History of the Grand Armee

I was composing a reply to the question What made Napoleon a successful commander?, and it occurred to me that I don't know enough about a some aspects of the topic to fully answer it. For example:

  • Did the Grand Armee have a better system for training recruits than other armies?
  • Why was Napoleon able to move faster than other generals? I am aware of how his Battalion system facilitated the movement of soldiers, but I don't know how he transported equipment and supplies.
  • Did the Grand Armee use better equipment than other armies?
  • Was the morale of his troops really higher than that of his enemies?

If you can answer these questions directly, please feel free to share, but the main reason I am posting is to receive appropriate reading recommendations.

So, is there any book you can recommend that focuses on the Grand Armee itself, rather than Napoleon and his generalship? I am also interested in any book on Napoleon and the emergence of Logistics.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

How did the Romans Punish People

I'm talking about murderers, Rapists, Traitors, Cowards, Incompetency, theft. How exactly did they go about doing this?

2 Answers 2016-09-21

Why is there little effect on the Spanish language even after the Arabs ruled over Spain for centuries?

2 Answers 2016-09-21

What reason did the Roman's use to justify their invasion of Gaul?

What role did Julius Caesar play in the justification for the conquest? How did he end up in the position of leading the campaign?

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Wednesday What's New in History | September 21, 2016

Previous weeks!

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

2 Answers 2016-09-21

Were there any Captain's wives aboard the English ships during the Battle of Trafalgar?

It is my understanding that Captains would sometimes choose to bring their wives on board in the Age of Nelson. Were any wives witness to Trafalgar? How did they fare?

What were the navy rules about captains and their wives, anyway?

2 Answers 2016-09-21

What are jettons?

(A google image search shows a nice variety of types.)
I've read an explanation that they were used as counters on a table, in the manner of an abacus. But this doesn't really fit with how these are found (by metal detectorists mostly) singly and everywhere where contemporary coins might also be found.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Was the millennium from 999-1000 ad marked in any special way?

If so, how did it vary in different countries/cultures?

I was wondering if anyone had gave it any significance or did people not really place much importance on it being a landmark year.

2 Answers 2016-09-21

The Western Front - lions led by donkeys? Book recommendations.

'Lions led by donkeys' books?

Hi Reddit Historians. I want to enquire about something very important to me currently. I need some history book recommendations.

This is my last year before university, and in my history course, we've been asked to pursue a personal investigation on a chosen topic.

My question I have chosen, which I cannot change -

'Lions led by donkeys.’  How valid is this assessment of the British army on the Western Front during the First World War?'

For reference, this is a brief idea of what we need to begin with.

⁃	A handful of primary sources arguing their own viewpoints

⁃	secondary sources

⁃	interpretations arguing different sides. 

Reddit, I am asking you for book recommendations. One I can think of currently is British politician Alan Clark's book 'Donkeys' which argues that yes, they were 'lions led by donkeys' essentially. There is another historian, Brian Bond, a revisionist, who disagrees with this view and argues that the losses were not futile and that Clark's view was basically unfair.

If any of you can recommend me some books to read and use for reference, that would be incredible! I'm not asking for information regarding the topic, only recommendations.

Hope everyone is having a good Wednesday.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Why did Reagan legalise no-fault divorce in 1970?

Given his later positions on family values, I would have thought he wouldn't necessarily have been interested in making divorce easier. Why did the Family Law Act of 1969 pass?

2 Answers 2016-09-21

Why has there been a shift from the way English is typeset?

When I read older books I tend to find a lot of quirks in the typeset that aren't found today, little things like changing "connections" to "connexions", changing "Muslims" to "Moslems", and the inclusion of diphthongs like æ.

Was spoken English different from when these books were printed (e.g. people really pronounced it mOslEms). Or were these artifacts from their original translations that got ironed out later?

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Why were the Ancient Greeks so intrigued by the idea of female warriors (Amazons)?

I've read that only Heracles is depicted more often on surviving Ancient Greek pottery, and virtually every mythical Hellenic hero kills or subdues Amazons at some point. The Athenian victory over the Amazons is even depicted on the Parthenon.

Is there some reason the Amazons held such a grip on Greek imagination? I can't think of an equivalent obsession in any other culture.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

To what degree did the Nazi's exercise ideological control over university education, and what sort of impositions did they make on university curricula?

1 Answers 2016-09-21

To what extend is it true that very few people can bring themselves to kill someone in combat?

I've seen it claimed on many places, but the closest I can find is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zViyZGmBhvs. I am interested whether historical claims (such as that 1700s battalion was able to score 500 hits on cloth but only three in combat) are true?

1 Answers 2016-09-21

What's the best slightly positive/non-Caro biography of LBJ?

After reading JUDGMENT DAYS Lyndon Baines Johnson, Martin Luther King Jr., and the Laws That Changed America I became very fond of LBJ and decided to look up a full biography.

Caro's books (I've gotten through 2, I'm guessing that the 4th book about hist presidency which I haven't gotten to yet will probably portray him more even handedly) are wonderful, super detailed things but the author seems to have a simple picture of Johnson and everything feels like another link in his argument chain. It's not that Caro hates LBJ or that he never portrays him positively but he seems to greatly accentuate his flaws. While portraying LBJ (and his crowd) as cynical and amoral it seem to me that he portrays some of the people around LBJ(like his mother, father, mentor Sam Rayburn, opponent Coke Stevenson) as saints, sanding of any of their rough edges to make him LBJ worse in comparison.

I was wondering if there's a 2nd/3rd best biography that while not being pro-LBJ propaganda accentuate more of his positive aspects, to balance me out.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Can ancient economic systems such as that of the Roman Empire be considered as capitalist?

4 Answers 2016-09-21

How was Europe able to become more economically powerful than the United States, in spite of the damage caused by World War 2?

1 Answers 2016-09-21

What's the First Recorded Breed of Domesticated Dog?

And who recorded it?

2 Answers 2016-09-21

In context of the Joseon Dynasty, what is a "chastity award"?

I was watching a Korean Drama, when the term "chastity award" came up. I tried googling around and I learned a lot about how women were treated during this time period, but I was unable to dig up this term. It may be a translation issue, as I do not speak Korean.

It mentioned towards the beginning of episode three of "My Love From Another Star", if that helps.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

What was searching for a job like during the Great Depression?

What did job advertisements look like?

Edit: in the US, to clarify.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Was it possible to leave the SS during WW2?

I know SS men who weren't comfortable participating in mass murder could transfer, or in some cases simply refuse. But could they actually choose to leave the SS altogether without facing persecution? How difficult was this?

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Did the Nazi's compare Jews to poisoned food during WWII?

And how was the information disseminated? Was it in print, over the radio, or in movies?

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Did FDR have plans to use nuclear weapons on either Japan or Germany?

We will never know what Roosevelt's final decision would have been since he died early 1945 before Germany's ultimate surrender. But, is there any hints at FDR's opinions on nuclear weapons, what situations he deemed appropriate for their use, and if one of those situations was what the Allies saw themselves in in late 1945, a drawn out long war?

2 Answers 2016-09-21

What rumors did the citizens of nazi Germany hear about the death camps, prior to the allied invasion.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

Was it common for slave owners to inherit their slaves stuff?

I came across a document during my research of a slave leaving their property to their "kind" master. It's off topic of what I was researching, but it made me curious if that was a common thing for slave owners to inherit from slaves, or if it's likely that the slave couldn't read and he drafted it up and just showed her where to sign.

1 Answers 2016-09-21

⯇ 3947 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start