union at anytime consider annexing any of its satellite states into the USSR? I read that Todor Zhivkov, the leader of Communist Bulgaria, once called the nation the 16th republic of the USSR and made requests for Bulgaria to become part of it, and was wondering if there was any movement by these republics to become part of the Soviet Union. Additionally were there any people in the USSR advocating expansion, especially considering some places like Poland had been part of Russia prior to the Communist Revolution?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

How can I look up my grandfather's service record?

This is probably a question that's asked quite a bit, so I apologize in advance.

My Grandpa passed away when I was still in grade school. I know he served in the European Theater of WWII. I've been told he fought in the Battle of the Bulge. I'd love to learn more about what he did during the war, but from what I understand he never liked to talk about his experience and no one in my family seems to know much. Does anyone know how I can look up his service record?

Edit: By the way, he was from the US.

2 Answers 2016-09-29

Soviet SV-1 Walking Tank. Was this an actual tank, or a hoax?

The SV-1 Walking Tank is showcased in the popular game Warthunder, and it is a very interesting concept, but I've been completely unable to find any reputable sources to verify it's existence. My question is, was this actually used by the soviets, or was it just made up?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

How come in WWII films, documentaries, and shows, you see American troops in the Pacific using water cooled machine guns, while in the Western theater you usually just see air cooled machine guns?

Did water cooled machine guns have a better advantage in jungles?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Recommendations for Babylonian History

It has been some time since I started looking for books on Mesopotamian culture/history, especially that of Babylon. However, I haven´t had much luck as of this moment. The only "prominent" example I get is a pop history book written by Paul Kriwaczek, whose authority on the subject I don´t know. Any book recommendation will be greatly appreciated, as would be commentary on the book I mentioned above as well as its author.

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Why did Machiavelli write The Prince in Italian and not in Latin (which was the common language at the time)

Was it to be innovative? What was the main purpose?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Is it incorrect to say that Islam mostly relied on territorial conquest to spread?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-09-29

So the Franco-Ottoman alliance(Francis and Suleiman) was viewed as a scandal in the Christian world , how did the Muslims feel about it?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Ken Burns Civil War series. I love it and have watched it numerous times over the years. My question is, in the 26 years since it's release, have any of the facts presented been subsequently disproven or fallen under heavy scrutiny?

2 Answers 2016-09-29

Did Joan of Arc use cannons in the Siege of Orleans?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

Did the Greek Steam Engine serve any practical use?

2 Answers 2016-09-29

Did milk and cheese become mainly consumed in Europe because Europeans were lactose tolerant or did Europeans become lactose tolerant because they consumed milk and cheese?

Or just dairy products in general. What happened in the medieval world when a European was lactose intolerant, did they just die from hunger because everybody drank milk and ate cheese? Did people understand lactose intolerance back then?

2 Answers 2016-09-29

On the Eastern front did Stalin's tactical and strategic prowess win WW2 or did Hitler mismanage Germany to a loss?

1 Answers 2016-09-29

In 1963, Khomeini met the Sunni scholar Abul Ala Maududi and later translated his works into Persian, "Iran's revolutionary rhetoric often draws on his themes." Was the incorporation of Sunni ideology a known part of the Iranian/Shia revolution?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Why did the Ottoman Empire fail/refuse to industrialize?

I read this article by George Friedman on MaudlineEconomics.com and this paragraph piqued my interest:

The Ottoman Empire collapsed after World War I primarily due to a single weakness. While the European and Russian empires participated in the industrial revolution, the Ottomans did not. And World War I was an industrial war. The Ottomans could win battles, but their empire couldn’t survive the war.

Does anyone here have a theory as to why the Ottoman empire couldn't/refused to industrialize?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Where To Find All WW1/WW2 Historical Footage?

Hola,

I'm looking for WW2 footage that I can use royalty free. There are many on Shutterstock and various other stock photo/video sites but their prices are extraordinarily high. I'm sure that there is some place on the internet that archives historical footage from the early 20th century (and preferably in chronological order).

1 Answers 2016-09-28

There was a time when everyone smoked cigarettes because the dangers of smoking hadn't been discovered yet. But did the public have any idea that cigarettes produced negative health effects? How did they explain away coughing fits and other respiratory problems associated with smoking regularly?

6 Answers 2016-09-28

Can someone recommend a book about pirate raids on land?

I'd like to learn more about pirate raids on land, both how small coastal villages defended themselves against the threat of pirates and what tactics the pirates themselves employed. Preferably something that covers multiple time periods and locations (e.g., Caribbean pirates but also northern Viking raids). I'm finding a lot of books about piracy at sea, but I'm only really interested in how they attacked villages. Thanks.

1 Answers 2016-09-28

⯇ 3928 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start