Why was Henry Tudor not considered part of the Plantagenet family?

Henry Tudor was a direct legitimate descendant of John Gaunt, who is a primary figure in the Lancaster line, and he was presented as a Lancaster candidate. He also married a York, Elizabeth of York. So his line unified the two cadet branches of Plantagenet. Why isn't the house of Tudor considered a cadet branch of Plantagenet/York/Lancaster?

1 Answers 2016-06-17

When did the story/myth about the deadliness of the Russian winter to invaders start?Is it credible?

Frankly I don't quite get it.Battles have been fought in colder places?So where did this 'Russian winter ' is impregnable go out from?

2 Answers 2016-06-17

How common was it for married couples in legislations where they could not simply divorce even if both wished to separate (specific example here: 1930's England) to stage a fake incident of infidelity in order to obtain a divorce?

There's this passage in Dorothy L. Sayers' "Busman's Honeymoon" (published 1937, set in England), from a letter written by an old Countess:

Not that many marriages can be called permanent these days, but I can't see Peter [Lord Peter Wimsey, who's about to finally get married] exhibiting himself in the Divorce Courts for his own amusement, though, no doubt, if asked to oblige, he would carry it through with an air.

(Which reminds me that my idiot great-nephew, Hughie, has bungled matters as usual. Having undertaken to do the thing like a gentleman, he sneaked off to Brighton with a hired nobody, and the Judge wouldn't believe either the hotel bills or the chambermaid—knowing them all too well by sight. So it means starting all over again from the beginning.)

So, as I read this, Hughie and his wife want to divorce, and "like a gentleman" Hughie is willing to take the blame. He stages a romantic getaway to the seaside with a "hired nobody", in which he is to be caught complete with a witness and written proof, so they can be divorced due to his supposed infidelity. But the judge seems to be familiar with this kind of ploy, and the attempt fails.

Which leads me to asking: Was this actually something people (and people of the upper class, too) did, being willing to be bear the public stigma of infidelity in order to be able to dissolve a marriage? Were there sensational cases of this sort, where the attempt succeeded or failed? Was there public discourse about them? Would Hughie or his wife be snubbed by their peers if they had managed to carry the scheme through?

I'm asking mostly about the setting of the novel, that is England around the 1930s, but of course similar cases from other places and times with a similar legal framework would also be interesting.

And please, if you have literature I can read about this sort of thing, do tell me! I'm not scared of academic literature, footnotes and all, in German or English.

1 Answers 2016-06-17

How much did conquered Soviet territories benefit te German war effort?

1 Answers 2016-06-17

How were crows, ravens and pigeons trained to take letters from one part of a country to another?

Re-binge-watching Game of Thrones and it got me wondering how birds are trained/selected to go to certain locations.

How was this done historically?

2 Answers 2016-06-17

What were the events that led up to the Second Vatican council (Vatican II)?

Did something happen to cause the council, and the drastic changes it produced or did they do it for another reason?

1 Answers 2016-06-17

When WWI began, how widespread were the red trousers of the French army?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-06-17

My sister is in jail and I can send her books. What would be the best 2-3 that can explain how the west got into the situation with the middle east (even if it covers everything lightly) that we are in. I know that is vague and I am looking for the situation with Israeli and the surrounding area.

11 Answers 2016-06-17

Marie Curie named the element Polonium at a time when Poland was not an independent country. Was this a radical political statement? How was the naming of Polonium received by the international community?

I'm particularly interested in how the French, German, and Russian governments responded to this naming.

1 Answers 2016-06-17

Were there any instances of the framers of the US Constitution solving disputes of constitutionality?

You hear a lot about the Supreme Court wrestling with how to interpret the Constitution. Basically, could James Madison have stood up during Marbury vs. Madison and said point blank, "this is what we intended when we wrote the Constitution?"

1 Answers 2016-06-17

Why is the king James version of the Bible considered by a lot of churches to be the best version?

I notice a lot of churches state that they use the KJV of the Bible because they think it's the best version.

I don't see churches claiming other versions of the Bible (are there other versions?) so I was wondering why they seem to be so zealous about tje KJV.

2 Answers 2016-06-17

Why did Islam take root in Albania but not in the rest of the Baltic states conquered by the Ottomans?

And why not Greece, for that matter?

1 Answers 2016-06-17

were Americans allowed to own cannons under the second amendment?

"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

basically, did the term "arms" refer only to the individual firearms of the time, or would it have been acceptable for an average person to own a cannon? are there any recorded instances of cannon ownership?

(i realize there's sort of a political tint to this question but i think it would be hard to ask a question about the second amendment that isn't political so i hope i at least phrased it in a neutral way)

2 Answers 2016-06-17

Were there any records of transgender people being persecuted during the Holocaust?

I know that there were gay men, and to a lesser degree, lesbian women persecuted in the Holocaust but were there transgender people persecuted?

If they were, were they considered mentally ill and as such fell under the purview of Nazi doctors or were they thrown into camps like gay men and women?

2 Answers 2016-06-17

Can anyone tell me any information on my grandfathers ww1 regiment based on this stein?

I am not sure if this is the appropriate sub for this so I'm sorry if it is not. I found this stein of my great grandfather who fought in the first world world. My German is not that great and I can't seem to get a lot of it translated or any historical context on it.

Imgur link: http://m.imgur.com/a/3XaTR

1 Answers 2016-06-17

What happened to the landed gentry of Victorian Era England and why aren't they so prominent today?

Pride and Prejudice shows these landed gentry of Victorian Era England as very wealthy and powerful people in England. Why aren't they so prominent today? Did their fortunes die out? Did they lose power but retain their estates? Do they still exist, just in a much quieter way?

2 Answers 2016-06-17

What did Native Americans think of rainbows?

Looking for any information on any culture in the Americas. Especially the Incas.

1 Answers 2016-06-17

Combined Arms Warfare Resources

I am looking for useful resources about early combined arms warfare. I want to research the stratagies and tactics of militaries that had limited implementation of firearms. Does anyone have suggestions for books or webpages?

Also appreciated would be resources for 30 years war era and Napoleonic tactics.

1 Answers 2016-06-17

Do other European countries have red zones like France from the vast amount of unexploded ordinance from a war?

1 Answers 2016-06-17

Have there been any negative depictions of Jesus in Islam?

Or does his status as a prophet prohibit this? And if the canon of Islam does prohibit it, how about the community at large? Have there been sects within the religion that permitted or encouraged ridicule of Jesus?

It just appears to me that from Dante to Charlie Hebdo the depictions have been pretty one sided, but I don't know too much about Islam.

Also, please note that I am not commenting on it being right or wrong one way or another within the framework of this question.

1 Answers 2016-06-17

How did Ancient people think the moon glowed?

2 Answers 2016-06-17

How widespread was Christianity amongst pagan Somali clans in the pre-Islamic era (before the 600's)?

Recent archeological discoveries of hundreds of pre-Islamic Christian tombstones, as well as the use of the Christian cross as camel clan-symbols is showing us a picture of that Somalia may have been a harbour of early Christianity. Any idea as to how widespread it may have been amongst pre-Islamic Somalis? Any records from Christian monks and travelers visiting the area?

1 Answers 2016-06-17

Did the USSR ever planned to incorporate East European Nations into Soviet Union?

After the Second World War, the Soviet Union seems to had free rein in Eastern Europe and the communist ideology, as far as a know, has a strong universalist leaning. Was there any plan to make Eastern Europeans Nations (Poland, Hungary, Romania etc.) republics of the Soviet Union?

1 Answers 2016-06-17

Is adding letters for emphasis ("yessssss", "Oh my godddddd", "hiiiiiii") a digital-era custom, or did it exist before computers were popular?

This may not be the right place, but it's the closest I could think of. Obviously, adding letters is a lot easier when all you need to do it to hold down a key on a keyboard, but I was wondering if there are any examples of it happening when people had to physically had to write down the extra letters?

2 Answers 2016-06-16

What did Europeans think of caffeinated beverages (i.e. tea and coffee) when they were first introduced?

From what I've read, tea and coffee were introduced to Europe in the 17th century (coffee slightly later than tea). This was decades before the "beginning" of the Enlightenment, so I'm guessing superstitions and fear of things not fully understood were still widespread.

If a drink were suddenly introduced giving consumers a burst of focus and energy, then wouldn't it be rejected as "magic" or something similar?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

4185 / 7255

Back to start