How do the scale and rate of casualties of WWI battles like the Somme or Verdun compare to ancient battles like The Cannae?

My question is inspired by listening to Dan Carlin's Blueprint for Armageddon. He talks about how the size of ancient armies and how their casualties were nothing compared to WWI. But according to Wikipedia, 50-70k Roman troops died in one day. And in WWI, 22k was close to the one day max.

So was WWI really not that extreme compared to ancient battles?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

Why was Karl Dönitz's prison sentence handed at Nuremberg relatively light compared to his fellow Nazis?

He was sentenced to only 10 years, as opposed to much longer sentences handed to the other members of the Spandau Seven.

2 Answers 2016-09-17

Why do battles of classical Europe consistently seem march larger then then medieval battles. For example, the battle of Medway, 43 AD, of the roman conquest of Britain (45k vs 150k) compared to the battle of Hastings (5k vs 7k) of the Norman Conquest, 1066 AD.

I am listening to the podcast, 'History of Rome', and keep getting surprised by the numbers i hear for both sides of the battles. It seems that the men fielded even just by city states Rome encounters are often much larger then what an entire country is able to muster during the Medieval period.

Was it just population decline of cities? Were the older civilizations more sophisticated when it came to logistics?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

What do we know about related history between Bulgarians and Macedonians?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

13th-century warhorse training

In the book I'm currently reading, the protagonist states his desire to acquire a horse "that knows how to carry a wounded rider and, when its rider falls, remains by him."

Does such training have a historical basis in reality?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

How were autistic people handled in medieval times?

2 Answers 2016-09-17

(NSFW 18+) How far back in history do BDSM and other forms of kink go?

3 Answers 2016-09-17

How much blame does Calvin Coolidge deserve for the Great Depression, and how did his efforts to shrink government affect the US economy before the financial crash?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

It's 1896 and I am a rich Cuban (private citizen) visiting America who wants to purchase some Gatling guns to bring to my country to fight for its freedom. Is this possible? What sort of paperwork/permissions will I need?

These days, such a major arms purchase would need end user certificates, all sorts of permits from a web of law enforcement agencies and the DoD, if not approval from Congress. Oh and I'd probably need to be a nation state (I think there's a seminar to become just that). But what kind of bureaucracy would I have had to deal with at the end of the 19th Century?

2 Answers 2016-09-17

How did governance in the European monarchies change from the high middle ages to the early modern period?

I am given to understand that in the 1600s most of the European monarchies were more centralized and more recognizable as states than their middle age counterparts, and I am interested in how exactly this transition occurred.

1 Answers 2016-09-17

Exactly how common were bayonets during WW1, and if so, what battles?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

Besides Market Garden, what are some other notable and interesting Allied failures of World War 2?

4 Answers 2016-09-17

During the tenure of great composers like Mozart, Bach & Beethoven, would it be common to hear their music played outside their country or did music spread slower?

For instance, Bach's Toccata and Fugue in D Minor, would this have been played by organists throughout Europe at the time? Or did the spread of composers' music accelerate at a later date?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

The Voyager Golden Record contains spoken greetings in 55 languages; why were so many (four) Chinese language varieties included?

Just wondering why they included four different varieties (Amoy/Hokkien, Cantonese, Wu, of course Standard Mandarin/普通话)only for the Chinese language. I know they chose most of the languages by how widely they were spoken - so why weren't languages like Tamil or Javanese or Swahili, that are much more widely spoken, chosen over say Amoy/Minnan?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

Saturday Reading and Research | September 17, 2016

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

9 Answers 2016-09-17

Why aren't there ruins and buildings from Roman Londinium in London, like there are in Rome?

I was just thinking of how Rome has loads of buildings, amphitheatres, coliseums from the Roman empire, but we don't seem to have any in London.

Is it because we didn't care about preserving them and took them down? Or did they get destroyed in battles? Or just natural wear and tear?

4 Answers 2016-09-17

Waffen SS soldiers

Did they have a part in killing Jewish people in the holocaust ? Like executing them etc. ? Were all of them supporters of Hitler's idelogoy ? I've heard that most of them were forced to fight(which sounds like a bunch of bullshit to me), is it true ?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

Book recommendations on the Battle of Jutland?

I prefer books with a lot of technical information, but also a decent narrative.

2 Answers 2016-09-17

Where did the major groups of European languages originate from?

I know there are some Germanic languages like German and Dutch and maybe a little bit English. But English is angel Saxion or something (sorry I'm clueless) and French and Spanish and Italian are roamed (Latin) languages. What about Scandinavian languages? And east Europe where they speak slav languages?(dunno that term either sorry)

Please inform me!

1 Answers 2016-09-17

How many samurais where there in a standard japanese army compared to non-samurai units (achigaru?) in feudal period of Japan?

If this might be to hard to answer because accounts may vary a great deal, could you give examples from maybe one or more famous battles and time periods.

1 Answers 2016-09-17

In the Mitchell and Webb sketch about Sir Walter Raleigh naming Virginia, it is remarked that it seems "rude to call a land after the fact that our Queen've never done it". Do we know his exact reasoning as to why choose that name rather than, say, Lizzieland?

To be serious, I know Elizabeth was presenting herself as pure and virginal and that her pale white make-up was a reflection of that. Was that image so inseparable that anyone would automatically connect the concept of "a virgin" to "Our beloved Queen Elizabeth"?

EDIT: Wow, only just now noticing the bad grammar and wording. Well, I did get some great stuff to read, worth the embarassment.

2 Answers 2016-09-17

Stalin seems to get lots of blame for the Holodomor (Ukrainian Genocide). But from what I've read, the Ukrainians voluntarily burned their food and killed their live stock which caused a mass starving. What did Stalin actually do during Holodomor?

3 Answers 2016-09-17

Why did the“Great Leap Forward” cause a schism between the USSR and China?

2 Answers 2016-09-17

How commonplace was contact between Koreans and Chinese people?

For example would there be bilingual Chinese and Korean speaking communities living in the same city? Did Chinese/Korean marriages ever happen?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

Is it true that women couldn't buy property in the US prior to 1974?

This comment claims that women were not allowed to buy property until 1974. This is pretty surprising to me. Is this true, and if it is, why did it only happen so long after enfranchisement?

1 Answers 2016-09-17

⯇ 3956 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start