How did the Mongols massacre entire cities, when outnumbered >10:1?

I once again stumbled upon some stuff about the Mongol conquests and the terrible massacres that they did everywhere, and then it struck me:

"How on earth could they massacre hundreds of thousands of civilians, when breaching the walls of a city?"

Seeing how the besieging armies were sometimes outnumbered up to 100:1 by the civilian population. After all, even a peasant with a stick is dangerous when fighting for his life and his families' life, and when there's 20 of them for every Mongol soldier. I just don't see how it'd be possible. Or do the estimates for the massacres consist solely of old women, cripple and children?

It's not like the usual 'paralysing fear', that often prevents prisoners from resisting, is applicable when the enemy is straight up running through the streets, entering houses and killing everyone in sight, either... right? You'd have to fight.

Extremely curious to hear on the matter from an expert. Cheers!

2 Answers 2016-08-09

What was the punishment for Adultery in Viking Society?

Please answer what would happen for both wife and husband, and whether there was consequences for the third party.

Also in extension the status of open marriages or polygamy

1 Answers 2016-08-09

What happened to kings once they lost a war in the Middle ages to Renaissance time period?

My question is pretty much the title, but to be more clear I was wondering what happened to the kings of conquered countries. As in, if a king was defeated by an attacking force were they usually captured, killed, or something else?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

My family has an inherited a WWII Alpini hat originally belonging to my husband's great uncle. What information can be ascertained by the style of the hat, and the various insignia?

My understanding is that most Alpini soldiers eventually surrendered to the Germans. Yet a small group went south and formed a new brigade and fought for the Allies. How can I determine which regiment Uncle Vito fought with? There is a number 2 on the front of the hat. Does that signify Tridentina?

All we know about him is that he was in what he called the "ski patrol", and that he was held in Russia for a while. There are what i believe to be Nazi pins on the hat; but I'm not sure if the the fact that they are still there signifies that he remained loyal to the Nazis, or if he simply never removed them. He eventually immigrated to Canada, and embraced his new country completely, denouncing the Nazis.

Here is an album of the hat, and a very brief description of him (in Italian) from a book, which we also inherited.

Uncle Vito's Alpini hat Uncle Vito's Alpini hat https://imgur.com/a/aNWIk

Brief description https://imgur.com/uRNzDtZ

Book https://imgur.com/khj6jAz

2 Answers 2016-08-09

Where the British really mean/controling of the American colonies before the Revolution?

I am a U.S. citizen and the way I was taught about the American Revolution really demonized the British. Where they actually huge jerks or is that just nationalist teaching?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

The Secret Service has a rather unfortunate acronym. Were they ever referred to as the SS and, if so, was there a conscious effort to separate themselves from that acronym?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Before the 22nd amendment, was it politically taboo to run for a 3rd term?

I know FDR did, and Teddy Roosevelt tried, but was there a general consensus among the electorate/parties that running for a 3rd term just wasn't the right thing to do?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Did any non-Christian ancient cultures accept the idea of a single, absolute truth?

I have a friend who claims that pluralistic views of the truth were the default 'pretty much everywhere' before Christianity. I find this difficult to believe, but I lack the expertise to be sure. Do we have surviving records of pluralist views expressed or widely accepted in other ancient cultures?

Edit: to clarify, I take him to mean by 'pluralist' something like 'relativist' - e.g. that something might be true for me, but false for you.

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Did Saxons have candy? What was it like?

So I recently heard a song on the radio about "Saxon Candy," and it got me thinking what types of preserved sweets similar to candies the Saxon inhabitants of England would have had without sugar.

Are there any examples out there?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

When The Iroquois Confederacy (The Six Indian Nation) wrote the 1774 letter declining their offer for college education, who wrote that? Is there a way to know if it was written by a certain individual or if it was just translated?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Was Napoleon really that evil? Like did he really do anything that was on the scale of Hitler or Stalin?

Sure wanting to conquer all of Europe is a pretty big deal but was his regime necessarily "evil"? From what I heard he loosened restrictions on Jews and promoted Education and really the only thing vaguely hitlerian about him was the complete and utter hatred of the English but even then he didn't want to wipe them off of the face of the earth? So why is he grouped as such a big dictator?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

How effective were the 1918 standard-issue infantry helmets of each of the belligerents of WWI? Why did they look so different, country to country? Were the differences primarily aesthetic or functional?

2 Answers 2016-08-09

Is there anything to the theory that lead poisoning was widespread in ancient Rome?

Especially given that I have read that Romans were aware of the toxicity of lead around the time of Julius Caesar's rule - Vitruvius wrote about it in Book VIII of De Architectura.

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Need help identifying a battle between France and Spain that is referenced in this passage from War and Peace

Hi all,

I was reading War and Peace and cannot for the life of me figure out which battle Tolstoy is talking about in Part 2, Book 5, Chapter 1. This is the passage:

The Spaniards, through the Catholic clergy, offer praise to God for their victory over the French on the fourteenth of June, and the French, also through the Catholic clergy, offer praise because on that same fourteenth of June they defeated the Spaniards.

Note that the year is 1811, so perhaps he is referring to a battle from the ongoing Peninsular War? But I couldn't figure out which battle was hailed as a victory by both sides. The Battle of Balien was in June/July, but it was an overwhelming Spanish victory.

If anyone can help, I would be very appreciative! I've tried to find an annotated edition that has more information, but so far haven't had any luck.

1 Answers 2016-08-09

How did a blacksmith operate during say the 12th century around the European parts of say England and france (Specifications in description)?

I have had an interest in metallurgy for quite some time now. I have also had an interest in history for as long as I can remember with feudal Europe as my primary interest.

I hope I can help answering this broad question by being a bit more specific. 1: What made the blacksmith decide what to make? For example: Did the lord give him an order or did he made what the citizens or villagers in his surrounding had demand for?

2: How did the blacksmith acquire ore and fuel? Did he buy it on the market, or from villagers finding ores in the forest or at river beds? Did he go out to find them himself or let his family find it?

3: How did the selling take place? Would he have a stall at a market or would he have a stall right outside the smithy where people would come by and buy something? Or would the customers come by, made an order for example: "Fix these horseshoes." and come by when the order was completed?

4: What kind of forge would be used most frequently during this period? Were different forges used for different goals?

5: Was there a big range from poor to prosperous blacksmiths during this period? If so what kind of blacksmith was expected to be more prosperous?

I hope these 5 guide lines helps you answering. I appreciate the help. I should note that in this example I assumed my blacksmith is a man. I'd rather not add /her /she everywhere. Thank you for reading!

3 Answers 2016-08-09

What effect, if any, did the Norman invasion of England have on the development of English/Scots in Scotland?

For example, English and Scots are very similar languages but are there components of the Scots language that still resemble Old English rather than Modern English?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Found this custom framed canvas at second-hand store, what exactly is it?

Hello,

I found this really cool custom framed canvas at the second-hand store today, and I'm wondering what it is. It looks like an evolution of language, but I'm curious to know more!

Here is the Canvas

2 Answers 2016-08-09

Roman historians -- How did the senate & the noble families of ancient Rome change their perception of having a ruler in a few generations? (100 BC - 14 AD)

Hello! I'll preface the question by adding that my knowledge of Rome prior to Julius Ceasars rule is limited at best & I'm not a native speaker, so I apologize in advance for any grammar mistakes.

My question is as follows, having read large amounts of Adrian Goldsworthy's work with regards to Augustus, how did the perception of a dictator or emperor change between Caesar being appointed dictator for life & Augustus becoming Princeps civitatis?

Was it simply the case of Augustus being the "better" ruler in terms of keeping the ruling class in check, that allowed him to hold power where Julius Ceasar had failed, or were there other factors at play?

Sidequestion; It is my understanding that the title Rex was more controversial than being proclaimed half-god or god, is there any known reason why that is? To a modern person it is rather perplexing because of the perceived power that the word "god" has.

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Tuesday Trivia: Hostile Takeovers

There was a thing--a religion, a book, a business, a country. It belonged to someone. Then it belonged to someone else. Tell us what happened in between!

4 Answers 2016-08-09

What was it like being an Austrian infantryman at the Battle of Königgrätz (1866)? Fighting Prussians armed with breech loading rifles while I only had muzzle loaded rifles?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

In ancient and medieval battles that lasted multiple days when would soldiers sleep?

2 Answers 2016-08-09

Why did cities keep rebelling against the Romans when they never succeeded and suffered brutal reprisals?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Von Papen's role in Nazi Germany from 1933 to 1946

I study modern history at high school, and we've recently learnt about how Von Papen was essentially vice chancellor to Hitler. The only places in the syllabus he is mentioned is in 1933, and then in 1946 at the Nuremberg Trials, so I was wondering what happened to Von Papen after the Enabling Act was passed?

Sorry if my formatting isn't great, this is my first ever post. Thanks heaps

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Between the development of Greek Fire and the modern flamethrower, were incendiary weapons used in European or Near Eastern warfare?

1 Answers 2016-08-09

Panbabylonism is the belief that the Old Testament, (among other Near Eastern religions) were either variations of Ancient Mesopotamian myths and beliefs, or heavily influenced by them. Is panbabylonism still in favor with modern assyriologists/religious scholars/theologians?

I know that similarities include parallels from the Flood Story of Gilgamesh/Enuma Elish to that of Genesis, that Gilgamesh and the Huluppu Tree is thought to have some parallel to the garden of Eden, and God is referred to as Elohim in Genesis 2, while the chief deity of Ancient Caanan was El. Are these parallels thought to be mere coincidence?

2 Answers 2016-08-09

⯇ 4053 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start