Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | September 05, 2016–September 11, 2016

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

4 Answers 2016-09-11

Was the Second London Naval Treaty ever officially repealed/revoked/cancelled?

The outbreak of WW2 certainly ended any pretenses at following any of the naval treaties of the interwar period, but I'm curious as to whether any mechanism of state ever officially (perhaps by name or implicit mention) revoked the treaty or anything along those lines.

1 Answers 2016-09-11

What was the contemporary public reaction in Kyoto when the Capital of Japan moved to Tokyo in 1868?

2 Answers 2016-09-11

This Week's Theme: "Food & Nutrition"

2 Answers 2016-09-11

What is the difference between Γραικουσ (Greek) and Ελληνική (Hellene) in ancient greek literature?

While reading Procopius's Wars (One side Greek, the other English) I came across the word Γραικουσ. Now I don't speak Greek but I know the letters and can sound them out well enough to recognize a few words.

I always had it drilled into my head in history and classics that the Greeks called themselves Hellenes, so why would an author writing in Greek use the word Γραικουσ ?

Here is an image of the page, the word Γραικουσ is used in paragraph 40

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Did atheists exist in the middle ages?

I know it was very much a time of religious fanaticism and superstition but there must have at least been a few skeptics. I'm curious to know what if any documented examples of people exist between 500-1500 AD who either questioned or outright doubted the existence of a god. In addition amongst common people (peasants, laborers, tradesmen) was belief in God universal?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Why didn't the allies consider invading Belgium instead of Normandy so that the port of Antwerp could be liberated much more earlier and thus having a bridgehead much more closer to Germany?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Stalin's mass purges against CPSU members during the 30s are widely seen as paranoid outbursts and/or brute-force elimination of opposition. However, is there any unifying theme or pattern that could be gleaned out of the killings?

I read about Kirov's death (allegedly ordered by Stalin, though not proven), and it was evident that he was a hard-working and loyal Communist, with no ulterior motives to oppose Stalin. However, it was mentioned that he was also very boisterous and independent-minded, leading somewhat of a Bohemian lifestyle that could have been in discord with Stalin's strict and spartan worldview. Stalin could have viewed him as some sort of bad role model, so in this case there is at least some "logic" (quotes intended).

What other "justification" would have Stalin had for other purged members?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Were there any pre-columbus failed expeditions in the direction of the Americas?

Did any country attempt to outfit an expedition that simply failed? Did someone try taking a multi-person boat in that direction and sunk? History seems to say that Columbus got extremely lucky in even making it to America, did anyone else try and fail? What type of records do we have of the expedition? I can't imagine much more than "we sent bob on a trip. Never came back. Presumed sunk."

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Why did the Wehrmacht Cap have a rope?

According to Wikipedia it's a rank symbol which were usually gold/silver. I'm just more curious if there were more uses to it except that, or if that was the only way it was worn? I also found examples with a leather strap or no rope at all. Can anybody expand more on this?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Where did medieval wealth in lands come from?

Yes I'm aware of the standard response of "medieval is a lot of land and a lot of time", but principally we can agree that medieval landholders was where the money was at (with understandable variation).

So, generally speaking, when someone generated wealth from their lands what was occurring to make them wealthy? Were they selling their goods to passing merchants? Did the lord strike an agreement with enterprises that needed their crop nearby? Did they sell their crop directly to the people living on their land?

I strangely doubt that a medieval lord put all his crops into a box and waited for the Harvest Moon guy to come along and pick it up and drop shekels into his account at sundown each day.

So what was the primary vessel of accruing wealth? What did the transactions look like? How did it go from crop to money in hand?

2 Answers 2016-09-11

Why did the Sovjets in 1939 decided to end the Franco-Sovjet-Treaty and to create the Hitler-Stalin-Pact?

Why did the treaty end in 1939? Why did USSR preferred allying with Nazi Germany in 1939? It was the "marriage with the devil" for them. Nazi Germany was anti-communistic with passion and also paranoid about communists/USSR attacking them and Nazi Germany was stronger and closer to them than France at that time, plus did Germany had interest to expand their territory - so in general was Nazi Germany a bigger threat to them.

What was Stalin's plan here? Did he expected Hitler to be his ally for real?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franco-Soviet_Treaty_of_Mutual_Assistance

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov%E2%80%93Ribbentrop_Pact

1 Answers 2016-09-11

What were the opinions of the English people on Henry VIII's reformation of the Church?

Hey guys, I'm fairly new around here. I currently have the task of presenting (in the form of a speech) the major achievements of a significant individual from Medieval Europe. As you can see, I have chosen Henry VIII and am currently working through the reformation of the English church. I have visited various websites as well as read through the book 'The Reformation: For Airmchair Theologians'. I have been able to research the significant people for and opposed to what led to the reformation, however, I am struggling to get a clear view of how the public viewed King Henry during and after the English reformation. Any answers would be greatly appreciated — thanks!

2 Answers 2016-09-11

During Boudicca's rebellion, why didn't Poenius Postumus send aid to Paulinus?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Why did it take Europeans so long to settle in the Americas?

Cannot find anything on google.

1 Answers 2016-09-11

For which consulship was the Republic at its height?

Kind of hard for me to put into a small question, but what I mean is, during what consulship of the Roman Republic did both consuls hold the values of the Republican tradition? Often it is shown that one consul was much more distinguished than the other (as seen with Scipio Aemilianus Africanus, Gaius Marius, etc.) or that they don't uphold the values of the Republic (i.e: Marius, The First Triumvirs, etc.) either through corruption or the breaking of constitution or tradition. So rather I'm asking as for which point did these morals or standards decline in the Roman politics and which consuls best upheld it. I'm trying not to make this sound like a "poll" question, rather as a "when/who" question.

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Why were the colonial US and Canada formed as separate colonies by the UK?

I'd assume it'd be for easier governing, but correct me if I'm wrong.

1 Answers 2016-09-11

What do historians think of James C. Scott's "The Art of Not Being Governed: An Anarchist History of Upland Southeast Asia"?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Information on Martin Luther

I googled this for 30 minutes. No avail. Was he speaking German at the Diet of Worms? Or English? And whats this that i hear he didnt say "Here i stand"? Did he even speak english?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

In America the 50's is often romanticized as being a time of vastly increasing wealth and prosperity . Is there any truth in this belief? And how did people come to perceive it as such?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Why have Jews been the subject of much hatred both historically and modernly?

From the Arabs centuries and millenia ago, to Hitler in the 1940s, and even to most Islamic countries nowadays -- the Jews seem to have a long history of conflict with other groups.

What were the major historical events that sowed the seeds for Antisemitism throughout ancient, recent and contemporary history? What made the Jews of interest to other groups?

1 Answers 2016-09-11

Hitler idolized Napoleon and Fredrick the Great, who did Stalin admire the most from history?

We already know Hitler's favorite kings and emperors from the past, but I have never heard of Stalin's favorites, those he admired and studied the most.

2 Answers 2016-09-11

How close was the outcome for WW2? Was it a landslide victory for the allies, or was it a 50-50, 60-40? In either case, what did the allies do that brought them to victory that the germans didnt?

Ive heard stories about ww2 but noone really clarified to me how exactly the allies "outplayed" the germans

1 Answers 2016-09-11

How developed were commercial networks in the Aztec state in 1518?

Were there regional market towns that were not administrative centers?

How commercialized was agriculture? Did farmers grow cash crops for export in the large cities like Tenochtitlan, or outside their immediate area?

Was there interregional commerce within the empire? If so, how did it work?

Was the economy principally based on money or barter? Did the empire produce coins? Is it true that cocoa beans were used as currency, and if so, how were the beans distributed across the empire? Would cocoa beans be accepted as money across the empire?

Was the large population of Tenochtitlan fed primarily by commercial networks, by the tribute sent to the center by the Aztec conquests, by the agriculture of the city's immediate hinterland, or by other means? Or was it a mixture of these methods?

Who were the people in Tenochtitlan, in terms of occupation? Were there large merchant populations in the city, or was the city inhabited largely by people (slaves, servants, artisans, etc) who were bondsmen or clients of the aristocracy?

Were there cities comparable in size to Tenochtitlan anywhere in Mesoamerica?

How did commerce work across multiple states, e.g. between the Tarascans and the Aztecs, or between the Aztecs and the Mixtecs?

2 Answers 2016-09-11

Did Stalin have an ideology?

On Wikipedia, the articles for Lenin and Trotsky devote paragraphs talking about their views of Communism and Marxism.

However the article for Stalin doesn't go into much detail about this. I tried using Google to find out more to satisfy my personal curiosity but links were mostly talking about Stalin's policies, paranoia, purges and so on....briefly mentioning the Communism in one country thing...

So my question is....did Stalin even have an ideology? Did he have in depth ideas about Marxism like Lenin and Trotsky did? Or was he just totalitarian?

2 Answers 2016-09-11

⯇ 3971 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start