2 Answers 2016-08-21
1 Answers 2016-08-21
4 Answers 2016-08-21
Today:
Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.
3 Answers 2016-08-21
In Dutch, the Dutch language becomes "Nederlands", and the Dutch people become "Nederlanders". However, in German, the German language becomes "Deutsch" and the German people are "Deutschen". Why we don't call the Dutch "Netherlanders" and the German "Dutch"?
3 Answers 2016-08-21
This applies to the rank and file, the military elite, and the King himself.
Was homosexuality common among the men who made up the rank and file of the military (the phalanx battalions, shield bearers, companion cav), or was it limited to the royal pages of the Macedonian elite?
And in regards to Alexander, it is widely acknowledged he had a sexual relationship with the eunuch Bagoas, but his relationship with Hephaestion isn't as obvious. What is the most likely consensus regarding Alexander's sexual partners during his lifetime?
1 Answers 2016-08-21
I've read that during the Empire's respective high points, the Praetorian guard was the military elite of the Roman army, especially during the reigns of the aforementioned Emperors? For example, they would frequently take the field during their campaigns. How well trained were they, and how much did they differ from other legionaries?
How did they fare in battle, and why did those Emperors try to deploy them as shock troops/reserve troops?
Thanks.
1 Answers 2016-08-21
I've watched a documentary series called "Soviet Storm" which goes in detail about the Eastern front, and they would often include quotes from Nazi generals comparing their invasion of the Soviet Union with their previous invasions, reiterating that the Soviets offered resistance that others didn't offer:
1. "Stubborn resistance by the Russians has forced us to fight by the rulebook once more..."
From what I gathered from the documentary and my prior knowledge of this topic, it seemed that the Soviets were completely unprepared for a strike from Hitler. Most of their experienced generals were killed in political purges, their defensive lines were practically non-existent, they were at a constant deficit of supplies, their shells couldn't pierce German tanks etc... It seems to me that they had much less going for them than the French. Could it be that if the French offered resistance similar to the Soviets they would have been able to repel the Germans?
Was the Soviet performance in the war, in fact, a triumph of the will?
1 Answers 2016-08-21
7 Answers 2016-08-21
We're costs local or fixed? What about different currencies?
2 Answers 2016-08-21
Please forgive me if this isn't exactly the right forum, but I couldn't think of a better subreddit to ask.
I think it would be possible to use such a replica as a really immersive sort of museum.
5 Answers 2016-08-21
I took a video of a Chinese Performance that I went to see in Hong Kong or was it Shenzhen?... I forgot the point is I don't understand Chinese but I am interested in what the story is about so can you please help me? Here's the link to the video https://youtu.be/_sjn5g7RR44
1 Answers 2016-08-21
I discovered a polish video about a guy talking about a "forgotten" polish empire.
He shows this map:
http://i.imgur.com/nEQD4e7.jpg
This is the video (It is in Polish) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PR2zf6ZIu5c
I went to Wikipedia to check out some maps from this time and I found an almost identical map, showing this here:
http://i.imgur.com/lqwzjkX.jpg
So I am pretty curious since I couldnt find any meaningful information about this "Lechian Empire" and wanted to know how much of it is true and what we actually now about the Slavic people in the time from 533 - 600.
1 Answers 2016-08-21
I read a book about this but it was a very long time ago and I can't find the book anymore... I only remember that it has a WW2 pilot said something like, "When the Musashi/Yamato fired, the shockwave was strong enough to make my whole plane rattle and I can feel that my wings are ready to fold at any moment."
Was the 18" blast shockwaves that powerful or does it have the same shockwave as 16" guns on the Iowa classes?
1 Answers 2016-08-21
First read this thing I wrote.
https://www.reddit.com/r/althistory/comments/4yu5zf/what_if_the_conquistadors_lacked_religious/
So I am curious. Was religious fanaticism a definite important factor? Was it important enough that the Conquistadors could not have conquered the Aztecs, Incans, Mayans, and other civilizations without it even with all the lucky advantages they had (as I mentioned one source stated that in my link above)?
Or was Spain really destined to conquer the Americas even if it was never religious as the result of the Reconquista?
2 Answers 2016-08-21
2 Answers 2016-08-21
As far as I know, Russia was a French ally after the War of the Fourth Coalition, and even fought Sweden for a French cause in the Finnish War in 1808-9. What changed from then to 1812 that soured relations to the point that Napoleon wanted to invade?
1 Answers 2016-08-21
The historical development of economies seems like a very complicated area, so I was wondering what historians think about this.
It seems obvious that Europe absorbing the natural resources of so much of the world would have some economic impact, but I'm not sure how much of that translates into the modern world, especially since the concentration of wealth in modern Europe does not seem to focus primarily on the countries which had the largest colonial empires.
1 Answers 2016-08-21
I've just been bingeing on nuclear test footage, and I've wondered this before but it just occurred to me again. How did they come up with the names for these tests? Operation Wigwam, Buster Jangle, Plumbbob, Niblick, etc. They don't seem to follow any code or military phonetics like Alpha, Bravo, Charlie, etc. They're just random names and I find them fascinating.
1 Answers 2016-08-21
The apostle Paul was a Roman citizen, and this allowed him to travel freely around the Empire to spread the gospel. But how would he prove this to the authorities as he passed through Roman territory? In his homeland, people knew him, but what if he went to Rome or Gaul? There we no ID cards back then.
1 Answers 2016-08-21
1 Answers 2016-08-21
Hi, I was wondering if anyone could explain to me the main Political powers in the Arabian peninsula 1900, I understand that the British empire had the colony of Aden and dominated the UAE, Bahrain and Kuwait but I'm more interested on the tribes in Oman, Yemen and Saudi Arabia. Who was the major tribes and powers in each country and how much territory did each own etc,
1 Answers 2016-08-21