Can anyone offer historical insight about the interrelationship of early twentieth century eugenics laws of various countries (including US) instituting compulsory sterilization, and the rise of Nazism?

Imagine first what a [SERIOUS] tag on this sub would mean, and then imagine that this has one.

I intend no flaming, controversy or trolling from this. I want to know more about something that did not occur in a vacuum.

Now, as to the question:

It seems to me that those sterilization laws fell into disfavor rather definitively when their logical end was made manifest in Hitler's Germany. I could be wrong about that, as I haven't done even more homework. But I was surprised to learn today that the origins of ideas about racial purity did not originate with The Nazis, but were a shared pool of the investigations and pronouncements of worldwide academia, and that the US had created what became a model law that the Germans government emulated in 1933.

Is that conversation over, or was it simply put on hold? Did the US and other countries abandon eugenics and sterilization after WWII? If so, was it because of Hitler's pogroms? Was the body of those beliefs held accountable in any way for the development of Nazi policies?

2 Answers 2016-08-21

Many Muslim men sport beards with no mustaches. How long has this been a trend, and is it religious, cultural, or fashionable in origin?

1 Answers 2016-08-21

What was the most one sided US presidential race? Statistically or otherwise.

1 Answers 2016-08-21

By the standards of the 1960's, was Abraham Lincoln a racist?

People on another subreddit were talking about politics and mentioned disappointment about a certain candidate nominated by the "party of Lincoln". Another poster said that Lincoln was deeply racist and that this wasn't a good criticism to make.

Anyways, this got me to think about this...was Lincoln really a racist? People mention this on the internet pretty frequently actually and I am very curious...

1 Answers 2016-08-21

How were siege towers ever effective? They seem too large and vulnerable.

Moreover, you have to put so many guys in them that if they fail, it seems like a major loss of both time and manpower.

1 Answers 2016-08-21

What was the situation with the papal-states during the creation of Italy

Were they forced into it and why didn't any catholic nations object?

1 Answers 2016-08-21

What is the meaning of the old phrase "Bawl(sp?) her out?" (A la Hank Williams).

1 Answers 2016-08-21

Did Moscow officials "pass the torch" to Los Angeles at 1980 closing ceremony, despite US pulling out of olympics that year?

There is usually a ceremonial hand-off of the Olympics from the current host to the next host at the closing ceremony. In 1980, this would have involved Moscow handing the Olympics to Los Angeles. However, the United States pulled out of the Moscow Olympics in protest over the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.

So, was there a hand-off at the closing ceremony and, for lack of a better term, was it awkward?

PS: Bonus music video of Moscow 1980 theme song.

PPS: Bonus video of Moscow 1980 closing ceremony.

1 Answers 2016-08-20

How did North Vietnam, the USSR, PRC and other communist powers react at the time when details of the My Lai Massacre became public?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

WW2: I've heard contradicting reports on how depleted the manpower of the major powers on each side was by the end of the war - How did the manpower situation for each country evolve throughout the war, and what was the situation at the end?

I've heard before that both sides were near the end of their manpower by the end of the war, and was wondering if
A: this was true?
B: How did the Axis powers manage to cause such a depletion of such numerically superior opponents?
C: how the manpower situations progressed through the war to their situations at the end?

I've asked this question twice before on AskHistorians in differing ways and failed to get a satisfactory answer - it's great that this sub keeps its standards so high! Here's hoping it's 3rd time lucky :)

1 Answers 2016-08-20

Is there reliable evidence that President James Buchanan may have been gay?

I've read that he was and was wondering if this was just speculation by people who don't know their history or whether there are any facts suggesting it.

1 Answers 2016-08-20

Can someone summarize the economic transitions of America from 1492-1750?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

Did black Afro American soldiers serve in their own platoons during WW2, or were they integrated amongst white soldiers?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

Who is this?

http://m.imgur.com/5le15SU

1 Answers 2016-08-20

Japan's annexation of Korea and its aftereffects?

As a tennage Korean living in America, I've been curious about this subject for a while now. So exactly what did Japan do to Korea during its annexation, and what are they still doing wrong? I've heard that Japan doesn't educate its students of the wrongs they did, and that they haven't really apologized to Korea. But on WIkipedia, there's a list of apologies Japan made. Are they not considered real apologies? Also, how do younger Koreans (teens-20s) feel about Japan?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

How were members recruited to the Black Shirts (Mussolini's fighting squad)?

Just started learning about the lead up to WW2 in my college history course and we were touching on Italy and talked about the black shirts and what they did but didn't touch on how members were recruited or how they had legal protection to act in the way they did, especially early on before they took power. I've tried to look online but couldn't find many sources that talked on the issues I'm trying to find. Any insight or pointing me in the right direction would be very appreciated.

1 Answers 2016-08-20

What was the likelihood that an infantryman who landed in France on or right after D-Day would be still be in infantry at wars end?

That is, how likely would it be that someone would still be in fighting condition and still able to engage in combat at the end of April, 1945?

2 Answers 2016-08-20

Is there any real chance that copies of the lost documents of the Library of Alexandria might exist elsewhere?

The Library of Alexandria was one of the most famous examples of knowledge databases of the ancient world. They manage to collect an immense body of information which they categorized and filed away for future records.

A large amount of information eventually became lost to us after a series of fires which occurred at different periods of history (contrary to popular belief there was more than one fire). Many portions of the records weren't restored and have been lost to history as a result.

My question:

Is it possible that copies of the records might still exist in other areas of the former empire? Possible in a forgotten backlog somewhere in the ancient world?

Was there any known system of making copies of these sorts of records which would give historians hope that something along those lines might exist? Some sort of example which shows "We know they made copies of these records here so it's possible they made copies of the others that were lost"

If such records might exist, where would they even be?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

In what capacity (if any) did the Ancient Romans use archers?

In all the texts I've read, there are no references made to archers. It appears to that the Romans preferred to use javelin wielding skirmishers or slingers rather than archers (in the pre-marian period at least). I'm puzzled by this, as I would assume that the range of archers would be much greater than that of any other ranged weapon of the period. Was there any reason for their preference of slings and pila?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

During WWI there was a shortage on guns which lead to the usage of older gun models, but wouldn't the demand for the bullets used on those guns not just increase to a point where the might as well make the newer versions?

Sorry if this is a bit unclear, I was getting a bit confused on this video explaining Austria Hungary weapon useage: link at 0:45 he tells us the were going through the weapons so fast the had to use older models, now here I'm assuming he mean going fast through the ammuntion as as far as I know the weapons didn't break regulary or anything like that, so what was actually going on?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

Did medieval nations define borders the same way we do today?

If you look at a map of modern day Europe, you will find a series of clearly defined lines that distinguish the borders of the different nations. My question is, was it always this way? Did medieval nations also define their borders as clear outlines or did they have a different approach to determining their borders?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

Why didn't the Ancient Romans wear beards?

It seems to me that most ancient cultures valued beards highly, associating them with virility and maturity, while the Romans associated them with decadent "eastern" cultures and considered them almost effeminate, in a paradoxical way. I do know that letting the beard grow was part of their mourning rituals.

Is there any consensus among historians on why Romans rejected the beard, or any contemporary opinions on the origin of their shaving customs?

2 Answers 2016-08-20

I was watching Mad Men and, apparently, elevator operators were common well into the 60's. Were elevators considered too difficult for the average person to operate or were elevators more complex than just the push button that we have today?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

How did rulers before the Modern period debase currency?

If I understand correctly, before the introduction in Europe of banknotes, bonds and similar, the value of money was entirely based on the worth of the precious metals inside. Barring a drop in the value of gold, how could a ruler decide to debase their money? Did they just declare that from now on, the new coins would contain less gold than before? If so, why didn't people who had a lor of the old coins just melt them for value and resold the metal?

Also, relatedly, what made certain currencies more sought after than other? Was it only the trust placed in the authority minting them that they wouldn't cheat on the metal composition?

1 Answers 2016-08-20

IN 1944, the USSR made a separate peace with Finland, why dint they just invade them and annex them outright; or at the very least make them a puppet?

The Red army in 1944 would've been quite capable of easily brushing aside the Finns, and its not like the western allies would do anything about it

1 Answers 2016-08-20

⯇ 4026 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start