Why is it so difficult for most movies and video games to accurately portray their historical settings?

Especially through outfits, architecture, weapons, tools, etc.

1 Answers 2016-06-08

Why was Australia never "discovered" from Indonesia?

It's always sort of baffled me that Australia was only "discovered" by Europeans in the 1600's. How is it that no ships from the massive maritime trading routes throughout Indonesia got there millennia earlier? What was stopping them?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

What language is this book, what is it about, how old?

I have cross posted this on some other subreddits and have found out some interesting stuff. I thought I might as well try it here.

17 Images

So far I have had some response that say it is part arabic part farsi. That it is a Shia text because Ali and his sword Dhul Fiqar is mentioned a lot. Also that ""written by Abu Alsaud Effendi" is in the text. What does it all mean?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

How much value did the Aztecs place on gold in Pre-Conquest Mexico?

Did they just see it as something which was shiny and didn't rust, and didn't place much value on it beyond decoration? Or did it have value well before the conquistadors arrived? I'm well aware of the European value for gold, but I'm interested in knowing the Aztecs view of it before the Wests devastating contact with them.

1 Answers 2016-06-08

Was slavery a thing in Europe?

We hear a lot about American slavery but was it ever a thing in Europe?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

When did we have the largest number of living US presidents?

Right now there are, I believe, five former/current presidents alive. Has this number ever been higher? If so when and who made up the list?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

Did ancient armies have names or titles?

Hi all,

So, the Romans had many legions, for example Legio X Fretensis, with their own symbol, a bull, a ship, Neptune and a boar - which were references to battles / campaigns etc.

And we know of more modern armies doing the same thing, for example the Coldstream Guards being the oldest British regular army regiment in continuous service (1650-date).

However, did other armies do the same?

Were specific units decorated (much like individual soldiers)?

I just find it odd that I haven't personally seen any references to unit names.

I guess the Macedonians had the Hypaspists and the Spartans had units like the Perioeci.

I find it very interesting and would love to know more, could anyone point me in the right direction?

Thanks

EDIT - Grammar

1 Answers 2016-06-08

Does anybody know anything about this wild west mohawk guy?

here: http://imgur.com/u2u3IBa

This picture just came up in /r/oldschoolcool and i was wondering how one would get a mohawk back in the day? It wasn't in style and things like hipsters or punks didn't exist back then.

Does anybody know more about 19th century hairstyles? Or anything about this person in particular?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

When Marx wrote that "A spectre is haunting Europe — the spectre of communism", was it? How influential was communism in 1848?

2 Answers 2016-06-08

Did the obstacles on the D-Day beaches actually offer cover?

We always see the Normandy beaches of D-Day being littered with these things.

And in D-day films such as "Saving Private Ryan" we see the men taking cover from the machine guns.

However in the multiplayer WW2 video games I played (yes I know not accurate to real history) such as the multiplayer D-Day maps on Red Orchestra 2 (western front mod) and Medal of Honor Allied Assault. I have always been easily shot by an enemy when I take cover behind one and vice versa.

So did they actually offer any cover? In movies they do, but in multiplayer video games they do not.

Thanks in advance.

2 Answers 2016-06-08

I just read in a book that household/family size has remained stable for hundreds of years. Never heard this before in my life. How true is it?

In the book How Should We Live by Roman Krznaric, in the chapter on Family, he states that it's a 'myth' that families used to be larger and include several generations all living under the same roof and that the nuclear family as we understand it (mom, dad, and their offspring) has been the dominant structure for several hundred years.

He cites a bunch of census data from both the U.S. and Britain, so I guess I'm only asking about those countries. But this is literally the very first time I've even heard a sniff of a rumor that multi-generational households weren't the norm for my ancestors, and that the whole nuclear family thing was a very 20th century phenomenon. Is this guy a quack, or what?

2 Answers 2016-06-08

Did Americans have a vigorous debate about gun control after the Kennedy and MLK assassinations?

Nowadays it seems like NRA and anti-gun proponents inevitably rise up and clash after terrible episodes like Columbine and Sandy Hook (and then sadly dissipate). Did such strong debates happen after RFK, JFK and MLK Jr? Did anything result from it? Or were society's attitudes about guns different back then?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

Why did Germany/Hitler refuse to surrender during WW2?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-06-08

How did the Romans regard the Greeks?

If I recall college correctly, I was taught that the Romans essentially idolized the Greeks, as shown by the Romans copying the Greek's religion and a lot of their artwork. More recently, I was told the Romans actually looked down upon the Greeks. They saw them as manipulators, liars and a lazy people who were not fit for combat. This claim was backed up by a source that looks pretty dubious to me, so I figured I'd ask here. What were the Roman's attitude toward the Greeks?

Did the Roman's attitude change towards Greece as Rome grew? For instance, did the Romans of the Republic period think of the Greeks differently than the Romans of the Empire period?

Also, I know the Western half of the Empire (ie, the Byzantine Empire) was predominantly Greek, and I'd imagine they may have had a significantly different view of themselves than the Eastern Empire may have. Is this the case?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

How Common Were Blackpowder Malfunctions?

I've played a lot of RPG's and wargames that prominently feature blackpowder weapons, most seem to include malfunction, explosion being the most common, as a mechanical nerfing, but I was wondering how unreliable blackpowder actually was, especially if used by someone who was skilled in its use?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

Why didn't Prussia try to get its former polish territories in the Congress of Vienna?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

Wednesday What's New in History | June 08, 2016

Previous weeks!

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

1 Answers 2016-06-08

How accurate is Polybius when describing the negotiations between Hannibal and Scipio before the Battle of Zama?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

How common was dessertion among British soldiers in the Revolutionary War? How easy would it be for them to integrate into life in American cities?

I'm lucky enough to have a grandmother who is interested in genealogy, and she found that one of our earliest family members to arrive in America came as a soldier from England, but appears to have deserted almost immediately and started a family in New York City.

I love knowing that one of my ancestors came in such a dishonorable, yet totally understandable way, essentially getting a free ride to a new country on King George III's ten pence. I'm curious how common that story was, and how easy it would be for a British soldier to desert and start a new life in New York unnoticed.

Thank you for your time. I always love reading AskHistorians and this is the first question I've thought of that I haven't seen answered (though there have been answers about the high rate of Hessian and mercenary desertion).

3 Answers 2016-06-08

How real to life are the sword fights we see in film and TV?

How real to life are the sword fights we see in film and TV such as Game Of Thrones? I have always thought they must be inaccurate due to safety concerns for the actors.

2 Answers 2016-06-08

How pivotal was the Battle of Midway to the allied victory in WWII?

2 Answers 2016-06-08

Why were a lot of ancient religions polytheistic?

It seems to me that a lot of ancient religions were polytheistic, like the Greek pantheon of gods, why were monotheistic religions unheard of until Judaism?

2 Answers 2016-06-08

What was the point of hiring a defence lawyer in classical Greece or Rome? What could a defence Lawyer do in a world before physical evidence?

3 Answers 2016-06-08

Good whole text Mein Kampf english version, preferably with annotations and footnotes?

I want to do a thing about copyright and want to use it as a Jumping off point (three cheers for public domain) but afraid of getting the edition that is like "Don't be stupid be a smarty. Come and join the Nazi Party!"

Would you be able to tell me of editions that have Hitlers intent come though, while also informing about the references that he uses?

I have a feeling that this is not the right subbreddit for this question, however I need an academics advice and knowledge to make sure I go down the right road, With a book like this, I'm sure you can understand why.

2 Answers 2016-06-08

Why are engineers in military called that way? Do they have a degree in engineering? Also, medics: do they have a medical doctor diploma?

1 Answers 2016-06-08

4206 / 7255

Back to start