A question after reading Germania by Tacitus

While reading his description of the Germanic tribes clothes I found this paragraph particularly interesting-

"They choose certain wild beasts, and, having flayed them, diversify their hides with many spots, as also with skins of monsters from the deep, such as are endangered in the distant ocean and in seas unknown"

What monster of the deep is he referring to? If I understand the geography correctly he must be referring to creatures from the North Sea, right? What sea creatures do we have on the fossil record from that area and time period that no longer exist?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

What was Joan of Arc's execution like?

Would there have been a lot of people there? Was she read her last rites? Are there any known last words? How extravagant was the execution?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Why is the European colonisation of North America seen as so morally wrong?

Native tribes took land from other tribes and had their own territorial conquests before the Europeans arrived, so why is there such a negative perception on the land being 'stolen' from the Native Americans, who had previously stolen it themselves?

3 Answers 2016-09-28

When did the word "sex" become synonymous with the word "coitus"?

I recently ran across a quote attributed to Oscar Wilde. Someone made the accusation the vocabulary was not used during his time and this could not possibly be his quote. The quote in question:

"Everything in the world is about sex except sex. Sex is about power."

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Why is there an ethnic difference between the indigenous groups of north and Latin America? Did they not both migrate to the Americas from the same place?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Did Talleyrand undermine Napoleon's Russian Diplomacy?

Did Talleyrand undermine Napoleon's diplomatic overtures to Tsar Alexander pre/during/post Tilsit? I've heard that Napoleon was attempting to create a stable imperial order with Russia and France as the two main European powers but Talleyrand, not liking this idea, alienated Tsar Alexander from Napoleon with backdoor dealing, is this true? If so, to what extent?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

How do I go about understanding history?

Say, for example, that I want to argue that the French Revolution contributed to the preference of conservative forms of government. What do I need to look at in order to understand the trends and motifs of that setting?

2 Answers 2016-09-28

What is the consensus on the accuracy for the almost overly-Homeric actions of Alexander the Great?

For example, I am referring to:

  • Several high-ranking Persian nobles were killed by Alexander himself or his bodyguards, although Alexander was stunned by an axe-blow from a Persian nobleman named Spithridates. Before the noble could deal a death-blow, however, he was himself killed by Cleitus the Black at Grannicus.

  • Alexander then mounted his beloved horse Bucephalus, took his place at the head of his Companion cavalry, and led a direct assault against Darius. The horses that were pulling Darius' chariot were injured, and began tossing at the yoke. Darius, about to fall off his chariot, instead jumped off. He threw his royal diadem away, mounted a horse, and fled the scene at Issus.

  • Alexander, while leading the charge, formed his units into a giant wedge, which quickly smashed right into the weakened Persian center. Darius' charioteer was killed by a spear, and chaos rang out as everyone (incorrectly) thought it was Darius who had been killed. The Persian line then collapsed, and Darius fled. Darius escaped with a small core of his forces remaining intact, although the Bactrian cavalry and Bessus soon caught up with him. The remaining Persian resistance was quickly put down. In all, the Battle of Gaugamela was a disastrous defeat for the Persians, and possibly one of Alexander's finest victories.

Pretty much in every single battle Alexander and his cavalry make some heroic charge and directly go to the heart of the Persian army and directly towards Darius. It always makes out Darius to be weak willed and a coward as well while Alexander is elevated to Homeric heroism.

How true is all of this, and is their a consensus among historians? From what I understand Hans Delbruck pretty much states that all of this is Macedonian propaganda.

1 Answers 2016-09-28

What was the Welsh reaction to the Norman conquest?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

In the history of Rome podcast, Mike Duncan says that when the vandals sacked Rome 455, they took took half of the roof of the temple of Jupiter. Why was the roof valuable? Why was the temple still there 140 years after Constantine?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

What's the earliest example we have of a "dick joke"?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

When the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons was proposed, there were predictions of 25–30 nuclear weapon states within 20 years. How reliable were these predictions and which were the leading candidate countries to acquire nuclear weapons ?

I came across the prediction on the Wikipedia page of NPT

At the time the NPT was proposed, there were predictions of 25–30 nuclear weapon states within 20 years. Instead, over forty years later, five states are not parties to the NPT, and they include the only four additional states believed to possess nuclear weapons.

1st line, 5th paragraph.

I realise Wikipedia can be unreliable, but I was just curious about such a bold prediction.

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Can my professor's claim about modes of production in the ancient east and west be substantiated?

One of common themes of the World Civ 1500-Present course I'm in is that from the onset of civilization, the east utilized collective property. The professor uses this as an explanation as to why state ownership is endemic to the east, also to hint that Maosim utilizes this ancient tendency.

By contrast, and attempting to explain the origins of capitalism/liberalism, he claims the west has always been based around private ownership.

I'm curious if there is much information to substantiate these claims, and although I don't mean to question the legitimacy of my professor and his research, I'm not totally convinced these theories are as important to explaining as much they're made out to. In short, if the modes of production of the ancient west and east offer any explanation to what we've been taught.

1 Answers 2016-09-28

How close was America to a second Civil War after the Lincoln Assassination?

I feel like the Union would've accused the Confederacy of Lincoln's Assassination and would've taken up arms again. Was this the case? If so, what prevented a second Civil War?

2 Answers 2016-09-28

Any truth to this story? During his war against the Aztecs, Cortez supposedly built a trebuchet to save on gunpowder. On the first shot, the projectile went straight up, came straight back down and destroyed it.

I've seen this several times online and it sounds plausible, but I've never been able to find a primary source.

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Who are some intriguing, or important, people that have been punished by Roman Damnatio Memoriae? How does this affect, or did affect, historians throughtout the ages?

Damnatio memoriae is absolutely fascinating. However, I don't have full understanding of the absolute severity. Also, the effects on Roman society and our current understandings of history. Are there missing pieces in history that are a byproduct of Damnatio Memoriae? Pieces of history historians wish they knew. It would be wonderful if anyone could provide excerpts, or simply share their favorites. I understand damnatio memoriae is not solely a Roman punishment. Huge Soviet history nerd, so I have a general understanding of its use during Stalin's time. If there any other personal favorites, from different time frames/cultures, that would be fun too. Thanks.

1 Answers 2016-09-28

In ancient Sumer, one city-state could achieve "kingship" over the others. What form did this kingship take? What privileges did kingship confer? How did one assert one's kingship?

"No one knows" is an acceptable answer.

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Why was Catherine Howard executed?

Please, I need a TL;DR answer, I just don't understand.
Thanks

1 Answers 2016-09-28

I have read that Crete produced some of the best quality archers in the ancient Mediterranean, what was it that set them apart from other archers of the time?

2 Answers 2016-09-28

What do historians think of Eric Williams book 'Capitalism and Slavery'?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Life in the medieval commune

I have been reading Kropotkin's Mutual Aid, as well as The State:its Historic Role, and find his descriptions of the medieval commune/free city very interesting. He focuses (obviously) mainly on the mutual aid institutions present, and perhaps is idealistic or overly focused on the good. An example:

"In short there is a massive and varied documentation to show that mankind has not known, either before or since, a period of relative well-being assured to everybody as existed in in the cities of the Middle Ages. The present poverty, insecurity, and physical exploitation of labour were then unknown."

"With these elements - liberty, organization from the simple to the complex, production and exchange by the Trades (guilds), foreign trade handled by the whole city and not by individuals, and the purchase of provisions by the city for resale to the citizens at cost price - with such elements, the towns of the Middle Ages for the first two centuries of their free existences became centers of well-being for all the inhabitants, centers of wealth and culture, such as we have not seen since."

Are his depictions of commune life accurate?

What works is it worth reading to learn more about life in the communes?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Has any "modern standard" version or translation of a bible been "retconned" by newly discovered text that are older than the source documents used for the current bible?

I was thinking about this last week reading about the En-Gedi scroll.

I believe the most popular bible in the western world is the King James version of the Christian bible. It's been around a very very long time. There has to have been many discoveries made through archeology since this version of the bible became popular, including older source texts being discovered.

Have there ever been any reliable discoveries that disproved or differed from the most modern translations of biblical text for the consumer market?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

Did Victorian England have a death penalty for crimes like pick pocketing?

According to this comment: "Victorian England publicly hanged pickpockets..." https://www.reddit.com/r/Documentaries/comments/54pw0y/condemned_to_die_2011_documentary_about_the_two/d84k8py

Is this true? It's seems wildly beyond the belief that the punishment should fit the crime.

Apologies if this has been asked before, a cursory search of "pick pocket hang" didn't have any results.

1 Answers 2016-09-28

How effective were the Spanish and Portuguese at denying south and central American peoples access to guns, steel blades, and other European weapons?

In North America many tribes during the 17th and 18th centuries had plentiful access to firearms due to European traders eager to get their hands on fur and other goods. With some amassing a significant amount of power thanks to guns and incorporating the weapons into their culture.

I sometimes hear this contrasted with central and south America where the Spanish government was able to keep a much tighter control over the arms trade. Just how effective were the Spanish at keeping european arms out of the hands of the natives and why were they apparently much better at it than European nations in North America?

1 Answers 2016-09-28

if you were a common person in Rome, assuming you survived the event, how did the city being sacked actually affect you? what did it matter to you if the aristocratos had their gold or not?

2 Answers 2016-09-28

⯇ 3929 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start